You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer policy
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer policy


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
beak Flag croydon 31 Oct 23 10.26am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I've noted from many comments on these forums there is a lot of discontent about our transfer policy e.g no Zaha replacement, no new full backs, no new striker, no loans brought in.
Furthermore, players brought in at goalkeeper and at centre back where we already have good players.
This is seen as misallocation of our scarce resources where we have glaring gaps elsewhere.
I can only assume the club are looking at the medium term as opposed to the immediate need.
It's likely to be Tomkins' last season and rumours continue around the future of Guehi and Anderson, so Holding may be viewed with the medium term in mind, particularly if the fee was reasonable.
The Henderson deal is a head scratcher for a number of reasons.
His injury record isn't great and Johnstone has done well.
It was generally thought we'd go for a talented and experienced back up instead.
Franca may well turn out to be a bargain, but it's a risk for a club of our stature
For £25 million we should be getting an immediate first team player.
I suppose the above highlights the discrepancy in approach between the fans and the club.
The fans want to see squad shortcomings dealt with now, whereas the club take a longer term view taking into account the terms of players' contracts which we are unfamiliar with.
Ideally you'd want to be able to do both, but this is evidently defeating us at present.

Parish like most good businessmen is thinking long term,most fans think very short term and thus it will ever be.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Oct 23 10.51am

Originally posted by beak

Parish like most good businessmen is thinking long term,most fans think very short term and thus it will ever be.

There's a Roy Hodgson sized flaw in that argument !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Oct 23 11.19am

Originally posted by beak

Parish like most good businessmen is thinking long term,most fans think very short term and thus it will ever be.

So Sorloth, Mateta, Meyer, to name but 3 of a long list was thinking long term?

They do make mistakes you know and spunking £40+million on an injury prone keeper and an unproven youngster could prove to be the latest in a long list.

If they come good then great, but you can’t call taking a chance, thinking for the future. It’s not like they came to us free of charge.

I think you will also find that the large majority of CEO’s are the most short termist people you’ve ever come across.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 31 Oct 23 12.26pm

Originally posted by beak

Parish like most good businessmen is thinking long term,most fans think very short term and thus it will ever be.

It doesn't matter how good a businessman he is, long term we will never be anywhere near the big 6, 7 now with Newcastle. We will never be a top 10 club long term. We will only ever have short term success anyway.

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Oct 23 12.37pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Question - which is most likely?

1. A finished new main stand
2. Buying a 15 goal a season striker

You might as well ask: Which is more likely?

1. Me winning the Euromillions on Friday
2. Me having a threesome with Rachel Riley and Ariana Grande on Friday.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 31 Oct 23 2.09pm

Originally posted by YT

You might as well ask: Which is more likely?

1. Me winning the Euromillions on Friday
2. Me having a threesome with Rachel Riley and Ariana Grande on Friday.

you're quite right, A Threesome with those two is much More likely to happen on a Saturday

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Oct 23 2.39pm

I don't think it is possible to piece together the club's transfer 'strategy' from the list of players we signed, or even from the list of positions where an upgrade was not signed.

We would need to see the list of players the club enquired about and/or tried to sign but ultimately did not, the proportion of our budget we were prepared to commit to the fee and wages, plus understand the reason each of those deals did not progress in order to understand the club's priorities. We don't have that information, and never will.

None of us know if the club, for example, went hell-for-leather in pursuit of a new right-back only for that player to get a better offer at the last minute. Or if we were in advanced talks with two right backs, one as backup to the other. Or three. Or ten, only for all of them to knock us back, or ask for silly money, or move somewhere else, or get injured. The absence of a new right-back alone tells you nothing about what the club wanted to do, tried to do, how hard they tried etc.

The best we can see is general trends over the medium term. It seems evident that, generally speaking, we have moved from spending money we don't really have on established top-flight players with European experience (Cabeye, Sakho, Benteke, PVA etc) to having no money to spend (the original Roy years) to signing young players with potential sell-on value that will have to be sold sooner or later (Olise, Eze, Dacoure, Guehi etc).

