You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Paddy ‘the manager’ McCarthy
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Paddy ‘the manager’ McCarthy


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Putitout Flag Oxford 05 Jul 23 10.19am

Watching the first training session the camera, made a lot of Paddy, with Roy, obviously working closely together, so the step up for Paddy is real, and he will have hands on from here on.
Come next season if things go well, Paddy is going to be right in the picture.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Jul 23 10.22am

Originally posted by Putitout

Watching the first training session the camera, made a lot of Paddy, with Roy, obviously working closely together, so the step up for Paddy is real, and he will have hands on from here on.
Come next season if things go well, Paddy is going to be right in the picture.

He isn’t.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 05 Jul 23 10.33am

BRING IT ON

Paddy, you have my vote next season.
Ive watched your career and your progress through the ranks and our Under 18's/21's under your managemnt have been impressive.
When you were a player, but out injured, you used to stand where the players came out, when they came back at half time, I watched you motivate players. You are Palace through and through, so hope at long last as with the Academy set up, we have a decent future plan and Paddy will get his chance.....


Originally posted by Jimmy Doyle

I think Paddy has been put in the position of understudy to Roy. To be sure I wouldn't be surprised to see him step into the hotseat for the 24/25 season.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 05 Jul 23 10.55am

What I thought was interesting was that in the games at the end of last season, often around the 60 minute mark, Roy, Ray & Paddy would often go into a bit of a huddle, have a few minutes chat about what was going on, what to do next - obviously as the Manager only Roy could make the ultimate decision but it was good to see them at least discussing the options.

(Maybe they were just having a chat about where to go for a beer after the game, but it didnt look like it)

Originally posted by Putitout

Watching the first training session the camera, made a lot of Paddy, with Roy, obviously working closely together, so the step up for Paddy is real, and he will have hands on from here on.
Come next season if things go well, Paddy is going to be right in the picture.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 Jul 23 11.18am

Originally posted by Painter

He isn’t.

Why?

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jul 23 11.28am

The decision to promote Paddy surely rests on the recommendation of Dougie as Director of Football.

Now, over the years there have been people on here moaning about the lack of succession planning within the Club.

So we presently have a situation where Palace are doing just that. And guess what….people are moaning.

We don’t know for certain what the plan is, but hey, it’s another thing to moan about. If Paddy is to be Roy’s successor, it would be nice for people to embrace the idea and give the guy some support.

It will either work out or it won’t - just the same as if we recruit outside of the club.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jul 23 11.38am

Originally posted by NEILLO

The decision to promote Paddy surely rests on the recommendation of Dougie as Director of Football.

Now, over the years there have been people on here moaning about the lack of succession planning within the Club.

So we presently have a situation where Palace are doing just that. And guess what….people are moaning.

We don’t know for certain what the plan is, but hey, it’s another thing to moan about. If Paddy is to be Roy’s successor, it would be nice for people to embrace the idea and give the guy some support.

It will either work out or it won’t - just the same as if we recruit outside of the club.


I agree. I would add, though, that I imagine Hodgson's input on Paddy's readiness etc. will carry a lot of weight as well.

Also, I wouldn't assume that Roy is only going to be here for one year. If things go well this season and he feels up to it, he may well carry on for a second year. If so, it should be pretty clear to him, Dougie and Steve by the end of the second year whether or not Paddy was ready to step up.


Edited by doombear (05 Jul 2023 11.46am)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Jul 23 11.53am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Why?

In the Premier no, in the Championship possible due to lack of money.

 

aashman12 Flag 05 Jul 23 12.39pm

Originally posted by Casual

If he wasn’t an ex player , he wouldn’t be in anyone’s top 500th choice for our next premier league manager

Of course not because he wouldn't have a job in our club, would any of the Liverpool boot room have got the job of they'd not been part of the club?

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Jul 23 1.07pm

Originally posted by aashman12

Of course not because he wouldn't have a job in our club, would any of the Liverpool boot room have got the job of they'd not been part of the club?

A very good point. L'pools boot room produced, what, 4 title winning managers & not one of them had any managerial experiance. So, why not 'Paddy'?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

est1905 Flag 05 Jul 23 1.18pm

Originally posted by Casual

If he wasn’t an ex player , he wouldn’t be in anyone’s top 500th choice for our next premier league manager

This,
Sentimental, romantic rubbish.

