You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC - The business vs The Football Club
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

CPFC - The business vs The Football Club


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Den1923 Flag 09 Jan 24 8.23pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I’d just like to start a season with a decent first 11 and a half decent second 11 providing cover for all positions. Surely it’s not too much to ask of a team that has had so many years in the PL and yet I can’t remember us ever having a full squad to go pre season training with.

Yes absolutely agree with this, it is the basics if you want to be stable in this league. If only we could have the squad as you suggest and a settled manager so that we can have a proper pre-season it's been such a sad joke the last few years!

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Jan 24 1.06pm

The Independent is reporting that John Textor is considering the sale of his 45% stake in the club and that discussions have been ongoing for a number of weeks.
The report goes on to say that a sale could be complicated by the fact that potential buyers would want total control of the club.
If this story has legs it begs the question of whether Harris and Blitzer still want out too.
Is the club in play?
Personally I feel uncomfortable about investors coming in who perhaps don’t have the best interests of the club at heart even if ostensibly they have deep pockets.
Parish has his critics , but I would prefer him to the owners of the likes of Man U, Notts Forest, Chelsea and Everton.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 10 Jan 24 1.27pm

Originally posted by silvertop

The crowd were quiet last night. I only heard the away support. This is not good. Lightening quick wingers and a boisterous audience are our brand. This dreary holding pattern is upsetting the natives.

I think the pattern is being held till the academy comes good, the stand is part developed, and commercial revenue reaches that of our close competitors - but it is a painfully long process.

What makes it worse is that those close competitors have similar resources but are not only doing it better but - in today's world of instant gratification - they are doing it much quicker.

That people have rose-tinted memories of the second tier stronger than, say, Crystanbul, will be a real problem for the management and the control of expectations.

Rose tinted memories of the past, are just a few games, there was loads of dross. You’re correct our default playing style for years was flying wingers on breakaway attacks. Football has changed style to a more technical slow game, we have to adapt to avoid getting left behind. Therein the problem, we can’t afford the top technical players, so play a containment game.
Years ago Palace fans could only dream of being in the top flight for 11 years, now they are bored with that, as we can’t compete with the mega rich clubs.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 10 Jan 24 5.21pm

Sorry, long post incoming, but it's an interesting subject. As the OP says, it is in many ways the topic behind all other topics that we discuss.

Our model.

I feel Palace are a test-case for 70-odd other football clubs that dream not only of becoming a top-flight outfit, but of doing so using methods like ours:

We are not truly fan-owned in a formal sense, but our Chairman is a fan.

We have foreign investment, but the fan-Chairman is a local who is here, in the building, all the time running the place.

We haven't sold our club's soul to dubious foreign money, but are able to go toe-to-toe in any one game with those that have.

We have invested in the academy, whilst being reasonably competitive on wages for established top-flight players.

We plan to improve the ground, having done the same to the other bricks-and-mortar assets we own.

We live within our means, albeit not without operational debt.


Alternative models?

I see two ways this business model could be changed.

Firstly, we could hope for a new, mega-rich owner. Such a person could spend big on the stadium (expanding Selhurst or building a new ground are both very difficult, but perhaps possible if money were literally no object) and on the squad, but only in the very short term. Ultimately FFP dictates that the club must make back what it spends. I can’t understand why people don’t understand that. Unless a sugar daddy splurge gets you into the Champions League, you will just end up selling everyone in the end like Wolves, or unable to spend even though the owner is rich, like Everton.

Thing is, who is out there that could afford it? Personally, I would rather go down than be owned by a state with links to terrorism and human rights abuses, even though so many football fans seem not to be bothered about that. Newcastle fans in particular appear, to my mind, absolutely f***ing shameless in that respect.

Secondly, we could take more risks in terms of transfer policy. I have no time at all for nit-picking about why we didn’t sign that particular player, or a new player for that particular position. Transfers are multi-party affairs in a competitive landscape. Nobody complaining about transfer activity has the first clue what deals the club tried to do, and why they didn't come off, so any criticism is based on guesswork and can, quite often, come across as a bit entitled or childish when the club plainly spends all that it can (you only need to read the accounts).

We could gamble more on left-field signings, hope that we get enough we can sell at a profit to make ends meet whilst still having a good team, like Brighton. They bring through the odd youth player so their strategy doesn’t seem to block their academy, but it is still higher-risk. They depend on huge fees regularly to break even, and will be deep in the s*** if that dries up.

All this ‘Parish doing things on the cheap’ stuff is nonsense, but I do understand the observation that he is risk-averse in many areas, and transfers is maybe one of them. I am not sure I would want to change that though.

