You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our Transfer Priorities - A Mystery?
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our Transfer Priorities - A Mystery?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 02 Sep 23 9.18am

The moaning here is so predictable but completely undeserved. We aren’t owned by the super rich prepared to chuck money at anything. Would you want that?

In my lifetime we have come from the 3rd Division South to being an established member of the best league in the world, with a team capable of giving all others a run for their money. We have 3 players selected for England and others being suggested who are worth the stupid money that today’s market commands. We have a world class academy operating in a great catchment area and with plans to expand our historical ground.

Transfer windows are never easy. Deals require the agreement of several parties often with others also making offers. This isn’t popping down to Tesco’s and buying a jar of caviar. If you have only got a small budget and not willing to use your credit card then maybe a can of beans will need to do. They often prove more nutritious than caviar anyway.

We’ve done well. We have held onto key players and signed a couple of solid ones and one potential. We have a winger who has done well on loan looking as though he will get time to now establish himself.

Enjoy the journey.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

jcreedy Flag 02 Sep 23 9.38am

Yes, we all wanted more attacking options, but knowing that SP and DF only tend to spend where there's value for money, we're going to have to trust their process.

Also worth considering that we have a very expensive main stand to pay for despite the majority of the ownership group either wanting out, or being unsettled.

SP has to take the long-term view, and gambling £30m on a new striker which may not affect league position, and subsequent merit patients, might arguably be seen as unjustified.

Assuming Luton, Sheff Utd and one other fill the bottom three this season, you'd expect us to have enough to not be that third team. So emotion and short-termism aside, of there are no decent options about, why not save money for future windows or the main stand?

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

rikz Flag Croydon 02 Sep 23 10.17am

Originally posted by jcreedy

Yes, we all wanted more attacking options, but knowing that SP and DF only tend to spend where there's value for money, we're going to have to trust their process.

Also worth considering that we have a very expensive main stand to pay for despite the majority of the ownership group either wanting out, or being unsettled.

SP has to take the long-term view, and gambling £30m on a new striker which may not affect league position, and subsequent merit patients, might arguably be seen as unjustified.

Assuming Luton, Sheff Utd and one other fill the bottom three this season, you'd expect us to have enough to not be that third team. So emotion and short-termism aside, of there are no decent options about, why not save money for future windows or the main stand?

A club our size can only ever have short-termism, we will never have a sustained period of success. We've got a great spine which just needed strengthening in a few more positions. Then we could have had a real challenge this year. Just seems like another season, we will settle for staying up. Will sell a couple of players next year and use that money to strengthen the rest of the squad and see what we can do. Massive opportunity missed for me and lack of ambition from the board.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 02 Sep 23 10.24am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The moaning here is so predictable but completely undeserved. We aren’t owned by the super rich prepared to chuck money at anything. Would you want that?

In my lifetime we have come from the 3rd Division South to being an established member of the best league in the world, with a team capable of giving all others a run for their money. We have 3 players selected for England and others being suggested who are worth the stupid money that today’s market commands. We have a world class academy operating in a great catchment area and with plans to expand our historical ground.

Transfer windows are never easy. Deals require the agreement of several parties often with others also making offers. This isn’t popping down to Tesco’s and buying a jar of caviar. If you have only got a small budget and not willing to use your credit card then maybe a can of beans will need to do. They often prove more nutritious than caviar anyway.

We’ve done well. We have held onto key players and signed a couple of solid ones and one potential. We have a winger who has done well on loan looking as though he will get time to now establish himself.

Enjoy the journey.

IMO the moaning isn't about the money we havent spent, its about what we have purchased.

Which ultimately ends up in us having to play Shlupp left wing for at least the first 2 months of the season, perhaps much longer.

Spending 20m on a keeper feels excessive for us. We could ahve got 2 full backs for that, or a decent winger.

There was some good value to be had in this window, and our games thus far have shown that we are going to struggle to score. Others managed to bring in good attacking options on loan on deadline day (e.g. Origi, Sinisterra)

 

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 02 Sep 23 10.31am

Stole my thunder. Bournemouth got Sinisterra on loan. Would be useful until Olise fit which will take a while and of course the Brazilian messiah.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Sep 23 10.35am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Of course what am I talking about! Abysmal memory!

TBF though our CBs slide tackling the ball into the opposition net hardly seems a promising strategy going forward.

We show the way. Pep will wonder why he never thought of it first.

 

jcreedy Flag 02 Sep 23 10.38am

Originally posted by rikz

A club our size can only ever have short-termism, we will never have a sustained period of success. We've got a great spine which just needed strengthening in a few more positions. Then we could have had a real challenge this year. Just seems like another season, we will settle for staying up. Will sell a couple of players next year and use that money to strengthen the rest of the squad and see what we can do. Massive opportunity missed for me and lack of ambition from the board.

A real challenge at what though?


A new main stand will apparently put us in the top ten in the league in terms of income generated. Getting that built will be the priority.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

rikz Flag Croydon 02 Sep 23 10.48am

Originally posted by jcreedy

A real challenge at what though?


A new main stand will apparently put us in the top ten in the league in terms of income generated. Getting that built will be the priority.

How much longer are you willing to wait before questioning the same old excuses of why we still haven't started work on the new stand. Same story, every couple of years it just gets delayed again.

 

jcreedy Flag 02 Sep 23 11.28am

Originally posted by rikz

How much longer are you willing to wait before questioning the same old excuses of why we still haven't started work on the new stand. Same story, every couple of years it just gets delayed again.

The excuses aren't always the same though. I have faith it'll happen, but there's no point in us losing sleep over when that will be.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Sep 23 11.47am

They found an old Roman fort under the main stand
They found an ancient Druid burial site under the Arthur
They found a top secret UFO base deep beneath the pitch

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Sep 23 12.24pm

Originally posted by jcreedy

The excuses aren't always the same though. I have faith it'll happen, but there's no point in us losing sleep over when that will be.

The progress / lack of, is well documented and in the public domain.

Palace prioritised the Academy development ahead of the new stand, and that has contributed to the delay.

But of course we have a number of supporters that think that everything in life is easy and laid on a plate.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Sep 23 12.36pm

Our Transfer Priorities - A Mystery?

Send for Hercule Poirot although I doubt he will be unable to unpick the shareholding in Delaware.

 


One more point

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 02 Sep 23 12.41pm

Problem for me is that we must (mustn't we?) have a recruitment strategy, but what the F*** is it? Young players with re-sale- Holding and Lerma, no. Prem experience? Franca...no. Back-up when we sell a star or two... just Franca, no. Do we only buy in the UK? Do we have no talent spotters in European leagues, seems that way.

There has been no visible sense whatsoever to our recruitment in this window other than (hopefully) we are gathering money for the next manager and for the new stand. I am very frustrated with this club but I guess I have been for most of the last 60 years.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Sep 23 12.51pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

The progress / lack of, is well documented and in the public domain.

Palace prioritised the Academy development ahead of the new stand, and that has contributed to the delay.

But of course we have a number of supporters that think that everything in life is easy and laid on a plate.

Could also be the fact that the academy cost what was it, £5m and the new stand is likely to cost £100m? I think I know what is easier and more productive to achieve. Not knocking it, but we have been talking about starting the build in the off season for the last two seasons, but not a shovel in sight.

Perhaps someone who knows the ins and outs can enlighten us as to exactly what is holding it up now because I thought all of the barriers had been overcome?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Sep 23 12.53pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Problem for me is that we must (mustn't we?) have a recruitment strategy, but what the F*** is it? Young players with re-sale- Holding and Lerma, no. Prem experience? Franca...no. Back-up when we sell a star or two... just Franca, no. Do we only buy in the UK? Do we have no talent spotters in European leagues, seems that way.

There has been no visible sense whatsoever to our recruitment in this window other than (hopefully) we are gathering money for the next manager and for the new stand. I am very frustrated with this club but I guess I have been for most of the last 60 years.

I wonder how many combined years of frustration there are amongst Palace supporters. A high number I would wager!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Sep 23 1.41pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Could also be the fact that the academy cost what was it, £5m and the new stand is likely to cost £100m? I think I know what is easier and more productive to achieve. Not knocking it, but we have been talking about starting the build in the off season for the last two seasons, but not a shovel in sight.

Perhaps someone who knows the ins and outs can enlighten us as to exactly what is holding it up now because I thought all of the barriers had been overcome?

The Academy has cost in excess of £20m.

Trying to develop a stadium in a built up, residential area is a complex project.

The delays have been frustrating. I think the whole scheme was announced by Steve Parish somewhat prematurely.

Work is now planned to start next May.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Sep 23 1.54pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

The Academy has cost in excess of £20m.

Trying to develop a stadium in a built up, residential area is a complex project.

The delays have been frustrating. I think the whole scheme was announced by Steve Parish somewhat prematurely.

Work is now planned to start next May.

Fingers crossed it does then. It’s a shame that in the last 5 years of us trying to achieve this, building/material costs have increased by about 50%. Concrete cost has risen massively last 5 years. That’s a couple of decent players lost to a load of bricks and mortar!


 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Sep 23 2.11pm

On a serious note I don't think there is a mystery to our transfer priorities.

Money is the driver and with the board unable or unwilling to invest large sums it's all about plugging gaps.

I'm sure that Roy would have loved 5/6 players but my guess is that he was given a Hobson's choice:

Goalkeeper:
Guaita wanted to leave and was kicking off. Johnson for some reason has not settled and the backup keepers are too young or not good enough.

Centre Half:
The game against Plymouth showed us that Tompkins is no longer reliable and Richards gets injured too easily. O'Brien was sold, was this a mistake or was it to placate Textor who publicly complained that he wasn't being listened to.

I expect Roy told Dougie and Steve I need a Zaha replacement and a forward and he was told sure but only if we can get them on loan which we couldn't.

In other words with the limited transfer budget we have been looking for bargains never an easy market to dip into.

Given all of the above and with Roy's defensive instincts I guess we prioritised the defence.

 


One more point

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Sep 23 3.07pm

Originally posted by Badger11

On a serious note I don't think there is a mystery to our transfer priorities.

Money is the driver and with the board unable or unwilling to invest large sums it's all about plugging gaps.

I'm sure that Roy would have loved 5/6 players but my guess is that he was given a Hobson's choice:

Goalkeeper:
Guaita wanted to leave and was kicking off. Johnson for some reason has not settled and the backup keepers are too young or not good enough.

Centre Half:
The game against Plymouth showed us that Tompkins is no longer reliable and Richards gets injured too easily. O'Brien was sold, was this a mistake or was it to placate Textor who publicly complained that he wasn't being listened to.

I expect Roy told Dougie and Steve I need a Zaha replacement and a forward and he was told sure but only if we can get them on loan which we couldn't.

In other words with the limited transfer budget we have been looking for bargains never an easy market to dip into.

Given all of the above and with Roy's defensive instincts I guess we prioritised the defence.

I wish they would tell us what their strategy is, because there were numerous players available on loans or for fees of less than £10m and we were not even associated with them. Yes, we tried for Ekitike but surely you don’t just stick all your eggs in one basket.

I disagree about Johnstone not having settled because all of the noise coming out of Palace is that they will be fighting each other for the number 1 spot and not that he will be moving on.

Would any manager other than Roy accept the fact that every time he asks for players he doesn’t get any? Let’s face it, this is not the first time he has not been supported.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 Sep 23 3.32pm

Johnstone hailed as an England player by the app one minute. Next minute Roy says Henderson will definitely start. I don't see this being problematic. We'll be looking for another keeper in January.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our Transfer Priorities - A Mystery?