You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > St Ives taking the p?
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

St Ives taking the p?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
BlueJay Flag UK 13 May 22 12.21am

They should be careful. There are consequences to decisions like this.... [Link]

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 May 22 6.48am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Amazing all the experts on Cornwall here. I might not be Cornish, but I do live here.

The story about the loos in St Ives is new, though. The principal isn't. It's quite usual for local people to be given a discount on things. We can get a yearly pass for the Eden Project, for instance. It encourages out of season use. Having to over provide facilities for the summer surge in visitors, which are then under-utilised during the off season, costs money. Never forget that Cornwall remains a deprived area.

Second homes here are becoming a crisis, especially in the coastal towns and villages, with prices being forced to levels completely unaffordable by local people, and then left empty for most of the year, turned into AirBnbs or holiday lets. Drive the local people away, and you also drive away part of what the people come here for in the first place.

I am sure this is not exclusive to Cornwall, but the whole idea of a rarely used second home, when people cannot afford a first one, doesn't sit well, does it?

So the local people would be happy driving the tourists away? Some areas do give discounts on local attractions but public loos? Come on Wissie.
Housing not being affordable to local people is not exclusive to coastal towns and villages. Try living in the SE,

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 May 22 6.49am

Originally posted by BlueJay

They should be careful. There are consequences to decisions like this.... [Link]

Isn’t that shop a bit of a dump anyway?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 May 22 7.28am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Amazing all the experts on Cornwall here. I might not be Cornish, but I do live here.

The story about the loos in St Ives is new, though. The principal isn't. It's quite usual for local people to be given a discount on things. We can get a yearly pass for the Eden Project, for instance. It encourages out of season use. Having to over provide facilities for the summer surge in visitors, which are then under-utilised during the off season, costs money. Never forget that Cornwall remains a deprived area.

Second homes here are becoming a crisis, especially in the coastal towns and villages, with prices being forced to levels completely unaffordable by local people, and then left empty for most of the year, turned into AirBnbs or holiday lets. Drive the local people away, and you also drive away part of what the people come here for in the first place.

I am sure this is not exclusive to Cornwall, but the whole idea of a rarely used second home, when people cannot afford a first one, doesn't sit well, does it?

Getting invaded by people not local to the area and it causing housing issues, who would have thought it. Welcome to the world that is the rest of the UK. I have zero sympathy, we have invited all of these problems on ourselves.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 May 22 9.46am

I visited a place called Beaminster about 20 years ago. Working there as a subcontractor for a week.
Nice enough village full of quite striking stone buildings for most of it.
Managed to find a nice B&B a few minutes walk away, which was run by a lady and her husband.

And so the historical nature of the village was that in centuries gone by, it was once the most affluent place in the UK. It attracted the wealthier people, and house prices rose. It had a couple of village pubs a petrol station and lots of shops on the High Street for 'local people'. Local people could live in their own little bubble world of affluence.
The rising house prices meant some local people cashed-in their chips and moved out, and gradually the demographic of the village changed to older persons. Younger people moved away to find careers, and better paid jobs.
Shops and pubs found they could no longer attract younger staff and struggled to keep open , so attracting less tourists bringing money.
A vicious circle ensued, as pubs and shops shut and the older residents now had to get in the car to drive to the supermarket in Yeovil.
House prices gradually stagnated, but the damage had already been done by losing amenities and the younger generation to help run them.
Was a bit of a ghost-town the last time i visited.

Me-thinks St. Ives better think of better longer-term strategies, because what is currently happening is going to deprive the local economy of more money than toilet charges generates.
A bit like putting up parking charges to £10 per hour, which would ultimately kill shopping centres.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 May 22 9.53am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

I visited a place called Beaminster about 20 years ago. Working there as a subcontractor for a week.
Nice enough village full of quite striking stone buildings for most of it.
Managed to find a nice B&B a few minutes walk away, which was run by a lady and her husband.

And so the historical nature of the village was that in centuries gone by, it was once the most affluent place in the UK. It attracted the wealthier people, and house prices rose. It had a couple of village pubs a petrol station and lots of shops on the High Street for 'local people'. Local people could live in their own little bubble world of affluence.
The rising house prices meant some local people cashed-in their chips and moved out, and gradually the demographic of the village changed to older persons. Younger people moved away to find careers, and better paid jobs.
Shops and pubs found they could no longer attract younger staff and struggled to keep open , so attracting less tourists bringing money.
A vicious circle ensued, as pubs and shops shut and the older residents now had to get in the car to drive to the supermarket in Yeovil.
House prices gradually stagnated, but the damage had already been done by losing amenities and the younger generation to help run them.
Was a bit of a ghost-town the last time i visited.