We spent money on players for Allardyce, and then could hardly spend at all under Roy. We’ve all got paid on the Friday, hit the town all weekend and ended up going hungry later in the week. Fine for a young person, not so much for a football club. Prudence and caution are not exciting, but are probably the best bet.


Progression.

All my life the dream, forever thwarted, was of Palace being an established top-flight side. The presumption was that just by being in the big time we would then develop as a club, year on year. In fact, we are now in almost exactly the same league position Pulis left us in after year one, and are still playing similar football.

I don’t understand the idea that we should be ‘kicking on to the next level’. The maths don’t work like that. The team is as good as its players, and the players are as good as the budget. There are the odd bargains out there (though there are far more rip-offs), but in the main and in the end, money talks.

Each year the clubs above us get more money than we do, so with each passing year the task of catching them becomes harder, not easier. That's the rub. Staying in the league for ten years puts us on a different financial planet to most professional clubs in the world, but not the clubs we actually compete with, and certainly not the clubs we would need to overtake to ‘kick on’. They get a greater advantage over us each season.

We are an established top flight club, but in a way that that just means we become underdogs more and more each year. It is not a ladder, it is a greasy ramp.


Entertainment or status?

Finally, and most importantly, is it fun? Was it worth it?

All those years of effort, hoping to be a top-flight team. Every chairman, player and manager were tasked with achieving it, and now we have. And it's often s***. Even if you overlook all the media s***, the cost, the daft kick-off times, the corporate emptiness, the diving, the real problem is the football. We are just so boring. We have, on the main, played tedious, risk-averse football throughout. For me, Roy is the symptom, not the cause.

We can’t develop as a club if we go down, but almost nobody our size stays up playing decent football. Under Pardew and Vieria we played decent stuff but only for half a season each. That's about it. That's not tactics or coaching, that's just form, and it often dips as fast or faster than it rises.

Nobody, of all the managers we have had, has managed to sustain decent football, and it’s not just us. Who else is there our size that sustains decent football without going down? I can’t see any examples to follow.

It was plainly more fun to watch in the Championship, and I sort of understand it when some fans hope to go down, but then what? If you are able to isolate each match as a stand-alone contest to be enjoyed, then fine, but most of us are mindful of the points tally and the league table. Would we be in the Championship hoping to have enjoyable games but not win enough to go up?!

It is like some existential crisis or something. Most teams our size don't survive this long in the top flight, so they don’t get to this stage of glass-ceiling, deep-rooted stodge. Usually a club has momentum one way or the other, but by succeeding in staying up we now have none whatsoever, cannot realistically generate any of the positive type, but surely do not want to embrace the negative type.

We are what happens to average clubs in the big league. I’m not sure if I’d like it to stop, but I’m not sure I would wish it on anyone else, either.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (10 Jan 2024 9.29pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Jan 24 5.26pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt


I don’t understand the idea that we should be ‘kicking on to the next level’. The maths don’t work like that.

Tell Parish that as it was he that said it a couple of years ago

 

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 10 Jan 24 5.44pm

The thing is what is the next level? most clubs in the PL and a few in the championship are in essence the same, unless you are owned by a oligarch or a country there is no next level, the big clubs can buy the players they want, very few players will turn down a megabucks move.
Is the next level a thursday evening away game to Quarabag FK??

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

TheBigToePunt Flag 10 Jan 24 9.19pm

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

The thing is what is the next level? most clubs in the PL and a few in the championship are in essence the same, unless you are owned by a oligarch or a country there is no next level, the big clubs can buy the players they want, very few players will turn down a megabucks move.
Is the next level a thursday evening away game to Quarabag FK??

It is, and it is as much a punishment as it is a reward.

In a logical structure, teams would be able to aim for Europa League football and use it as a basecamp from which to develop their teams even further, hopefully into Champions League hopefuls.

In reality, anyone our size who finishes 7th immediately has to choose between having a decent crack at Europe at the expense of the league, or the opposite.

Modern football. It's s***.

 

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 11 Jan 24 12.17pm

I don't really understand this vision that giving the club over to somebody with loads of money means guaranteed success. It doesn't.

It means spending lots of money on supposedly good players but it doesn't guarantee you a good manager nor players that want to fight for the badge. Hence why DF and Parish always spout on about finding the right players.

It also doesn't help the fact that Selhurst is still in a bloody horrid place for it to expand unless you build a new stadium elsewhere.

It also doesn't get away from FFP.

Palace doesn't bring in lots of money and is reliant on selling assets to cover that.... it seems to me that DF has found quite a few young assets lately which can be sold and we now have an academy producing some young talent which will hopefully show more as the years go on.

