You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bad recruitment


Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Mar 23 9.36am

Originally posted by Painter

It’s easy to say, they should have got rid of different players, but if they are under contract and nobody wants to buy them, you have a problem. It was widely stated that we would enter a transitional period of moving to younger players with resale value, you can’t do this in a couple of transfer windows it takes time.
Every club has fans that complain about recruitment, nothing is ever good enough, it’s the nature of expectation.
The main problem this season is the players aren’t fit enough or motivated enough, that is squarely the responsibility of the manager and coaching staff. How many games have we faded in the second half and given away goals?

I agree this is a management failure but I also think many of our players are too old and incapable of being fit enough or fast enough to play modern PL football. Players like Ward, Tomkins and Milivojevic legs have gone and they look like they are wading through treacle.

The game has changed as well though and you can no longer walk around the centre circle and dictate play with a few neat skills. It’s all about high speed pressing and counter attacking now. At least half our team look incapable and uninterested in doing either. Our press is a half hearted attempt to close down and easily bypassed. It lasts 15 minutes and then it’s almost like there is a collective, ‘nah, that’s too tiring’ and we drop back to the halfway line.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Mar 23 9.40am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I don't know if I'd go so far as to say "really good", but it certainly had its moments. But that's only on the basis of doing half the job.

As I see, there are two parts (or halves) to recruitment:

1. Player replacement
2. Player signings

In terms of 2, we've done pretty well. Eze, Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Schlupp, and Hughes, have all looked to some degree or another like decent signings, some very good indeed. Edouard and Mateta have been disasters, but they're very much the minority. More signing have been good than bad. Unfortunately, both of our terrible signings have come in the same position, so that's had a greater impact than it should.

In terms of point 1, though, our recruitment has been awful. We have simply not replaced key players, and as a result, the squad suffers from having a number that are way, way past their sell-by dates. Ward should have been put out to pasture two years ago, Clyne at least a year ago, Luka two years ago, Tomkins two years ago, McArthur probably two years ago, and Conor was never replaced at all. That's left six yawning chasms in what's a small squad to begin with. Most of the above can barely even contribute for ten minutes off the bench, let alone provide competition within the squad. Heaven knows I love Joel Ward, but he was just embarrassing today. And to add insult to injury, we've repeatedly recruited sick notes. Nathan Ferguson? Seriously? He was broken before we bought him. How was that ever going to end well? Chris Richards...great player, but perpetually injured everywhere he's been. What was the point? Someone to keep Ferguson company on the physio's table?

The reality is that the success of a handful of our signings has obscured the fact that our overall recruiting strategy has been appalling and now we're paying the price for it with an unbalanced, weak squad that has no depth and provides the manager with no alternatives when the going gets tough. In short, we're a mess.

Really good might have been overstatement, I guess my issue is that because of previous fallings, we've left ourselves too much to do.

Instead of adding 2/3 players a window, we've been left in a position where we pretty much need to do the whole squad in 1 go.

I'm not too bothered about players like Ferguson. Stuff isn't going to work out all the time and we'll get unlucky with some. Wouldn't be an issue if the rest of the recruitment was ok. But when we have 2 terrible RB's - everyone is looking to the signing of a kid with 20 games under his belt as the answer to all the problems. When in reality, he should have been 1 of 2 RB's signed an in the bracket as one for the future.


 

NE14T Flag 20 Mar 23 9.56am

It would be nice if we pulled in a couple of players from the U21/reserve squad. Surely we have a right back who is half decent and would be an improvement on Wardy who is clearly now ‘done’. Same goes for Clyne. If we don’t have a young right back who is now better than him what on earth is the point of the academy and U21 squad?

The bar is ridiculously low to oust many first team players and it’s extremely worrying no one is bursting through and grabbing their chance. Maybe they’re just not there which would be incredibly sad so let’s hope it’s more a case that they’re not being given a chance which a new manager (with a better eye) can rectify.

Edited by NE14T (20 Mar 2023 10.01am)

Edited by NE14T (20 Mar 2023 10.06am)

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 20 Mar 23 9.56am

Milivojevic, Schlupp, J Ayew, Tomkins and Ward all should have gone by now and replaced with upgrades.

Money should have been spent on a half decent forward, its gonna take a long time to sort this mess out.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 20 Mar 23 5.37pm

every time I watch Danny Imray in the U-21's I wonder why he hasn't been given a chance, maybe it is a bit too early, but at least he can run into space and cross a ball decently and then get back to cover defensively, something that neither Ward or Clyne can do. They leave us hugely exposed, they get overloaded and then Olise spend way too much time trying to cover, (which he is still learning), instead of being further forward to get an early ball to get past defenders ..... thats the last of the armchair coaching for today

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Mar 23 5.57pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Milivojevic, Schlupp, J Ayew, Tomkins and Ward all should have gone by now and replaced with upgrades.

