You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mcarthur injured - to miss start of new season
November 16 2026 3.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mcarthur injured - to miss start of new season


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Jul 22 2.09pm

Originally posted by YT

WTF are you talking about? If you actually read the posts from 3 weeks ago, someone said that he deserves a contract extension based on his past contribution. I agreed with another poster that to pay a player on that basis is madness. I never even mentioned Jimmy Mac. If he does have a valued contribution to make in future, then that's fine; but that's not what I was commenting on.

Oh well, excuse me. The thread was specifically about Jimmy Mac so hence my assumption you were sticking to the subject matter.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 31 Jul 22 2.29pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Oh well, excuse me. The thread was specifically about Jimmy Mac so hence my assumption you were sticking to the subject matter.

What, after following this site for 20 years?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 31 Jul 22 3.15pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Oh well, excuse me. The thread was specifically about Jimmy Mac so hence my assumption you were sticking to the subject matter.

I've been thinking about visiting Cumbria for a while.

 


Red and Blue Army!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Jul 22 4.03pm

Originally posted by JRW2

What, after following this site for 20 years?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 31 Jul 22 5.58pm

Luka, Schlupp and Hughes are not adequate longer term replacements for McArthur in my view.
Luka and Hughes don't play with McArthur's intensity or energy and while Schlupp has good athleticism he doesn't have McArthur's nous or all round game.
He has very good moments and can do a job in midfield,but can look like a square peg in a round hole.
This is not a criticism of Schlupp.
He was never used in central midfield until he joined us.
It's not going to be an easy task to replace McArthur.
I like Tielemans who has similar all round attributes to McArthur although I recognise such a move would be a non starter.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 31 Jul 22 7.40pm

Originally posted by JRW2

What, after following this site for 20 years?

Not quite, still got 2 months to go, still, if you have to resort to time insults, you've(imo) lost your argument. Sad really.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

sprites Flag Auckland 31 Jul 22 9.07pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

No he didn't, too old and injury prone, sentimental hogwash

You've posted some terrible rubbish on here in your time, Lanzon. But this takes the cake. Diabolical viewpoint and post. McArthur's an absolute legend and still puts in more of a shift at 30 something than most 20 year olds.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jul 22 9.37pm

Originally posted by sprites

You've posted some terrible rubbish on here in your time, Lanzon. But this takes the cake. Diabolical viewpoint and post. McArthur's an absolute legend and still puts in more of a shift at 30 something than most 20 year olds.


"still..."?
That was the case until his injury last November. Since then his injury record has become worrisome and it was always going to be a gamble to offer him the extra year. It doesn't look as if it's a gamble that will pay off. He looked well off the pace when he did play some minutes in pre-season before getting injured again.

I don't expect him to feature much during this season as I think he'll struggle to get up to match fitness again.

Yes, he's been a great servant for Palace and I shall miss his
battling qualities in midfield. I hope he does well in whatever role/career he takes on after he leaves us.

Finally, whilst I wouldn't go so far as Lanzo in his response to the poster, I would agree with him that it wasn't a case of McArthur 'deserving' an extension.

 

OldFella Flag London 31 Jul 22 11.41pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

No he didn't, too old and injury prone, sentimental hogwash

How's that incisive book of yours coming on, little chap?

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

sprites Flag Auckland 31 Jul 22 11.43pm

Originally posted by doombear


"still..."?
That was the case until his injury last November. Since then his injury record has become worrisome and it was always going to be a gamble to offer him the extra year. It doesn't look as if it's a gamble that will pay off. He looked well off the pace when he did play some minutes in pre-season before getting injured again.

I don't expect him to feature much during this season as I think he'll struggle to get up to match fitness again.

Yes, he's been a great servant for Palace and I shall miss his
battling qualities in midfield. I hope he does well in whatever role/career he takes on after he leaves us.

Finally, whilst I wouldn't go so far as Lanzo in his response to the poster, I would agree with him that it wasn't a case of McArthur 'deserving' an extension.

Yes, 'still' meant generally as a player in his 30s running rings around players in their 20s. Which has been the case over the last few seasons.

