You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Nunez head butt!
November 16 2026 3.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Nunez head butt!


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 17 Aug 22 11.24am

Originally posted by Barcelona eagle

Not sure if you have seen the video on twitter, but Anderson was all over him the whole time, pushing, pulling, using the dark arts, almost Latin in his approach to defending, Nuñez could say he was provoked. Imagine if someone pushed and barged you for 50 minutes. brilliant defending from Anderson though

I have the words 'It's a contact sport' ringing in my years from my youth.

To go with the analogy, if someone was dancing next to you on a dancefloor and kept bumping into you, flailing their arms about (as part of their 'dancing' for however long, whilst it may well provoke an incredible urge to hurt them deliberately, you would still be in trouble for any very deliberate assault. There's a difference between identifying someone as a c**t, cleverly getting back at them yourself and blatantly assaulting them. I actually had it once at an England game with some very Mancunian (not sure) sounding bods who were a bit feisty in getting in and getting caught in what I would call a 'shuffling war' as we jostled for space upon entering. Both sides were obviously peeved, my back had certainly arched, however the first to throw would have certainly be deemed the culprit of something more extreme.


Nothing Andersen did warranted any severe punishment either inside or outside of the playing field. It's a defenders job to stop, put off a striker or throw him off his game. Even if Nunez did a 'Zlatan-esque' elbow to the head in the guise of competing for a header, that would be of less condemnation than the incident.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 17 Aug 22 11.26am


fighting/Brawling/Punching/Headbutting is not Sportsmanlike behaviour, and so should be treated as such.

That being said, it's a very dangerous road to begin on to get outside authorities involved in prosecution of such acts. As soon as the money grabbing lawyers have a precedent, they'll start prosecuting for everything, first the outright displays of violence, then The 'Reckless' challenges, then the accidentals.

THAT being Said. If someone gets Seriously injured or even dies in a fight, then it'd be negligent for the police not to investigate.

So there has to be a line where external authorities are called in. There's only so much a club can (and wants) to do against their costly and prized asset. The reality is that the clubs (and the FA) want the stars playing if it means they're more likely to win football matches, regardless of their on field 'behaviour' - so the punishment rarely fits the crime.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 17 Aug 22 11.35am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I have the words 'It's a contact sport' ringing in my years from my youth.

To go with the analogy, if someone was dancing next to you on a dancefloor and kept bumping into you, flailing their arms about (as part of their 'dancing' for however long, whilst it may well provoke an incredible urge to hurt them deliberately, you would still be in trouble for any very deliberate assault. There's a difference between identifying someone as a c**t, cleverly getting back at them yourself and blatantly assaulting them. I actually had it once at an England game with some very Mancunian (not sure) sounding bods who were a bit feisty in getting in and getting caught in what I would call a 'shuffling war' as we jostled for space upon entering. Both sides were obviously peeved, my back had certainly arched, however the first to throw would have certainly be deemed the culprit of something more extreme.


Nothing Andersen did warranted any severe punishment either inside or outside of the playing field. It's a defenders job to stop, put off a striker or throw him off his game. Even if Nunez did a 'Zlatan-esque' elbow to the head in the guise of competing for a header, that would be of less condemnation than the incident.

Football is not A Contact Sport. never has been.
It's a Partial Contact sport, in that Contact is not in the Rules of the game(a la rugby), but it is Inevitable.

Strictly speaking all 'Contact' in football should be 'accidental'. That is why you can't go 'through a player' when tackling, and you should be 'playing the ball'.
The amount of Grappling/Tugging/holding/Barging and Hugging that goes on in a the Penalty areas is not really allowed, but is accepted for the flow of the game. That and it is too hard to officiate effectively.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Casual Flag Orpington 17 Aug 22 11.49am

With Anderson’s range of long passing (best in the league for a center back in my opinion), if he has now gained a nasty streak.Add a few goals , he could play for any team in the league.
Great buy.

 

YT Flag Oxford 17 Aug 22 11.54am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Football is not A Contact Sport. never has been.
It's a Partial Contact sport, in that Contact is not in the Rules of the game(a la rugby), but it is Inevitable.

Strictly speaking all 'Contact' in football should be 'accidental'. That is why you can't go 'through a player' when tackling, and you should be 'playing the ball'.
The amount of Grappling/Tugging/holding/Barging and Hugging that goes on in a the Penalty areas is not really allowed, but is accepted for the flow of the game. That and it is too hard to officiate effectively.

Au contraire. Have you not heard of the shoulder charge?

Edited by YT (17 Aug 2022 11.54am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 17 Aug 22 12.31pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Football is not A Contact Sport. never has been.
It's a Partial Contact sport, in that Contact is not in the Rules of the game(a la rugby), but it is Inevitable.

Strictly speaking all 'Contact' in football should be 'accidental'. That is why you can't go 'through a player' when tackling, and you should be 'playing the ball'.
The amount of Grappling/Tugging/holding/Barging and Hugging that goes on in a the Penalty areas is not really allowed, but is accepted for the flow of the game. That and it is too hard to officiate effectively.

[Link]

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 22 1.31pm

Originally posted by YT

Au contraire. Have you not heard of the shoulder charge?

Edited by YT (17 Aug 2022 11.54am)

I believe it was barge.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 17 Aug 22 1.43pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I believe it was barge.

People may have mistakenly called it a barge, however:

[Link]

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 17 Aug 22 1.44pm

not sure that article has convinced me...

yes, I forgot about the Shoulder Barge, so in that respect I'd have to concede it is. But that is the only instance that it is allowed.


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Aug 22 1.52pm

Dixie Dean(Everton?) scored 60/62 goals in one season many, many, moons ago. Most of those were when he shoulder barged the 'keeper into the net.

