You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Government Statistics, Why they Are Important
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Government Statistics, Why they Are Important


Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 9.11am

I have posted a number of times about how appalling this country is on simple counting e.g.

How many people from the EU live in this country. Mrs May "3.5m" when it was actually 5.5m.

The ONS is not fit for purpose.

The there is the forecasting. Since the OBR was established to provide data to the government to set economic policy it has been woeful in its predictions. The Bank of England is the same, it can't pick a winner in a one horse race.

This stuff matters.

Today we have the BOE Chairman explaining that the jobs data maybe out by 1m people either way. Think about that 1 million people, that is not a tiny percentage that is huge.

[Link]

How is the government and the bodies that do economic forecasting supposed to get it right when we have no idea about the basics of the economy.

This is not a party political issue but somebody needs to get a grip and do better. I have mentioned before that in Croatia all sales tills are linked to the government. There is plenty of technology available to improve our data gathering I can only assume that the ONS has been crying out for it otherwise they are really not doing their job.

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Dec 23 9.30am

Originally posted by Badger11

I have posted a number of times about how appalling this country is on simple counting e.g.

How many people from the EU live in this country. Mrs May "3.5m" when it was actually 5.5m.

The ONS is not fit for purpose.

The there is the forecasting. Since the OBR was established to provide data to the government to set economic policy it has been woeful in its predictions. The Bank of England is the same, it can't pick a winner in a one horse race.

This stuff matters.

Today we have the BOE Chairman explaining that the jobs data maybe out by 1m people either way. Think about that 1 million people, that is not a tiny percentage that is huge.

[Link]

How is the government and the bodies that do economic forecasting supposed to get it right when we have no idea about the basics of the economy.

This is not a party political issue but somebody needs to get a grip and do better. I have mentioned before that in Croatia all sales tills are linked to the government. There is plenty of technology available to improve our data gathering I can only assume that the ONS has been crying out for it otherwise they are really not doing their job.

These are usually excuses for a national ID card. I never supported it in the past but would now - particularly if we could deport the illegal people in the black economy or fake welfare recipients. However, we all know they won't be going anywhere. They can now pretend to be Palestinian - along with the other pretences used.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 10.21am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

These are usually excuses for a national ID card. I never supported it in the past but would now - particularly if we could deport the illegal people in the black economy or fake welfare recipients. However, we all know they won't be going anywhere. They can now pretend to be Palestinian - along with the other pretences used.

I am not convinced of the benefits of an ID card unless everybody was forced to carry one and produce it upon demand which would never happen.

For the majority of law abiding people it is fairly easy to prove our identity, for the rest they would not carry an id card anyway.

But this isn't about id's it about statistics. A lot of the numbers are just statistical sampling which in the past was probably the most efficient method at the time.

Today we should be able to do real time data mining for a lot of this stuff e.g. Point of Sale, employment figures etc. For some reason though no one is interested in upgrading our economy to do this.

 


One more point

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 10 Dec 23 10.35am

in places like Leicester, every back-garden has an unofficial mini-house....packed full of fellas. All working cash-in-hand. And no official data to measure this.

some boffin calculated that the quantity of weekly garbage collected in Leicester has gone off the Richter scale.....the only reliable measure.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 10.54am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in places like Leicester, every back-garden has an unofficial mini-house....packed full of fellas. All working cash-in-hand. And no official data to measure this.

some boffin calculated that the quantity of weekly garbage collected in Leicester has gone off the Richter scale.....the only reliable measure.



Exactly my point. We don't know how many people are living in this country legally, does anyone believe the officials numbers? The illegals will always be difficult to gauge because they are well illegal. But if you can't get the number that is here by right correct what chance do you have.

And then they wonder why public services are inadequate.

Then of course there are our trade figures, import and export. Think of a number then months later you will find out it's wrong by a large margin.

Is it that difficult to collate trade numbers?

I suspect that other countries have a far better handle on these stats.

 


One more point

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 10 Dec 23 11.16am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in places like Leicester, every back-garden has an unofficial mini-house....packed full of fellas. All working cash-in-hand. And no official data to measure this.

some boffin calculated that the quantity of weekly garbage collected in Leicester has gone off the Richter scale.....the only reliable measure.