Money should have been spent on a half decent forward, its gonna take a long time to sort this mess out.

This is correct yes, but it's not the fault of Milivojevic, Schlupp, J Ayew, Tomkins and Ward that they're needed to do the best they can which is what they're all trying to do and the abuse they suffer is quite disgusting and most definitely not helping them in any way I would imagine, we should support them and encourage them because confidence is a killer, this is not aimed at you Dangerclose, but aimed at all our so called fans who seem to think it's clever to have a go at particular players.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Mar 23 8.27am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

This is correct yes, but it's not the fault of Milivojevic, Schlupp, J Ayew, Tomkins and Ward that they're needed to do the best they can which is what they're all trying to do and the abuse they suffer is quite disgusting and most definitely not helping them in any way I would imagine, we should support them and encourage them because confidence is a killer, this is not aimed at you Dangerclose, but aimed at all our so called fans who seem to think it's clever to have a go at particular players.

Jeez, calm down before you melt. This is top level professional football. If you can’t cut it you deserve what you got coming to you. It’s a fickle game, always has been. One season a hero, the next a villain. I also doubt these pages are followed by players earning millions a year and if they screw up on the field do you stand there shouting, “stop using hurty words you’ll ruin his confidence “. My guess is no, you won’t.

 

NE14T Flag 22 Mar 23 3.42pm

Paddy blundered into the mistake of sticking with experience and forgetting that Ward and Milo’s playing weaknesses greatly outweighed any experience advantages.

Let’s hope Roy doesn’t follow this mistake and instead bring in a couple of guys from the U21’s.

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 22 Mar 23 4.00pm

Saw Danny Imray 3 or 4 times last season when he was loaned back to his old (and my local) team Chelmsford City. You could see flashes of him being better than most of the players, though there was a time when he was dropped from the team. That's National League South, though he was coming back from injury.

Certainly he was very highly regarded before he came to Palace.

Originally posted by radicalsteve

every time I watch Danny Imray in the U-21's I wonder why he hasn't been given a chance, maybe it is a bit too early, but at least he can run into space and cross a ball decently and then get back to cover defensively, something that neither Ward or Clyne can do. They leave us hugely exposed, they get overloaded and then Olise spend way too much time trying to cover, (which he is still learning), instead of being further forward to get an early ball to get past defenders ..... thats the last of the armchair coaching for today

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 22 Mar 23 4.03pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

This is correct yes, but it's not the fault of Milivojevic, Schlupp, J Ayew, Tomkins and Ward that they're needed to do the best they can which is what they're all trying to do and the abuse they suffer is quite disgusting and most definitely not helping them in any way I would imagine, we should support them and encourage them because confidence is a killer, this is not aimed at you Dangerclose, but aimed at all our so called fans who seem to think it's clever to have a go at particular players.

Its about recruitment and not having ago at players its not there fought, We have been in the prem for 10 seasons now so you would have thought we would have a better squad.

Ward replaced Clyne
AWB replaced Ward
Ward replaced AWB who was sold
Clyne brought back to replace Ward

The cycle is complete.

Next season a new manager will come in and i hope he is better funded.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Mar 23 4.15pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Its about recruitment and not having ago at players its not there fought, We have been in the prem for 10 seasons now so you would have thought we would have a better squad.

Ward replaced Clyne
AWB replaced Ward
Ward replaced AWB who was sold
Clyne brought back to replace Ward

The cycle is complete.

Next season a new manager will come in and i hope he is better funded.

Given the recent announcement I am looking forward to Danny Butterfield signing on a short-term deal to play when Ward gets injured.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 22 Mar 23 4.47pm

I think the division has improved and we lack the financial muscle to compete.

When I look at our recruitment of the past few years, only Mateta gives me meaningful doubts and it's clear how hard it is to find good Prem strikers.

Eze, Olise, Andersen, Doucoure, Guehi, Ahamada, Edouard, Johnstone, Richards -- I like them all and believe under the right manager they'd be amazing. Lokonga too but he's not ours.

That's a superb success ratio.

It suggests to me that the real issue is just an unwillingness to spend because the club is relatively poor, not a failure to find good players.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 22 Mar 23 4.59pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I think the division has improved and we lack the financial muscle to compete.

When I look at our recruitment of the past few years, only Mateta gives me meaningful doubts and it's clear how hard it is to find good Prem strikers.

Eze, Olise, Andersen, Doucoure, Guehi, Ahamada, Edouard, Johnstone, Richards -- I like them all and believe under the right manager they'd be amazing. Lokonga too but he's not ours.

That's a superb success ratio.

It suggests to me that the real issue is just an unwillingness to spend because the club is relatively poor, not a failure to find good players.


I don't know if that's 100% true. Sure money helps, and it helps you be lazy with recruitment.