If the club had given him a three-year contract, I'd raise an eyebrow. But for me, he's still well worth a year extension. And aside from his capabilities on the field, he's by all accounts a big character off the field. Spent time as captain last season. Players like that, who set high standards, are worth having around. One year extension was the right call, for me.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Aug 22 9.29am

Originally posted by sprites

Yes, 'still' meant generally as a player in his 30s running rings around players in their 20s. Which has been the case over the last few seasons.

If the club had given him a three-year contract, I'd raise an eyebrow. But for me, he's still well worth a year extension. And aside from his capabilities on the field, he's by all accounts a big character off the field. Spent time as captain last season. Players like that, who set high standards, are worth having around. One year extension was the right call, for me.

i'd agree. A fit Macca still gets into the 1st X1 so his extension was justified. He just needs to stay fit - maybe he was rushed back a little early as the same injury has flared up??

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Aug 22 9.50am

Originally posted by doombear


"still..."?
That was the case until his injury last November. Since then his injury record has become worrisome and it was always going to be a gamble to offer him the extra year. It doesn't look as if it's a gamble that will pay off. He looked well off the pace when he did play some minutes in pre-season before getting injured again.

I don't expect him to feature much during this season as I think he'll struggle to get up to match fitness again.

Yes, he's been a great servant for Palace and I shall miss his
battling qualities in midfield. I hope he does well in whatever role/career he takes on after he leaves us.

Finally, whilst I wouldn't go so far as Lanzo in his response to the poster, I would agree with him that it wasn't a case of McArthur 'deserving' an extension.

Coaching WITH us I hope. A natural leader.

Edited by silvertop (01 Aug 2022 9.50am)

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Aug 22 9.59am

When asked about McArthur, Vieira said they should know the extent of the injury today but hoped it wouldn't be too serious.
Does anyone know whether he's having a recurrence of the same injury or whether it's a series of smaller injuries?
If it's the same injury it strikes me that he's not fully recovering and aggravating the injury each time he returns and it could be another stop/start season for him.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 Aug 22 10.26am

McArthur is a big talker on the pitch and leads by example as well. Until his injury last season he was one of our best players. Since then he's struggled to get a run of games. I definitely think a new deal was the right move even ignoring sentimental reasons as he exemplifies what a footballer should be and that is important in an increasingly youthful squad, a bit like Noble was in the last few seasons at Spam.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 01 Aug 22 12.43pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Not quite, still got 2 months to go, still, if you have to resort to time insults, you've(imo) lost your argument. Sad really.

What on earth has upset you? What insults, what argument? My mock-question was made in jest, and the poster to whom it was addressed, NEILLO, made it clear by his response that he took it in that cheerful spirit. If my post saddened you, I'm sorry.

 

fishbone Flag London 03 Aug 22 7.57am

Oh no not Mac he will be sourly missed.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Aug 22 8.30am

Stats suggest the reality: whereby he used to be a mainstay in the midfield, for the last two seasons he has appeared 18 and 21 times in the league respectively, in addition to which he hasn't scored either in each of those seasons. To imagine the he is an essential part of the midfield these days is deluded thinking; he is in the twilight of his PL career and this season will probably be his last at this level.
Nevertheless, a great pro for the club and maybe there will be a space for him somewhere in the coaching set up should he so wish to go down that route.

 

VKR1888 Flag London 08 Aug 22 4.40pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

McArthur is a big talker on the pitch and leads by example as well. Until his injury last season he was one of our best players. Since then he's struggled to get a run of games. I definitely think a new deal was the right move even ignoring sentimental reasons as he exemplifies what a footballer should be and that is important in an increasingly youthful squad, a bit like Noble was in the last few seasons at Spam.

We would not have lost the first goal on Friday if he was playing. He would have had players actually in positions that made sense and would have got a grip of that midfield.

Sorely missed while he is injured.

 

YT Flag Oxford 08 Aug 22 5.13pm

Originally posted by fishbone

Oh no not Mac he will be sourly missed.

Yes, it will be a bitter pill to swallow.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 08 Aug 22 6.15pm

Originally posted by YT

Yes, it will be a bitter pill to swallow.

An I seed he was doing so well last season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mcarthur injured - to miss start of new season