You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thin squad going to get thinner
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thin squad going to get thinner


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Dec 23 9.49am

Originally posted by SnapperKain

And we might also lose Schlupp to Ghana as well if he gets called up...

I think we might be forced to bring some of the youngsters that we've included in the squad this year into the first team and perhaps we might get a Zaha, AWB or Mitchell style impact from one of them, but having too many against someone like Man City... it'll be men versus boys.

Unlikely to be called up, or play any further internationals as I read somewhere that he fell out with the management.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 12 Dec 23 10.37am

Originally posted by The Yorkshire Eagle

Following a punch-up last night, or rather assault on a referee, unbelievably by The President of the TFA, the entire Turkish league has been “suspended indefinitely”.
We could plead extenuating circumstances to the Prem, Wilf could take a few weeks leave and help us out over the Christmas period!
On a more serious note, although it was time for him to move on, it has become apparent these past weeks that we so do miss him. Regardless of his failings latterly with fitness and oft attitude, he was the one player who gave us that feeling of expectancy whenever he got the ball, as you nearly always could be certain something would happen when he played and received the ball... if only drawing a foul. His very presence could also draw a defence to create space. Even our current breed of starlets, injured of otherwise don’t raise the excitement to the same level as he once did. Pack your case Wilf !

Happy Christmas.


Never mind Wilf ,Id take Icardi and Boey

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 12 Dec 23 11.32am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Some of us on here (well, I have anyway) been crying out for some of our academy starlets to be given a game. Unfortunately, the last time Roy did this it crashed badly. Adapting to the pace and sheer skill prevalent in the PL is almost impossible for youngsters to cope with, no matter how good they appear in the Under 21s.

You may be right but I cant say I remember Roy ever giving academy starlets much of a chance. And perhaps he was right as none of our academy players who have moved on are playing in the PL.

That aside, I don't think any of us in our right mind would suggest throwing in several young players at the same time. However, I would like to think one or two might be worth a try, and it needs to be for more than the last few minutes e.g. David Ozoh against Liverpool.

But, as others have said, if our injury woes persist, and we fail to to get fresh blood in the transfer window, Roy may have no choice but to call on some academy players.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Dec 23 12.01pm

Originally posted by Pete53

You may be right but I cant say I remember Roy ever giving academy starlets much of a chance. And perhaps he was right as none of our academy players who have moved on are playing in the PL.

That aside, I don't think any of us in our right mind would suggest throwing in several young players at the same time. However, I would like to think one or two might be worth a try, and it needs to be for more than the last few minutes e.g. David Ozoh against Liverpool.

But, as others have said, if our injury woes persist, and we fail to to get fresh blood in the transfer window, Roy may have no choice but to call on some academy players.

There are some who have considered the possibility of Mr Hodgson not being at the helm in January if results in December,as expected, are somewhat dire.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 12 Dec 23 12.32pm

Hodgson, has actually given chances to young players , only a couple have come off. It’s that simple. Remember a kid called Perick ,or something similar , a couple of seasons back. Does anyone know if he still plays at any level?
The proof of the pudding , is not actually with Hodgson, it lies in the fact that none of our younger group of players can even get a Championship loan. Ask yourself Why .? And even young players that have left in Hodgsons time, do not feature above div 1 and then not regularly .
Malachi Boateng, does really well in Scotland , now with Dundee, in the Scots Prem, plays most weeks rarely subbed , as was the case last season in the Scot’s championship with Queens Park.. But he is the only one that achieves this sort of consistent level. Maybe we should call him back.
It’s only an opinion, I have watched him a few times ,last year and this one, for me he obviously has something, to play week in week out even up there, but I’m still left thinking , as far as the Premiership in England is concerned still a bit to do, but maybe he is one Hodgson could help to become a top class player.


