This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yep I do agree hence my caveat. I remember years ago there was a teller of tall tales in a pub I drank in. He had an identical twin and being in the rough ol' land of Lewisham mistakenly took himself for a reincarnation of a Kray. He used to blurt out a lot of fantastical untruths and allude to things in suggestion that he was somehow involved in nefarious, underworld activity and would provide winks and nose-touches as accoutrements as if this would somehow lure you into entertaining his stories. I get the same feeling from these online 'journalists' whenever anything football but especially Palace related is peddled. Not to say they all are of course, some must be genuine but I suspect there's enough of them out there and most sway into this bracket. 'Read into that what you will' is my usual line.
In life, as in football, I'm always on the victim's side of the fence.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly my fear. Wasn't he trying to fob us off with the new Brazilian wonder kid? If Textor doesn't have the money and I suspect that is the case then American business strategy is to go onto the offensive. Blame Parish for not spending money he has not made available to Parish or as Becky so eloquently puts it try's to sell us crap from his other clubs and then complains about Parish's lack of ambition. I am really concerned now if Textor has north of 40% as some reports suggest then Parish is in a dangerous position and could easily be ousted.
|
|
|
Neillo, regarding your observations, my thoughts are: Originally posted by NEILLO
While I don’t disagree with this, the question then is why Textor is building a portfolio of clubs rather than focusing on increasing his stake in Palace. ...because you cannot buy (Palace) unless you have a party willing to sell or, if you have a party willing to sell, you are able to meet the asking price. We know that, compared to Harris and Blitzer, Textor's fortune is far, far smaller. I would imagine acquiring a PL club is beyond his reach. Originally posted by NEILLO
The Premier League is where the big money is and is surely a better investment opportunity than Brazil, Belgium or France. And more high profile. This is not entirely correct. The big, big money is in qualifying for Europe, and the PL is the most difficult (and expensive) league in Europe from which to do that. Palace is the 26th biggest club in the WORLD in terms of revenue but because we play in the PL, our chances of European football are effectively zero. Textor's French club, which probably has revenues a fraction of the size of Palace's, was bought for far, far less than we would cost to acquire but affords him a very good chance of qualifying for European football. That's the Return on Investment a smart buyer would look for. Originally posted by NEILLO
If, as it seems they have, Harris and Blitzer have little interest in Palace, then selling their shares to Textor would give them the exit they have been wanting for some time. Of course. 100% correct. In Textor they have a ready-made buyer and I'm sure they'd love to sell the club to him tomorrow. The trouble is, Textor doesn't have the money to buy it so your point is moot. Originally posted by NEILLO
It strikes me as odd that the minority shareholder that is Steve Parish has more influence than Textor. It's not odd. Harris and Blitzer are not interested in running Palace. For them, it's an investment. They have therefore "hired" Parish to run the club day-to-day on their behalf. Therefore, even though Parish himself owns only a very small share of the club, as CEO he makes decisions representing the entire voting block comprised of himself, Harris, and Blitzer. The combined percentage of those three obviously is far more influential than Textor alone. Originally posted by NEILLO
And surely, before pumping the reported £90m into Palace, Textor would have done sufficient due diligence to understand Parish’s strategy and approach to the transfer market. A difference in risk appetite perhaps. On this point I agree with you entirely. Either a). Textor didn't do a very good job of due diligence, b). he believed that once he came in, he would be able to be more influential than he has been, or c). he was fleeced by Harris, Blitzer, and Parish who saw a chance to part an enthusiastic fool from his money to secure additional investment. Either way, in terms of what he personally wants to gain, Textor has bought a pup.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
The HFs anti-Textor position demonstrates a profound lack of understanding about how the club is run from a financial perspective. I hope that anyone watching the game realised that the stupid banner only represented the views of a tiny minority of fans and the rest of us are happy not to condemn someone without knowing the facts
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I hope that anyone watching the game realised that the stupid banner only represented the views of a tiny minority of fans and the rest of us are happy not to condemn someone without knowing the facts That tiny minority seem to feel as though they are the ones who run this club though ME. You can therefore see where the public demonstration of anger comes from -.-'
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
Simple solution is for Textor to put some of his precious cash into the club, rather than buying a team in every league on earth. Or does Textor want Parish to just put more of Parish's money in? Our "investors" are really disappointing. The may be better than nothing, but none of them have any real interest in the club, nor are they putting significant money into it. I actually have no idea why they signed on. Textor is a snake oil salesman, and Harris & Blitzer are leeches. Well you have my vote for taking over. Show us your funds and you have my support. Edited by Wilbraham413 (20 Jan 2023 2.19am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
Neillo, regarding your observations, my thoughts are: On this point I agree with you entirely. Either a). Textor didn't do a very good job of due diligence, b). he believed that once he came in, he would be able to be more influential than he has been, or c). he was fleeced by Harris, Blitzer, and Parish who saw a chance to part an enthusiastic fool from his money to secure additional investment. Either way, in terms of what he personally wants to gain, Textor has bought a pup.
