You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Views on PV
November 16 2026 3.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Views on PV


Page 2 of 17 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 23 4.09pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

He did a very good job last year, incorporating lots of new players and a very different way of playing whilst maintaining a healthy midtable position (and a cup run, although they happen more by mistake these days).

This year we have maintained a reasonable midtable position but not been anything like as good to watch. You would hope the team would be more cohesive in a managers second year, but the opposite is true, at least as an attacking force.

For me, the issue is the quality and type of attacking player at the managers disposal. For a decade we've played defensive football and relied on moments of individual endeavour to get goals. Each of Zaha, Bolasie, Townsend, Ayew, Edouard etc wants (or wanted) the ball to feet so they can improvise. None of them make good runs off the ball to make sharp forward passing possible, or have any great gift for combination play.

That didn't matter so much until we started trying to have more of the ball. Our periods of possession and pressure come around more often now, but only serve to illustrate how infrequently our forwards are capable of coordinated movement or combinations. One of the forwards coming towards our midfield asking for the ball to feet is common, but how often do you see a well timed run behind the opponents defence? One of the forwards trying to find a way past two or three opponents (often without success) happens almost every time we attack, but you can wait weeks to see a simple one-two passing combination. In fact, one and two touch pass and move football in the opposition half appears to be an alien concept.

Pundits say that individualistic players are hard to play against because they are unpredictable, but actually they are entirely predictable - every time they get they will try and beat you by themselves, and if they can't, they will hold the ball for far too long before releasing it so the momentum of the attack disappears.

That's why we've scored so infrequently, but the manager only has the players he has.

I'd like to see a post-Zaha Palace involve at least one forward who runs off the ball at pace, and a midfielder who times runs into space. We can then develop a team around football intelligence and movement as well as individual endeavour, which will get the best from Eze and Olise. Both players are capable of beating their man occasionally, but we aren't getting any benefit from their passing range and awareness at the moment.

All the time that Vieira has to select from Ayew, Edouard and Mateta, I find it hard to criticise him for our stodgy forward play.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.44pm)

Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.46pm)

We are 'Birds on the same twig' on a number of your points you have made and I have expressed these sentiments in private conversations.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jan 23 4.25pm

Originally posted by Runningman


Zaha isn’t half the player he was last year. Don’t want to write him off but I think we looked a lot more mobile after he was subbed off yesterday.

I agree, but I do think he's a better passer than he shows. He could benefit from having intelligent running ahead of him (though he'd probably ignore the option as often as not).

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Jan 23 4.33pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

He did a very good job last year, incorporating lots of new players and a very different way of playing whilst maintaining a healthy midtable position (and a cup run, although they happen more by mistake these days).

This year we have maintained a reasonable midtable position but not been anything like as good to watch. You would hope the team would be more cohesive in a managers second year, but the opposite is true, at least as an attacking force.

For me, the issue is the quality and type of attacking player at the managers disposal. For a decade we've played defensive football and relied on moments of individual endeavour to get goals. Each of Zaha, Bolasie, Townsend, Ayew, Edouard etc wants (or wanted) the ball to feet so they can improvise. None of them make good runs off the ball to make sharp forward passing possible, or have any great gift for combination play.

That didn't matter so much until we started trying to have more of the ball. Our periods of possession and pressure come around more often now, but only serve to illustrate how infrequently our forwards are capable of coordinated movement or combinations. One of the forwards coming towards our midfield asking for the ball to feet is common, but how often do you see a well timed run behind the opponents defence? One of the forwards trying to find a way past two or three opponents (often without success) happens almost every time we attack, but you can wait weeks to see a simple one-two passing combination. In fact, one and two touch pass and move football in the opposition half appears to be an alien concept.

Pundits say that individualistic players are hard to play against because they are unpredictable, but actually they are entirely predictable - every time they get they will try and beat you by themselves, and if they can't, they will hold the ball for far too long before releasing it so the momentum of the attack disappears.

That's why we've scored so infrequently, but the manager only has the players he has.

I'd like to see a post-Zaha Palace involve at least one forward who runs off the ball at pace, and a midfielder who times runs into space. We can then develop a team around football intelligence and movement as well as individual endeavour, which will get the best from Eze and Olise. Both players are capable of beating their man occasionally, but we aren't getting any benefit from their passing range and awareness at the moment.