Outside of overall trends, an opportunity to sign someone might be attractive for any number of reasons. Like most, I've no idea why we signed Henderson, for instance, but then I don't work at the club in a senior position. Maybe Johnstone wants to leave. Maybe the club think one or other goalie can be sold at a profit somewhere down the road. Maybe they just feel that, following Guiata's tantrum, having two top-class keepers is essential and couldn't get a cheaper one. Christ knows. One thing is for sure though, the thought process will not be the same as that which led to the signing of Lerma, which in turn will not be the same as the thinking behind signing Franca. Each deal will have its own set of circumstances, and may or may not adhere to the general trend.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Oct 2023 2.46pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Oct 23 3.03pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I don't think it is possible to piece together the club's transfer 'strategy' from the list of players we signed, or even from the list of positions where an upgrade was not signed.

We would need to see the list of players the club enquired about and/or tried to sign but ultimately did not, the proportion of our budget we were prepared to commit to the fee and wages, plus understand the reason each of those deals did not progress in order to understand the club's priorities. We don't have that information, and never will.

None of us know if the club, for example, went hell-for-leather in pursuit of a new right-back only for that player to get a better offer at the last minute. Or if we were in advanced talks with two right backs, one as backup to the other. Or three. Or ten, only for all of them to knock us back, or ask for silly money, or move somewhere else, or get injured. The absence of a new right-back alone tells you nothing about what the club wanted to do, tried to do, how hard they tried etc.

The best we can see is general trends over the medium term. It seems evident that, generally speaking, we have moved from spending money we don't really have on established top-flight players with European experience (Cabeye, Sakho, Benteke, PVA etc) to having no money to spend (the original Roy years) to signing young players with potential sell-on value that will have to be sold sooner or later (Olise, Eze, Dacoure, Guehi etc).

Outside of overall trends, an opportunity to sign someone might be attractive for any number of reasons. Like most, I've no idea why we signed Henderson, for instance, but then I don't work at the club in a senior position. Maybe Johnstone wants to leave. Maybe the club think one or other goalie can be sold at a profit somewhere down the road. Maybe they just feel that, following Guiata's tantrum, having two top-class keepers is essential and couldn't get a cheaper one. Christ knows. One thing is for sure though, the thought process will not be the same as that which led to the signing of Lerma, which in turn will not be the same as the thinking behind signing Franca. Each deal will have its own set of circumstances, and may or may not adhere to the general trend.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Oct 2023 2.46pm)

You are right, we don’t know what didn’t occur, but we all know pretty well what actually occurred at the last window and at the previous window and the one before that, ad nauseum. I think we have had 5 possibly 6 windows now in which we have been looking at a RB replacement. Why we haven’t bought Walker-Peters is a bit of a mystery. He would have been perfect for us.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Oct 23 4.06pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You are right, we don’t know what didn’t occur, but we all know pretty well what actually occurred at the last window and at the previous window and the one before that, ad nauseum. I think we have had 5 possibly 6 windows now in which we have been looking at a RB replacement. Why we haven’t bought Walker-Peters is a bit of a mystery. He would have been perfect for us.


Leaving aside that we did sign Ferguson, Clyne, and Richards in that time, neither of us know if we did try to sign Walker-Peters, or if we did, how hard we tried, or why we didn't get him. Very hard to be critical of Palace without that information, and that's my point really.

Maybe we did bid for Walker-Peters but were outbid by Southampton, or he wanted to leave London, or they offered more in wages, or he fancied his chances of being first choice for them more than for us.

Maybe the club didn't think much of him (I personally don't). Who knows? Either way, if we are looking for players that were seemingly feasible signings you can take Walker-Peters and times him by at least a hundred over the last few years I'd guess. Each will have a story of its own that we will never know.

 

beak Flag croydon 31 Oct 23 4.24pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

So Sorloth, Mateta, Meyer, to name but 3 of a long list was thinking long term?

