You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > what do consider is a successful season ?
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

what do consider is a successful season ?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
YT Flag Oxford 23 Aug 23 5.57am

Originally posted by PatrickA

The paucity of the ambition in the above posts ( not a criticism) is why the Premier League model will not ultimately be sustainable.
The greed is good nature of the set up will lead to a breakaway super league / greater split of tv revenues to the bigger clubs / ongoing hoovering up of talent from ‘lesser clubs.’
The wealthy owners have only just begun in their Machiavellian manoeuvres.
The essence of sport is competition and once you take that away what are you left with ?
The domination by Real Madrid and Barcelona has killed the game in Spain and it’s not that much better in Germany.
Total dominance is not necessarily attractive to fans of the dominant clubs either.
They’re not happy with a 1-0 v e.g Luton, demanding a 5-0.

I take your point, however for Palace in the top flight, the situation has hardly changed since 1969. It's always been about survival as most other clubs have always been bigger than we are. The numbers are just bigger now than they used to be, and with new sources of cash (most recently Saudi Arabia) they will keep getting bigger. Who remembers being shocked by David Mills signing for West Bromwich Albion in 1976 for half a million; the first English footballer to command such a fee? I remember at the time saying "what madness"..."this can't go on" etc! (In fact who even remembers David Mills? Other than me, obvs.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 23 Aug 23 7.44am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

I remember when we lost the FA Cup Final to United. Our fans were cheering the team and singing their hearts out whilst their fans boo'd them going up the stairs as just an FA Cup "wasn't good enough"

Or to put that another way:

In 1990 Man Utd beat Crystal Palace in the FA Cup Final - an achievement significant enough for the manager to keep his job, having finished a disappointing 13th in the league.

In 2016 Man Utd beat Crystal Palace in the FA Cup Final - an achievement not significant enough for the manager to keep his job, despite having finished 5th in the league.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

PatrickA Flag London 23 Aug 23 8.15am

We did briefly threaten the top at one point in the Coppell years
when we finished third and would have been in the Champions League equivalent if English clubs weren't banned.
That team had Bright, Wright, Gray, Thomas,Salako and Martyn.
These days the greed is good league would never have allowed us to retain these players, chopping us off at the knees before we could threaten.
The inherent imbalance in the league is built in and will only get worse.
This is largely accepted by the fans (probably realistically).
Hence a good season is defined as and limited to 'staying up', 'a good cup run,'seeing some good football.'

Originally posted by YT

I take your point, however for Palace in the top flight, the situation has hardly changed since 1969. It's always been about survival as most other clubs have always been bigger than we are. The numbers are just bigger now than they used to be, and with new sources of cash (most recently Saudi Arabia) they will keep getting bigger. Who remembers being shocked by David Mills signing for West Bromwich Albion in 1976 for half a million; the first English footballer to command such a fee? I remember at the time saying "what madness"..."this can't go on" etc! (In fact who even remembers David Mills? Other than me, obvs.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 23 Aug 23 8.50am

Comfortably stay up, more wins at home than away, because I don’t do many always these days, hopefully win or draw the ones I do go to, bloody the nose of a couple of the big boys, which tend to do each season, and a cup run would be a bonus

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 23 Aug 23 9.58am

Originally posted by PatrickA

The paucity of the ambition in the above posts ( not a criticism) is why the Premier League model will not ultimately be sustainable.
The greed is good nature of the set up will lead to a breakaway super league / greater split of tv revenues to the bigger clubs / ongoing hoovering up of talent from ‘lesser clubs.’
The wealthy owners have only just begun in their Machiavellian manoeuvres.
The essence of sport is competition and once you take that away what are you left with ?
The domination by Real Madrid and Barcelona has killed the game in Spain and it’s not that much better in Germany.
Total dominance is not necessarily attractive to fans of the dominant clubs either.
They’re not happy with a 1-0 v e.g Luton, demanding a 5-0.

You haven't answered the OPs question, most of what you said is correct, but, we cant do anything about it as a club, so what IYO is a successful season for us?

