You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Penalties "A Lottery"
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Penalties "A Lottery"


YT Flag Oxford 19 May 22 8.43am

I watched BBC Breakfast this morning for about 4 minutes (yes I know; sorry) and heard 3 different people say that penalty shootouts were "a lottery" (as yet another cup final fails to produce a winner after extra time).

Perhaps a big pedantry alert is required here, but it really annoys me when this is said, yet it's one of those phrases that has become 'implied knowledge'. A shootout is a test of sporting ability just like any other.

Taking the example of last night, one team drilled their five penalties home without a stutter, whereas the other team didn't. The one player who missed ran up to the ball with a complete absence of conviction before duly scuffing a weak shot straight at the keeper. Why was that "a lottery"; it was one team performing better than the other team.

'Lottery' is the wrong word in any case. A lottery requires multiple entrants and minimal numbers of winners. A shootout is one v one.

Edited by YT (19 May 2022 8.45am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

HeathMan Flag Purley 19 May 22 8.51am

Agree

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 May 22 9.08am

Originally posted by YT

I watched BBC Breakfast this morning for about 4 minutes (yes I know; sorry) and heard 3 different people say that penalty shootouts were "a lottery" (as yet another cup final fails to produce a winner after extra time).

Perhaps a big pedantry alert is required here, but it really annoys me when this is said, yet it's one of those phrases that has become 'implied knowledge'. A shootout is a test of sporting ability just like any other.

Taking the example of last night, one team drilled their five penalties home without a stutter, whereas the other team didn't. The one player who missed ran up to the ball with a complete absence of conviction before duly scuffing a weak shot straight at the keeper. Why was that "a lottery"; it was one team performing better than the other team.

'Lottery' is the wrong word in any case. A lottery requires multiple entrants and minimal numbers of winners. A shootout is one v one.

Edited by YT (19 May 2022 8.45am)

Yep!

I would be inclined to suggest that this saying is based upon the
assumption that every professional footballer is expected to score a penalty which is clearly not the case.

It would be my personal expectation of them to do so however it ignores several variables:

1. The quality of GKs these days?
2. The ability of a player to handle the pressure mentally?
3. How physically and mentally prepared a player is after often 120mins?
4. Of course the actual ability to strike a ball with conviction?

I actually find it shocking how often players are both treated and act as though taking a pen in a shootout was a completely unforeseeable circumstance. I think it is more mental than technical but even at that juncture the onus should surely be on a manager to identify those best placed to take one considering the factors.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 19 May 22 9.20am


Yep, lottery is really undervaluing the mental and technical abilities on display.

And to put your pen away you need to have both elements locked.

The keepers sniff out indecision a mile away. and are good enough to get to most pens if not perfectly struck.

I'll always remember an interview with Shearer about pens. His POV was that if he executed his pen properly (top corner) no keeper would get it. So instead of letting indecision creep in, he always went there. Then the only thing he had to nail was hitting the spot, and not worry about what way he thought the keeper might dive.


 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 19 May 22 9.30am

It'll be nice to have at least half of Scotland not now revelling in us losing to Germany in penalty shoot outs. People in glass houses and all that.....

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

YT Flag Oxford 19 May 22 9.43am

Originally posted by mezzer

It'll be nice to have at least half of Scotland not now revelling in us losing to Germany in penalty shoot outs. People in glass houses and all that.....

Or to Italy. Or indeed Portugal. In fact England last lost a shootout to Germany (their 2nd such loss) 26 years ago. Since then, they've lost 2 to Italy and 2 to Portugal.

Edited by YT (19 May 2022 10.12am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

eaglesdare Flag 19 May 22 10.28am

the minute I seen Ramsey in the shootout I knew he didint look confident! as someone has said keepers can sniff someone who is not confident!
More often than not the unconfident person will go down the middle and keep the penalty on target!

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 19 May 22 10.59am

Originally posted by YT

Or to Italy. Or indeed Portugal. In fact England last lost a shootout to Germany (their 2nd such loss) 26 years ago. Since then, they've lost 2 to Italy and 2 to Portugal.

Edited by YT (19 May 2022 10.12am)

Which is the real reason people voted Leave

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

A89M Flag Streatham 19 May 22 11.51am

Originally posted by MrRobbo


Yep, lottery is really undervaluing the mental and technical abilities on display.

And to put your pen away you need to have both elements locked.

The keepers sniff out indecision a mile away. and are good enough to get to most pens if not perfectly struck.