 

est1905 Flag 05 Jul 23 1.20pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

A very good point. L'pools boot room produced, what, 4 title winning managers & not one of them had any managerial experiance. So, why not 'Paddy'?

OMG, Are you seriously comparing the Liverpool boot room that had world class knowledge passed from Paisley to Shankly to Fagan etc to Paddy Macarthy managing our youth team?


 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 05 Jul 23 1.23pm

I believe Pep's first coaching job was the Barca u-21 or B team, before he got the top job there .... just saying ....

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 05 Jul 23 1.38pm

Originally posted by Painter

He isn’t.

You seem very certain.? You could say he is in the picture already, just needs to prove himself , before the big question is asked.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Jul 23 1.44pm

Originally posted by radicalsteve

I believe Pep's first coaching job was the Barca u-21 or B team, before he got the top job there .... just saying ....

Pep McCarthy? Doesn't have same ring to it...

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jul 23 1.46pm

Originally posted by est1905

OMG, Are you seriously comparing the Liverpool boot room that had world class knowledge passed from Paisley to Shankly to Fagan etc to Paddy Macarthy managing our youth team?



Are you suggesting that Hodgson with all his experience doesn't have 'world class knowledge'?

No-one (as far as I can tell) is suggesting that McCarthy is ready to take over now, but then he's not being asked to. He's being asked to continue his apprenticeship as Hodgson's assistant for at least the next season. Time will tell whether he develops sufficiently to be considered as our next manager.

As an aside, the order at Liverpool was Shankly, Paisley, Fagan and, if my memory serves me right a lot of football pundits were sceptical when Liverpool appointed Fagan but he proved them wrong.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 05 Jul 23 2.02pm

Originally posted by doombear


Are you suggesting that Hodgson with all his experience doesn't have 'world class knowledge'?

No-one (as far as I can tell) is suggesting that McCarthy is ready to take over now, but then he's not being asked to. He's being asked to continue his apprenticeship as Hodgson's assistant for at least the next season. Time will tell whether he develops sufficiently to be considered as our next manager.

As an aside, the order at Liverpool was Shankly, Paisley, Fagan and, if my memory serves me right a lot of football pundits were sceptical when Liverpool appointed Fagan but he proved them wrong.

Also Roy Evans came through their system, Ronnie Moran on a temporary basis and arguably Kenny Dalglish.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Jul 23 2.02pm

Originally posted by doombear


Are you suggesting that Hodgson with all his experience doesn't have 'world class knowledge'?

No-one (as far as I can tell) is suggesting that McCarthy is ready to take over now, but then he's not being asked to. He's being asked to continue his apprenticeship as Hodgson's assistant for at least the next season. Time will tell whether he develops sufficiently to be considered as our next manager.

As an aside, the order at Liverpool was Shankly, Paisley, Fagan and, if my memory serves me right a lot of football pundits were sceptical when Liverpool appointed Fagan but he proved them wrong.

Roy Evans & Kenny Dalglish(although he was a player before)

Teddy Eagle has just beaten me to it

Edited by eagleman13 (05 Jul 2023 2.03pm)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

aashman12 Flag 06 Jul 23 7.46am

Originally posted by est1905

OMG, Are you seriously comparing the Liverpool boot room that had world class knowledge passed from Paisley to Shankly to Fagan etc to Paddy Macarthy managing our youth team?


It's all relative, he's working under Roy and Ray who have vast knowledge of the game.

 

est1905 Flag 07 Jul 23 5.30pm

Originally posted by aashman12

It's all relative, he's working under Roy and Ray who have vast knowledge of the game.

Ted Buxton worked under Terry Venables for 30 years and was a damn good coach. Peter Taylor worked for over 20 years alongside Brian Clough and was very talented at spotting talent. Alex Fergusson had numerous No.2s over 30 odd years, not one of them became as good as he was. Only a couple even made it in management. I cant think of one thats still in work as a no.1.
There's nothing 'relative' about it. You're clutching at straws. If Macarthy makes it as a manager in the future I'll be genuinely happy for him. Right now there is zero evidence to back that up. Working a year as a no.2 will do little to change that.
Drawing comparisons with historical figures within the game is reaching at best.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Paddy ‘the manager’ McCarthy