Edited by Putitout (12 Dec 2023 12.35pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Dec 23 12.41pm

Ozoh certainly looks to be pushing for more time with the first-team. He stands out in the U21s for his build and athleticism and looked solid in preseason. The fact he came on against Liverpool speaks volumes given the game wasn't lost. You do wonder how many gaps there will be to fill in the team come Saturday.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Dec 23 12.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

There are some who have considered the possibility of Mr Hodgson not being at the helm in January if results in December,as expected, are somewhat dire.

It'll be Gareth Southgate, in the Championship, with the Academy kids

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 12 Dec 23 1.27pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

It'll be Gareth Southgate, in the Championship, with the Academy kids

Damn I had Colonel Mustard in the Library with the dagger.

 


One more point

TheBigToePunt Flag 13 Dec 23 12.04pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Hodgson, has actually given chances to young players , only a couple have come off. It’s that simple. Remember a kid called Perick ,or something similar , a couple of seasons back. Does anyone know if he still plays at any level?
The proof of the pudding , is not actually with Hodgson, it lies in the fact that none of our younger group of players can even get a Championship loan. Ask yourself Why .? And even young players that have left in Hodgsons time, do not feature above div 1 and then not regularly .
Malachi Boateng, does really well in Scotland , now with Dundee, in the Scots Prem, plays most weeks rarely subbed , as was the case last season in the Scot’s championship with Queens Park.. But he is the only one that achieves this sort of consistent level. Maybe we should call him back.
It’s only an opinion, I have watched him a few times ,last year and this one, for me he obviously has something, to play week in week out even up there, but I’m still left thinking , as far as the Premiership in England is concerned still a bit to do, but maybe he is one Hodgson could help to become a top class player.


Edited by Putitout (12 Dec 2023 12.35pm)

Spot on. The simple fact is that very few people are good enough to be professional footballers, and very few of them are good enough to play in the top flight. If filling squad vacancies was as simple as just giving kids a chance then the club would force it upon the manager as part of the contract.

When the people who have spent a fortune, a load of time and almost all their energy on the academy, and shouted from the hilltops about it, are also in charge of the manager's terms of employment, they wouldn't stand back and do nothing if they felt he was blocking players who were good enough.

I would struggle to name a single player to leave Palace's youth system and go on to prove the club wrong.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 13 Dec 23 12.23pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Hodgson, has actually given chances to young players , only a couple have come off. It’s that simple. Remember a kid called Perick ,or something similar , a couple of seasons back. Does anyone know if he still plays at any level?
The proof of the pudding , is not actually with Hodgson, it lies in the fact that none of our younger group of players can even get a Championship loan. Ask yourself Why .? And even young players that have left in Hodgsons time, do not feature above div 1 and then not regularly .
Malachi Boateng, does really well in Scotland , now with Dundee, in the Scots Prem, plays most weeks rarely subbed , as was the case last season in the Scot’s championship with Queens Park.. But he is the only one that achieves this sort of consistent level. Maybe we should call him back.
It’s only an opinion, I have watched him a few times ,last year and this one, for me he obviously has something, to play week in week out even up there, but I’m still left thinking , as far as the Premiership in England is concerned still a bit to do, but maybe he is one Hodgson could help to become a top class player.


Edited by Putitout (12 Dec 2023 12.35pm)

Brandon Pierrick, I saw him come on as sub New Year’s Day up at Norwich about 4 years ago now, for his debut, he was at Dover Athletic last season and I believe he’s at Croydon Athletic now.

I’ve been saying for years, some of our fans keep banging on about giving youth a chance, well the truth is most of them are just not good enough and end up lower down the leagues or at non league level


Edited by monkey (13 Dec 2023 12.26pm)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Dec 23 12.44pm

I am no expert on football ability, but when you come across a winner you can normally see it straight away. The first time I saw Olise for us he scored after about 10 minutes coming on and some of his touches made me think he was real quality.
I can't say I have had the same feeling watching any of our other youngsters getting a run in the premier.
It was the same with Wan-Bissaka, that day we played him v Tottenham.
To be fair, Im talking about REAL quality. As I say Im no expert. I dont know what it was like the first time Joel Ward say ran out for Portsmouth.
There must be some who take time to materialise into average premier players, but top stars, I reckon you know from the off. Its just whether they make the distance mentally and physically.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Dec 23 12.50pm

Originally posted by Willo

There are some who have considered the possibility of Mr Hodgson not being at the helm in January if results in December,as expected, are somewhat dire.

