You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Perspective Please
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Perspective Please


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 04 Dec 23 12.40pm

No you are right we have failed to invest in our squad at the rate of our comparators so we are now light years behind them in terms of a squad ( we have a decent enough starting 11. )

Also we have a manager who operates on a squad system l that being 11 and if you don't fit his starting 11 you may as well not be there.

We got lucky yesterday with a goal they gifted us

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 04 Dec 23 12.46pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I don't think it's quite that simple, although I know where you're coming from. And our operating model isn't unique. I'm sure Potter and then Poch had little influence over Chelsea's recent transfer windows.

If you look at the summer signings, Lerma has been selected when fit. Holding was always going to be a squad player. Henderson will provide direct competition for the goalkeeper position. Franca is the big gamble, and the one which I would say it was unlikely Hodgson would throw in at the deep end. The fact that the player was injured when he joined up has also delayed his progress.

My argument would be that unlike us, there is no limited budget and a rather large choice of squad players or loans that could be called back to choose from.

If Roy had a choice he would undoubtedly have bought some old hands in to steel the squad, but Parish wants youngsters who are going to provide some excitement and have future value. The net result as you rightly say is Lerma plays, Hughes plays, Schlupp continues to play and Ahamada, Franca, Ebiowei, Rak Sakhi are constantly on the bench.

 

EddieMac Flag 04 Dec 23 12.55pm

Another thing to put things into perspective is just look at the league table. Every single game in this division is so hard to call. With a bit of luck we could beaten Everton and Luton and be sitting level with Brighton. This is the league we are in.

It’s not easy to get points.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 04 Dec 23 12.56pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The starting eleven that West Ham put out cost 282.2M EUR
Our starting eleven that we put out cost 89.3M EUR
Figures from Transfermkt, i would be embarrassed if i supported the Spammers, i would certainly question Moyes, if after spending that amount of money the putting in a performance like that, for me it was a 50/50 game, think about that before putting in a reply

Its good perspective for sure.

And a good response to anyone who says that money is the answer.

However on the pitch its 11 x 11 as Luton showed us.

An away point at WH is a good result. If it had of been preceded by a couple of wins we'd be sitting in the top half looking forward to Bmouth.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 04 Dec 23 12.59pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

No you are right we have failed to invest in our squad at the rate of our comparators so we are now light years behind them in terms of a squad ( we have a decent enough starting 11. )

Also we have a manager who operates on a squad system l that being 11 and if you don't fit his starting 11 you may as well not be there.

We got lucky yesterday with a goal they gifted us

I don't think that's the case. I think the issue is the strength of the bench.

If we were 2-0 down we may have seen Franca, but at 1-1, its too big a gamble, Roy will always respect the point.

 

Steve T Flag Cumbria 04 Dec 23 1.15pm

Edouard worked hard yesterday and took his goal well. However, he should have scored when he failed to get his head to a good cross that Ward Prowse headed over. His other problem is he fails to hold onto balls played long to hi m. A good centre forward needs to have that in his armoury to enable his colleagues to get up the pitch.
We most definitely deserved the point as for periods we shaded the encounter

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 04 Dec 23 3.50pm

Originally posted by Steve T

Edouard worked hard yesterday and took his goal well. However, he should have scored when he failed to get his head to a good cross that Ward Prowse headed over. His other problem is he fails to hold onto balls played long to hi m. A good centre forward needs to have that in his armoury to enable his colleagues to get up the pitch.
We most definitely deserved the point as for periods we shaded the encounter

Same problem as Benteke, doesn’t attack the ball in the penalty area. Mark Bright , Muzza or any other decent centre forward would’ve thrown themselves at that ball in to make contact and not worried about getting hurt

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 04 Dec 23 5.41pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Its good perspective for sure.

And a good response to anyone who says that money is the answer.

However on the pitch its 11 x 11 as Luton showed us.