So I would contend that he would have enough funds to buy Harris and Blitzer out if, as I said, his focus was on Palace only. Harris and Blitzer would have had to sell up if their bid for Chelsea had been successful. That, together with their reported desire to sell a couple of years ago, suggests that they would sell when the right buyer came along. I totally get that H and B effectively hire Parish to run the club. And I think he’s done a pretty good job. But if the reports of friction are true we are in for interesting times because if Textor sees Parish as a blocker to his investment in Palace growing, he will do something about it. My point about due diligence I caveat with the observation that none of these guys got wealthy by accident.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
What I am struggling with is that it appears that Textor and Parish got together this week to discuss transfer targets for this window. The window is half over! Had there been any serious intention to sign anyone decent then the deal making should have started by now. We should not be looking at what that budget is. I know they say only the desperate or mad buy in January but I suggest we might be bordering on the desperate! Whilst I thought this too, perhaps there was a suggestion Textor envisaged some activity, which Parish would oversee, but as we are all too aware, there has been none. Just a suggestion nothing borne from knowledge or insight.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Whilst I thought this too, perhaps there was a suggestion Textor envisaged some activity, which Parish would oversee, but as we are all too aware, there has been none. Just a suggestion nothing borne from knowledge or insight. Hmm Having read the article I'm more coming round to what "Syd" has said and the above. In that I'm beginning to wonder whether the scenario is that is Parish is being asked to match investment in percentage terms according to shareholding that other investors are willing to put in - but just isn't in a financial position to do so. Look we all know that Parish whilst "rich" isn't Premier League rich..!! In which case is this causing the frustration..?? Give you an example I was with a Brighton fan today and we were discussing club ownership - he thought Parish owned us - when I said we were 76% American owned and that Parish only owned 10% he was shocked..!! So in those terms Parish is and loves being the face of Crystal Palace in terms of ownership. To put an analogy on it is Parish happy and loves to be seen driving around in his Ferrari but he only has a 10% deposit on it and has no financial resources to pay for the running, maintenance or required upgrades to it..!! I could be entirely wrong - but if you were supporting the vast majority of the costs for running and development (income aside) of Palace and someone else was taking all the credit for it - whilst putting no money in themselves wouldn't it begin to irk you..!! Just a thought..!! COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
All of this rings absolutely true. I don't know why so many people have an issue with Textor when it's plain to see that the problem is Harris and Blitzer. Textor is a minority investor with a relatively limited say in how things work. He's plainly more ambitious than both Harris and Blitzer, but he's constrained in what he can do and to what extent he can influence our plans due to his very limited status. I don't blame him for his French ventures; at least he can drive his latest club forward without being hindered by his partners. As a minority owner, Textor cannot independently just put money into Palace to fund transfers or anything else without permission from the majority owners, who would presumably have to match his appetite for progress by putting in equivalent funds of their own (or by increasing Textor's share of the club) and don't want to. Textor is right that we should be building on the foundation of last year's success. That Harris and Blitzer seemingly have no desire to do that is hardly his fault. If Parish and Textor had a meeting this week, one would hope the subject was "what are we going to do about Blitzer and Harris?" Although the relationship between Parish and Textor appears to have been adversarial to date, it seems they have a common interest in that both recognise the need to invest in the team, a view not, as I said, shared by the majority owners of the club. If Parish and Textor could put their differences aside and improve their personal relationship, it would serve us all well. To repeat what I've been saying for some time now, Harris and Blitzer really need to either a). get serious about Palace, and start really supporting the club rather than simply trying to increase the capital value of their asset, or b). sell the club to someone who has genuine ambition to see progress beyond simply the building of new facilities. The HFs anti-Textor position demonstrates a profound lack of understanding about how the club is run from a financial perspective. (And by the way, would whoever started this thread please learn the f***ing difference between poetry and competition? It's VERSUS. Not verses.) Edited by sydtheeagle (20 Jan 2023 9.41am) Noted, you condescending old c***.