You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bring back Roy
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bring back Roy


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Oct 22 8.46am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

FFS, our first bad result of the season and we get this trollop….

I personally was one of the few Roy fans on here appreciating that he did a good job with an aged squad - however, it was bloody dull to watch - we all know that.

Fans were saying ‘I don’t mind us losing as long as it’s entertaining’ - bar the last two away games, we’ve been exciting and scoring goals. Can’t please everyone.

On the whole it’s tough to argue that PV has done anything but a fantastic job. We look thin in CM and have no LB cover - is that PV’s fault or recruitment? I’d agree that trying to fit in Zaha/Eze/Olise/Ayew/striker in the same 11 appears an odd move, but equally it could eventually prove to be a stroke of genius if he can find a way to effectively accommodate all those players in the same line up.

I for one am very happy with the PV and the squads progress so far. We’ll finish in our usual mid table position this season but we’ll have some decent performances along the way, rather than grinding out undeserved points like we did under Roy.

The squad is young but improving with experience. We’re going in the right direction

In the last 5 seasons we have finished between 11th and 14th in the PL and I for one believe we will finish below 14th this campaign, in actual fact I would not be surprised if we ended the season in the bottom 3.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 Oct 22 9.07am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

FFS, our first bad result of the season and we get this trollop….

I personally was one of the few Roy fans on here appreciating that he did a good job with an aged squad - however, it was bloody dull to watch - we all know that.

Fans were saying ‘I don’t mind us losing as long as it’s entertaining’ - bar the last two away games, we’ve been exciting and scoring goals. Can’t please everyone.

On the whole it’s tough to argue that PV has done anything but a fantastic job. We look thin in CM and have no LB cover - is that PV’s fault or recruitment? I’d agree that trying to fit in Zaha/Eze/Olise/Ayew/striker in the same 11 appears an odd move, but equally it could eventually prove to be a stroke of genius if he can find a way to effectively accommodate all those players in the same line up.

I for one am very happy with the PV and the squads progress so far. We’ll finish in our usual mid table position this season but we’ll have some decent performances along the way, rather than grinding out undeserved points like we did under Roy.

The squad is young but improving with experience. We’re going in the right direction

Well said.

Like you, I defended Roy to the hilt on here. His methods were a means to an end, with the objective of keeping us competitive without any major investment in players.

But with the loosening of the purse strings, it was time to move forward in a different direction. PV's preferred style of play has been a radical departure and was bound to have some bumps in the road. Now is not the time to get misty eyed about someone that the majority were glad to see the back of.

Pundits, Media, Fans and PV himself are of the view that the squad is lightweight. The known issue in midfield was highlighted on Saturday where we just didn't compete.

At the risk of repeating myself, Potter's Brighton team struggled for the first two seasons under him. In the third season, with the help of some decent recruitment, they flourished. I'm expecting similar from Palace.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Oct 22 9.37am

Originally posted by Badger11

I don't think any of us were happy with yesterday but the OP seems to forget we had plenty of those performances under Roy.

Think he has forgotten the 7-0 at home to Liverpool under Roy.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Oct 22 9.51am

By the final season of Roy's tenure I was not enjoying watching Palace at all. Even the wins often felt like defeats because the performances were so negative. He was the pragmatic manager we needed due to our limited investment in the squad, but to suggest anyone would want him back baffles me.

Everton was a shocker, but it's the only game we've lost to a team outside the top four. If it really is about results and not performances then Vieira is doing a great job. If it is about performances then I think you would struggle to find someone who doesn't think we are playing better football under Vieira.

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 24 Oct 22 11.35am

Originally posted by VinceHilaire

I was at the game - I can assure you all the Palace team looked gutted with both their performances and result. It could be the ‘reality kick’ they need to ensure we push on and get some more points before the World Cup starts.

PV is doing a great job with the squad available to him…


Maybe this could be our Bournemouth 9-0 moment. Sometimes you can drift a little and think it's all gong well. We had done quite well uo to the weekends match. Now we know there are some issues to address in January if we really want to go anywhere this season.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 24 Oct 22 1.16pm

Originally posted by Painter

Think he has forgotten the 7-0 at home to Liverpool under Roy.

