This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Is the old Luka back?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
waddy Highton,Melbourne 30 Oct 22 2.06pm |
|
|
1st half was Brilliant- 2nd half woeful- Everton play came back The attacking from Wilf/Olise/Ebbs/Ward/Mitchell was non stop. Yet Our Midfield is under utilized as them players are defensively minded.
Milo played “ok” but his mistakes came back 3 times where he allowed them shooting opportunities- plus in 2nd half he did not take command like a captain should Soton were all over us. Viera made changes that I think he only needed to make one - Luka no one else And switch Wilf & Ed over
Milo needs to be sold ! Along with Ward and lazy lazy Ayew - We walks on pitch like he’s been out all night - then he gives the ball away & strolls back - god damn lazy I would have subbed him back off !
Forever Palace Proud
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Oct 22 3.07pm |
|
Originally posted by waddy
1st half was Brilliant- 2nd half woeful- Everton play came back The attacking from Wilf/Olise/Ebbs/Ward/Mitchell was non stop. Yet Our Midfield is under utilized as them players are defensively minded.
Milo played “ok” but his mistakes came back 3 times where he allowed them shooting opportunities- plus in 2nd half he did not take command like a captain should Soton were all over us. Viera made changes that I think he only needed to make one - Luka no one else And switch Wilf & Ed over
Milo needs to be sold ! Along with Ward and lazy lazy Ayew - We walks on pitch like he’s been out all night - then he gives the ball away & strolls back - god damn lazy I would have subbed him back off !
I was at the game and it seems we watched different games or at least saw the game differently. 1. Ayew was not lazy. His work during the final 25 minutes or so enabled us to get the ball forward. Indeed, he won the corner for us that resulted in the last play of the game, not to mention a couple of fouls that helped us re-organize. 2. Edouard was virtually dead on his feet by 60-65 minutes - he had to come off for someone with fresh legs and energy. Several people in my area of the ground were calling for PV to make that change at least 10 minutes before he did. It was obvious Edouard had run himself into the ground. Our front 4/5 put a lot into the first half with the high press we put on Soton. 3. Luka needed defensive support towards the end of the 2nd half - not replacing. He got that support in the form of Hughes and then Riedewald and we saw the game out.
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 30 Oct 22 3.52pm |
|
|
Saints were absolutely terrible first half.... losing the ball, snapping under pressure... sure this performance would have done him good, but any other prep team on form would have worried him..... and me
This was once a quality forum....
|
Gribbo Bromley 30 Oct 22 5.02pm |
|
|
To answer your question, no.
Got caught on the ball again yesterday like he did for the first goal at Everton. Lying face down thumping the ground is not an appropriate response.
Passing abysmal, as evidenced by the Edouard booking.
Freekicks as dreadful as ever.
Too slow, sits too deep. Southampton bossing midfield until Hughes came on in the second half.
Good enough in his day, sadly that day is gone. Should have kept Kouyate, or made a better fist of bringing in Flynn Downes. Need 1 or 2 decent midfielders to replace Luka and the injury prone Jimmy Mac. Nobody currently in the academy who seems to be able to step up.
|
dg1937 30 Oct 22 5.02pm |
|
|
Mind boggling that anyone can describe Ayew as ‘lazy’!
|
Gribbo Bromley 30 Oct 22 5.03pm |
|
|
Meant to add, it's Patrick's position, so you think he would be able to figure it out.
|
Spiderman Horsham 30 Oct 22 5.35pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
I was at the game and it seems we watched different games or at least saw the game differently. 1. Ayew was not lazy. His work during the final 25 minutes or so enabled us to get the ball forward. Indeed, he won the corner for us that resulted in the last play of the game, not to mention a couple of fouls that helped us re-organize. 2. Edouard was virtually dead on his feet by 60-65 minutes - he had to come off for someone with fresh legs and energy. Several people in my area of the ground were calling for PV to make that change at least 10 minutes before he did. It was obvious Edouard had run himself into the ground. Our front 4/5 put a lot into the first half with the high press we put on Soton. 3. Luka needed defensive support towards the end of the 2nd half - not replacing. He got that support in the form of Hughes and then Riedewald and we saw the game out.
Absolutely spot on
|
Spiderman Horsham 30 Oct 22 5.35pm |
|
Originally posted by dg1937
Mind boggling that anyone can describe Ayew as ‘lazy’!
Indeed
|
Spiderman Horsham 30 Oct 22 5.38pm |
|
Originally posted by Gribbo
To answer your question, no.
Got caught on the ball again yesterday like he did for the first goal at Everton. Lying face down thumping the ground is not an appropriate response.
Passing abysmal, as evidenced by the Edouard booking.
Freekicks as dreadful as ever.
Too slow, sits too deep. Southampton bossing midfield until Hughes came on in the second half.
Good enough in his day, sadly that day is gone. Should have kept Kouyate, or made a better fist of bringing in Flynn Downes. Need 1 or 2 decent midfielders to replace Luka and the injury prone Jimmy Mac. Nobody currently in the academy who seems to be able to step up.
