You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate Sacked ?
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southgate Sacked ?


Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
HeathMan Flag Purley 05 Jun 22 8.12pm

Someone has said that all teams will lose from time to time. we have to hope that the defeat will lead to a team that is up to it. Agree that at the moment there is too much football and the lads should be on the beach (hopefully not being transported by Easyjet).

There, sadly, remains the naming of a team that will win the World Cup. Putting PALACE first, I think we have enough English players to put 15 into the squad.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 06 Jun 22 11.46am

I'm no fan of Southgate, but if you Look at the numbers, it's hard to argue against him; a Final and Semi final in our last 2 major tournaments is better than any manager I can remember.
He's refreshed the national game, and injected pace, youth and opportunity into the team. He's made it clear that form gets you in the door and remwards good performances - everthing that's been lacking since 1998!

It's when you look at the style of play and those opponents that we've played, that his looks less impressive. I don't actually think huge amount has changed on the pitch. We still struggle to break teams down in the final third and are still relying on the odd player to get us through games (without Sterling last Euros how far would we have got?)
If you look at The last 2 tournaments, the Euros in particular, We got lucky with the draws, and, Germany aside, avoided the big names. Saying that, right Up until half time of the final, his Tactics were spot on throughout the tournament... and its not even like he played the same 11 each time. It was only when Plan A needed changing(against the first top quality opposition - coincidence?) that it all fell apart.

Looking back at those 2 tournaments, we've blatantly improved. We actually looked good to watch at times in the last one. Is he still improving?

Look, I don't like him and I think he's well overachieved, but to get rid now after an experimental League of nations game in a World Cup year is crazy talk.


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Jun 22 11.58am

He's an upgrade on Sven, McClaten and Fabio but, then again, so is the sh1t on my shoes. I won't mention Roy out of misguided Palace loyalty but he was bloody awful too. When you think of why Hoddle got sacked, probably makes some of sense of Southgate.

 


Red and Blue Army!

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 06 Jun 22 1.04pm

Just wish he'd picked U21 squad, at least we'd see a bit of commitment. Maguire must have serious dirt on Southgate to keep getting picked because knowone can see a reason for his selection, not even deluded manure fans.

 

The Dolphin Flag 06 Jun 22 1.42pm

England have a dreadful history with Managers.
Ramsay should have been allowed to stay on as should Robson.
Clough - what a bit of fun that would have been.
Venables for all of his "deals on the side" was right up there in terms of talent - gone.
Hoddle was great - one silly comment - gone.
Harry would have been a good National Manager - deals on the side - never got a look in.
Those that choose the man for the job seem a little lacking in football knowledge.
Southgate has done well but should have done better - he needs to stay on but keep him away from tactical matters!

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Jun 22 1.47pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

England have a dreadful history with Managers.
Ramsay should have been allowed to stay on as should Robson.
Clough - what a bit of fun that would have been.
Venables for all of his "deals on the side" was right up there in terms of talent - gone.
Hoddle was great - one silly comment - gone.
Harry would have been a good National Manager - deals on the side - never got a look in.
Those that choose the man for the job seem a little lacking in football knowledge.
Southgate has done well but should have done better - he needs to stay on but keep him away from tactical matters!

Could it be that we're just feckin stupid when it comes to assessing them...?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Jun 22 1.50pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I'm no fan of Southgate, but if you Look at the numbers, it's hard to argue against him; a Final and Semi final in our last 2 major tournaments is better than any manager I can remember.
He's refreshed the national game, and injected pace, youth and opportunity into the team. He's made it clear that form gets you in the door and remwards good performances - everthing that's been lacking since 1998!


It's when you look at the style of play and those opponents that we've played, that his looks less impressive. I don't actually think huge amount has changed on the pitch. We still struggle to break teams down in the final third and are still relying on the odd player to get us through games (without Sterling last Euros how far would we have got?)
If you look at The last 2 tournaments, the Euros in particular, We got lucky with the draws, and, Germany aside, avoided the big names. Saying that, right Up until half time of the final, his Tactics were spot on throughout the tournament... and its not even like he played the same 11 each time. It was only when Plan A needed changing(against the first top quality opposition - coincidence?) that it all fell apart.