They do make mistakes you know and spunking £40+million on an injury prone keeper and an unproven youngster could prove to be the latest in a long list.

If they come good then great, but you can’t call taking a chance, thinking for the future. It’s not like they came to us free of charge.

I think you will also find that the large majority of CEO’s are the most short termist people you’ve ever come across.

Parish has £200 million he must have done something right surely.

 

beak Flag croydon 31 Oct 23 4.53pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

you're quite right, A Threesome with those two is much More likely to happen on a Saturday

Well,your mistake is your nomenclature, the Crazy frog (a much better moniker) has defo done number two.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Oct 23 6.11pm

Allegedly Roy is here for this season only. Why therefore would Parish and Co sanction transfer funds in January knowing that there will be a different manager next season, probably with a different tactical outlook?


Edited by southnorwoodhill (31 Oct 2023 6.51pm)

 

pssguy Flag 31 Oct 23 6.18pm

Originally posted by beak

Parish like most good businessmen is thinking long term,most fans think very short term and thus it will ever be.

Tomkins and Clyne extensions suggest you are wrong

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Oct 23 7.33pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Tomkins and Clyne extensions suggest you are wrong


Why?
It just as easily (and more likely IMO) says that the club isn't looking to upgrade those two until next season when a new manager may be brought in. For example the new manager may want to play three at the back and ask for wing-backs etc.

Edited by doombear (31 Oct 2023 7.34pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Oct 23 8.45pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Allegedly Roy is here for this season only. Why therefore would Parish and Co sanction transfer funds in January knowing that there will be a different manager next season, probably with a different tactical outlook?


Edited by southnorwoodhill (31 Oct 2023 6.51pm)

It will be Paddy and Ray so no difference really-

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 7.47am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It will be Paddy and Ray so no difference really-

If so I envisage relegation in a season or two. My reasoning is based partly on Paddy's lack of experience at this level, but mainly on the players available.
I divide the players into two groups: those who are good enough to attract interest from clubs higher up the league, and those who are not.
Of those good enough my contention is that they will ask for a transfer because they are ambitious and have had interest from other clubs. Given that a few will have contracts near expiration the only way CPFC can keep them is by improving their conditions to match what other clubs offer, not only financially, but in terms of the chance to win something, playing in a first rate stadium, playing in Europe etc. Unlikely.
The second group of players is made up of those who make up the numbers. These are divided into players comfortable with their place at CPFC, plodding round for a decent pay packet, and those who can go to to clubs sideways or below.
I am reminded of a reply to a post of mine by Dubai Eagle suggesting we have spent what we have to stand still. Accurate I think, and given so, it is likely we will lose our ambitious best players with no ready replacements available due to lack of finances.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 8.31am)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 01 Nov 23 8.58am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I don't think it is possible to piece together the club's transfer 'strategy' from the list of players we signed, or even from the list of positions where an upgrade was not signed.

We would need to see the list of players the club enquired about and/or tried to sign but ultimately did not, the proportion of our budget we were prepared to commit to the fee and wages, plus understand the reason each of those deals did not progress in order to understand the club's priorities. We don't have that information, and never will.

None of us know if the club, for example, went hell-for-leather in pursuit of a new right-back only for that player to get a better offer at the last minute. Or if we were in advanced talks with two right backs, one as backup to the other. Or three. Or ten, only for all of them to knock us back, or ask for silly money, or move somewhere else, or get injured. The absence of a new right-back alone tells you nothing about what the club wanted to do, tried to do, how hard they tried etc.

The best we can see is general trends over the medium term. It seems evident that, generally speaking, we have moved from spending money we don't really have on established top-flight players with European experience (Cabeye, Sakho, Benteke, PVA etc) to having no money to spend (the original Roy years) to signing young players with potential sell-on value that will have to be sold sooner or later (Olise, Eze, Dacoure, Guehi etc).