All the time that Vieira has to select from Ayew, Edouard and Mateta, I find it hard to criticise him for our stodgy forward play.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.44pm)

Edited by TheBigToePunt (22 Jan 2023 3.46pm)

Very good post

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Jan 23 4.35pm

Originally posted by rikz

Since when ? Stuck Roberto Carlos in midfield, Harry kane on corners haha that tells you everything you need to know about him, terrible at Liverpool, you wouldn't have his career if you was bad but I definitely wouldn't describe him as good and playing for a draw at home to struggling teams in the league. No thanks

Viera is doing a great job, managers always need 3 years to build their own squad. Unless things are going drastically wrong then you keep them. If things go drastically right they usually get a bigger club. It would make no sense at all to get rid of viera and no chance the club would anyway.

You must be crackers, Rikz

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Jan 23 4.37pm

PV is still work in progress.

I think we generally agree that he has been let down in terms of replacing Gallagher and Kouyate.

He’s made mistakes without a doubt.

All managers have their team selections and tactics questioned and criticised by supporters, Vieira is not unique in that respect.

Ultimately it’s a results business, and all things considered we are around about where we can reasonably expect to be .

Calls for him to be sacked I find completely ludicrous

 


Old, Ungifted and White

YT Flag Oxford 22 Jan 23 5.26pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

You must be crackers, Rikz

Groan!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 22 Jan 23 5.32pm

I'm not necessarily defending the persistence with Jeff Schlupp nor any other selection choices, but regarding the team changes v Newcastle, it's perhaps worth bearing in mind that the Newcastle game kicked off just 67 and a half hours after the (very tough) Man U game finished, so maybe a bit of rotation was called for.

Edited by YT (22 Jan 2023 5.33pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jan 23 5.52pm

Originally posted by YT

I'm not necessarily defending the persistence with Jeff Schlupp nor any other selection choices, but regarding the team changes v Newcastle, it's perhaps worth bearing in mind that the Newcastle game kicked off just 67 and a half hours after the (very tough) Man U game finished, so maybe a bit of rotation was called for.

Edited by YT (22 Jan 2023 5.33pm)

I totally agree. It's a shame we don't have world beaters to bring on but that's just the way it is. It's a funny old fixture list this season and it's pretty obviously impacted teams in worse ways than ours. And for people liking PV's subs to Roy's - Vieira does make changes slightly earlier in a game - and on a more regular basis, than Roy. I didn't agree with Roy's subs but a lot of PV's are basically just unavoidable in the wider context of a squad over a season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Jan 23 7.03pm

Originally posted by YT

I'm not necessarily defending the persistence with Jeff Schlupp nor any other selection choices, but regarding the team changes v Newcastle, it's perhaps worth bearing in mind that the Newcastle game kicked off just 67 and a half hours after the (very tough) Man U game finished, so maybe a bit of rotation was called for.

Edited by YT (22 Jan 2023 5.33pm)

Well said. We often fall into the trap of playing 'fantasy football' and forgetting that the manager has to juggle all the things the real world throws his way.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Jan 23 7.44pm

Originally posted by YT

I'm not necessarily defending the persistence with Jeff Schlupp nor any other selection choices, but regarding the team changes v Newcastle, it's perhaps worth bearing in mind that the Newcastle game kicked off just 67 and a half hours after the (very tough) Man U game finished, so maybe a bit of rotation was called for.

Edited by YT (22 Jan 2023 5.33pm)

I think the very cynical view is that PV just picked a team nobody wanted to see despite them all being physically fine.

We have United again next, away this time and a break in between. That should tell us more and hopefully we’ll see a team most of us would expect/desire to see.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

cardiff eagle Flag 22 Jan 23 9.01pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I think the very cynical view is that PV just picked a team nobody wanted to see despite them all being physically fine.

We have United again next, away this time and a break in between. That should tell us more and hopefully we’ll see a team most of us would expect/desire to see.

Agreed- it was very coincidental that Hughes got dropped rather than any of the other players who have played way more games!

 

cardiff eagle Flag 22 Jan 23 9.04pm

My general feeling is that we can't sack PV because there is. no reason to on the face of it. However, I do think we have deteriorated probably from Jan 22 in terms of performances. Thought from August 21-December 22, we played great football, had passion and deserved more points than we got. Since then, I think we are reverting a fair bit to Hodgson style football and the only reason it might look better on occasion is because we have flair players like Eze, Zaha, Olise etc it will always look better.