Me-thinks St. Ives better think of better longer-term strategies, because what is currently happening is going to deprive the local economy of more money than toilet charges generates.
A bit like putting up parking charges to £10 per hour, which would ultimately kill shopping centres.

I guess this is what is being reversed by work from home, but second homes are not adding anything much. Tourism, of course, is likely the mmain business of a lot of these areas. It's stupid to hassle the tourists and make them go somewhere else. I had a friend who was a staunch Cornish nationalist. He spoke Cornish, he was in the Royal Engineers, he had no problem saying what he thought of second homes.
Last time I was in Cornwall was maybe 40 years ago. My Grandad blew up the caravan by cooking a Fray Bentos pie unopened in the microwave. We were in St Ives.

Edited by ASCPFC (13 May 2022 10.13am)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 May 22 10.11am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Amazing all the experts on Cornwall here. I might not be Cornish, but I do live here.

The story about the loos in St Ives is new, though. The principal isn't. It's quite usual for local people to be given a discount on things. We can get a yearly pass for the Eden Project, for instance. It encourages out of season use. Having to over provide facilities for the summer surge in visitors, which are then under-utilised during the off season, costs money. Never forget that Cornwall remains a deprived area.

Second homes here are becoming a crisis, especially in the coastal towns and villages, with prices being forced to levels completely unaffordable by local people, and then left empty for most of the year, turned into AirBnbs or holiday lets. Drive the local people away, and you also drive away part of what the people come here for in the first place.

I am sure this is not exclusive to Cornwall, but the whole idea of a rarely used second home, when people cannot afford a first one, doesn't sit well, does it?

Welcome to Capitalism and the free-market economy. I thought everyone had a choice ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 May 22 12.25pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Welcome to Capitalism and the free-market economy. I thought everyone had a choice ?

I recognise that, and why governments are reluctant to get involved. So that's why it tends to be local action.

Second home ownership is discouraged in several places. In parts of Wales, I believe as well is in some places here. Guernsey has had an open and closed market housing policy for a long time, in which the very wealthy can buy a few open market homes at exorbitant prices but only locals can buy in the closed market.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 May 22 12.33pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

I visited a place called Beaminster about 20 years ago. Working there as a subcontractor for a week.
Nice enough village full of quite striking stone buildings for most of it.
Managed to find a nice B&B a few minutes walk away, which was run by a lady and her husband.

And so the historical nature of the village was that in centuries gone by, it was once the most affluent place in the UK. It attracted the wealthier people, and house prices rose. It had a couple of village pubs a petrol station and lots of shops on the High Street for 'local people'. Local people could live in their own little bubble world of affluence.
The rising house prices meant some local people cashed-in their chips and moved out, and gradually the demographic of the village changed to older persons. Younger people moved away to find careers, and better paid jobs.
Shops and pubs found they could no longer attract younger staff and struggled to keep open , so attracting less tourists bringing money.
A vicious circle ensued, as pubs and shops shut and the older residents now had to get in the car to drive to the supermarket in Yeovil.
House prices gradually stagnated, but the damage had already been done by losing amenities and the younger generation to help run them.
Was a bit of a ghost-town the last time i visited.

Me-thinks St. Ives better think of better longer-term strategies, because what is currently happening is going to deprive the local economy of more money than toilet charges generates.
A bit like putting up parking charges to £10 per hour, which would ultimately kill shopping centres.

The primary problem there is second homeownership, making the town unaffordable for local people. We avoid it as much as we can during the tourist season, as it gets so many people there that it becomes almost impossible. I don't know, but I suspect they would like to reduce the numbers going there and encourage those that do to have a more comfortable experience, stay longer and spend more. There are loads of other places here which are just as nice and much more easily accessible.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 13 May 22 1.03pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I recognise that, and why governments are reluctant to get involved. So that's why it tends to be local action.

Second home ownership is discouraged in several places. In parts of Wales, I believe as well is in some places here. Guernsey has had an open and closed market housing policy for a long time, in which the very wealthy can buy a few open market homes at exorbitant prices but only locals can buy in the closed market.

Doesn't sound great for the sellers if all the open market places age gone.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 May 22 1.18pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I recognise that, and why governments are reluctant to get involved. So that's why it tends to be local action.

Second home ownership is discouraged in several places. In parts of Wales, I believe as well is in some places here. Guernsey has had an open and closed market housing policy for a long time, in which the very wealthy can buy a few open market homes at exorbitant prices but only locals can buy in the closed market.