We wouldn't sack a manager for not getting results given a really tough run of fixtures would we ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Dec 23 1.11pm

Originally posted by monkey

Brandon Pierrick, I saw him come on as sub New Year’s Day up at Norwich about 4 years ago now, for his debut, he was at Dover Athletic last season and I believe he’s at Croydon Athletic now.

I’ve been saying for years, some of our fans keep banging on about giving youth a chance, well the truth is most of them are just not good enough and end up lower down the leagues or at non league level


Edited by monkey (13 Dec 2023 12.26pm)

Yes and yep.

I think it somewhat a mere desperate fantasy that we have an academy filled with Zahas and Zidanes, they're just not being given the chance.

I understand this desperation, especially when we have one of our frequent spells of not winning for a given amount of time, but the truth remains that very few in any of these will ever play in the top flight or at any reasonable level, for good reason.

It's a very romantic notion, a kid from the academy making his debut, scoring a hattrick and turning out to be one of the best players in the world. The reality is very different however and that's what the manager has to contend with.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

TheBigToePunt Flag 13 Dec 23 1.49pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I am no expert on football ability, but when you come across a winner you can normally see it straight away. The first time I saw Olise for us he scored after about 10 minutes coming on and some of his touches made me think he was real quality.
I can't say I have had the same feeling watching any of our other youngsters getting a run in the premier.
It was the same with Wan-Bissaka, that day we played him v Tottenham.
To be fair, Im talking about REAL quality. As I say Im no expert. I dont know what it was like the first time Joel Ward say ran out for Portsmouth.
There must be some who take time to materialise into average premier players, but top stars, I reckon you know from the off. Its just whether they make the distance mentally and physically.

I think you are correct that quality usually stands out quickly.

On one hand, Olise and AWB are more or less champions-league standard players, so comparing a youth-team graduate to them might be a bit unfair, but on the other, it does give us a barometer because they were both good enough to get in our side and stay there at a young age.

Mitchell was less of an obvious star (still isn't) but he does the job in the top flight, so has probably saved us £10-20m, which I think we would have to spend on a top-flight English defender his age.

I wasn't there to see Ward make his Pompey debut either, but the interesting thing about him is that he had time to develop at a lower level, before building his career up in stages to be an established top-flight player. Youth team graduates at Palace don't get to do that really, the loan system isn't quite the same thing as earning your corn in a League 1 team, then getting bought by a Championship side, then helping them to promotion, then staying up etc.

It's quite possible that a 19-year-old Ward doesn't get a chance at Palace. Maybe the same is true of any of our established senior players apart from those who happened to be stand-out youngsters.


 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Dec 23 2.12pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I think you are correct that quality usually stands out quickly.

On one hand, Olise and AWB are more or less champions-league standard players, so comparing a youth-team graduate to them might be a bit unfair, but on the other, it does give us a barometer because they were both good enough to get in our side and stay there at a young age.

Mitchell was less of an obvious star (still isn't) but he does the job in the top flight, so has probably saved us £10-20m, which I think we would have to spend on a top-flight English defender his age.

I wasn't there to see Ward make his Pompey debut either, but the interesting thing about him is that he had time to develop at a lower level, before building his career up in stages to be an established top-flight player. Youth team graduates at Palace don't get to do that really, the loan system isn't quite the same thing as earning your corn in a League 1 team, then getting bought by a Championship side, then helping them to promotion, then staying up etc.

It's quite possible that a 19-year-old Ward doesn't get a chance at Palace. Maybe the same is true of any of our established senior players apart from those who happened to be stand-out youngsters.