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Hmm Having read the article I'm more coming round to what "Syd" has said and the above. In that I'm beginning to wonder whether the scenario is that is Parish is being asked to match investment in percentage terms according to shareholding that other investors are willing to put in - but just isn't in a financial position to do so. Look we all know that Parish whilst "rich" isn't Premier League rich..!! In which case is this causing the frustration..?? Give you an example I was with a Brighton fan today and we were discussing club ownership - he thought Parish owned us - when I said we were 76% American owned and that Parish only owned 10% he was shocked..!! So in those terms Parish is and loves being the face of Crystal Palace in terms of ownership. To put an analogy on it is Parish happy and loves to be seen driving around in his Ferrari but he only has a 10% deposit on it and has no financial resources to pay for the running, maintenance or required upgrades to it..!! I could be entirely wrong - but if you were supporting the vast majority of the costs for running and development (income aside) of Palace and someone else was taking all the credit for it - whilst putting no money in themselves wouldn't it begin to irk you..!! Just a thought..!! COYP Meant to say whilst insisting on full autonomy, management and control..!! As I said Hmm..!! COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Textor paid approx £300m for a 77% share in Lyon. That’s aside from his other club interests.
That is not strictly correct. Eagle Football, of which John Textor is chairman and a shareholder paid £300 million for Lyon. Eagle Football is an investor group. The £300m is not John Textor's but the cumulative sum made up by the various parties in the group. It may well be that they had no interest in spending their money on CPFC and thought Lyon was an investment that would yield a better return. If that's the case, there's nothing Textor could do. He can recommend purchasing Palace, but that is all. It's not his money to spend as he wishes. Edited by sydtheeagle (20 Jan 2023 7.44pm)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by Qwijibo
Noted, you condescending old c***. Old, true (and now ten hours older than when I initially condescended). C±±t. Yes. Too much evidence to deny it. Condescending. Proven. But literate. There's a silver lining to every c±±ntish cloud, isn't there?
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I hope that anyone watching the game realised that the stupid banner only represented the views of a tiny minority of fans and the rest of us are happy not to condemn someone without knowing the facts This. I think we have been on the same page, for several years, when we have said that any prospective buyers would be put off by Parish wanting to keep his present role. Maybe it is time to move one. Is SP only interested in the future of CP? I am beginning to doubt this, 3rd highest paid Chairman in the PL!
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
What I am struggling with is that it appears that Textor and Parish got together this week to discuss transfer targets for this window. The window is half over! Had there been any serious intention to sign anyone decent then the deal making should have started by now. We should not be looking at what that budget is. I know they say only the desperate or mad buy in January but I suggest we might be bordering on the desperate! Gives Parish a get out of jail card when no incoming transpires. Not for the first time
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
This. I think we have been on the same page, for several years, when we have said that any prospective buyers would be put off by Parish wanting to keep his present role. Maybe it is time to move one. Is SP only interested in the future of CP? I am beginning to doubt this, 3rd highest paid Chairman in the PL! Only validates my concerns further.! COYP
|
|
[Tweet Link]
Maybe already posted but a bit more from Textor on his 'vision'. Seems a fairly reasonable set of statements.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Originally posted by Spiderman Only validates my concerns further.! COYP Only validates my concerns further.! COYP This is a complete non-issue. Parish may very well want to be chairman for life, but he owns a tiny minority share and he has no say in the matter at all. He's kept the role as CEO simply because he's persuaded Harris and Blitzer that he's the best man for the job. If they sell their shares and thus sell the club, the new owner of Palace would be under no obligation whatsoever to retain Parish as CEO. As I said, this is simply not an issue.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.