You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ramadan-a-ding-dong
November 21 2026 9.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ramadan-a-ding-dong


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Apr 23 9.49am

Originally posted by Pembroke

Its not necessary. If the fasting player isn’t fit enough use the squad, if supplements are needed for an ultra fit athlete use them before kick off, at half time, go to the sidelines and grab a gel like cyclists, or go off the pitch while the game is on.

Football here does not have breaks in the game here for religion, or religions.

But it does have mandatory water breaks

This topic is simple dog whistle nonsense. Get a sense of proportion and move on like the rest of the world. Dubai Eagle has been highly articulate and made the point well, as has Becky


Edited by Mapletree (09 Apr 2023 9.50am)

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 09 Apr 23 10.05am

As someone else was saying earlier, currently both sides have to agree to a break & inform the referee beforehand - if both sides have Muslim players fasting then its likely not going to be an issue -
If the PL decides that its not something that they want to allow then there are plenty of ways for a club / player to work around it with the game continuing.

Originally posted by Pembroke

Its not necessary. If the fasting player isn’t fit enough use the squad, if supplements are needed for an ultra fit athlete use them before kick off, at half time, go to the sidelines and grab a gel like cyclists, or go off the pitch while the game is on.

Football here does not have breaks in the game here for religion, or religions.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Apr 23 10.11am

Originally posted by becky

That's the one! Both Fofana and Kouyate broke their fasts - April 2021

If I remember correctly, if no-one had commented on it, most people wouldn't have noticed as it actually took less time than Manu player spend arguing with the ref after any tackle on one of their players...

Edited by becky (09 Apr 2023 9.45am)

Grealish, Kane and Ayew spend more time flying though the air. VAR invariably takes longer.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 09 Apr 23 10.27am

ah yes, well we must give respect to all religions.

can we start with the native Jews of North Africa. From Morocco to Egypt they seem to be an endangered species....hunted and killed in some cases.

And how about the minority Christian Copts of Egypt....also suffering terrible persecution from the majority.

Respect is a two-way street, after all ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Pembroke Flag Bristol 09 Apr 23 10.45am

Originally posted by Mapletree

But it does have mandatory water breaks

This topic is simple dog whistle nonsense. Get a sense of proportion and move on like the rest of the world. Dubai Eagle has been highly articulate and made the point well, as has Becky


Edited by Mapletree (09 Apr 2023 9.50am)

I dont understand the dog whistle thing .. Your dog whistling?

Mandatory water breaks in the cool UK? The rest of the world or some? Its not all.

Evening kicks off. Sundown is prior to kick-off so these religious players can have water and gels (??) then, or at any time during the game without there being a drinks break for a religious reason.

The problem there is? Physical? Rubbish the players can last for forty five minutes with out the game being stopped for them.

If a player isn't fit enough without rule changes to fit around their own choice then they shouldn't be on the pitch.


Edited by Pembroke (09 Apr 2023 10.46am)

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 09 Apr 23 10.52am

Genuine question.
Do they have to eat the moment the sun goes down -or if necessary can they leave it a bit longer to eat. Having fasted all day another half hour wait wouldn’t hurt to much surely . Mind you I can’t normally go more than four hours without eating so I wouldn’t want to wait !

Edited by rob1969 (09 Apr 2023 10.54am)

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 09 Apr 23 10.54am

With the break being around the 26th minute mark, I just couldn’t understand why they couldn’t just take on the food and fluids at half time. If you have been 14 hours or so without food then another 20 minutes wouldn’t make much difference.

Not anti it the break, it just seems something that could wait.

I would be more concerned about a professional athlete starving themselves and what effect it has on their stamina and performance.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Apr 23 11.02am

Originally posted by rob1969

Genuine question.
Do they have to eat the moment the sun goes down -or if necessary can they leave it a bit longer to eat. Having fasted all day another half hour wait wouldn’t hurt to much surely . Mind you I can’t normally go more than four hours without eating so I wouldn’t want to wait !

Edited by rob1969 (09 Apr 2023 10.54am)

The Sunnah is to hasten to break the fast, which means breaking fast straight after the sun has set.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 09 Apr 23 11.05am

Intentionally breaking the fast late without good reason during Ramadhan is considered a sin, however its clearly a matter for each individual as to what is considered a good reason -

Personally I think its more to stay true to the ritual itself, so that the observance of Ramadhan by the individual is a more complete & satisfying experience -


Originally posted by rob1969

Genuine question.
Do they have to eat the moment the sun goes down -or if necessary can they leave it a bit longer to eat. Having fasted all day another half hour wait wouldn’t hurt to much surely . Mind you I can’t normally go more than four hours without eating so I wouldn’t want to wait !

