This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
The problem with this is that, the same idiots are making the decisions Yep very true. Unfortunately the incompetency of officiating in football for me has been ever present. It is as though they've all read the book and done the course however never played the game in their lives.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
The problem with this is that, the same idiots are making the decisions Which is why I prefer the 'buffer' for offside It's one less complicated decision for them to make; any doubt, then it's the onfield decision. Edited by CrazyBadger (05 Sep 2022 2.02pm)
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
The implementation is shocking. We were certainly fortunate on Saturday, but I've seen far worse VAR decisions which didn't hit the headlines. Said it before and I will again... Scrap it for normal play and give each captain 1 review per game to be used on penalty/goal/red card incidents. Captain will keep the review if they correctly overturn the decision. 20 second limit to review from two angles - shouldn't need more time than that to spot a 'clear and obvious' error. VAR was introduced to prevent phantom goal situations and clear errors which might realistically happen 5 times a season. Not interfering with every goal incident. Can't celebrate goals anymore. Hate it. Retrospective bands for diving should also be reintroduced. Good idea, but never implemented properly. I know a gentleman who detests VAR and seemingly every conversation I have with him contains a diatribe from this chap expressing his view in forthright fashion. One of the issues he has raised concerning the celebration of goals with players and supporters unsure if a goal is to be awarded, often having to endure a break in play whilst the referee is waiting for the dialogue from the VAR.In bygone days one simply had to look at the referee's signal confirming the goal. He also expressed the view that the authorities over the years have tried to aid the flow of the game citing the back pass to the goalkeeper and the multi-ball system yet now the game is interrupted by the referee having to wait for the VAR and in some instances having to refer to the pitchside monitor. He has also asserted that in bygone days one found fault with the decisions of the referee, now fault is found not only with the referee but the VAR.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
Which is why I prefer the 'buffer' for offside It's one less complicated decision for them to make; any doubt, then it's the onfield decision. Edited by CrazyBadger (05 Sep 2022 2.02pm) The trouble with a 'buffer' is where does the buffer end? The offside rule in theory is very black and white - as is the line call in a tennis match. We just need to keep it simple - using the end of the foot is the obvious solution. It becomes a total nonsense when we start using shoulders/arms etc. As per my previous comment, only refer to the offside VAR if the linesman's decision was challenged.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yep very true. Unfortunately the incompetency of officiating in football for me has been ever present. It is as though they've all read the book and done the course however never played the game in their lives. Nic, as i have been a ref & then an assessor, ex-players are not suited to be refs(too old). IF, someone wants to become an 'Elite' ref ie: EPL/UEFA/FIFA standard, they will have to start at 14yo & then have to go through all the age groups in their County system & hope they shine & progress up the ladder enough to further their careers. An 'Elite' ref in England has to retire at 54, when i was reffing it was 48, Collina in Italy had to retire at 42. So, therefore, ex-players are no way suited to become on field refs, putting them in at Stockley Park would work & should be tried, wether the FA/EPL would allow/try it, remains to be seen.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I think you may be correct on all points . Some very strange comments about taking things forward with the authorities! Edited by Spiderman (05 Sep 2022 1.26pm) Stavely: “But we are dealing with that, talking to officials and we’re trying to get something that we think will work going forward.” WTF does that mean? It almost sounds like NFC are trying to dictate how games are refereed? Parish was unhappy at Man City, had a moan, moved on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
The trouble with a 'buffer' is where does the buffer end? The offside rule in theory is very black and white - as is the line call in a tennis match. We just need to keep it simple - using the end of the foot is the obvious solution. It becomes a total nonsense when we start using shoulders/arms etc. As per my previous comment, only refer to the offside VAR if the linesman's decision was challenged. but it's not Accurate enough. VAR cannot determine the exact point the ball Was kicked. Currently, if the lines are touching it's Onside. so the same would be for the buffer, if the lines touching the buffer then it's the Onfield decision. I think Fans would accept that. Like they do with Cricket, where more than 1/2 the ball needs to be hitting the wicket, else the Umpire's decision stands.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
I honestly thought that both goals disallowed in the chelsea and newcastle game were correct calls. Both keepers were fouled I dont see what the big issue is!
