You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Andersen
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Andersen


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Jun 23 7.45am

Originally posted by samprior

The bit I read says 25m-30m. I reckon we'd consider 35m+ and some add ons. I think Andersen would be keen to play Champions League football.


I'd be worried if he wasn't keen. He's 27 and a move to Newcastle would be a good one for him.

The question is whether they would be willing to pay our asking price given he has 3 years left on his contract.

As much as I like Andersen, I'd rather lose him than Guehi. Clickbait is suggesting that we aren't budging from our Guehi valuation and Levy isn't prepared to meet it.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 23 Jun 23 7.59am

Originally posted by doombear


I'd be worried if he wasn't keen. He's 27 and a move to Newcastle would be a good one for him.

The question is whether they would be willing to pay our asking price given he has 3 years left on his contract.

As much as I like Andersen, I'd rather lose him than Guehi. Clickbait is suggesting that we aren't budging from our Guehi valuation and Levy isn't prepared to meet it.

Dont agree with that one, Andersen is the general of the defense with a superb passing range, almost irreplaceable, Guehi is a good defender, pace and strength, lacks height and isn't very vocal, i think much easier to replace, only my opinion.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

PJEagle Flag London 23 Jun 23 8.31am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dont agree with that one, Andersen is the general of the defense with a superb passing range, almost irreplaceable, Guehi is a good defender, pace and strength, lacks height and isn't very vocal, i think much easier to replace, only my opinion.

I saw his performance in the England match against Malta, admittedly weak oppposion, but Guehi was very good, an excellent CB performance. We need to keep both of them. Add in a couple of good young strikers, and a versatile young back, and I think we could be looking at a top ten finish

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Jun 23 9.01am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dont agree with that one, Andersen is the general of the defense with a superb passing range, almost irreplaceable, Guehi is a good defender, pace and strength, lacks height and isn't very vocal, i think much easier to replace, only my opinion.


As you say Lanzo - opinions.

It's a tough call but my thinking (if we have to lose one of them) is:
1. Guehi is defensively more solid than Andersen
2. He reads the game better and so is not caught out as often as Andersen.
3. Guehi, who will be turning 23 next month has the bulk of his career in front of him, whereas Andersen, having turned 27 in May, has entered his peak years. Consequently, Andersen's transfer value isn't going to increase much (if at all) from how we value him now, whereas Guehi's could increase significantly if he continues to improve.
4. Guehi qualifies as a home grown player whereas Andersen, of course, doesn't.
5. I acknowledge that we would lose Andersen's passing skills but believe that Johnstone has shown that he can pick a pass and that both Guehi and Richards are good enough to develop longer passing skills due to their comfort on the ball which enables them time to assess passing options.

 

beak Flag croydon 23 Jun 23 9.25am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Here's something to make you laugh this morning [Link] someone speculating that maybe Newcastle Arabia could get Andersen for 20m. This rumour has been bouncing around the last few days but seems to have little merit.

I think he's been great for us, but I do think we're his level.

Perhaps we should strive to become his level.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 23 Jun 23 9.27am

Originally posted by doombear


As you say Lanzo - opinions.

It's a tough call but my thinking (if we have to lose one of them) is:
1. Guehi is defensively more solid than Andersen
2. He reads the game better and so is not caught out as often as Andersen.
3. Guehi, who will be turning 23 next month has the bulk of his career in front of him, whereas Andersen, having turned 27 in May, has entered his peak years. Consequently, Andersen's transfer value isn't going to increase much (if at all) from how we value him now, whereas Guehi's could increase significantly if he continues to improve.
4. Guehi qualifies as a home grown player whereas Andersen, of course, doesn't.
5. I acknowledge that we would lose Andersen's passing skills but believe that Johnstone has shown that he can pick a pass and that both Guehi and Richards are good enough to develop longer passing skills due to their comfort on the ball which enables them time to assess passing options.

I respect your opinions, i know, lets keep both

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

palace99 Flag New Mills 23 Jun 23 9.43am

Originally posted by doombear


As you say Lanzo - opinions.