An away point at WH is a good result. If it had of been preceded by a couple of wins we'd be sitting in the top half looking forward to Bmouth.

Once again we hear the magical "if" - "if only", if this if that". We didn't. We lost against teams below us, our current form is nothing to write home about. Now, if we want to talk about "if", how about "if" we win a few games in succession at home for starters? Then we would be talking about present and future possibilities, rather than things that have past, incidentally which we should learn from - will we?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (04 Dec 2023 5.48pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Dec 23 7.57pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

No you are right we have failed to invest in our squad at the rate of our comparators so we are now light years behind them in terms of a squad ( we have a decent enough starting 11. )

Also we have a manager who operates on a squad system l that being 11 and if you don't fit his starting 11 you may as well not be there.

We got lucky yesterday with a goal they gifted us

Where is the investment coming from?

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 04 Dec 23 9.25pm

The recent young players we have bought clearly have potential and talent. Currently they are not used for whatever reason which only Roy and his team of coaches know. They are sometimes on the bench sometimes not.What I I cannot understand is why are they not playing every game in the U23 teams to showcase themselves and to gain match fitness , all be it at a lower level. It is one thing to try and show your qualities in training sessions and another to show you qualities in matches. I think it maybe more in their interests to play a competitive match to showcase their capabilities rather than in training where they maybe inhibited.I am sure they will be of great value in the future and given more playing time will get them in the first team quicker , failing that get them out on loan to develop if we are not currently going to use them.COYP

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 04 Dec 23 9.26pm

The recent young players we have bought clearly have potential and talent. Currently they are not used for whatever reason which only Roy and his team of coaches know. They are sometimes on the bench sometimes not.What I I cannot understand is why are they not playing every game in the U23 teams to showcase themselves and to gain match fitness , all be it at a lower level. It is one thing to try and show your qualities in training sessions and another to show you qualities in matches. I think it maybe more in their interests to play a competitive match to showcase their capabilities rather than in training where they maybe inhibited.I am sure they will be of great value in the future and given more playing time will get them in the first team quicker , failing that get them out on loan to develop if we are not currently going to use them.COYP

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Dec 23 7.02am

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

The recent young players we have bought clearly have potential and talent. Currently they are not used for whatever reason which only Roy and his team of coaches know. They are sometimes on the bench sometimes not.What I I cannot understand is why are they not playing every game in the U23 teams to showcase themselves and to gain match fitness , all be it at a lower level. It is one thing to try and show your qualities in training sessions and another to show you qualities in matches. I think it maybe more in their interests to play a competitive match to showcase their capabilities rather than in training where they maybe inhibited.I am sure they will be of great value in the future and given more playing time will get them in the first team quicker , failing that get them out on loan to develop if we are not currently going to use them.COYP

I read somewhere the other day that after scouting Franca, there was a belief that he was ready to go straight into the first team.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Dec 23 7.10am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I read somewhere the other day that after scouting Franca, there was a belief that he was ready to go straight into the first team.

If this were to be the case it just illustrates how far away from reality those in charge are. Fantasy Football indeed.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Dec 23 7.13am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

If this were to be the case it just illustrates how far away from reality those in charge are. Fantasy Football indeed.

Yes - wish I could recall where I read that, might have been a snippet from The Athletic.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Dec 23 8.19am

Originally posted by Uphill

And what evidence do you have to justify that statement when neither have yet been given a starting place? And not likely to when we have a manager not willing to take any chances.

I suspect that's his brief. Holding pattern until..?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Dec 23 8.27am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Yes - wish I could recall where I read that, might have been a snippet from The Athletic.

As I posted elsewhere I heard Brentford's Dougie equivalent interviewed. Buys in January are not expected to hit full impact till the new season. Add his back injury, youth and need to adapt in so many ways, the suggestion of an immediate impact is likely click bait bollox.

RH knows a player who can make an impact as his resurrection of Eze shows.