And herein lies just one of the problems. How do you define 'local' ? There must be some definition used by Local Authorities/Governments.
And if you have enough money and desire, you can always get past the rules.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 May 22 1.21pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Doesn't sound great for the sellers if all the open market places age gone.

Another point. If you had a house for sale for the locals market, but your neighbour lived outside the boundary and could sell their property on the open market (for 40% more), wouldn't you move heaven and earth to get your property out of the locals market ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 13 May 22 1.41pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I recognise that, and why governments are reluctant to get involved. So that's why it tends to be local action.

Second home ownership is discouraged in several places. In parts of Wales, I believe as well is in some places here. Guernsey has had an open and closed market housing policy for a long time, in which the very wealthy can buy a few open market homes at exorbitant prices but only locals can buy in the closed market.

There was, in the Eighties, quite a lot of 2nd homes getting burned down in Wales, hence the joke doing the rounds at the time.

"Come home to a real fire...buy a holiday home in Wales"

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 May 22 2.26pm

I think, and it is only my opinion. That Cornwall has exploited itself as a holiday destination for many years. Todays situation has been brewing away, unchallenged, for decades.

Wales was slightly different, that towns are areas, that although beautiful and scenic in their own right, also had working communities. Not just places like Newport and Port Talbot , but also large swathes of agriculture and rural infrastructure.

And you can blames the Welshies for selling at high prices to people after a second home, but a lot of the local industries need protection, which is why the Welsh Government feels it had to step in. House prices were becoming unaffordable for Welsh workers, who if i'm brutally honest, can be poorly paid when compared to London, and other English cities.

Wales is seeking to conserve it's rural heritage and dissuade holiday home use, whereas St Ive's is torn as it relies heavily on tourism for income to the area.

Just my random thoughts. Happy to hear others

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

W12 13 May 22 5.25pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

And herein lies just one of the problems. How do you define 'local' ? There must be some definition used by Local Authorities/Governments.
And if you have enough money and desire, you can always get past the rules.

I think everyone instinctively knows what that means.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 13 May 22 6.31pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Isn’t that shop a bit of a dump anyway?

. If it wasn't it is now!

 

YT Flag Oxford 13 May 22 7.10pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

There was, in the Eighties, quite a lot of 2nd homes getting burned down in Wales, hence the joke doing the rounds at the time.

"Come home to a real fire...buy a holiday home in Wales"

That joke was made by 'Not The Nine O'Clock News'. It was a parody of a TV advert of the time by British Coal. Yes, as recently as the late 70s/early 80s, coal was still being advertised on the telly!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 May 22 10.44pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

And herein lies just one of the problems. How do you define 'local' ? There must be some definition used by Local Authorities/Governments.
And if you have enough money and desire, you can always get past the rules.

I am not aware of the detail of how it works in Guernsey, but believe the homes that are in each category were determined a long time ago. It's neither geographical or size. Only people born in Guernsey can buy closed market homes there.

The little knowledge I have is because the ex-husband of my sister married his second wife, who was Guernsey born. They were both working for a stock-broker in the City and decamped to Guernsey where they bought a mansion in the closed market, overlooking the sea, and he set up as a broker there managing the funds of the rich and famous, "offshore". Footballers we all know and love are among his clients. To say he has done well, would be an understatement!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 13 May 22 11.18pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I guess this is what is being reversed by work from home, but second homes are not adding anything much. Tourism, of course, is likely the mmain business of a lot of these areas. It's stupid to hassle the tourists and make them go somewhere else. I had a friend who was a staunch Cornish nationalist. He spoke Cornish, he was in the Royal Engineers, he had no problem saying what he thought of second homes.
Last time I was in Cornwall was maybe 40 years ago. My Grandad blew up the caravan by cooking a Fray Bentos pie unopened in the microwave. We were in St Ives.

Edited by ASCPFC (13 May 2022 10.13am)

I've probably mentioned this on another thread of which the topic I forget, but I was working in a well known Manhattan bar & It wasn't unusual as the bar was Irish owned & operated for customers to twist themselves into a knot & deny any English roots.
Italian, Irish, Spanish German, French, Dutch, Scottish, Welsh you name it but anything but being Anglo/English American
On one occasion I had one dropkick describe himself to the Barman as being 'Cornish American'

 


Pro USA & Israel

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 13 May 22 11.22pm

On a lighter note. Could this not be a perfect business opportunity for someone? Planning permission aside.
Build a state of the art restroom with obviously toilets as well as a sauna, jacuzzi, showers etc.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > St Ives taking the p?