You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Refs
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Refs


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Elpis Flag In a pub 15 Aug 23 2.40pm

Im all for goal line technology but they really do need to ditch var .It creates more problems than it solves with refs not even making decisions anymore but waiting for var intervention .

There was a game at the weekend ,I tink it was Newcastle V Villa when a Newcastle player a mile offside is through on goal . Because its a goalscoring chance the lino is told to not flag and leave it up to VAR . The keeper saves and it goes out and a corner is given
Complete madness , nothing came of it but what happens when they score from the corner ,they dont bring it back to the offside do they .
Its been missused and the refs have become pawns to be controlled from outside the ground

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 15 Aug 23 4.16pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

The penalty given against Lewis Dunk was shocking. Funny but even so it was a shocking decision.

never mind, they get enough help from referees anyway, usually in the form of a penalty whenever they need it

referees just continuing the big club bias at Old Trafford, twas ever thus and always will be

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Aug 23 5.14pm

Originally posted by YT

Well you only have to compare it to Liverpool's shocking penalty at Selhurst Park a couple of seasons back to prove your point about big club bias.

Agreed. The challenge by the keeper last night was pretty close to a martial arts full on assault. Going for the ball as a keeper doesn’t entitle you to wipe out players, more particularly when you get nowhere near the ball. That was a penalty all day long just as the one given against Palace wasn’t.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 15 Aug 23 6.03pm

VAR room at Old Trafford last night

368010214_286814247278197_4886249371119244064_n.jpg Attachment: 368010214_286814247278197_4886249371119244064_n.jpg (89.95Kb)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Aug 23 6.54pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

VAR room at Old Trafford last night

maybe not quite as blatant as that but almost certainly true to an extent.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 15 Aug 23 7.04pm

The IFAB and FIFA are testing the new offside this season in Italy Holland and Sweden. It will give forwards an extra metre. It will come in next season for sure. Wenger has come up with it and it makes a lot of entertainment sense.
The game will become even more about speed.
With Olise on his way and Wilf gone, we gotta buy speed players.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Aug 23 7.18pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Agreed. The challenge by the keeper last night was pretty close to a martial arts full on assault. Going for the ball as a keeper doesn’t entitle you to wipe out players, more particularly when you get nowhere near the ball. That was a penalty all day long just as the one given against Palace wasn’t.

The problem being ,three refs in total wouldn’t call it a pen. Most people including the refereeing bosses knew it was, yet those three contrive a blatantly wrong decision.
Putting these three down for a week isn’t enough, and apologies from the top are not enough . If we have got to the point when three not ,one official can not spot such an obvious penalty , something is really wrong. There have been so many dubious to say the least decisions since VAR, all the more dubious because in each event it takes two or three individuals to agree to be blatantly wrong.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Aug 23 10.41pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Any refs on here?

Why was Ayew given offside at Sheffield last week?

According to the Premier League the rule is as follows.

Though Law 11 (offside) has not explicitly changed, the new guidelines make clear that an attacking player who is offside will not automatically become onside upon a defender touching the ball, unless it was a save.

I had a think about this - so a defender can pass straight to an opposition attacker who is offside? They can score but will be disallowed as offside? The mind boggles. There is going to be mayhem. Shearer, Lineker and Wright will never get their heads round that but Pep will. Almost comical in a farcical, Benny Hill music type of way. I think VAR should be accompanied by said music and edited in that sped up but cut out, missed frame fashion.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 15 Aug 23 11.53pm

Originally posted by Willo

With the utmost respect I have viewed some of the comments on the discussions pertaining to referees with incredulity and concluded that they are nor rooted in sound judgement.

I shall refrain from contesting the 'Charges' for the sole reason that the debates will descend into animus and acrimony and lo and behold a dastardly 'Willo Thread' will be the outcome.

In the interests of HOL I shall keep my counsel.

You really are surpassing yourself already Willow! -.-'

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 23 7.53am

Originally posted by eagleman13

I see the two VAR's & the match official have been *ahem* 'not selected' for this w/ends matches, wonder why?

Happened to Michael Salisbury last season as well

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 23 7.56am

Originally posted by eagleman13

I wish i could give you a proper answer DW, what the people at the EPL HQ do is anybody's guess, same as all big firms tho. I agree with both you & Elpis, it is a quagmire, one that thankfully i no longer have to negotiate after 40 years of reffing & then being an assessor.

Trouble with the laws as they are & have been, everybody has a different interpretation of each & every one of them, Offside law being the biggest, imo. Each country has different ideas on how the game is played, the governing bodies(FA, EPL & EFL) also have different ideas as do the Refereeing bodies like the PGMOL & Referee's Association in England. Who's right? End of the day its the Ref's on the field of play.

As for Ayew, he was offside before the ball was played & when it was played & before it may or may not of touched a defender, therefore, once he received it, boom, flag up. Pity, good goal otherwise.

If decisions can be interpreted differently by officials gives them more wriggle room for big team bias, right?

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Aug 23 8.41am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Happened to Michael Salisbury last season as well

Yes, you're right, he did, not looking good for him atm. As for your 2nd post to mine, probably will/does, tho not for a bit, they will tighten up things then it'll go back to normal after the international break. That's my guess.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Refs