Dubai Eagle 29 Oct 23 8.33am |
|
|
Might be more effective against Everton -
Originally posted by n wales eagles
I think his frustration lies in the lack of financial support he is given especially in the striker situation and probably he's getting a bit p****d off with the injury situation particularly to eze and oliseA great gesture of our support would be a chant of "cos we support Roy hodgson Roy hodgson Roy hodgson and that's the way we like it". at Burnley.We really owe this guy a lot .
|
PatrickA London 29 Oct 23 8.39am |
|
|
I thought the reason for the uncharacteristic praise was that Roy knew he didn't plan to have him in Friday's squad so the praise was a way of giving him a boost to offset the disappointment of being left out. Perhaps I'm overthinking...
Originally posted by Badger11
And didn't even put him on the bench which I thought was a strange decision given his fulsome praise.
|
Badger11 Beckenham 29 Oct 23 8.52am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I thought the reason for the uncharacteristic praise was that Roy knew he didn't plan to have him in Friday's squad so the praise was a way of giving him a boost to offset the disappointment of being left out. Perhaps I'm overthinking...
You could be right who knows however if I was ME I would find it confusing fulsome praise and then ignored.
One more point
|
Aray South London 29 Oct 23 9.29am |
|
|
I thought Roy was unwise to criticise the young players he gave 20 mins to failing to overcome the position we were due to experienced pros. If it was a moan to Parish/board it was a poor decision as it was unlikely to give JRS, Franca or anyone else much of a boost. I think confidence is important for players to perform, especially when they are unproven.
Let’s face it. Roy would never have been the manager to have overseen the creation of this new squad. But he’s so far done a great job of getting us back on track after Vieira got derailed. I hope any frustration he has from the gaping holes in the squad strength (striker and fullbacks IMO) don’t stop him from making the most of the potential talent available. This is an opportunity
|
eritheagle Erith 29 Oct 23 9.48am |
|
Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE
Some good comments here..I just don't think he should be knocking the youngsters, see how things turn out against Burnley and Everton
I saw it as Roy doing it as a challenge to these subs/young players. He can't have a go at the older players (as they won't stand for it) in this way but he can aim it at the younger ones and get away with it and hopefully get a positive reaction from them.
I hope this doesn't put Roy off playing youngsters though as i'm praying he gives a striker from the U10's a chance against Burnley rather than those 2 numpty's, Lazy G1t and Headless Chicken, who we play up front every game!
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Oct 23 9.58am |
|
|
At our club we have several positions in the side where a 16 year old who can play football would do just as well as the supposed professionals we have. Up front is the first that springs to mind. Edouard over Mateta but pretty much anyone except them anyway.
Red and Blue Army!
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Oct 23 10.18am |
|
|
I think some people are being naive if they think Roy is just a pleasant, avuncular chap.
He's a Premier League manager with 500 games under his belt. You don't achieve that by being nice all the time.
His words may seem a little harsh especially as they are in the public domain, but he was right in what he said.
The youngsters need to step up when given an opportunity, and I think he was making that point.
And I'm sure he will be re-iterating that in training this week.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 29 Oct 23 10.24am |
|
|
I also think that people forget that 90% of the games he played for Flamengo (which admittedly wasn't many) where in the center of the pitch, CF, AM or SS
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
southnorwoodhill 29 Oct 23 10.30am |
|
|
With these comments Roy is attempting to shift attention away from his favoured tactics which for him end in a perfect 0-0. It worked at home against Forest and Fulham, congratulations. I'm not sure how stating that a top ten finish is the aim on the one hand, and playing for 0-0 results on the other can possibly exist on the same page, but here we are. Chuck youngsters on for 10/15 minutes to chase a losing game and then insinuate that it didn't happen because of them, ha ha...
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 29 Oct 23 10.30am |
|
Originally posted by eritheagle
I saw it as Roy doing it as a challenge to these subs/young players. He can't have a go at the older players (as they won't stand for it) in this way but he can aim it at the younger ones and get away with it and hopefully get a positive reaction from them.
I hope this doesn't put Roy off playing youngsters though as i'm praying he gives a striker from the U10's a chance against Burnley rather than those 2 numpty's, Lazy G1t and Headless Chicken, who we play up front every game!
I hope not too, Ayew LW, Ahamada AM, Schlupp RW and Franca CF, with Ebowei coming on for Schlupp or Ahamada, but i think that is unlikely as me having a c**p in King Charlies Briefcase
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
Putitout Oxford 29 Oct 23 10.31am |
|
|
Hodgson was pleased with the teams general performance he made that very clear, so he wasn’t under mining the teams confidence. Having said that he was very truthful to the young players, they are all he is left with, and in every respect this is the big time, they have to perform, and he can not wait for them to find that out by some longer route. I think it’s the board he is really frustrated with, what he has said was as much for them as these lads , because he really should not have to throw them into the fire, as is the case when getting hammered at St James, and losing 2-0 to a top of the league Spurs . It’s a bit of a joke really, as we were never going to put them on 3-0 up were we? And that’s how it should be done, no pressure.
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Oct 23 10.45am |
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
With these comments Roy is attempting to shift attention away from his favoured tactics which for him end in a perfect 0-0. It worked at home against Forest and Fulham, congratulations. I'm not sure how stating that a top ten finish is the aim on the one hand, and playing for 0-0 results on the other can possibly exist on the same page, but here we are. Chuck youngsters on for 10/15 minutes to chase a losing game and then insinuate that it didn't happen because of them, ha ha...
Not at all. Roy praised the overall performance of the players.