TBF I think we did all we could with Downes. Media videos done etc. The fact his agent is the daughter of WH assistant manager, they would have got inside knowledge of deal + Downes is WH fan. I am happy to criticise our recruitment policy but not over this. However perhaps we should have paid what Ipswich wanted
Edited by Spiderman (30 Oct 2022 5.38pm)
|
redshift Toronto 30 Oct 22 6.32pm |
|
|
To be fair he had a few good games last year when subbed on. I think it's correct to say he can't go 90 minutes anymore and definitely can't play back to back games. Probably still useful as a sub if we manage his minutes. My problem with this is we have MacArthur in the same situation. We're getting to the point where our midfield, particularly our DCM staff, just isn't up to the rigours of the game anymore.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.
|
sprites Auckland 30 Oct 22 6.48pm |
|
|
Potentially.
Could it be that actually all he needed was a couple of solid starts under his belt to feel himself again?
Not sure.
Personally I still don't think he's the long term answer. But if we can get more performances like yesterday out of him, we'll have a decent CM on our hands again. His quality has never been in doubt for me.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 30 Oct 22 7.35pm |
|
Originally posted by Badger11
He did well especially in the first half however he tired and I think that is the reason Soton won the second half.
Luka doesn't have the legs for a 90 min performance.
reminds me of Jason Puncheon......a fast & rapid decline.
Not really at Prem level anymore.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 30 Oct 22 7.38pm |
|
Originally posted by dg1937
Mind boggling that anyone can describe Ayew as ‘lazy’!
only a Brighton troll would say that.
Ayew runs his guts out , every game. And makes a ton of tackles. And often seems to get an assist.
Still an Eagle.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
MrWhyNot 30 Oct 22 8.14pm |
|
Originally posted by dg1937
Mind boggling that anyone can describe Ayew as ‘lazy’!
People with nothing to do or say often still find a way to to do so very loudly.
Edited by MrWhyNot (30 Oct 2022 8.15pm)
|
Casual Orpington 30 Oct 22 8.49pm |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
reminds me of Jason Puncheon......a fast & rapid decline.
Not really at Prem level anymore.
Yep. Very similar. Was decent a while ago. 2 Bob now unfortunately, half a game playing ‘less sh*t than expected’ doesn’t make him decent. Was in the Albion when the team was announced , a groan went round the pub.
|
Dubai Eagle 31 Oct 22 6.13am |
|
|
Although PV obviously sees something in him (maybe some of it has been through lack of choice) but he has been bringing him on as sub for some time now & whilst the start on Saturday didnt give any confidence to the faithful (who had fully expected Decoure to return) he didnt let us down -
We have 3 games in just a few days coming up, I wouldn't be at all surprised to see Decoure start the 2 league matches but Luca to come on with 15 minutes to go ( or some combination of Luca & Will Hughes) & for Luca to start & play the whole the cup game-
Its a squad game these days & a manager has to make use of all of his resources in line with the circumstances he finds himself -
I would also expect to see Jairo involved in the Newcastle game.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Oct 22 8.19am |
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Although PV obviously sees something in him (maybe some of it has been through lack of choice) but he has been bringing him on as sub for some time now & whilst the start on Saturday didnt give any confidence to the faithful (who had fully expected Decoure to return) he didnt let us down -
We have 3 games in just a few days coming up, I wouldn't be at all surprised to see Decoure start the 2 league matches but Luca to come on with 15 minutes to go ( or some combination of Luca & Will Hughes) & for Luca to start & play the whole the cup game-
Its a squad game these days & a manager has to make use of all of his resources in line with the circumstances he finds himself -
I would also expect to see Jairo involved in the Newcastle game.
Agreed. Newcastle away will be very difficult (I expect us to lose) and I suspect PV will want to keep his best options for the two PL games so as to give us the best chance of going into the WC break ("World Cup" or "water closet" - take your pick) on a positive note. I'm expecting the game at Newcastle to comprise a starting XI something like this (depending on injuries/fitness).
Johnstone
Clyne/Rodney Tomkins Guehi Riedewald
Milivojevic Phillips Hughes
Ebiowei Mateta Gordon
I suspect there will be several 1st team players who simply won't make the journey, so as to ensure they're fresh for the Forest game (we're playing Sunday - Wednesday - Saturday, so 3 games in 7 days).
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 31 Oct 22 10.46am |
|
|
Yep, hopefully we play a 2nd string at the toon.
They are flying high and will want to keep that winning feeling going. We need to be 100% ready for forest.
And whilst not a great one, we do have a squad so we need to use it.
|
Painter Croydon 31 Oct 22 11.14am |
|
|
He is a decent player and gets unfairly ridiculed. A view from an unbiased report.
[Link]
|
spartakev2 Anerley 31 Oct 22 5.56pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
Agreed. Newcastle away will be very difficult (I expect us to lose) and I suspect PV will want to keep his best options for the two PL games so as to give us the best chance of going into the WC break ("World Cup" or "water closet" - take your pick) on a positive note. I'm expecting the game at Newcastle to comprise a starting XI something like this (depending on injuries/fitness).
Johnstone
Clyne/Rodney Tomkins Guehi Riedewald
Milivojevic Phillips Hughes
Ebiowei Mateta Gordon
I suspect there will be several 1st team players who simply won't make the journey, so as to ensure they're fresh for the Forest game (we're playing Sunday - Wednesday - Saturday, so 3 games in 7 days).
If the team is anything like that, I'll eat my palace bobble hat.
PV will want to do well In the cups, and I see only a couple of changes....
|