It's a tough call but my thinking (if we have to lose one of them) is:
1. Guehi is defensively more solid than Andersen
2. He reads the game better and so is not caught out as often as Andersen.
3. Guehi, who will be turning 23 next month has the bulk of his career in front of him, whereas Andersen, having turned 27 in May, has entered his peak years. Consequently, Andersen's transfer value isn't going to increase much (if at all) from how we value him now, whereas Guehi's could increase significantly if he continues to improve.
4. Guehi qualifies as a home grown player whereas Andersen, of course, doesn't.
5. I acknowledge that we would lose Andersen's passing skills but believe that Johnstone has shown that he can pick a pass and that both Guehi and Richards are good enough to develop longer passing skills due to their comfort on the ball which enables them time to assess passing options.

some good points, and IMHO losing Andersen rather than Guehi would make more business sense.

However, whilst Guehi's passing game may develop without relying on Andersen beside him, Richards seems very limited in this area. The few games he has played he looks like an old fashioned defender get the ball and give it to the person closest to you.
IMHO he looked uncomfortable on the ball and reminded me of Tomkins. Happy to be proved wrong

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Jun 23 10.52am

Originally posted by palace99

some good points, and IMHO losing Andersen rather than Guehi would make more business sense.

However, whilst Guehi's passing game may develop without relying on Andersen beside him, Richards seems very limited in this area. The few games he has played he looks like an old fashioned defender get the ball and give it to the person closest to you.
IMHO he looked uncomfortable on the ball and reminded me of Tomkins. Happy to be proved wrong [/quote]

A game of opinions indeed palace99!

When we first got Richards my assumption, which came off a platform of complete ignorance about the player, was we'd get some sort of NBA near miss in the American Richards - an astounding, real athlete albeit with little footballing ability.

Personally, perhaps as my bar was set so low, I have been pleasantly surprised by his footballing ability, especially given he has played very little and had numerous injuries in his short career. Equally happy to be proved wrong but I've rarely if ever thought him to look clumsy or lacking in technical ability.

Edited by Nicholas91 (23 Jun 2023 10.53am)

Edited by Nicholas91 (23 Jun 2023 10.53am)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jun 23 11.19am

I was always a fan of Supermarionation.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Jun 23 12.08pm

We need more centre halves not less.

He is another quality player we should not sell.

Guehi, Anderson, Eze and Olise should be retained no matter what.

We have the makings of a top 8 team if we add a little more up front.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (23 Jun 2023 12.11pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Jun 23 12.15pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dont agree with that one, Andersen is the general of the defense with a superb passing range, almost irreplaceable, Guehi is a good defender, pace and strength, lacks height and isn't very vocal, i think much easier to replace, only my opinion.

I think Guehi will be one of the best centre halves in the country within 5 years, I couldn't say the same for Andersen.

Both superb defenders, and Andersen's passing range is a huge platform to build from, but he's nowhere near as rounded defensively.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Jun 23 1.08pm

Personally, I think both Andersen and Geuhi are overrated. If we can rush Newcastle, Spurs, or whoever, £40-50m for either of them then we will have pulled off a coup to eclipse even the AWB deal.

For two years now the lazy journalistic narrative has been that Palace are a team transformed from dull, defensive, and old to exciting, skillful, and young. There is some truth to this of course, but our centre-backs reputations have been artificially inflated along the way.

It's not quite a case of 'the emperor's new clothes' but were it not for the team's current media image I think both Andersen and Geuhi would simply be seen as unreliable, mid-table level defenders.

Geuhi is mobile, competitive, and can bring the ball out quite well. He is also too short for a centre-back, regularly loses headers and/or his man when defending crosses coming in from our right flank (I feel certain opposition coaches have been targeting the Guehi/Mitchell area with deep crosses for ages now), and I question whether his media and international recognition has more to do with his age, nationality and background (i.e being on the FA radar from a young age) than his actual performances.

Anderen has a good long passing range but falls far short of punching his weight defensively. He should be our main aerial presence but loses so many headers that he seems to get shorter when he jumps.

They are not bad players, but they are certainly not excellent ones. They are almost un-dropable not because of performances but because we made so great an investment in them, and have no obvious alternative in the squad.