But plenty of examples of players that don't cost the earth.

How much did Brighton's first team cost? Brentford?

As you pointed out we've started to find good young players. Issue being the teams that are good at this have been doing this for years. And we've only just started. We're also not good enough at identifying them early enough.

All the players mentioned had a profile and (because we needed to) were first team ready.

As well as loads of money, we lack a long term recruitment plan. As much as it pains to say look at some of our neighbours stars:

Mitoma - £2.5m
Caicedo - £4.5m
Mac Allister - £7m

All bought for modest fees, all loaned out for a season or 2 before being ready for hte first team. All now worth a LOT.

Realistically we are light years away from them.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Mar 23 5.38pm

we have clearly has limited transfer budgets for a number of years. The purchases of Tekkers and Sakho left us hamstrung for the next few years and not just due to their transfer fees. As both were on £100k plus a week the overall wage bill got out of control. Zaha got a big increase etc and others such as VG and Luka managed to get increased contracts etc. Gambles such as Max Meyers would not have been taken if we had a more sensible wage structure.

With the two original American investor clearly not overly interested it was only when Textor came in over the summer of 2021 that the budget was given a much needed boost, albeit a temporary one.

However, it is not just transfer dealings that have been out failing. Have the players progressed?

Look at Fulham. They have a team that has yo-yoed between the divisions and a manager who has been sacked from at least 2 prem clubs (Watford and Everton). Yet he has got good Championship players like Reid, Reed and Ream performing very well.
He has also got his better players such as Mitrovic and Robinson performing consistently well.

We have players like Eze who has lost his mojo, Edouard's confidence looks shot and has a low workrate and experienced players like Schlupp and Ayew and even Zaha have been consistently well below par.

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Mar 23 6.59am

My main difficulty with our recruitment is the unbalanced nature of it which leaves glaring gaps in the squad.
In recent seasons Ayew has frequently occupied the position of the front 3.
I understand the need for competition and for his ultimate replacement, but did we need 3 players to fulfil this function?
We purchased Olise , have the highly regarded Rak Saki coming through and then went and bought Ebiowei.
They are of a similar age and are all left footed players who favour playing on the right and cutting in from that side.
They can’t all play in the team.


In my view this is excessive when we have the following issues

- only one out of form left back and two veteran right backs. The full back position has desperately needed strengthening for a while.
- two strikers who show no signs of being of the required standard
- for the bulk of the season weakness in central midfield where numbers (Luka, Jairo, Schlupp) have proved no substitute for quality.
- no evidence of a succession plan for Zaha with his possible
departure in mind

Where is the forward planning?

We did well at centre back where we had a number of ageing and unfit centre backs and to address this issue purchased 3 talented players who look very good already and also have great potential.
It would have been good to see similar foresight in other areas .

The club may argue they tried to address the full back and midfield areas through AWB and Gallagher, but when this didn’t happen I refuse to believe that there weren’t viable alternatives.
At the end of the season we have a large number of players out of contract who will need replacing along with the need for a new manager.
This also begs another question in relation to the input of the new manager into players retained or purchased leading to another potentially chaotic summer if there is a delay in appointing a new manager.

It is recognised that the club don’t have the resources to do everything immediately but there should at least be some evidence of a coherent strategy.


 

PatrickA Flag London 24 Mar 23 8.37am

It’s noteworthy that AWB and Gallagher are getting more minutes for their clubs now and that Gallagher is in the England squad.
It has to be very unlikely that we’ll be able to prise them away now as even if they were available they would probably be too expensive and not the cheaper options they might have been earlier in the season.
With players out of contract and unlikely to be renewed I suspect we’ll need around four or more new players in the summer.


Originally posted by PatrickA

My main difficulty with our recruitment is the unbalanced nature of it which leaves glaring gaps in the squad.
In recent seasons Ayew has frequently occupied the position of the front 3.
I understand the need for competition and for his ultimate replacement, but did we need 3 players to fulfil this function?
We purchased Olise , have the highly regarded Rak Saki coming through and then went and bought Ebiowei.
They are of a similar age and are all left footed players who favour playing on the right and cutting in from that side.
They can’t all play in the team.


In my view this is excessive when we have the following issues

- only one out of form left back and two veteran right backs. The full back position has desperately needed strengthening for a while.
- two strikers who show no signs of being of the required standard
- for the bulk of the season weakness in central midfield where numbers (Luka, Jairo, Schlupp) have proved no substitute for quality.
- no evidence of a succession plan for Zaha with his possible
departure in mind

Where is the forward planning?

We did well at centre back where we had a number of ageing and unfit centre backs and to address this issue purchased 3 talented players who look very good already and also have great potential.
It would have been good to see similar foresight in other areas .