We took a few good hidings in Roy’s last year or so, we even managed to get totally outclassed by Villa and Leeds away, much as l loved Roy for what he did for a couple or 3 years and him being a gent, it had got just too painful to watch and once we started leaking goals as well, his time had definitely come, so anyone who wants him back is one sandwich short of a picnic I’m afraid

 

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 24 Oct 22 1.22pm

Bring back Frank de Boer! It makes about as much sense as bringing back Roy at the moment.

Personally, I liked Roy. Yeah, it was boring at times, but he kept us in this division and arguably built the bedrock that enabled PV to have the cash to buy players. I've no doubt that some of our investment came through us being in this league for a good long time, as the likes of Textor haven't invested because they're fans.

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

Johng Flag 24 Oct 22 1.50pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Roy had a far more limited team to select from PV has the best players since being in Prem.

Look at last season Wolves didn't score many but also stopped other scoring which resulted in the high league position.

It's not only one game we have been poor this season and did you forget about Leicester game a team which has the worst record in the league we didn't even try to beat them.

Open style only at the back going forward we are still poor making same mistakes slow build up players holding onto ball too long not getting quick balls into box.

We should be counter attacking teams quickly when we tried to do this look how it works the same with putting balls in box quickly yet we like to play this side to side and backwards passing game which is dull and gets possessions stats up but nothing else.

More excuses from you so we was missing one player who is not a "super star" it would have made no difference the tactics plus selection was all wrong.

This game we should have played a pairing of something like Hughes and Milo also Mitchell needs dropping Ried looked better when he came of the bench the other day why not give him a chance.

The manager is not even trying other players out this is whats annoying.

If the manager doesn't get positive results in the next few games really do need to consider other options (SP appears to like Dyche and we had been linked with him before could be the next manager)

This is absolutely correct and I couldn't have put it better myself and why on earth hasn't Malcolm Ebiowei been given a start yet?

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 27 Oct 22 5.59am

Originally posted by Johng

This is absolutely correct and I couldn't have put it better myself and why on earth hasn't Malcolm Ebiowei been given a start yet?

Whilst Ebiowei has looked exciting in YouTube videos and shown some glimpses of magic, with respect, PV watches him daily in training and knows all the players abilities and where they fit into his style of play and tactics far better than you and I. When ME is ready for a start, he will be selected.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 27 Oct 22 7.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

In the last 5 seasons we have finished between 11th and 14th in the PL and I for one believe we will finish below 14th this campaign, in actual fact I would not be surprised if we ended the season in the bottom 3.

Same

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 Oct 22 8.17pm

Do we know Roy's current situation?

I read that he retired from football management in May 2022 after Watford.

I would be surprised if he is not involved in football in some way.

 

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 28 Oct 22 9.21am

Anyone who's thinking he should return and has forgotten how terrible we were, should remember his even worse spell at Watford where he continued to make the same mistakes.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Oct 22 9.58am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Do we know Roy's current situation?

I read that he retired from football management in May 2022 after Watford.

I would be surprised if he is not involved in football in some way.

He's captain of Lewisham Borough's U'90s 1st XI.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 28 Oct 22 10.22am

If we are looking at bringing anyone back then we should look no further than one of our most successful managers on a % win/lose /draw basis ever. He is still in management and available.

Bring back Steve Bruce!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Oct 22 12.43pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

He's captain of Lewisham Borough's U'90s 1st XI.

Joe Biden had better hurry up with his move to Catford if he wants to play in honour of his heroes Lee Anne O'Brady and Frank Staplegun.

 

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 28 Oct 22 6.06pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

If we are looking at bringing anyone back then we should look no further than one of our most successful managers on a % win/lose /draw basis ever. He is still in management and available.

Bring back Steve Bruce!

Ha ha. He's a bigger mercenary than Tony Pulis

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 28 Oct 22 6.15pm

I think the OP might have been referring to Roy Castle or Roy Rogers or Jenkins.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 28 Oct 22 6.27pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I think the OP might have been referring to Roy Castle or Roy Rogers or Jenkins.

More like Roy of the Rovers!

I really don't know why I've contributed to this ridiculous thread, but hey!

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bring back Roy