Edited by rob1969 (09 Apr 2023 10.54am)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Apr 23 11.06am

Originally posted by Pembroke

I dont understand the dog whistle thing .. Your dog whistling?

Mandatory water breaks in the cool UK? The rest of the world or some? Its not all.

Evening kicks off. Sundown is prior to kick-off so these religious players can have water and gels (??) then, or at any time during the game without there being a drinks break for a religious reason.

The problem there is? Physical? Rubbish the players can last for forty five minutes with out the game being stopped for them.

If a player isn't fit enough without rule changes to fit around their own choice then they shouldn't be on the pitch.


Edited by Pembroke (09 Apr 2023 10.46am)

Can you put this into a form that others can understand?

Mandatory one minute water breaks were brought in by the Premier League in June 2020.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 09 Apr 23 11.08am

Thank you Mapletree for the explanation. I thought it could just wait until half time.

Still could I guess, as it would be a reasonable compromise. I can’t imagine them stopping a 10,000 metre race half way through.

Originally posted by Mapletree

The Sunnah is to hasten to break the fast, which means breaking fast straight after the sun has set.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 09 Apr 23 11.39am

so eating & drinking is forbidden ? what about replenishing one's levels of hydration intraveneously ? say, with a Saline solution in a water bag, on a little hospital tripod ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Apr 23 11.47am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

so eating & drinking is forbidden ? what about replenishing one's levels of hydration intraveneously ? say, with a Saline solution in a water bag, on a little hospital tripod ?

They're not Jehovah's Witnesses.

 


Red and Blue Army!

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 09 Apr 23 11.58am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

They're not Jehovah's Witnesses.

i do recall Roy Keane taking blood out of players. But i have never seen a match with blood being put in.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Apr 23 4.13pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i do recall Roy Keane taking blood out of players. But i have never seen a match with blood being put in.

They were at my door today - must hatch at Easter.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Pembroke Flag Bristol 11 Apr 23 1.13pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Can you put this into a form that others can understand?

Mandatory one minute water breaks were brought in by the Premier League in June 2020.

Mandatory water breaks are not every game, or every level of football. They are based upon extreme temperatures, not religious choices.

Fasting players could eat/drink before, or at half time, or go to the side of the pitch instead of stopping the game for a choice they made.

The physiological aspect here? If they cant run for forty five minutes without these breaks , they are unfit to play, they have chosen to make themselves unfit to play. A fit human body stores enough carbs, glycogen to pay football for forty five minutes easily.

So that leaves dehydration in forty five minutes of football un the UK cool climate necessitating a break of several minutes because they are dehydrated? Its a nonsense.

 

Pembroke Flag Bristol 11 Apr 23 1.21pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

Thank you Mapletree for the explanation. I thought it could just wait until half time.

Still could I guess, as it would be a reasonable compromise. I can’t imagine them stopping a 10,000 metre race half way through.

A 10.000 metre runner should not be stopping to refuel drink in a six mile race.

A pro football player will run 3-4 miles in a half.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Apr 23 1.26pm

Originally posted by Pembroke

Mandatory water breaks are not every game, or every level of football. They are based upon extreme temperatures, not religious choices.

Fasting players could eat/drink before, or at half time, or go to the side of the pitch instead of stopping the game for a choice they made.

The physiological aspect here? If they cant run for forty five minutes without these breaks , they are unfit to play, they have chosen to make themselves unfit to play. A fit human body stores enough carbs, glycogen to pay football for forty five minutes easily.

So that leaves dehydration in forty five minutes of football un the UK cool climate necessitating a break of several minutes because they are dehydrated? Its a nonsense.

I really wish you would read, think and then post.

For Sunnis it is Sunnah to break fast (a glass of water and a fruit) at Maghrib, following which they must pray. Breaking fast takes just about the same length of time as Wilf rubbing his shins and complaining to the referee.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Apr 23 1.35pm

If this were not announced would anybody really notice or indeed care?

If the players want to sit down for a four-course meal during a game, say some prayers and have a kip, I think most will protest however I do not see the need to draw too much attention to this beyond acknowledging it's existence for those who may be left feeling unnerved by a few players having a quick drink or what-have-you without a formal announcement.

VAR still seems surreal to me in just standing around completely uninformed as to what is happening sometimes but I'm slowly getting over it. I've probably spent more time watching Wayne Hennessey trying to travel a distance of 6m+ before in a game.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 11 Apr 23 1.51pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I really wish you would read, think and then post.

For Sunnis it is Sunnah to break fast (a glass of water and a fruit) at Maghrib, following which they must pray. Breaking fast takes just about the same length of time as Wilf rubbing his shins and complaining to the referee.

Genuine enquiry. What happens when prayer times come during game time in afternoon and evening kick-offs?

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ramadan-a-ding-dong