I think give him until the end of the season, and assuming we haven't gone down, another transfer window and then evaluate in December.

Edited by cardiff eagle (22 Jan 2023 9.04pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 23 Jan 23 9.27am

As a club we are progressing in most areas. Academy, style of football, age of players etc

Progression cant be judged game to game, we need to take a bit of a helicopter view on things.

The positives are that we are in a decent position in the league, with a good points buffer over the relegation places.

We've had a difficult spell, but we've stopped the rot, against 2 of hte inform teams in the league. Which shows some resilience and courage in the squad.

Its only natural to want for more, but we're doing ok

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 23 Jan 23 9.47am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

As a club we are progressing in most areas. Academy, style of football, age of players etc

Progression cant be judged game to game, we need to take a bit of a helicopter view on things.

The positives are that we are in a decent position in the league, with a good points buffer over the relegation places.

We've had a difficult spell, but we've stopped the rot, against 2 of hte inform teams in the league. Which shows some resilience and courage in the squad.

Its only natural to want for more, but we're doing ok

Wouldn't disagree with you Mr R.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Jan 23 9.56am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

As a club we are progressing in most areas. Academy, style of football, age of players etc

Progression cant be judged game to game, we need to take a bit of a helicopter view on things.

The positives are that we are in a decent position in the league, with a good points buffer over the relegation places.

We've had a difficult spell, but we've stopped the rot, against 2 of hte inform teams in the league. Which shows some resilience and courage in the squad.

Its only natural to want for more, but we're doing ok

Well said.

In Potters second season at Brighton, there were a large number of their fans wanting him out.

This time last year, Arteta was being slated by Arsenal fans ( as Martin Tyler mentioned in his commentary yesterday ) who were wanting PV to replace him.

As a club I think we are still in a transitionary period. There's bound to be bumps in the road.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jan 23 10.09am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well said.

In Potters second season at Brighton, there were a large number of their fans wanting him out.

This time last year, Arteta was being slated by Arsenal fans ( as Martin Tyler mentioned in his commentary yesterday ) who were wanting PV to replace him.

As a club I think we are still in a transitionary period. There's bound to be bumps in the road.

In Potter's 1st season, Brighton finished in 15th place, in his 2nd season in 16th place.
Brighton never defeated us whilst Potter was at the helm.

 

pssguy Flag 23 Jan 23 10.21am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

What exactly do you expect? PV has actually done better league positionally than Roy, who originally inherited a decent squad. When that side was run down and out of contract PV had to pick up the pieces and start over.

Hardly Hodgson's fault that he didn't have Guehi, Andersen, Gallagher and Olise in his squad

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Jan 23 10.35am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well said.

In Potters second season at Brighton, there were a large number of their fans wanting him out.

This time last year, Arteta was being slated by Arsenal fans ( as Martin Tyler mentioned in his commentary yesterday ) who were wanting PV to replace him.

As a club I think we are still in a transitionary period. There's bound to be bumps in the road.

As I often say, the right to moan as a football fan should remain a valid outlet from minute to minute on matchday and day to day outside. However I think some sage comments have been made this morning.

I still very much see us as transitioning, which if/when complete can never come soon enough. I still think financial investment is needed in playing staff and PV has many a lesson ahead however the fear of an inevitable catastrophe always somewhat distorts the reality as a Palace fan.

A few more points and God forbid a player or two before the end of the month may just mitigate that.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

The groover Flag Danbury 23 Jan 23 10.36am

Just like a young player he is still learning. More to come.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 23 Jan 23 11.43am

I would not hold him accountable for the squad, ie. He has said he wants players but the issue appears to be with the hierarchy.

However, there are a couple of issues with him (and they are no different to when Roy was here).

He clearly has his favourites. How Schlupp gets in ahead of Hughes is baffling. Playing Ward ahead of Clyne is another one.

He doesn't give any of PL2 players a chance. Ozoh came on the other night but only for a very short period and that first youngster who has played any PL minutes for quite a while.

We have put in some awful performances yet PV still resists on using any youngsters. You don't know how good they are until they are played.

I thought we might have passed the Roy issues.

 

Page 2 of 17 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Views on PV