The far cheaper, lower-profile centre-backs we have had (Cahill, Tompkins, Dann, Delaney, etc) were not as good on the ball but were better defenders, and we achieved the same mid-table finishes with them as with the current players. I feel that we could replace both Guehi and Andersen easily enough and make a sizable profit if we were prepared to go back to signing journeymen. That is not without flaws as a strategy of course, and Brentford and Wolves will not make any money from selling on Ben Mee or Craig Dawson for instance, but both those are better defenders than ours, and relatively inexpensive. If we were to go back to signing that type of player then we might be able to sell one or both our current centre-backs, replace them for a fraction of the fee, and have cash to upgrade in the centre-forward and (post-Zaha) left-wing areas, making us a noticeably better team overall.

My only reservation about selling either centre-back is that it may start the dominoes falling. We would suddenly become a selling club, and Eze and Olise would want their move soon after. That would be far harder to recover from than losing Andersen or Guehi.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 1.11pm)

 

beak Flag croydon 23 Jun 23 1.25pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I was always a fan of Supermarionation.

Don't be so filthy.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Jun 23 1.39pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Personally, I think both Andersen and Geuhi are overrated. If we can rush Newcastle, Spurs, or whoever, £40-50m for either of them then we will have pulled off a coup to eclipse even the AWB deal.

For two years now the lazy journalistic narrative has been that Palace are a team transformed from dull, defensive, and old to exciting, skillful, and young. There is some truth to this of course, but our centre-backs reputations have been artificially inflated along the way.

It's not quite a case of 'the emperor's new clothes' but were it not for the team's current media image I think both Andersen and Geuhi would simply be seen as unreliable, mid-table level defenders.

Geuhi is mobile, competitive, and can bring the ball out quite well. He is also too short for a centre-back, regularly loses headers and/or his man when defending crosses coming in from our right flank (I feel certain opposition coaches have been targeting the Guehi/Mitchell area with deep crosses for ages now), and I question whether his media and international recognition has more to do with his age, nationality and background (i.e being on the FA radar from a young age) than his actual performances.

Anderen has a good long passing range but falls far short of punching his weight defensively. He should be our main aerial presence but loses so many headers that he seems to get shorter when he jumps.

They are not bad players, but they are certainly not excellent ones. They are almost un-dropable not because of performances but because we made so great an investment in them, and have no obvious alternative in the squad.

The far cheaper, lower-profile centre-backs we have had (Cahill, Tompkins, Dann, Delaney, etc) were not as good on the ball but were better defenders, and we achieved the same mid-table finishes with them as with the current players. I feel that we could replace both Guehi and Andersen easily enough and make a sizable profit if we were prepared to go back to signing journeymen. That is not without flaws as a strategy of course, and Brentford and Wolves will not make any money from selling on Ben Mee or Craig Dawson for instance, but both those are better defenders than ours, and relatively inexpensive. If we were to go back to signing that type of player then we might be able to sell one or both our current centre-backs, replace them for a fraction of the fee, and have cash to upgrade in the centre-forward and (post-Zaha) left-wing areas, making us a noticeably better team overall.

My only reservation about selling either centre-back is that it may start the dominoes falling. We would suddenly become a selling club, and Eze and Olise would want their move soon after. That would be far harder to recover from than losing Andersen or Guehi.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 1.11pm)


An interesting take BTP and whilst I agree with you to an extent regarding Andersen, I don't see Guehi in the same light. Yes, he's not that tall (just 6 ft) but I think he generally competes well with the opposition's attackers, although he can be outjumped by the best.

Turning to your final reservation, I see a return to journeymen as a backward step, and one which basically says

" we recognize we are lucky to be the PL and we don't expect to
be here much longer"

As you say, it could (and IMO would)result in us losing our attacking talent as well and then we would be Championship bound.

Such journeymen can play a role as a stop gap solution but not for not for much longer IMHO because the way the game is changing it will be more and more difficult for the seasoned journeymen defenders of the old school to survive.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Jun 23 1.47pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Personally, I think both Andersen and Geuhi are overrated. If we can rush Newcastle, Spurs, or whoever, £40-50m for either of them then we will have pulled off a coup to eclipse even the AWB deal.

For two years now the lazy journalistic narrative has been that Palace are a team transformed from dull, defensive, and old to exciting, skillful, and young. There is some truth to this of course, but our centre-backs reputations have been artificially inflated along the way.

It's not quite a case of 'the emperor's new clothes' but were it not for the team's current media image I think both Andersen and Geuhi would simply be seen as unreliable, mid-table level defenders.