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Stavely: “But we are dealing with that, talking to officials and we’re trying to get something that we think will work going forward.” WTF does that mean? It almost sounds like NFC are trying to dictate how games are refereed? Parish was unhappy at Man City, had a moan, moved on. Your 2nd paragraph were my thoughts exactly. Questions need to be asked about her statement by other clubs. Could backfire, of course, fingers crossed
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Stavely: “But we are dealing with that, talking to officials and we’re trying to get something that we think will work going forward.” WTF does that mean? It almost sounds like NFC are trying to dictate how games are refereed? Parish was unhappy at Man City, had a moan, moved on. Well we can’t have the great new hyped up show time at money bags St James,s spoilt by refs decisions we don’t like, can we. However games are refereed there will be contentious if not bad decisions, and every club gets them. She and shearer obviously think they are a bit different to the rest.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
I honestly thought that both goals disallowed in the chelsea and newcastle game were correct calls. Both keepers were fouled I dont see what the big issue is! Neither do I, in both cases the goalies did not have the ball when they were clattered.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Stavely: “But we are dealing with that, talking to officials and we’re trying to get something that we think will work going forward.” WTF does that mean? It almost sounds like NFC are trying to dictate how games are refereed? Parish was unhappy at Man City, had a moan, moved on. Maybe get a private invitation to the Saudi Embassy and exit in either several pieces of diplomatic baggage, or much richer but ready to make more palatable decisions for our new overlords.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Stavely: “But we are dealing with that, talking to officials and we’re trying to get something that we think will work going forward.” WTF does that mean? It almost sounds like NFC are trying to dictate how games are refereed? Parish was unhappy at Man City, had a moan, moved on. Well Mason, is shelved for a week . But is that because his intervention , has caused massive embarrassment , to the VAR hierarchy .After being chased By Stavely, and her big money backers . More than after all his years in the job not knowing the rules and the evidence of his eyes.?
|
|
|
Anybody else quite fancy Staveley? Surely she'd be on top steering the ship - so to speak.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Nic, as i have been a ref & then an assessor, ex-players are not suited to be refs(too old). IF, someone wants to become an 'Elite' ref ie: EPL/UEFA/FIFA standard, they will have to start at 14yo & then have to go through all the age groups in their County system & hope they shine & progress up the ladder enough to further their careers. An 'Elite' ref in England has to retire at 54, when i was reffing it was 48, Collina in Italy had to retire at 42. So, therefore, ex-players are no way suited to become on field refs, putting them in at Stockley Park would work & should be tried, wether the FA/EPL would allow/try it, remains to be seen. I appreciate that comment Eagleman for insight however I was not suggesting that ex-players are suited to refereeing. My comment is a very subjective observation regarding refereeing as I have witnessed in my life. As an example, shockingly in SE London, I went to a school where Palace fans were at a premium yet 'Man U' fans ran rampant. The typical United fan was the one who couldn't even join in playground football due to lack of ability or experience but could however reel you off every team, their captain and manager in the Moldovan 2nd division. That's the impression I get from many a referee at PL level even in this country. They have studied the game academically but do not 'understand' football at it's core and therefore make bizarre decisions based on 'academic' research. This for me has been further obfuscated by the new and ever changing rules which are determined by those who have no real experience of football, at any level! Hence Bowen being adjudged to have fouled a 6'6 goalkeeper by brushing him with his foot whilst hurdling him (not that I have any condolence for WHU fans) for example, amongst a billion other decisions. Rhubarb!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
Well Mason, is shelved for a week . But is that because his intervention , has caused massive embarrassment , to the VAR hierarchy .After being chased By Stavely, and her big money backers . More than after all his years in the job not knowing the rules and the evidence of his eyes.? Genuine question, no point scoring, but I wonder whether anyone who has argued that VAR and the ref were correct is now having second thoughts, following Mason's suspension. I'd be particularly interested in the views of one of our members (respected by me), who has traditionally been very supportive of officials (to the annoyance of many on here) and who I think expressed his support for them earlier in this thread.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Genuine question, no point scoring, but I wonder whether anyone who has argued that VAR and the ref were correct is now having second thoughts, following Mason's suspension. I'd be particularly interested in the views of one of our members (respected by me), who has traditionally been very supportive of officials (to the annoyance of many on here) and who I think expressed his support for them earlier in this thread. He maybe 'suspended' from all VAR duties this w/e, thats only because he is officiating in the EFL. Oh, & if you Willo, why not say so, that way he can reply Nes Pas?
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Genuine question, no point scoring, but I wonder whether anyone who has argued that VAR and the ref were correct is now having second thoughts, following Mason's suspension. I'd be particularly interested in the views of one of our members (respected by me), who has traditionally been very supportive of officials (to the annoyance of many on here) and who I think expressed his support for them earlier in this thread. I don’t know who you want to hear from. But in answer to your question, I really don’t think so . And this is the problem , you either think Mitchell could have pushed their player not just forward but upwards at a rate of knots, merely by touching him, or you don’t.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
I don’t know who you want to hear from. But in answer to your question, I really don’t think so . And this is the problem , you either think Mitchell could have pushed their player not just forward but upwards at a rate of knots, merely by touching him, or you don’t. I stand by my viewpoint that any contact Mitchell MAY have made with Willock was not sufficient enough to propel him into Guaita who was clearly fouled.Lee Mason with the benefit of VAR and able to review the incident several times concluded there was a foul on the keeper but of course there are polarised views which have been well aired.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.