You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team
November 16 2026 3.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 07 Jan 23 10.40pm

In answer to the original question I think it starts with the team failing to play to the manager's instructions and senior players briefing the Chairman and younger players against the manager.

I've not seen anything on the pitch to suggest that's happening at the moment and the relative lack of "strong" characters has been highlighted already.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 07 Jan 23 10.49pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

I don't need examples. I'm aware of what goes on. It doesn't mean it's right.

It's the board's decision whether the manager should go, not the players. If you want examples, see Manchester United's form since Ronaldo left.

Yes they're high achievers. Yes they're paid millions. They're paid millions to play football for Crystal Palace to the best of their ability. Under a management structure. They're not paid to direct club strategy, or recruit their own bosses. They're not entitled to decide whether the manager is worthy of their effort.

Why are you so confrontational? Asking 'what planet I'm on?' In another thread you stated that someone was talking 'absolute rubbish' after they articulated some perfectly reasonable points. You don't have to agree with what people say, but it's not as if you yourself are anyone of any consequence. You're a complete irrelevance. Show some respect.


Tell this to FDB a few of SP chums who are players moaned he was fired.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

aashman12 Flag 08 Jan 23 10.01am

Originally posted by Qwijibo

Well they need to do what the f***ing manager tells them to do. His managerial CV - not to mention his playing career - is infinitely better than anything any one of those lot has ever achieved.

It's not their choice whether they turn up to work or not.

Zaha was the only one who looked like he gave a s***. And he is unlikely to be here in 6 months.

Today it was like we had a good start, and then just assumed that because it was Southampton that the result was a formality. Then once we conceded, there was zero ability or desire to shift the tide of momentum. And worst of all.... it wasn't as if Southampton ground out a result. They were s***. They are s***. They will be s*** for the remainder of the season. Both their goals were f*** ups from players just playing without the required intensity.

So does that mean they don't respect the manager? I don't know. I don't want to give up on him yet. Where would that leave us?

Eze could be good, Olise could be good, Edouard could be good, but none of them strike me as a leader of men when the going is tough. Where is MacArthur for 2023, or Jedinak, or anyone for that matter who will intimidate the opposition as well as our own players?


Oh, what it would be to have a Bryan Robson, or a Roy Keane in midfield. Or a Vieira.

His managerial cv is pretty thin

 

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Jan 23 10.15am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Complete rubbish, open your eyes, the players are nowhere as bad as the performances, get those PV tinted glasses off

You think eze will win the ballon d'or in 3 years, your judgement on how good our players are is terrible. We've got about 5 regular players who wouldn't get into any other team in the prem, viera needs backing with funds and a chance to build his own team

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 08 Jan 23 2.36pm

Originally posted by rikz

You think eze will win the ballon d'or in 3 years, your judgement on how good our players are is terrible. We've got about 5 regular players who wouldn't get into any other team in the prem, viera needs backing with funds and a chance to build his own team

Name those players if you would.

PV has been backed if he gets more money what would be next excuse someone else purchased those players they are not his.

We are not a top team a manager is expected to use players and get most out of them and add in a few for the style they want PV has had those players.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Croydon-Trucker Flag 08 Jan 23 3.10pm

Tompkins

Reidaweld

Joel Ward , a great servant but the legs have gone

Awew

Luka

Mateta

 

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Jan 23 9.59pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

Name those players if you would.

PV has been backed if he gets more money what would be next excuse someone else purchased those players they are not his.

We are not a top team a manager is expected to use players and get most out of them and add in a few for the style they want PV has had those players.

Mateta, ayew, schlupp, ward, guaita. Clyne and Mitchell are borderline, let's be honest Mitchell would only generate interest because of his age and nationality, lb is a position we could quite easily improve. Then we have numerous squad players we would struggle to give away.

A manager needs 3 seasons, unless they're doing a drastically terrible job which viera isn't then you give them the chance to build their own squad.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 08 Jan 23 10.04pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

Name those players if you would.

PV has been backed if he gets more money what would be next excuse someone else purchased those players they are not his.

We are not a top team a manager is expected to use players and get most out of them and add in a few for the style they want PV has had those players.

Exactly and we are 12th with a game in hand of 5 teams in front of us and only 3 points behind Chelsea. Where do you think we should be ? How many points do you think we should be on ?

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 08 Jan 23 10.18pm

Originally posted by rikz

Exactly and we are 12th with a game in hand of 5 teams in front of us and only 3 points behind Chelsea. Where do you think we should be ? How many points do you think we should be on ?

We should be in the fourth round of the cup with a home tie against Blackpool as that’s what Southampton have got.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 09 Jan 23 1.28am

Originally posted by Qwijibo

I'm asking for some leadership in midfield. Not Roy Keane as manager.

Would Shaun Derry have put up with that s***? Or Jedinak? In days gone past, players with a fraction of the ability of those currently in the side would have done something to increase the collective heart beat, even if it was just Clint Hill booting an opponent. I just feel like there's a lot of shoulder-shrugging and very little examples of anyone taking ownership of the performance.