Looking back at those 2 tournaments, we've blatantly improved. We actually looked good to watch at times in the last one. Is he still improving?

Look, I don't like him and I think he's well overachieved, but to get rid now after an experimental League of nations game in a World Cup year is crazy talk.


But he asked people not to racially abuse his players, so how can he possibly be good!?!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 06 Jun 22 3.29pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

But he asked people not to racially abuse his players, so how can he possibly be good!?!

Comments like that contribute to why racism still exists. You are a stirrer of a pot that doesn’t need to be stirred.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Jun 22 3.31pm

Ask yourself how England would do with Conte, Tuchel, Klopp or Pep and you have your answer about Southgate. Southgate is not a winning manager - even if has the best players. He just doesn't have the pedigree.

 


Red and Blue Army!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Jun 22 4.19pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Ask yourself how England would do with Conte, Tuchel, Klopp or Pep and you have your answer about Southgate. Southgate is not a winning manager - even if has the best players. He just doesn't have the pedigree.

This is like us signing a player and saying well he's not Messi, Ronaldo, Neymar, Kroos or Modric, so there's your answer.

If we're going to pretend that unless you're top 5 in the world at something, you're rubbish, it's a pretty pointless conversation.

We had Capello who was decorated as anything in club football and he was woeful at International level - considerably worse than Southgate, for example.

I don't love Southgate, and his limitations are quite obvious to see, but I also think to deny the good job he's done over the past few years is silly.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Jun 22 4.21pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Comments like that contribute to why racism still exists. You are a stirrer of a pot that doesn’t need to be stirred.

I'd suggest it's people who get their back up about an anti-racism gestures and consider positions like being against racism as WOKE, but that's just me.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Jun 22 4.52pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This is like us signing a player and saying well he's not Messi, Ronaldo, Neymar, Kroos or Modric, so there's your answer.

If we're going to pretend that unless you're top 5 in the world at something, you're rubbish, it's a pretty pointless conversation.

We had Capello who was decorated as anything in club football and he was woeful at International level - considerably worse than Southgate, for example.

I don't love Southgate, and his limitations are quite obvious to see, but I also think to deny the good job he's done over the past few years is silly.

I think the team is the best it's been since I can basically remember but I find it impossible to ignore the madness of the subs v Italy. A real 'lost it' moment in my opinion. However, England undoubtedly better with Southgate than Roy or Capello.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 06 Jun 22 7.45pm

Bowen and maybe Walker turned up to play but the rest didn't. They got what they deserved. End of our domestic season and their minds are already on their hols. Southgate could have used the game as an opportunity to give more of our newbies a run out. I hope he does next week. Who cares about the Mickey Mouse tournament anyway?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

becky Flag over the moon 06 Jun 22 8.21pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Bowen and maybe Walker turned up to play but the rest didn't. They got what they deserved. End of our domestic season and their minds are already on their hols. Southgate could have used the game as an opportunity to give more of our newbies a run out. I hope he does next week. Who cares about the Mickey Mouse tournament anyway?

In reality, no body...but if he treats it as a trial game for youngsters/untrieds you just know that there will be screams about that from some quarters

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

nhp61 Flag Goring-By-Sea born, now in Brackne... 06 Jun 22 10.02pm

He hasn't done too bad a job in comparison to many of those before him. In reality, he is England's second best manager, getting us to the European Championship final for the first time. Only Alf Ramsey has achieved more success for England.

As for taking the knee, maybe those booing are not booing the players, but booing the taking of the knee, which, in spite of Southgate's protestations, is widely viewed to be tied with the BLM movement, a political organisation which demands for the police to be defunded.

In other words, taking the knee is seen by many to be a political statement. Politics should be kept out of football. Southgate should just concentrate on the football side of things and not debate subjects which are not related to the team and how they play.

Racism is a problem, but nowhere near as big a problem as some like to portray.

Football is supposed to be entertainment, and should be treated as such, not to be used to display pointless virtue signalling.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 06 Jun 22 11.57pm

Originally posted by nhp61

He hasn't done too bad a job in comparison to many of those before him. In reality, he is England's second best manager, getting us to the European Championship final for the first time. Only Alf Ramsey has achieved more success for England.