Geuhi is mobile, competitive, and can bring the ball out quite well. He is also too short for a centre-back, regularly loses headers and/or his man when defending crosses coming in from our right flank (I feel certain opposition coaches have been targeting the Guehi/Mitchell area with deep crosses for ages now), and I question whether his media and international recognition has more to do with his age, nationality and background (i.e being on the FA radar from a young age) than his actual performances.

Anderen has a good long passing range but falls far short of punching his weight defensively. He should be our main aerial presence but loses so many headers that he seems to get shorter when he jumps.

They are not bad players, but they are certainly not excellent ones. They are almost un-dropable not because of performances but because we made so great an investment in them, and have no obvious alternative in the squad.

The far cheaper, lower-profile centre-backs we have had (Cahill, Tompkins, Dann, Delaney, etc) were not as good on the ball but were better defenders, and we achieved the same mid-table finishes with them as with the current players. I feel that we could replace both Guehi and Andersen easily enough and make a sizable profit if we were prepared to go back to signing journeymen. That is not without flaws as a strategy of course, and Brentford and Wolves will not make any money from selling on Ben Mee or Craig Dawson for instance, but both those are better defenders than ours, and relatively inexpensive. If we were to go back to signing that type of player then we might be able to sell one or both our current centre-backs, replace them for a fraction of the fee, and have cash to upgrade in the centre-forward and (post-Zaha) left-wing areas, making us a noticeably better team overall.

My only reservation about selling either centre-back is that it may start the dominoes falling. We would suddenly become a selling club, and Eze and Olise would want their move soon after. That would be far harder to recover from than losing Andersen or Guehi.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 1.11pm)

It will be interesting to compare Guehi's career in 10 years' time with those players you've mentioned as better defenders.

He already has more England caps than all of them bar Cahill.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Jun 23 1.53pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Personally, I think both Andersen and Geuhi are overrated. If we can rush Newcastle, Spurs, or whoever, £40-50m for either of them then we will have pulled off a coup to eclipse even the AWB deal.

For two years now the lazy journalistic narrative has been that Palace are a team transformed from dull, defensive, and old to exciting, skillful, and young. There is some truth to this of course, but our centre-backs reputations have been artificially inflated along the way.

It's not quite a case of 'the emperor's new clothes' but were it not for the team's current media image I think both Andersen and Geuhi would simply be seen as unreliable, mid-table level defenders.

Geuhi is mobile, competitive, and can bring the ball out quite well. He is also too short for a centre-back, regularly loses headers and/or his man when defending crosses coming in from our right flank (I feel certain opposition coaches have been targeting the Guehi/Mitchell area with deep crosses for ages now), and I question whether his media and international recognition has more to do with his age, nationality and background (i.e being on the FA radar from a young age) than his actual performances.

Anderen has a good long passing range but falls far short of punching his weight defensively. He should be our main aerial presence but loses so many headers that he seems to get shorter when he jumps.

They are not bad players, but they are certainly not excellent ones. They are almost un-dropable not because of performances but because we made so great an investment in them, and have no obvious alternative in the squad.

The far cheaper, lower-profile centre-backs we have had (Cahill, Tompkins, Dann, Delaney, etc) were not as good on the ball but were better defenders, and we achieved the same mid-table finishes with them as with the current players. I feel that we could replace both Guehi and Andersen easily enough and make a sizable profit if we were prepared to go back to signing journeymen. That is not without flaws as a strategy of course, and Brentford and Wolves will not make any money from selling on Ben Mee or Craig Dawson for instance, but both those are better defenders than ours, and relatively inexpensive. If we were to go back to signing that type of player then we might be able to sell one or both our current centre-backs, replace them for a fraction of the fee, and have cash to upgrade in the centre-forward and (post-Zaha) left-wing areas, making us a noticeably better team overall.

My only reservation about selling either centre-back is that it may start the dominoes falling. We would suddenly become a selling club, and Eze and Olise would want their move soon after. That would be far harder to recover from than losing Andersen or Guehi.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 1.11pm)

An interesting read.