Outside of overall trends, an opportunity to sign someone might be attractive for any number of reasons. Like most, I've no idea why we signed Henderson, for instance, but then I don't work at the club in a senior position. Maybe Johnstone wants to leave. Maybe the club think one or other goalie can be sold at a profit somewhere down the road. Maybe they just feel that, following Guiata's tantrum, having two top-class keepers is essential and couldn't get a cheaper one. Christ knows. One thing is for sure though, the thought process will not be the same as that which led to the signing of Lerma, which in turn will not be the same as the thinking behind signing Franca. Each deal will have its own set of circumstances, and may or may not adhere to the general trend.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Oct 2023 2.46pm)

I don't disagree with the thrust of your argument.

And I can only presume the club had a strategy for this window. My issue would be that if they did, they failed miserably.

Not replacing your talisman. Someone who has carried the club for a decade is at best reckless, at worse suicidal.

In other windows I would have been more accepting, but it felt like there was a lot of business done, at our level. I still cant get away from the Jack Harrison loan.

So I guess to surmise, no we don't know what the strategy was, but we know the result. Accountability still lies in the same place.

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 01 Nov 23 9.03am

Paddy and Ray next season is very unlikely to happen. They don’t appear to get on. Many of you will not have noticed the incident in the Bournemouth game last season where Ray ordered Paddy to sit down when he tried to approach Roy during the match. This did not go unnoticed in the Director’s Box and Ray was subsequently confined to the dugout. To show his annoyance Ray wore long trousers in the Forest Match.
There seems to be an uneasy peace between them now. It appears to me that Paddy is responsible for the forwards, an area Roy has admitted on several occasions he does not coach (and it shows), with Roy and Ray marshalling the midfield and defence. The introduction of the three younger players happened after a chat with Paddy. Could it be that Roy’s comments not only show his frustration with the Club’s transfer inaction but also a backhanded jibe at the imposition of Paddy as assistant manager?

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 23 9.24am

I have no idea of the substance of these rumours, but have observed there is little interaction between McCarthy and Lewington during games or indeed in the training videos.
This may just be coincidence.
Ray and Roy are very much a team with about 80 years experience between them and may find it difficult to accept input from McCarthy who has very little experience at present.
One strange thing that I have noticed is that Derry was reintroduced to the first team coaching team this season and then left.
Roy was asked whether Derry would be replaced and just tersely replied ‘No.’
Which begs the question what Derry’s role was in the first place if it was a role that did not need replacing.
Maybe Derry thought he had become the ‘bibs and cones’ man and wanted a change with more responsibility , but he seems to be in very much a back room role at Wolves.


Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

Paddy and Ray next season is very unlikely to happen. They don’t appear to get on. Many of you will not have noticed the incident in the Bournemouth game last season where Ray ordered Paddy to sit down when he tried to approach Roy during the match. This did not go unnoticed in the Director’s Box and Ray was subsequently confined to the dugout. To show his annoyance Ray wore long trousers in the Forest Match.
There seems to be an uneasy peace between them now. It appears to me that Paddy is responsible for the forwards, an area Roy has admitted on several occasions he does not coach (and it shows), with Roy and Ray marshalling the midfield and defence. The introduction of the three younger players happened after a chat with Paddy. Could it be that Roy’s comments not only show his frustration with the Club’s transfer inaction but also a backhanded jibe at the imposition of Paddy as assistant manager?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Nov 23 9.26am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I don't disagree with the thrust of your argument.

And I can only presume the club had a strategy for this window. My issue would be that if they did, they failed miserably.

Not replacing your talisman. Someone who has carried the club for a decade is at best reckless, at worse suicidal.

In other windows I would have been more accepting, but it felt like there was a lot of business done, at our level. I still cant get away from the Jack Harrison loan.

So I guess to surmise, no we don't know what the strategy was, but we know the result. Accountability still lies in the same place.

Agree.

Only to the extent however that it's actually the ignorance drives me mad, more so than the actual result, and that's what will drive the conspiracy!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer policy