The last few games have been frustrating. Without the creativity of Eze and Olise we are left with a workmenlike outfit with the already known gaps in squad quality and quantity now being highlighted. Quite what more Hodgson can do about that I don't know.
I didn't interpret his comments as blaming the youngsters for losing the game. Just that they didn't have the positive impact hoped for.
Oh and the aspiration of a Top 10 finish clearly died when the transfer window closed. Hanging onto our star players was laudable but the budget was spent badly.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
ripleyeagle Ripley Surrey 29 Oct 23 10.51am |
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I think some people are being naive if they think Roy is just a pleasant, avuncular chap.
He's a Premier League manager with 500 games under his belt. You don't achieve that by being nice all the time.
His words may seem a little harsh especially as they are in the public domain, but he was right in what he said.
The youngsters need to step up when given an opportunity, and I think he was making that point.
And I'm sure he will be re-iterating that in training this week.
I totally agree with this comment.
|
Wright stuff Bexley 29 Oct 23 11.00am |
|
|
Yes he should go, worst form of management undermining young players who need a confidence boost not a dressing down in front of the public!
|
bromleysteve01 Bromley 29 Oct 23 11.01am |
|
|
I think perhaps the youngsters would do better given more chances and opportunity Once Eze and Olise return sell off Mateta, Schlupp, Tomkins and Reidwald in January and buy 1 or 2 upgrades and put more youngsters on the bench
|
Glazier#1 29 Oct 23 11.05am |
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
With these comments Roy is attempting to shift attention away from his favoured tactics which for him end in a perfect 0-0. It worked at home against Forest and Fulham, congratulations. I'm not sure how stating that a top ten finish is the aim on the one hand, and playing for 0-0 results on the other can possibly exist on the same page, but here we are. Chuck youngsters on for 10/15 minutes to chase a losing game and then insinuate that it didn't happen because of them, ha ha...
Give it a rest, please. You may consider your fulsome disdain to be 'my opinion and entitled to it' but you have this entrenched view of Mr Hodgson which will never shift, regardless of the evidence presented to you time and time again which refutes your stubborn view..
According to you, we should go gung-ho for the win, no matter who we are playing. God, I'm glad you're not in control of the team: we'd be relegated by now if you were.
|
southnorwoodhill 29 Oct 23 11.26am |
|
Originally posted by Glazier#1
Give it a rest, please. You may consider your fulsome disdain to be 'my opinion and entitled to it' but you have this entrenched view of Mr Hodgson which will never shift, regardless of the evidence presented to you time and time again which refutes your stubborn view..
According to you, we should go gung-ho for the win, no matter who we are playing. God, I'm glad you're not in control of the team: we'd be relegated by now if you were.
I'd refer you back, as I often do, to a certain Tony Pulis, who also liked a solid defensive game, but somehow found a way for his arguably lesser talented side to score a goal or two using the means available to him / them. I'm tired of all this "Poor Roy, he doesn't have the players" or "Roy can play attacking football, just look at last season" nonsense. PV was lambasted for a period of Patball during a very tricky run of games last season, Roy plays a bit of Royball and it's (again) "He has to play like this while so and so players are injured". All excuses for a manager who tactical default setting is to negate rather than create. I'd say get on with it Roy, and be a little bolder against teams like Forest and Fulham. That's all, show some intent.
|
Putitout Oxford 29 Oct 23 11.36am |
|
|
Obviously the board think the young players are good enough to take on the Newcastles, Spurs, of this world. Can anyone here honestly say from what they have seen of them say they are. ? I have seen a lot of them at their levels, and in their cameos, and I can’t. And it’s because most lack really good first touch and close control, then throw in physicality . It’s a case of grasping at straws, Ebowei, scores a goal, and does well on the night, great, and Hodgson praised him. That doesn’t translate to first team success, he will rarely if ever be allowed a goal like that in the Premier and his general play is still a little to loose for the big league, this applies not just him but virtually all of our younger players,
|
PatrickA London 29 Oct 23 11.40am |
|
|
I would agree that we should show more intent, at least against mid table and lower teams, and also on the observations re Pulis who seems to be disliked for reasons of his personality as opposed to his achievements.
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
I'd refer you back, as I often do, to a certain Tony Pulis, who also liked a solid defensive game, but somehow found a way for his arguably lesser talented side to score a goal or two using the means available to him / them. I'm tired of all this "Poor Roy, he doesn't have the players" or "Roy can play attacking football, just look at last season" nonsense. PV was lambasted for a period of Patball during a very tricky run of games last season, Roy plays a bit of Royball and it's (again) "He has to play like this while so and so players are injured". All excuses for a manager who tactical default setting is to negate rather than create. I'd say get on with it Roy, and be a little bolder against teams like Forest and Fulham. That's all, show some intent.
|
Putitout Oxford 29 Oct 23 11.42am |
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
I'd refer you back, as I often do, to a certain Tony Pulis, who also liked a solid defensive game, but somehow found a way for his arguably lesser talented side to score a goal or two using the means available to him / them. I'm tired of all this "Poor Roy, he doesn't have the players" or "Roy can play attacking football, just look at last season" nonsense. PV was lambasted for a period of Patball during a very tricky run of games last season, Roy plays a bit of Royball and it's (again) "He has to play like this while so and so players are injured". All excuses for a manager who tactical default setting is to negate rather than create. I'd say get on with it Roy, and be a little bolder against teams like Forest and Fulham. That's all, show some intent.
Would you say the team showed no intent to attack the Spurs goal.? Whatever your answer, it’s on the record they did. There was no one saying don’t have a go .
|