This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I think you are right, but I have come to look at the issue of squad depth differently lately. I get the idea that you can never have too many good players. However, if you have too many players for too few minutes on the pitch then, it seems to me, you are not going to get full value from them. Players can get stale or lazy if they are not challenged for their place, but they can just as easily be prevented from developing to their full potential, and from taking on responsibility if they are rotated too much. Late collapse or not, Arsenal have had a storming season based on picking the same team most weeks. Martinelli, Saka, White, Saliba, Gabriel and Odegard have all not only shown evident personal development, they have carried the weight too. It's old-school, the kind of thing Souness or Keane talk about, but it is their team, they play as if they are responsible for the results because they are - they play every week so who else can be? Chelsea on the other hand have spent far more and have at least two very expensive players for each position, but none of them are first choice, none of them have developed or been given the chance to take responsibility for results. Turning back to Palace and our financial model, if we see the players as assets that we will develop and sell then the development of the individual is paramount. If Rak-Sakyi can only play wide right, and unless Olise can move to a different position and seamlessly continue his current upward development curve, we would have tow promising players (and valuable assets) for one position. There is a danger that the development of one or both would be stunted if they were made to share minutes on the pitch. Far better that Rak-Sakyi goes back out on loan again where he can develop through playing every week than to have him go stale whilst proving cover for Olise, in my opinion. We will be in trouble without Zaha, and I think our best bet is not to replace him directly (impossible) but to get a different type of left winger and a better goal scoring forward. What, in my opinion, we can't do is buy two decent left wingers and rotate them. We need one good first choice player in that position to play most games, develop (including playing through dips in form) and take responsibility. Obviously this all requires that we don't get too many serious injuries, but that is true for most sides. I agree with this and dispensing of financial considerations the same for the CF position too. I almost feel that in buying Mateta and Edouard, what we have done is go for two 'maybe' strikers in the hope one might make the position their own. What we have now is two strikers neither of whom are probably good enough to warrant a starting place, get rotated if not play at all and are on downward curves. I'd like us to sign someone to play left wing and say 'this is our man' and then we can look at the likes of academy players and cheaper, younger options to understudy and challenge.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I think you are right, but I have come to look at the issue of squad depth differently lately. I get the idea that you can never have too many good players, but if you have too many players for too few minutes on the pitch then, it seems to me, you are not going to get full value from any of them. Players can get stale or lazy if they are not challenged for their place, but they can also be prevented from developing to their full potential, and from taking on responsibility, if they are rotated too much. Late collapse or not, Arsenal have had a storming season based on picking the same team most weeks. Martinelli, Saka, White, Saliba, Gabriel and Odegard have all not only shown evident personal development, they have carried the weight too. It's old-school, the kind of thing Souness or Keane talk about, but it is their team, they play as if they are responsible for the results because they are - they play every week so who else can be? Chelsea on the other hand have spent far more and have at least two very expensive players for each position, but none of them are first choice, none of them have developed or been given the chance to take responsibility for results. Turning back to Palace and our financial model, if we see the players as assets that we will develop and sell then the development of the individual is paramount. The next stage in Olise' development is to carry some weight for results. No more flitting in and out of games, no more deferring responsibility to Zaha, he now has to carry us, as does Eze. If Rak-Sakyi can only play wide right, and unless Olise can move to a different position and seamlessly continue his current upward development curve, we will have two promising players (and valuable assets) for one position,and one of them needs to be playing all the time now. There is a danger that the development of one or both would be stunted if they were made to share minutes on the pitch. Far better that Rak-Sakyi goes back out on loan again where he can develop through playing every week than to have him go stale whilst providing cover for Olise, in my opinion. We will be in trouble without Zaha, and I think our best bet is not to replace him directly (impossible) but to get a different type of left winger and a better goal scoring forward. What, in my opinion, we can't do is buy two decent left wingers and rotate them. We need one good first choice player in that position to play most games, develop (including playing through dips in form) and take responsibility. Obviously this all requires that we don't get too many serious injuries, but that is true for most sides. Edited by TheBigToePunt (17 May 2023 12.59pm) 100%. Its a tricky balance. We cant afford a squad full of top players. But nor would a top player come to Palace to sit on the bench. He's starting a bit too much for my liking, but its why you need utility players like Jeff in the squad. Who are capable of playing in a few different roles.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.