I agree, there is no leader... milo was way too soft.. and the nonsense of him coming on as a sub and getting the arm band.. what soft nonsense...

the game well be changing, but the desire, spirit and instinct needs to be there...Are we seeing player power where managers are unable to say what they truly feel?

 


This was once a quality forum....

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 09 Jan 23 1.31am

Originally posted by rikz

Exactly and we are 12th with a game in hand of 5 teams in front of us and only 3 points behind Chelsea. Where do you think we should be ? How many points do you think we should be on ?

So performances don't matter to you? It's dropped dramatically of late and better performances often yield better results.. Fulham losing 3 nil? Weakened spurs side thumping us 4-0. Today?
We can handle losses. We can't accept heads gone.

 


This was once a quality forum....

CT Charlie Flag 09 Jan 23 6.20am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

We should be in the fourth round of the cup with a home tie against Blackpool as that’s what Southampton have got.

That's exactly where we would be, except for Guaita's dreadful misplay of two balls, one of which was the result of Ward's embarrassing whiff on a routine header.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 09 Jan 23 7.08am

The way Ward ducked under it I wouldn't be surprised if he got a "Leave it" call from a team mate - I wasn't there & couldn't pick one up from the highlights, did anyone at the game hear anything ?

Originally posted by CT Charlie

That's exactly where we would be, except for Guaita's dreadful misplay of two balls, one of which was the result of Ward's embarrassing whiff on a routine header.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 09 Jan 23 7.55am

Originally posted by Vaibow

So performances don't matter to you? It's dropped dramatically of late and better performances often yield better results.. Fulham losing 3 nil? Weakened spurs side thumping us 4-0. Today?
We can handle losses. We can't accept heads gone.

We prioritised bringing the average age of the squad down, we've got a young team, we are a midtable team in the strongest and most competitive league in the world. We will have poor runs and poor performances. Do you think we are going to play like City every week ?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Jan 23 8.23am

Originally posted by rikz

We prioritised bringing the average age of the squad down, we've got a young team, we are a midtable team in the strongest and most competitive league in the world. We will have poor runs and poor performances. Do you think we are going to play like City every week ?

Regulars Guaita,Ward,Clyne,Schlupp, Ayew and Zaha are in their 30s.
Milivojevic who has mostly been on the bench is in his 30s.
Tomkins who played against Fulham is in his mid-30s.
Overall we don't have a youthful squad !

 

The Dolphin Flag 09 Jan 23 8.23am

To be fair to Vaibow and other posters - it is not about playing like City every week.
We have our own standards and our performances of late have fallen well below those standards.
Losing I can accept - it is the way that we lose that worries me.
PV was a combative midfield player with fire in his belly - that does not seem to be a directive given to some of our players.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Jan 23 8.33am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

To be fair to Vaibow and other posters - it is not about playing like City every week.
We have our own standards and our performances of late have fallen well below those standards.
Losing I can accept - it is the way that we lose that worries me.
PV was a combative midfield player with fire in his belly - that does not seem to be a directive given to some of our players.

Good post, agree.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 09 Jan 23 8.41am

I don't see that PV has '' lost '' the dressing room.

What I do see is an unbalanced squad of players, several of them who are triers but way past their best, combined with some promising younger players that are desperately in need of some on field leadership.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 09 Jan 23 8.52am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I don't see that PV has '' lost '' the dressing room.

What I do see is an unbalanced squad of players, several of them who are triers but way past their best, combined with some promising younger players that are desperately in need of some on field leadership.

Yes, we lack leadership quality. Someone who sets the example week in week out, is respected, and who is not afraid to ruffle feathers.

 

PatrickA Flag London 09 Jan 23 9.41am

I’m not sure it’s a case of Vieira having lost the dressing room.
I occasionally read footballer autobiographies and a common theme seems to be that players who are continually overlooked by managers are understandably unhappy and may spread some poison, there are manager’s favourites (often nicknamed ‘son of the manager’) and those players who are indifferent to who the manager is.

As many have observed on this site we played our best football under Vieira when he was able to field a midfield containing Gallagher , McArthur and Kouyate.
That was a midfield full of energy and zest which meant that we were competitive in every game .
We no longer have this option and I can’t understand why Vieira has continued with his 433 approach when we clearly don’t have these type of players in the squad.
He has on occasions used Olise, Eze and Doucoure in midfield which must be the least competitive midfield in the Premier League.
It will work and be pleasing on the eye on occasions but is destined not to get results as opposition runs won’t be tracked, second balls won’t be won and there will be a lack of the necessary sheer physical intensity .
Vieira was a fantastic player over a long career winning most things and like many on here I can’t understand why he persists with square pegs in round holes.
In the absence of decent midfield options (which I don’t think Vieira can be held responsible for) in my view it would be sensible to play some combination of 442/451 so at least we had the numbers in midfield to compete.
You could even make an argument for 352 if we had proper wing backs which I don’t believe we have.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team