I'll always remember an interview with Shearer about pens. His POV was that if he executed his pen properly (top corner) no keeper would get it. So instead of letting indecision creep in, he always went there. Then the only thing he had to nail was hitting the spot, and not worry about what way he thought the keeper might dive.


Exactly. Kane seems to have followed suit with this - One of the best I've seen at hitting side netting consistently, I bet he practices these every week, if not daily. 'Lottery' is just an excuse for the team who loses.

Another one that annoys me is - 'You cannot replicate the atmosphere' and whilst this is true, you can practice your technique over and over again until it becomes natural. Small margins make the difference in these tense situations.

 

YT Flag Oxford 19 May 22 12.32pm

Originally posted by A89M

Exactly. Kane seems to have followed suit with this - One of the best I've seen at hitting side netting consistently, I bet he practices these every week, if not daily. 'Lottery' is just an excuse for the team who loses.

Another one that annoys me is - 'You cannot replicate the atmosphere' and whilst this is true, you can practice your technique over and over again until it becomes natural. Small margins make the difference in these tense situations.

Quite, and true of any and every sport.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 May 22 12.36pm

I agree generally.
I think the term Lottery is born out of the fact that the Keeper basically guesses as To where your gonna shoot. if he guesses right, he saves the penalty. (bit simplistic I know)

A Penalty is a different skill to the rest of the game, it's about nerve, clarity of thought and technique. A perfect pen is almost impossible to Save. The onus is on the attacker to score; the keeper is not expected to Save anything.

I'm not convinced that penalties are a just way to end a tournament, but I haven't got a better solution than Penalties.

I quite like the idea that Extra time should begin with a loss of a player on each side, then every 5 mins each team loses another player until someone scores.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 May 22 12.40pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I agree generally.
I think the term Lottery is born out of the fact that the Keeper basically guesses as To where your gonna shoot. if he guesses right, he saves the penalty. (bit simplistic I know)

A Penalty is a different skill to the rest of the game, it's about nerve, clarity of thought and technique. A perfect pen is almost impossible to Save. The onus is on the attacker to score; the keeper is not expected to Save anything.

I'm not convinced that penalties are a just way to end a tournament, but I haven't got a better solution than Penalties.

I quite like the idea that Extra time should begin with a loss of a player on each side, then every 5 mins each team loses another player until someone scores.

But you could end up with just Calvin Andrew on one team and Wayne Andrews on the other, in which case the duration of the match would span seasons let alone hours.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 May 22 1.01pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

But you could end up with just Calvin Andrew on one team and Wayne Andrews on the other, in which case the duration of the match would span seasons let alone hours.

haha, but what a spectacle!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 May 22 1.36pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

haha, but what a spectacle!

Might be interesting to introduce some new rules into football.

Personally, I would go for:

1. A penalty, or even penalty shootout, is taken by a randomised selection of a seat in the ground for the corresponding team, for example: A home penalty for Palace will be taken by 'Row X, Seat X in the Lower/Upper Hols, Arthur, CA, GL etc'.

or

2. Similar to Pool, you have some sort of Black Styrofoam Pillar placed randomly on the pitch for each game and if anyone knocks it over at any stage their team lose immediately.

I have many more ideas but those are my top 2 for now.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 May 22 3.19pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

haha, but what a spectacle!

Not sure it would be spectacular. Probably mildly amusing.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 May 22 4.39pm

I always favoured the idea that you have to take the goal keepers off for extra time. That would have some of the tacticians scratching their heads but would probably guarantee goals.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 28 May 22 5.00pm

Most of the time it's down to the team that holds their nerve, the better keeper but you do get the odd occasion like Chelsea Liverpool in the league Cup where it goes to the keepers or utd vs villarreal, where it goes around twice, which is a lottery. I'd rather have replays, if you don't win after 120 mins and 11 penalties then you definitely don't deserve to lift a cup.

 

YT Flag Oxford 28 May 22 7.47pm

Originally posted by rikz

Most of the time it's down to the team that holds their nerve, the better keeper but you do get the odd occasion like Chelsea Liverpool in the league Cup where it goes to the keepers or utd vs villarreal, where it goes around twice, which is a lottery. I'd rather have replays, if you don't win after 120 mins and 11 penalties then you definitely don't deserve to lift a cup.

There, it's that word "lottery" again. Why is it?

Anyway, I'd like to enhance your closing suggestion. If the scores are level after 120 minutes in a cup final just say that no-one wins the trophy that year. That would focus the mind!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

eagleheath Flag Burgess Hill 28 May 22 7.56pm

As Simon Cowell would say on the other channel - It’s a No from me

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Penalties "A Lottery"