I suspect we will see Franca in the FA Cup where he can play with less risk to the club's future.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 05 Dec 23 7.24pm

Originally posted by Uphill

And what evidence do you have to justify that statement when neither have yet been given a starting place? And not likely to when we have a manager not willing to take any chances.

I tend to agree with this..!!

My issue is that Roy just seems so reluctant to give youth and potential a chance, instead he reverts to proven mediocrity..!!

Whilst other teams around us and Managers are giving youth and potential the chance to prove themselves.

Look at Saturday - if Schlupp hadn't pulled out for personal reasons I'm fairly certain that he would have played ahead of Richards.

But Richards played and played well and proved what some of us have been saying for weeks that he is by far a better option than Ward.

As others have said both Ahamada and Franca have shown glimpses of what they can/could potentially do - given the opportunity..!!

But Roy will not afford them that opportunity - he was the same with England - just played so called "experienced mediocrity" despite how many times they had previously demonstrated they weren't good enough..

Another example where was Ozoh on Saturday not even on the bench - yet Reiedewald was - we all know he ain't good enough, yet he was bought on ahead of Ahamada.

Another one Mateta - we all know he's hopeless - why not bring on Franca give him a run and put Ayew up front..!!

Roy just won't do it - whereas as I mentioned other teams and Managers are giving youth and potential a go..!!

All this seems totally at odds to me to the strategy of the club - who are heavily investing in and backing the academy.

Something got's to give and me thinks Parish's patience will be running thin with Roy's perceived stubbornness..!!

Them is my thoughts..!!

COYP

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Dec 23 7.33pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

I tend to agree with this..!!

My issue is that Roy just seems so reluctant to give youth and potential a chance, instead he reverts to proven mediocrity..!!

Whilst other teams around us and Managers are giving youth and potential the chance to prove themselves.

Look at Saturday - if Schlupp hadn't pulled out for personal reasons I'm fairly certain that he would have played ahead of Richards.

But Richards played and played well and proved what some of us have been saying for weeks that he is by far a better option than Ward.

As others have said both Ahamada and Franca have shown glimpses of what they can/could potentially do - given the opportunity..!!

But Roy will not afford them that opportunity - he was the same with England - just played so called "experienced mediocrity" despite how many times they had previously demonstrated they weren't good enough..

Another example where was Ozoh on Saturday not even on the bench - yet Reiedewald was - we all know he ain't good enough, yet he was bought on ahead of Ahamada.

Another one Mateta - we all know he's hopeless - why not bring on Franca give him a run and put Ayew up front..!!

Roy just won't do it - whereas as I mentioned other teams and Managers are giving youth and potential a go..!!

All this seems totally at odds to me to the strategy of the club - who are heavily investing in and backing the academy.

Something got's to give and me thinks Parish's patience will be running thin with Roy's perceived stubbornness..!!

Them is my thoughts..!!

COYP

Richards played in midfield. He is not a RB.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Plaistow Eagle Flag 05 Dec 23 7.46pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Richards played in midfield. He is not a RB.

This is exactly the mentality I am referring to - how do you know unless you give it a go..!!

So in answer to your question - and what Ward is a Premier League standard right back is he..?? No he is not..!!

So why not try Richards there - he can't possibly be any worse..!!

If not try three at the back - just try something please, rather than this constant playing of known mediocrity in the vain hope that some day they will be better than they have been to date - it just ain't going to happen..!!

COYP

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Dec 23 12.07am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

This is exactly the mentality I am referring to - how do you know unless you give it a go..!!

So in answer to your question - and what Ward is a Premier League standard right back is he..?? No he is not..!!

So why not try Richards there - he can't possibly be any worse..!!

If not try three at the back - just try something please, rather than this constant playing of known mediocrity in the vain hope that some day they will be better than they have been to date - it just ain't going to happen..!!

COYP

What, exactly, did Joel Ward do to piss you off at WH?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Perspective Please