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

PatrickA Flag London 23 Aug 23 10.49am

For me a successful season would entail finishing above Fulham, Brentford and Brighton.
I can accept that we operate on a different level to the top 6 who we're unlikely to catch.
I can't accept that we operate on a different level to Fulham, Brighton and Brentford.
Once you accept that they too have overtaken us, it won't be long before the next club comes along to surpass you.
You're playing at moving forward, but in reality you're moving backwards.
The danger in aiming low is that you can still miss.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 23 Aug 23 12.43pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

For me a successful season would entail finishing above Fulham, Brentford and Brighton.
I can accept that we operate on a different level to the top 6 who we're unlikely to catch.
I can't accept that we operate on a different level to Fulham, Brighton and Brentford.
Once you accept that they too have overtaken us, it won't be long before the next club comes along to surpass you.
You're playing at moving forward, but in reality you're moving backwards.
The danger in aiming low is that you can still miss.

Yes, agree, realistic goals

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 23 Aug 23 12.47pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

For me a successful season would entail finishing above Fulham, Brentford and Brighton.
I can accept that we operate on a different level to the top 6 who we're unlikely to catch.
I can't accept that we operate on a different level to Fulham, Brighton and Brentford.
Once you accept that they too have overtaken us, it won't be long before the next club comes along to surpass you.
You're playing at moving forward, but in reality you're moving backwards.
The danger in aiming low is that you can still miss.

Not realistic this season. Success for me would be getting our highest place in the Prem years i.e.10th or higher.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 23 Aug 23 2.31pm

Mid table with a good cup run.
or
Upper mid table having beaten 2 or 3 of the billionaire clubs.

With both scenarios making SP a fortress that no PL team looked forward to visiting.


Be delighted with either.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Den1923 Flag 23 Aug 23 4.06pm

Securing EPL status for another year without flirting with the bottom three and thus ensuring that we have the best football for our fans to watch and enjoy, a good cup run would be an added bonus but not at the expenses of EPL safety

 

Simber Flag Rustington 23 Aug 23 8.58pm

Surviving the season with such a thread bare squad would be an achievement

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Aug 23 9.10pm

Why is it unrealistic?
I would take Johnstone, Guehi, Anderson, Doucoure, Lerma,Olise and Eze ahead of their equivalents in Fulham, Brentford and Brighton sides ( although Paulinha may have a shout).
Brighton has lost their entire central midfield and two of their best players from last last year.
Fulham has lost their main striker and key player in Mitrovic.
Brentford will be without top scorer and key player, Toney, for half a season.
I would say it's a perfectly reasonable objective to finish higher than these clubs.


Originally posted by rollercoaster

Not realistic this season. Success for me would be getting our highest place in the Prem years i.e.10th or higher.

 

Simber Flag Rustington 24 Aug 23 7.09am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Why is it unrealistic?
I would take Johnstone, Guehi, Anderson, Doucoure, Lerma,Olise and Eze ahead of their equivalents in Fulham, Brentford and Brighton sides ( although Paulinha may have a shout).
Brighton has lost their entire central midfield and two of their best players from last last year.
Fulham has lost their main striker and key player in Mitrovic.
Brentford will be without top scorer and key player, Toney, for half a season.
I would say it's a perfectly reasonable objective to finish higher than these clubs.

Agree with your comments about Fulham and Brentford, but you must have a much brighter pair of red n blue glasses than me if you think that 3right0n will struggle this year


 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Aug 23 7.39am

Paradiso - winning the league and the cup and seeing the new stadium umveiled
Purgatory - treading water in 12th place
Inferno - Brighton PL winners, Millwall promoted, Palace relegated

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 24 Aug 23 7.59am

12th or higher (only Chelsea should be overtaking us)
Good cup run (s)
Roy handing over the reins in May to a new manager in their 40s who knows what they are doing

(The last one is probably the least likely)

 

dorking Flag 24 Aug 23 6.22pm

Take the cups seriously - play our absolute strongest team in every cup game. If we do that I have no complaints

 

mogrem Flag 24 Aug 23 8.25pm

For me it's finishing above some of the bigger clubs and ahead of some.
Been so much talk about how good Fulham and Brentford has been för 1-2 years that you all forgot how good we were like we were like those 2 clubs. Do you see any of them have a 10 year stint? I don't

But it's been so much complaints how we are not better then those, and forgetting last season we were better then Chelsea, Forest, Everton and so on.

And this is not just last year, as the years have gone on in PL we are constatly having more simular clubs to us or bigger below us.

Oops sorry for bad English and beers.

Edited by mogrem (24 Aug 2023 8.26pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > what do consider is a successful season ?