For me, Andersen and Guehi have been the poster boys for our new identity, leaving behind the old one, where the likes of Dann, Delaney, Cahill, Tomkins etc reigned supreme. A big part of that identity was us being characterised as a team trying to endure all manner of onslaught whilst nicking the odd counter attack goal (usually via Zaha). The older school, blood and guts defenders were much better suited to this.

A lot of time is now, sometimes infuriatingly, spent knocking the ball across the backline. This has been the platform for us to play a more proactive, possession based game and one almost universally viewed as an improvement upon our previous existence. I am an advocate of this new approach. Andersen is the long-ball (quarterback) player and Marc the more mobile defender who can move with the ball.

Both these players, for me, lack aerial prowess and often leave something to be desired where you just need non-nonsense, bodies on the line defending. Were they able to offer both aspects I'd suggest they would indeed both be plying their trade somewhere more glamorous and for a lot more money than we are paying them.

I agree that they may not be the greatest centre-backs in the world and leave enough to be desired however were they to depart that proverbial foundation for our team would be dented and as others have mentioned the domino effect may be catastrophic (on the assumption we struggle to/do not recruit adequate replacement). I'd much rather we brought in adequate support for them, and they remain, however recognise that may well be beyond anyone's control.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Jun 23 2.04pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Personally, I think both Andersen and Geuhi are overrated.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 1.11pm)

I'm glad you aren't a scout.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 23 Jun 23 2.15pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Personally, I think both Andersen and Geuhi are overrated.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 1.11pm)

Good arguments and I agree with some of the sentiments. For my ten-pennorth, what Guehi gives us which the 'better' defenders mentioned do not is speed. This means we have been able to defend higher and move from boring Royball to the more adventurous way we play now. Anderson is quite slow so replacing him, I feel, with an old school defender might be more doable albeit we would lose the accurate raking pass than comes with Anderson but gain better aerial defending.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Jun 23 2.46pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

It will be interesting to compare Guehi's career in 10 years' time with those players you've mentioned as better defenders.

He already has more England caps than all of them bar Cahill.

Fair point, but Guehi is getting in squads and/or a little run out against weak teams at the moment in the same way many young, eligible players do. AWB and Mitchell did, along with all sorts over the years, and most of them do not kick on to the next level.

Guehi, like many before him, is getting some England recognition because he has a bit of promise and potential, not because he is already a top-class player.

He may never get much better than he is now, but the potential is attractive and therefore expensive. Those few England caps now might make this the best time to cash out, in much the same way we did with AWB, before the player has a chance to plateau.

Do United still think £50m was money well spent for AWB? Is he a better player now than he was when they bought him, or was he actually close to his 'finished' level from the outset? Would we have got anything like that money for him 18 months later? I doubt it. Perhaps Guehi is the same. There is a gamble either way of course because he might go on to get 100 England caps and be brilliant, but there is also a gamble in keeping him - his value may never be so high again.

Aside from the significance of England caps, another issue is whether Guehi is getting caps where Dann, Tompkins, etc did not because is a better defender than our old guard, or simply a better footballer.

For 95% of their games, England need defenders to move the ball quickly and with quality so they can break down stubborn but inferior opponents. Palace, by contrast, need defenders to defend properly, and I'm really not convinced that Guehi (or Andersen for that matter) can.

I'm not in favour of Palace selling anyone and have always been concerned about the 'buy young, develop and sell' model, but if I had to choose one or two to sell in order to reinvest then both centre-backs would be my choice.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (23 Jun 2023 2.48pm)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Jun 23 2.55pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Good arguments and I agree with some of the sentiments. For my ten-pennorth, what Guehi gives us which the 'better' defenders mentioned do not is speed. This means we have been able to defend higher and move from boring Royball to the more adventurous way we play now. Anderson is quite slow so replacing him, I feel, with an old school defender might be more doable albeit we would lose the accurate raking pass than comes with Anderson but gain better aerial defending.

I agree, but we can't play with a high line if at least two (maybe three) of the back four are slow, as has been the case.

We also need our forwards to press aggressively for our defence to hold a high line, and Eze, Olise, Edouard, etc seem set to continue the trend set by Zaha and others of not really being any good at (or willing to do) that.

I dare say Guehi would fit like a glove at Man City, or Barcelona, but I'm not convinced we get more from him than we would from a cheaper, less glamourous alternative.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Andersen