I remember Vieira saying that less than 2% of academy players will make it to full blown pros. If only half of those make it to the premier, (and Im guessing here) but that is probably only one or two per season.
So many young players. So few that make it.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Dec 23 2.21pm

I try not to criticise Parish but I do think he over hypes the Academy.

Yes it's important to have one and it would be great to have a conveyor belt of talent but the truth is that most will never make it as full time professionals let alone in the PL.

So when we see much talked about youngsters not getting a chance it's not because Roy is anti youth but simply they are not as good as the PR coming from the club would have us believe.

If I was Parish I would tone down the hype until a young player breaks through.

 


One more point

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 13 Dec 23 3.05pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I try not to criticise Parish but I do think he over hypes the Academy.

Yes it's important to have one and it would be great to have a conveyor belt of talent but the truth is that most will never make it as full time professionals let alone in the PL.

So when we see much talked about youngsters not getting a chance it's not because Roy is anti youth but simply they are not as good as the PR coming from the club would have us believe.

If I was Parish I would tone down the hype until a young player breaks through.

I think the truth of the matter is that he hypes the academy to try and attract the better youth talent out there to the club. In years gone by we've had our academy players poached by other clubs with better facilities and at least with our academy now, we're more likely to do the poaching rather than having our talent youngsters pied piped away by the promise of shiny things and the latest gadgets.

I think we as fans feel like the academy should be a conveyor belt of top new talent for free the way that it's gone on about, but rather than a factory, I think it's more like a bespoke workshop of top-quality stuff that might only allow the odd one or two things out a year if we're lucky. Different with the new setup is that someone won't go in and nick our nearly finished, crafted stuff before it's ready to go out in the world.

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 13 Dec 23 4.20pm

I am of a slightly different opinion to some of those in this post.

If we are going to give academy players a chance, then they need to playing in and around a team with a decent players who are playing well. It's no good throwing them in for a cup final game where we are virtualling playing our reserve team. There is too much onus on them.

It also depends on the position. I would say it's easier to bring in a winger than a central midfielder, and slightly easier to bring in a fullback than a central defender. Those central areas are key to controlling game and bringing in a academy player is a massive gamble.

So that being said there could be an opportunity for someone like Danny Imray (?) to get game time at some point (as long as we strengthen in January).

The Centre Forward position is an interesting one. If we can create chances for the centre forward, then the opportunity is there for a academy player to make a name for themselves if they can finish. The issue is that we don't create alot of chances and often our centre forward has to plough a lone furrow. That is too much for an academy player.

You can't always judge a youth player straightaway on whether they make it. I remember Hayden Mullins when he first come into the 1st team on the left wing, and he wasn't great at all. Yet, a couple of seasons later he was exceptional when playing sweeper. Granted, some make a debut and they look distinctly out of their depth.

We had games where Roy had every opportunity to play at least one young player, especially toward the end of the season when we safe, and has failed to do so. Vieira was similarly as guilty.

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 13 Dec 23 5.27pm

If you’re going to Selhurst Park take your boots. You might get a game.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 14 Dec 23 5.23am

There is naivety amongst football fans in general about the level(s) involved in the game. Currently the vast majority of players in the premier league are proven international performers so we are looking at the best players in the world playing in the Premier League. It is great having a well resourced academy, that will help improve the players that come through it, but there is no guarantee it is going to be a steady conveyor belt of premier league ready players. It will need world wide recruiting of the best young players coupled with the best coaches. Some of the players will still need to gain experience by going out on loan. Chelsea attempted something like this but then had problems blooding these players in their first team and people like Guehi end up at Palace.
At least we do produce a top player but this seems to be about once in a 3-4 year period.
People may forget that the acadamy did help produce Jake O'Brien who whilst not featuring in the first team was still sold in the summer to Lyon for 1 million pounds. This will at least help justify the role of the acadamy has in producing players that can make a living from the game and make money for the club.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thin squad going to get thinner