There are plenty of teams around us, below us and only just above us with billionaire owners. Brighton have done very well to get where they are but they still have to sell lots of their players and find new ones. They have done this with ample success of late because Chelsea are completely insane with throwing money at players.

Could Parish do better? Most likely, but he is human. Does anybody reasonably think Textor has the clubs interests at heart? The other 2 Americans have their sights on other sports franchises in the US, and they probably don't pay attention to Selhurst Park because it's such a headache to expand and upgrade.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 12 Jan 24 8.47am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Sorry, long post incoming, but it's an interesting subject. As the OP says, it is in many ways the topic behind all other topics that we discuss.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (10 Jan 2024 9.29pm)

What a great post TBTP.

It encapsulates a lot of my feelings. The main one being almost everyone here is desperate for us to make that next step. But nobody is really sure what that is, and more importantly what risk it would involve.

Given the top are almost uncatchable, I always find it helpful to take a look at an alternative league table: top half of the Championship and bottom half of the Prem (almost super league style).

That would sit us 4th in the table, but just look a the list of historically BIG teams we are ahead of Forrest, Everton, Sheffield, Leicester, Saints, Leeds, Brom, Sunderland etc etc

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 12 Jan 24 8.48am

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

The thing is what is the next level? most clubs in the PL and a few in the championship are in essence the same, unless you are owned by a oligarch or a country there is no next level, the big clubs can buy the players they want, very few players will turn down a megabucks move.
Is the next level a thursday evening away game to Quarabag FK??

For me yes. But not expecting it every season. Once every, say, 5 years it would be lovely to have an FA Cup run to Wembley, or away at Quarabag FK.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Jan 24 9.15am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

What a great post TBTP.

It encapsulates a lot of my feelings. The main one being almost everyone here is desperate for us to make that next step. But nobody is really sure what that is, and more importantly what risk it would involve.

Given the top are almost uncatchable, I always find it helpful to take a look at an alternative league table: top half of the Championship and bottom half of the Prem (almost super league style).

That would sit us 4th in the table, but just look a the list of historically BIG teams we are ahead of Forrest, Everton, Sheffield, Leicester, Saints, Leeds, Brom, Sunderland etc etc

I think the obvious flaw and most miserable thing to point out in every aspiration is to then ask 'what next after that?'. For example, we move to a bigger stadium, finish outside the 'big boys', qualify for Europe, then we will want to push for a title, and Champions League, then every trophy etc. etc.

For me, the next step is less important than the restoration of competing for something beyond a mundane but stable and admirable finish outside of the relegation zone. We have already made a step up in ascending above the main candidate pool for relegation each season.

I would therefore describe the next step up as having a competitive first XI, where we have a squad with players still trying to break into it as opposed to glaring holes which then make us look very vulnerable with sometimes only a single absentee.

Once we have that, relegation may become so distant a thought we do actually turn our attention to the cups and perhaps confidently assess where we will be finishing within the top half, and if we can achieve a European spot, as opposed to 'will we be relegated or not?' and 'when is so-and-so back as we're nothing and getting relegated without him?' etc.

Just my opinion of course.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

silvertop Flag Portishead 12 Jan 24 9.31am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I think the obvious flaw and most miserable thing to point out in every aspiration is to then ask 'what next after that?'. For example, we move to a bigger stadium, finish outside the 'big boys', qualify for Europe, then we will want to push for a title, and Champions League, then every trophy etc. etc.

For me, the next step is less important than the restoration of competing for something beyond a mundane but stable and admirable finish outside of the relegation zone. We have already made a step up in ascending above the main candidate pool for relegation each season.

I would therefore describe the next step up as having a competitive first XI, where we have a squad with players still trying to break into it as opposed to glaring holes which then make us look very vulnerable with sometimes only a single absentee.

Once we have that, relegation may become so distant a thought we do actually turn our attention to the cups and perhaps confidently assess where we will be finishing within the top half, and if we can achieve a European spot, as opposed to 'will we be relegated or not?' and 'when is so-and-so back as we're nothing and getting relegated without him?' etc.

Just my opinion of course.

And one widely shared. I check the EPL Injury Table before I check the EPL table!

Bar the most dramatic change in fortune, we will never have a squad like Man City. However, it would be nice to have a mid table equivalent where gaps are not filled by playing the walking wounded, or a player out of natural position, or one not playing to the necessary standard.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Jan 24 9.51am

Originally posted by silvertop

And one widely shared. I check the EPL Injury Table before I check the EPL table!

Bar the most dramatic change in fortune, we will never have a squad like Man City. However, it would be nice to have a mid table equivalent where gaps are not filled by playing the walking wounded, or a player out of natural position, or one not playing to the necessary standard.

Absolutely!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC - The business vs The Football Club