As for taking the knee, maybe those booing are not booing the players, but booing the taking of the knee, which, in spite of Southgate's protestations, is widely viewed to be tied with the BLM movement, a political organisation which demands for the police to be defunded.

In other words, taking the knee is seen by many to be a political statement. Politics should be kept out of football. Southgate should just concentrate on the football side of things and not debate subjects which are not related to the team and how they play.

Racism is a problem, but nowhere near as big a problem as some like to portray.

Football is supposed to be entertainment, and should be treated as such, not to be used to display pointless virtue signalling.

Correct. Lets kick Politics out of Sport.

Sven Goran Ericsson & Ulrika Johnsson.....now that's Entertainment

Edited by PalazioVecchio (06 Jun 2022 11.58pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

becky Flag over the moon 07 Jun 22 6.46am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Correct. Lets kick Politics out of Sport.

Sven Goran Ericsson & Ulrika Johnsson.....now that's Entertainment

Edited by PalazioVecchio (06 Jun 2022 11.58pm)

If those two are still at it, I don't know about entertainment, it's a bloody miracle!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

A89M Flag Streatham 07 Jun 22 7.34am

He's done exactly what would have been expected of him considering the fortune of the draws in the knockout stages of both tournaments. Beat the teams we should beat and come close against the better nations, Italy had experienced World Class players across the team and were in great form going into that final, it was always going to be difficult.

I personally believe we have one, maybe two World Class players. Kane being the standout with Foden potentially being the second if he continues to improve. All others are very good players but when you come across Croatia/Italy who have a midfield full of world class players, they can take the game away from you.

We play 352/343 because our most experienced CB pairing are too slow to be left one-on-one.

The media and some fans are starting to remind me of how they were during our golden generation era, we're becoming far to confident with our team when in reality the squad does not match up to the top nations,, France, Brazil, Belgium, etc

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 07 Jun 22 11.05am

Originally posted by nhp61

He hasn't done too bad a job in comparison to many of those before him. In reality, he is England's second best manager, getting us to the European Championship final for the first time. Only Alf Ramsey has achieved more success for England.

As for taking the knee, maybe those booing are not booing the players, but booing the taking of the knee, which, in spite of Southgate's protestations, is widely viewed to be tied with the BLM movement, a political organisation which demands for the police to be defunded.

In other words, taking the knee is seen by many to be a political statement. Politics should be kept out of football. Southgate should just concentrate on the football side of things and not debate subjects which are not related to the team and how they play.

Racism is a problem, but nowhere near as big a problem as some like to portray.

Football is supposed to be entertainment, and should be treated as such, not to be used to display pointless virtue signalling.

Ukraine demonstrations were obviously fine though.

The bit in bold is always the funniest - someone tells you why they're protesting, and the answer is essentially "no you're not".

I'm sure Southgate, Kane and the rest of the national team are really pro 'defund the police' and not just sick of seeing their colleagues abused on social media.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 07 Jun 22 11.06am

Originally posted by A89M

He's done exactly what would have been expected of him considering the fortune of the draws in the knockout stages of both tournaments. Beat the teams we should beat and come close against the better nations, Italy had experienced World Class players across the team and were in great form going into that final, it was always going to be difficult.

I personally believe we have one, maybe two World Class players. Kane being the standout with Foden potentially being the second if he continues to improve. All others are very good players but when you come across Croatia/Italy who have a midfield full of world class players, they can take the game away from you.

We play 352/343 because our most experienced CB pairing are too slow to be left one-on-one.

The media and some fans are starting to remind me of how they were during our golden generation era, we're becoming far to confident with our team when in reality the squad does not match up to the top nations,, France, Brazil, Belgium, etc

You can do what is expected or you, but those Expectations change based on your current situations.
Woefully naïve vs an ageing Croatian side, which I can forgive as we were a young side then.
But in a winning position vs Italy, screaming for changes as Italy freshened their side, only one thing was going to happen - harder to forgive. I'd be expecting to win that one especially after the 1st half performance.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate Sacked ?