A poster earlier in the thread said that all the 'argy-bargy' that goes on in the penalty box, can't be policed by the ref, yes it can, it just needs a brave ref to give a pen(both ends) & for other refs to follow suit & it will soon stop. Bit like refs now allowing the game to flow a lot more & the likes of JA not getting his squillions of free-kicks per game.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 17 Aug 22 1.56pm

Originally posted by pax3908

If that head butt had occured in the local night club or pub,there would have been all sorts of reaction along the lines of the culprit being arrested and charged etc etc,why is it then acceptable to deal with this offence by internal discipline when it is clearly an offence that should be dealt with by the police,what kind of example does it give to population if there is one rule for footballers and everyone else is treated differently,it is about time this was dealt with by criminal prosecution route!!

Nonsense to suggest police should be involved with a relatively minor on field altercation. Had it got out of hand resulting in a serious injury then I might agree. Professional football is physical and emotive and these types of incidents happen most weekend across the professional leagues in England.

However, I do think the aggressive nature of the headbutt should be more than the standard 3 match ban.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Aug 22 2.21pm

Nunez is Uraguayan. South American football is full of ruff tuff centre halves who dish it out. His reaction was more due to his frustration at his piss poor performance.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 17 Aug 22 3.35pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Dixie Dean(Everton?) scored 60/62 goals in one season many, many, moons ago. Most of those were when he shoulder barged the 'keeper into the net.

Like Nat Lofthouse, who got his second goal for Bolton in the 1958 Cup Final against Manchester United in exactly that way. It can be viewed on Google and to a modern observer looks utterly shocking, but obviously was within the laws. In fact, opposition players were allowed to barge the goalie whenever he had the ball in his hands, thus putting him under serious pressure when he was trying to kick out. Are those things still within the laws?

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 17 Aug 22 3.45pm

Football is self ruling and would give larger fines and bans , all sport that involves contact of sorts is self ruled and offences are dealt with .

People who think that the police should get involved are woke mustn't do this mustn't do that for god sake lets not breath that is the way this world is going ,

if weekend players do what nunez did ref sends off and you get a ban if its a serous act then the police get involved and you are banned for life also then face criminal charges , so was it bad not really so why do you need police to get involved

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 17 Aug 22 3.51pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Did anyone else notice what provoked Anderson into pushing him?

I thought Nunez had tried to headbutt him in the previous tussle, but missed, and this angered Anderson.

If I am right, then I suspect his suspension may be quite a long one as it wasn't simply a reaction to a push, but part of a pattern.

My take was an elbow prior to the cross that came in to their eventual goalscorer. It wasn't clear from highlights, but Nunez seemed to throw his elbow into JA's chest to steal a march on him, but it was moot as the cross was nowhere near them. Andersen reacted understandably, but unprofessionally and the rest is history.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Aug 22 4.10pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Did anyone else notice what provoked Anderson into pushing him?

I thought Nunez had tried to headbutt him in the previous tussle, but missed, and this angered Anderson.

If I am right, then I suspect his suspension may be quite a long one as it wasn't simply a reaction to a push, but part of a pattern.

Yes it was but many in the media are seemingly ignoring that

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 17 Aug 22 4.11pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Like Nat Lofthouse, who got his second goal for Bolton in the 1958 Cup Final against Manchester United in exactly that way. It can be viewed on Google and to a modern observer looks utterly shocking, but obviously was within the laws. In fact, opposition players were allowed to barge the goalie whenever he had the ball in his hands, thus putting him under serious pressure when he was trying to kick out. Are those things still within the laws?

No they are not. Simple.

Also Andy Gray for Everton in the FA Cup final against Watford (1984?). His winning goal was a thundercrack on their keeper. Should never have stood.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Aug 22 4.11pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Yep, think that has been well documented WE.

I suspect Andersen was doing nothing out of the ordinary by giving Nunez a tough time and using a bit of physicality and that Nunez's first attempts of sticking his head in Andersen's face was the initial reaction which provoked Andersen to (rightly) remonstrate somewhat and shove Nunez's outstretched arm which in turn led to 'the' headbutt.

Again, as has been mentioned by many, I am sure this has not gone unnoted by many a PL defender as an expose of Nunez's fragility and inability to handle a bit of 'rough-housing' and his 'red card' mishandling of the situation.

There was also quite a nasty foul on Andersen in the first half. JA did nothing more than a good PL defender does. Wait until Nunez comes up against Leeds!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Aug 22 4.15pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Dixie Dean(Everton?) scored 60/62 goals in one season many, many, moons ago. Most of those were when he shoulder barged the 'keeper into the net.

A poster earlier in the thread said that all the 'argy-bargy' that goes on in the penalty box, can't be policed by the ref, yes it can, it just needs a brave ref to give a pen(both ends) & for other refs to follow suit & it will soon stop. Bit like refs now allowing the game to flow a lot more & the likes of JA not getting his squillions of free-kicks per game.

The challenge that resulted in Bert Trautman breaking his neck, comes to mind ( I have on,y seen it on film)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Aug 22 4.16pm

Originally posted by pstrutt

My take was an elbow prior to the cross that came in to their eventual goalscorer. It wasn't clear from highlights, but Nunez seemed to throw his elbow into JA's chest to steal a march on him, but it was moot as the cross was nowhere near them. Andersen reacted understandably, but unprofessionally and the rest is history.

You are wrong, he did “rub” his head into Andersen’s face at 1min 10. Also watch the tackle at 26 seconds. Absolutely schooled by JA, a masterclass

[Link]

Edited by Spiderman (17 Aug 2022 4.22pm)

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Nunez head butt!