I don't know where I found the information (it was about a decade ago), but there was a report doing the rounds which estimated that the population of the country was about 5 million out from official figures (that's an extra 5 million people than expected). The data was collected from the supermarkets who could work out how much food was being sold and what the average person consumed. Never heard of it since but there will be other ways of estimating the true figures for the population. But don't expect the government to be collating these sorts of statistics; far too embarrassing for them.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 10 Dec 23 12.54pm

Some data will be used. Then manipulated by statistics to make a case for something.
Other data will fall by the wayside and be discarded, because it's uncomfortable reading.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 12.58pm

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

I don't know where I found the information (it was about a decade ago), but there was a report doing the rounds which estimated that the population of the country was about 5 million out from official figures (that's an extra 5 million people than expected). The data was collected from the supermarkets who could work out how much food was being sold and what the average person consumed. Never heard of it since but there will be other ways of estimating the true figures for the population. But don't expect the government to be collating these sorts of statistics; far too embarrassing for them.

I suspect you are on to something.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Dec 23 1.50pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

These are usually excuses for a national ID card. I never supported it in the past but would now - particularly if we could deport the illegal people in the black economy or fake welfare recipients. However, we all know they won't be going anywhere. They can now pretend to be Palestinian - along with the other pretences used.

The benefits of the ID card are significantly beaten by the negatives.

We don't need it to deport who shouldn't be here.....this was always Blair's idea....use immigration to push for the ID card and put a major implementation plank of the social credit system into place.

The reality is that they won't use an ID card to solve immigration....at most they would slow it down a little. The same result of minority status just ten years further down the line.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Dec 2023 1.53pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 2.37pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The benefits of the ID card are significantly beaten by the negatives.

We don't need it to deport who shouldn't be here.....this was always Blair's idea....use immigration to push for the ID card and put a major implementation plank of the social credit system into place.

The reality is that they won't use an ID card to solve immigration..
..at most they would slow it down a little. The same result of minority status just ten years further down the line.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Dec 2023 1.53pm)

The Spanish Train bomb terrorist all had valid id cards. As I said above most people can prove their identity if required. The criminal and the illegal would never carry id anyway (it's kinda the point).

So what is the benefit of a copper forcing me to produce id when I already have a Driving Licence, credit cards on the Electoral roll , credit reports etc.

The only reason I can see is if they link government benefits to a national id card. Currently there are millions of dodgy National Insurance numbers either having been issued based on fraudulent documents, not cancelled due to death or simple incompetence. I shared the same NI number with another individual due to a clerical cock up.

Now as long as the ID scheme worked properly you could then eliminate all the dodgy NI numbers.

Anyway it aint going to happen and as another poster suggested the politicians may not want to know what the real stats are as I suspect the voters would be less than impressed.

 


One more point

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Dec 23 2.51pm

Am I right in thinking that the only forms of legal ID in the UK for Britain's is Full indate Passport & Photo Full Driving Licence?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 3.12pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Am I right in thinking that the only forms of legal ID in the UK for Britain's is Full indate Passport & Photo Full Driving Licence?

I'm not sure there is a clear answer. There are lots of forms of id it will depend on what you are doing. Certainly applying for a job employers want to see your passport as this confirms nationality.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 3.16pm

My fault I don't want to turn this into another immigration thread.

My original post is about how rubbish we are at collecting and collating data that is vital to planning and running the country.

Technology has moved on so this stuff should be seamless to business and public bodies. On a daily basis the government should be able to know the ins and outs for import exports, how many people are on the payroll, what the public is spending money on and how much etc. etc.

This might sound like big brother but they have been doing this for decades (badly).

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Dec 23 3.38pm

Originally posted by Badger11

The Spanish Train bomb terrorist all had valid id cards. As I said above most people can prove their identity if required. The criminal and the illegal would never carry id anyway (it's kinda the point).

So what is the benefit of a copper forcing me to produce id when I already have a Driving Licence, credit cards on the Electoral roll , credit reports etc.

The only reason I can see is if they link government benefits to a national id card. Currently there are millions of dodgy National Insurance numbers either having been issued based on fraudulent documents, not cancelled due to death or simple incompetence. I shared the same NI number with another individual due to a clerical cock up.

Now as long as the ID scheme worked properly you could then eliminate all the dodgy NI numbers.

Anyway it aint going to happen and as another poster suggested the politicians may not want to know what the real stats are as I suspect the voters would be less than impressed.

Indeed.

All the positives of an ID card could and would be possible by other means if the the political will was there to achieve them.

It's always been an excuse for what they really want....Once given that power won't be coming back.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 11 Dec 23 11.39am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Some data will be used. Then manipulated by statistics to make a case for something.
Other data will fall by the wayside and be discarded, because it's uncomfortable reading.

The info below from the same nation that outlawed DNA paternity tests ( for the sake of preserving peaceful family-life )....

And if one group of society is massively productive and hardworking. And another group is lazy, unproductive and parasites off the former.. Quel Dommage

Cucks

[Link]

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Dec 23 2.07pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

The info below from the same nation that outlawed DNA paternity tests ( for the sake of preserving peaceful family-life )....

And if one group of society is massively productive and hardworking. And another group is lazy, unproductive and parasites off the former.. Quel Dommage

Cucks

[Link]

Interesting, I didn't know that the French state does not collect racial data.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Dec 23 2.34pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Interesting, I didn't know that the French state does not collect racial data.

It is, and I didn’t know either.

I can see why though and is something I believe we need to adopt asap. It’s what I have long argued for.

We need to get away from categorising people in ways they have no control over and start categorising them in ways they have.

Criminals are criminals. They aren’t black, white, Muslim or Christian criminals. Good people are just good people. Why attach labels that then stick to others?

There are plenty of ways to collect the data without resorting to meaningless labelling.

It makes my buttocks wince whenever I read here, or anywhere else, people described by their skin colour. If someone carries a knife, robs a bank or molests a child what does it matter if they are black, white, brown or pink? It only matters that they need to be caught. Describing people as “White Europeans” is especially offensive given the number who aren’t but have been born in Europe and have as much right to be there as all the others.

Giving people an excuse by claiming society is prejudiced against them needs to be eradicated by not being prejudiced. Criminals need calling out as criminals, nothing else.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 11 Dec 23 4.29pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It is, and I didn’t know either.

I can see why though and is something I believe we need to adopt asap. It’s what I have long argued for.

We need to get away from categorising people in ways they have no control over and start categorising them in ways they have.

Criminals are criminals. They aren’t black, white, Muslim or Christian criminals. Good people are just good people. Why attach labels that then stick to others?

There are plenty of ways to collect the data without resorting to meaningless labelling.

It makes my buttocks wince whenever I read here, or anywhere else, people described by their skin colour. If someone carries a knife, robs a bank or molests a child what does it matter if they are black, white, brown or pink? It only matters that they need to be caught. Describing people as “White Europeans” is especially offensive given the number who aren’t but have been born in Europe and have as much right to be there as all the others.

Giving people an excuse by claiming society is prejudiced against them needs to be eradicated by not being prejudiced. Criminals need calling out as criminals, nothing else.

Interesting. It would automatically remove racist attacks and racism from society. What is Dianne Abbot going to use as an excuse for complaining about something?

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 11 Dec 23 5.05pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It is, and I didn’t know either.

I can see why though and is something I believe we need to adopt asap. It’s what I have long argued for.

We need to get away from categorising people in ways they have no control over and start categorising them in ways they have.

Criminals are criminals. They aren’t black, white, Muslim or Christian criminals. Good people are just good people. Why attach labels that then stick to others?

There are plenty of ways to collect the data without resorting to meaningless labelling.

It makes my buttocks wince whenever I read here, or anywhere else, people described by their skin colour. If someone carries a knife, robs a bank or molests a child what does it matter if they are black, white, brown or pink? It only matters that they need to be caught. Describing people as “White Europeans” is especially offensive given the number who aren’t but have been born in Europe and have as much right to be there as all the others.

Giving people an excuse by claiming society is prejudiced against them needs to be eradicated by not being prejudiced. Criminals need calling out as criminals, nothing else.

on the one hand, yes...i agree with you. On the other, tons of data will help to get effective Government spending and govt policy.
health, education, transport , whatever.

you need an intimate knowledge of your populace....age, gender, ethnicity, shoe size, whatever.

there is no point helping white people to conquer sickle cell anaemia. And its maybe futile trying to lecture them on the horrors of arranged cousin-marriage. Policy needs to be targeted.

only lefties see the whole population as vanilla flavour. Then they give tampons to men.

Good Government Statistics help us to understand the World we live in. In all its hidden complexity. They shed light on darkness and must not be suppressed for political reasons. If there is a hidden problem of, say, female baby infanticide...in China, India..... the data are needed to prove it. And they do.

[Link]

Edited by PalazioVecchio (11 Dec 2023 10.11pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Dec 23 4.34pm

Did anyone else notice the BOE's gloomy inflation forecast which meant they decided to maintain interest rates as is (14 Dec).

Followed days later by a unexpected large fall in inflation (20 Dec) which suggests that the BOE should be cutting rates.

This is what I am talking about folks poor data leads to poor decision making.

What will the BOE do in January.

 


One more point


You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Government Statistics, Why they Are Important