You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Andy Madley
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Andy Madley


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
JRW2 Flag Dulwich 04 Jan 23 3.21pm

Originally posted by Willo

Mark was not biased towards any team he made decisions based on his professional judgement.

I have never agreed with the claim that referees are biased - at least not consciously so. But "Mark" behaved disgracefully and utterly unprofessionally before that Cup Final in indulging in a smiling, laughing chat with one manager before the game. Just like a judge having a friendly meeting outside the court room with counsel for one side immediately before a major trial.

But back to the general point. You say that Madley made decisions "based on his professional judgment". Yes, that's what referees do, but that doesn't mean they get everything right, and I think you are at fault in never, ever being willing to admit that a mistake has been made. At least, I have no memory of your ever having done so.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 23 3.30pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I have never agreed with the claim that referees are biased - at least not consciously so. But "Mark" behaved disgracefully and utterly unprofessionally before that Cup Final in indulging in a smiling, laughing chat with one manager before the game. Just like a judge having a friendly meeting outside the court room with counsel for one side immediately before a major trial.

But back to the general point. You say that Madley made decisions "based on his professional judgment". Yes, that's what referees do, but that doesn't mean they get everything right, and I think you are at fault in never, ever being willing to admit that a mistake has been made. At least, I have no memory of your ever having done so.

As I mentioned I am not going to respond to any further comments relating to Mark Clattenburg for the reason I have stated indeed I have already answered all the criticisms labelled against him.

Apropos your general point I have consistently asserted that referees are human beings and as such err from time to time.Madley made decisions based on his professional judgement not because he was biased against either team.

Edited by Willo (04 Jan 2023 3.38pm)

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 04 Jan 23 3.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

As I mentioned I am not going to respond to any further comments relating to Mark Clattenburg for the reason I have stated indeed I have already answered all the criticisms labelled against him.

Apropos your general point I have consistently asserted that referees are human beings and as such err from time to time.Madley made decisions based on his professional judgement not because he was biased against either team.

Edited by Willo (04 Jan 2023 3.38pm)

Well, I must take your word as a gentleman. But, as I said, I have no recollection of your ever having asserted that a referee has "erred".

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Jan 23 4.12pm

Originally posted by Willo



Mark was not biased towards any team he made decisions based on his professional judgement.

I have no more comment to make on any sentiments raised on here apropos Mark as the discussion will only disintegrate into a dastardly Willo thread.Forgive me if do not respond.

"Agreed, in no way was he bias" Sir Alex Ferguson.

 


One more point

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 04 Jan 23 4.32pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

In all fairness Eagleman, I don't think I am 'off the mark'.

The number of 'I could have...' people in this country is staggering. For an anecdote, I was actually scouted by WHU and on the books/played a number of games but broke my arm quite badly whilst playing for Lewisham district, that ended all hope. I would never consider myself as coming that close, quite frankly my PE teacher at school also doubled up as a WHU scout and therefore I was quite fortunate in the first instance. I was the greatest footballer of all time of course however, life, you know.

As for your point apropos bias, I believe this backs up my poorly articulated point and have no problem accepting your commentary as truth. Same with footballers actually. Jamie Redknapp, Frank Lampard etc. etc. The list of footballing dynasties is quite long and I fail to believe that is a genetics and merit over connections 'thing' in fact quite the opposite.

I did say 'I am suspicious' so as not to put forth my little world view as an assertion of fact, it's just how it looks for me. I was sort of alluding to a quasi-cabal of referees, hence both the Madleys being one. That can't just be coincidence/free of other contributors separate from ability. That was sort of my point really, on top of the pool being a lot smaller, I fail to believe it is a pure meritocracy that resultantly produces PL referees.

Combined with poor leadership from governing bodies and a now impractical lawbook, I have very little faith in most PL referees. I therefore reject your attempt to nullify my highly subjective, ill-informed, immature, impetuous digs and belittlement of them! That is my right as a football fan

No problem from me Nick, your right as a football fan should be upheld & applauded, i was just trying in my own way to give my experience as a former ref in reply to your post.

The way the process is nowadays is far removed from 'my time'. Nothing i can say (or post) will ever change peoples perception of referees, just hope some might 'understand' them a bit more.

Either way, lets hope for 3 points tonight & we all have a better day tomorrow

Edited by eagleman13 (04 Jan 2023 4.33pm)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Andy Madley