The club may argue they tried to address the full back and midfield areas through AWB and Gallagher, but when this didn’t happen I refuse to believe that there weren’t viable alternatives.
At the end of the season we have a large number of players out of contract who will need replacing along with the need for a new manager.
This also begs another question in relation to the input of the new manager into players retained or purchased leading to another potentially chaotic summer if there is a delay in appointing a new manager.

It is recognised that the club don’t have the resources to do everything immediately but there should at least be some evidence of a coherent strategy.


 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 24 Mar 23 9.17am

I think it was Parish who said something along the lines of we'd only buy the right player for the right price and they wouldn't buy players for the sake of it.

That sounds great in principal but it may have also been one of the factors that has left us with such an imbalanced squad. As has already been pointed out with have Olise, Ebiowei and Rak-Sakyi who all could fill the same position. Yet we have two old right backs, one left back and only 2 forwards.

For me we need to highlight the positions where we are incredibly weak and ensure that we get something in for those positions. Whether it be first, second or third choice. Providing we stay up we will need a younger right back, we will need another left back, we will need another striker, we will need another midfielder when Lokonga goes back on loan.

Ensure that happens. It puts pressure on the player currently in that position to perform and means we are not putting players in positions they shouldn't be in.

We made mistakes in our early Premier League campaigns since we came up but we did seem to have options in each position.

Currently we have half a team that is as good as anyone outside the top 7, but 3 positions where we probably have the worst options in the entire league.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 24 Mar 23 9.28am

It seems that we spent the entire summer trying to get these two on loan and it was better to wait until the next window rather than find an alternative. Albeit one which wasn't perhaps quite so good. As in my other post I think this was a major error.

The fact that people target our ageing right backs and we haven't had sufficient drive in midfield are two of the major factors why we have struggled. Of course we also sold Benteke and thought we didn't need a third striker.

If it looks like our prime target won't be available, then move on. If they then become available at the end of the window, then so be it. Don't put all your eggs in one Conor Gallager/AWB basket, because the failure to get no one in in that position is far worse than failing to get that individual. Of course leaving everything to transfer deadline day doesn't help either.


Originally posted by PatrickA

It’s noteworthy that AWB and Gallagher are getting more minutes for their clubs now and that Gallagher is in the England squad.
It has to be very unlikely that we’ll be able to prise them away now as even if they were available they would probably be too expensive and not the cheaper options they might have been earlier in the season.
With players out of contract and unlikely to be renewed I suspect we’ll need around four or more new players in the summer.


 

TheBigToePunt Flag 24 Mar 23 9.43am

I'm not sure how people form such firm views on the club's performance in the transfer market. We only see the deals that come off, and none of those that don't. We never know who the club went in for, what they offered, how hard they worked on deals, or why they didn't come off.

People sometimes talk as if buying players is like buying your shopping; you simply decide what you want, find it, then pay the price. I always think it's far more similar to trying to get a really good job; you are one of a number of suitable, interested candidates, you apply along with several others, do your best but must appreciate that someone else might succeed ahead of you. Afterwards, it makes sense to ask yourself if you could have done more, and what if anything to do better next time, but have to accept that it was never in your control to begin with. Ultimately you just have to keep trying, and may have to compromise at times.

Then there's the money issue for Palace. It is a matter of recorded fact that we have one of the smaller budgets in the league, that we've generally spent all that we can on players, and that it gets harder rather than easier every year because the teams above us get more money from league placing, TV, commercial, tickets, hospitality etc than we do.

The idea that Parish or Freedman have 'failed' because we haven't got a back up left back, or because our strikers are s*** (which they certainly are) is based on totally unreasonable and unrealistic expectations.

It's f***ing Palace, not Real Madrid.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (24 Mar 2023 9.45am)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Mar 23 9.45am

Originally posted by fish mitten

I think it was Parish who said something along the lines of we'd only buy the right player for the right price and they wouldn't buy players for the sake of it.

That sounds great in principal but it may have also been one of the factors that has left us with such an imbalanced squad. As has already been pointed out with have Olise, Ebiowei and Rak-Sakyi who all could fill the same position. Yet we have two old right backs, one left back and only 2 forwards.

For me we need to highlight the positions where we are incredibly weak and ensure that we get something in for those positions. Whether it be first, second or third choice. Providing we stay up we will need a younger right back, we will need another left back, we will need another striker, we will need another midfielder when Lokonga goes back on loan.

Ensure that happens. It puts pressure on the player currently in that position to perform and means we are not putting players in positions they shouldn't be in.

We made mistakes in our early Premier League campaigns since we came up but we did seem to have options in each position.

Currently we have half a team that is as good as anyone outside the top 7, but 3 positions where we probably have the worst options in the entire league.

Explains how we ended up with Eduoard and Mateta mwa ha ha. Bad recruitment.

 

Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment