You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton to be deducted 12 points
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton to be deducted 12 points


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Oct 23 4.40pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

A Toffee hammer?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Oct 23 4.41pm

Originally posted by Goalpost1

I think they'll end up losing 6 points because the powers that be will want to give them a chance to escape relegation. Even with their recent Houdini style acts in recent seasons it'd be a mountain for them to climb with a 12 points deduction. They'd need to be in the territory of playing to the level to get into Europe and they are nowhere near that.

Looking at the teams in PL this season I think I would risk accepting a 6 point deduction. Hopefully, if they appeal and lose, deduction is increased

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 Oct 23 5.16pm

It's not enough to give them a 12 points deduction, to get rid of Andy Burnham you would have to relegate them.

A football regulator with teeth long overdue.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Oct 23 5.39pm

I agree that its both complex & convoluted -

The only way that I think it could work is if the PL employed say 4 full time sports specialized accountant / auditors, these accounts / auditors being responsible for say 5 clubs each, they work hand in hand with each club as sort of financial watchdogs throughout each season, so that at any given time there is a financial report available so it can be easily seen by club & PL if a club is within the rules or about to take a decision which will put them outside the rules so that this transparency provides the basis for any FFP charges.

Of course it relies on the PL employing the right people & the clubs agreeing to allow complete transparency to these auditors throughout the clubs financial lifetime.

I doubt it would happen & if it did it would probably just drive any underhand dealings deeper underground.


Originally posted by grumpymort


Correct as soon as you go into administration it is applied.

It is delayed because it's complex.

Think of it as a trial you need to gather the evidence and present it to the other side first with a fair amount of clubs making it slow/difficult to even get all the records required.

Look at Man City for example its been years and on purpose they are holding things up because they can afford to.

Those clubs which have been relegated it's over and have no valid case you can't prove that by them spending more has changed any results and the same with if you argue if they had so many points they would have been relegated again you don't know that.

It's messy and doesn't look good for the sport I expect some payments will be paid that is it.

They need to make football in this country transparent too much hidden away everything when it comes to money side of things should be open (they wont do this because its another corrupt sport)

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 19 Nov 23 5.52pm

So it came to pass - no one likes to see it..!!

Payback for Vieira..!!

If we’d only have beaten them last weekend, as we should have done - they would been bottom of the league on 1 point..!!

If you believe what you read - both Leeds and Leicester have said should the case be proven - they will both be sung Everton for £100M each..!!

That with the deal with the new owners not done - and them declining to comment on the current situation - plus new.ground not paid for and current cost at £760M and still climbing- things looking decidedly bleak..!!

As I said no one likes to see it..!!

COYP

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 19 Nov 23 6.54pm

Seeing Everton deducted points is great. They aren't very nice.
Any club who breaks the rules deserves punishment.

I feel like the league have done this at a good time for Everton because I expect them to stay up even with ten points knocked off.

The question will now be whether the rule makers have the bottle to chuck Man City out of the league if the allegations about their activities are upheld.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 20 Nov 23 3.26am

Is there a run down of what may be up for city - we all know they work the loop holes, I can't see them being touched,

 


This was once a quality forum....

uncleneal Flag Croydon 20 Nov 23 7.37am

Good season for the fine - think they will still stay up.

So Annoying we did not beat them

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Nov 23 7.48am

On the Everton points deduction a lot depends upon what happens next with any legal claims for compensation from the clubs that were relegated, substantial damages could derail the takeover & force Everton into administration & another 9 point deduction which would probably end up being a nail in their proverbial PL coffin.

 

YT Flag Oxford 20 Nov 23 8.29am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

On the Everton points deduction a lot depends upon what happens next with any legal claims for compensation from the clubs that were relegated, substantial damages could derail the takeover & force Everton into administration & another 9 point deduction which would probably end up being a nail in their proverbial PL coffin.

Any such damages claims, if challenged, will take years to progress and conclude.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Nov 23 9.13am

Originally posted by uncleneal

Good season for the fine - think they will still stay up.

So Annoying we did not beat them

Yep agree, might be the lowest survival point total required of all time.

Everton have hit a bit of form too. I wouldn't put it past them now to galvanise and put together a little run.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Nov 23 9.31am

A delayed compensation case wouldn't help Everton as its doubtful any prospective new owner would want to take over whilst legal proceedings remain inconclusive.

Originally posted by YT

Any such damages claims, if challenged, will take years to progress and conclude.

 

Den1923 Flag 20 Nov 23 9.54am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

A delayed compensation case wouldn't help Everton as its doubtful any prospective new owner would want to take over whilst legal proceedings remain inconclusive.

Yes fully agree, whilst legal proceedings are on going then the club will have to make provisions in its accounts for any future legal costs and likely compensation awards. Not something a new owner would be happy to take on!

 

Jacey Flag 20 Nov 23 11.16am

City have over 100 charges of various breaches to face and Chelsea are also in the mix for their various breaches.
It cannot be right that two of the big six can escape sanctions when Everton have been deducted 10 points and I expect even larger penalties for these two big fish!!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Nov 23 11.18am

Originally posted by Jacey

City have over 100 charges of various breaches to face and Chelsea are also in the mix for their various breaches.
It cannot be right that two of the big six can escape sanctions when Everton have been deducted 10 points and I expect even larger penalties for these two big fish!!

Can't wait for this and our new main stand.

 


Red and Blue Army!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 20 Nov 23 12.06pm

Found this which gives predicted final placings & yes, Everton do escape . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Nov 23 2.26pm

I still think the ultimate outcome will be a slap-on-wrist fine after appeal.

And I fail to see any winnable cause of action from the relegated clubs.

Also stop gloating. There but for the grace of God we have been!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 20 Nov 23 2.47pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I still think the ultimate outcome will be a slap-on-wrist fine after appeal.

And I fail to see any winnable cause of action from the relegated clubs.

Also stop gloating. There but for the grace of God we have been!

We have indeed been, were docked 10 points and only just avoided relegation.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 22 Nov 23 7.38pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I still think the ultimate outcome will be a slap-on-wrist fine after appeal.

And I fail to see any winnable cause of action from the relegated clubs.

Also stop gloating. There but for the grace of God we have been!

GTBH - don’t get the “stop gloating” part..!!

If it was us in the same scenario - do you seriously think we would get any sympathy from them - err that would be no then..!!

After what happened at Goodison with all things Vieria and their fans - I consequently have no sympathy for them..!!

They have been breaching the rules that the rest of us abide by - so in simple terms “cheating” - they can dress it up in any way they want but that’s the bottom line..!!

If I feel sorry for anyone in this scenario- it’s Leicester and Leeds - IMO both better teams than Everton last season - but Everton stayed up and have now been duly sanctioned because they cheated..!!

I just wish the Premier League had dealt with it within the season as the Championship have done on numerous occasions - then the right outcome would have been achieved in that either Leicester or Leeds would have rightfully stayed up..!!

COYP

 

crvenaeagle Flag 22 Nov 23 8.19pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

GTBH - don’t get the “stop gloating” part..!!

If it was us in the same scenario - do you seriously think we would get any sympathy from them - err that would be no then..!!

After what happened at Goodison with all things Vieria and their fans - I consequently have no sympathy for them..!!

They have been breaching the rules that the rest of us abide by - so in simple terms “cheating” - they can dress it up in any way they want but that’s the bottom line..!!

If I feel sorry for anyone in this scenario- it’s Leicester and Leeds - IMO both better teams than Everton last season - but Everton stayed up and have now been duly sanctioned because they cheated..!!

I just wish the Premier League had dealt with it within the season as the Championship have done on numerous occasions - then the right outcome would have been achieved in that either Leicester or Leeds would have rightfully stayed up..!!

COYP

You're right, no, but I don't think the behaviour of an Everton fan is one with which to set your standards.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton to be deducted 12 points