You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What has happened/is going to happen?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What has happened/is going to happen?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
PatrickA Flag London 21 Jan 24 10.13am

I suppose there's another scenario.
Let's say for once there is actually a succession plan in place and Parish has lined someone up, but he is only available or only wants to take the job in the summer.
In that case it's either Hodgson for the rest of the season or a caretaker manager,with the former being more likely.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 21 Jan 24 10.26am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Do we expect Roy to be incharge against Sheff Utd, and do we expect any new signings to be playing in that game.


Sadly, yes and no in that order. I say sadly regarding Hodgson because I think he's too stubborn to change the way he sets us up and that means IMO that we are unlikely to win the games needed to stay up.

Last calendar year we conceded the first goal in more games than any other PL team (for the 3rd time in about 7 years) yet Hodgson still sets us up to try and not concede goals!

 

beak Flag croydon 21 Jan 24 10.32am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I feel that Roy (2nd time around) was only a placeholder to steady the ship / keep us in the PL until we -

a) Get the main stand built (which increases the stadium capacity & therefore revenue, which helps us with profit & sustainability)
b) Lower the salary / revenue %age (83% down to 64% down to ?
c) Complete the academy / sports science upgrade (soon ?)

The underlying feeling of the shareholders at the start of the season being that the current squad should be good enough to carry us through until the summer window when the main stand construction begins & the other 2 targets are sorted - Obviously injuries have thrown a spanner in the works.

At the risk of stating the obvious - the big question is what do we do next with a little over a week of the transfer window left,
Effectively its stick or twist with the manager & the transfer window - those are big decisions, SP will earn his money on Monday morning & only history will dictate whether he made the right decisions.



Can you promise that MORE fans will WANT to come to watch us? That at the moment is at best fanciful.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Jan 24 10.36am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Firtstly Nicholas an excellent post and indeed the replies. There comes a time when you are found out and I think our time is here. Clearly we are reliant on Textor and co’s cash and all being able to be on the same page. If the media reports are true this is now not the case which, will inevitably affect the running of the club. For the good of CPFC the board need to sit down and have a grown up conversation and resolve the issues and quickly.
There is seemingly no recruitment plan and this goes back years. I would love to know what our scouting network is I.e where we find rough diamonds for decent money and polish them up. Given the results of this I doubt it extends much beyond Google! When you look at Brighton (very sorry to say) it is clear they have something we can only dream of and bringing players through from the academy …. The centre forward Ewan ?? springs to mind. They can do it so why can’t we??

We don’t seem to think ahead, no strategic planning and because of this we are forever working hand to mouth and doing our transfer window shopping in Aldi at 9.45pm. Saying all this we must be careful what we wish for in wanting SP out ….. Reading FC!!

Finally, the manager, a previous post said that good managers improve players and sorry Roy but this isn’t happening and I also believe that you have lost the dressing room. Lots of things to put right and it needs strong leadership from the top to right the ship.

With respect Evan Ferguson was signed from Bohemians.

In terms of Brighton, when one considers their current squad, the only players who have progressed from the academy are Jack Hinshelwood and Lewis Dunk.

Brighton have signed a number of players from abroad for insignificant sums in PL terms :

Mitoma £2.5 Mill, Buonanotte £10 Mill, Adingra £8 Mill, Enciso £11.5 Mill, Moder £6 Mill, Dahoud Free, Mac Allister £7 Mill, Caicedo £4.5 Mill, Bissouma £15 Mill, Cucurella £15 Mill etc etc.

Edited by Willo (21 Jan 2024 11.17am)

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 21 Jan 24 10.38am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Do we expect Roy to be incharge against Sheff Utd, and do we expect any new signings to be playing in that game.

Good question Lanzo me ol mucker , I am going to say no and no . Bassed on the line Parish came out with live on Sky whe the Dutch bloke was in charge and the day before he was sacked , Steve was asked by the reporter " Steve Is the managers job in jeopardy if he doesn't get a win this weekend? to which Steve replied Frank's not stupid he knows its a results bassed job and if you're not gettig the results the you are going to lose your job , the next day he was sacked . We all know Steve is a man of his word as Wilf will tell you ... and im sure Roy is up there now if not worse than FDB and Vs points tally . Please correct me if im wrong .

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 21 Jan 24 10.39am

Originally posted by beak


Can you promise that MORE fans will WANT to come to watch us? That at the moment is at best fanciful.


People love a good soap opera!

Also, there is a waiting list for STs but I've no idea how long it is. In any event, Hodgson WON'T be here next season whichever league we are in.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Jan 24 11.03am

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

Good question Lanzo me ol mucker , I am going to say no and no . Bassed on the line Parish came out with live on Sky whe the Dutch bloke was in charge and the day before he was sacked , Steve was asked by the reporter " Steve Is the managers job in jeopardy if he doesn't get a win this weekend? to which Steve replied Frank's not stupid he knows its a results bassed job and if you're not gettig the results the you are going to lose your job , the next day he was sacked . We all know Steve is a man of his word as Wilf will tell you ... and im sure Roy is up there now if not worse than FDB and Vs points tally . Please correct me if im wrong .

If we're quoting Steve Parish, he also said back in 2015 that he believed Palace could win the Premier League in the '' next 10-15 years ''.

I think Hodgson will still be in charge for the Sheffield United game.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Jan 24 11.08am

Trigger will be pulled. It always is.

 


Red and Blue Army!

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 21 Jan 24 11.14am

Originally posted by Willo

With respect Evan Ferguson was signed from Bohemians.

In terms of Beighton, when one considers their current squad, the only players who have progressed from the academy are Jack Hinshelwood and Lewis Dunk.

Brighton have signed a number of players from abroad for insignificant sums in PL terms :

Mitoma £2.5 Mill, Buonanotte £10 Mill, Adingra £8 Mill, Enciso £11.5 Mill, Moder £6 Mill, Dahoud Free, Mac Allister £7 Mill, Caicedo £4.5 Mill, Bissouma £15 Mill, Cucurella £15 Mill etc etc.

Which is 1 more than we currently have in our team, if you can call Mitchell a success!

Look at the players you listed who are either doing well in their team or been sold for a big profit. That is something that we don’t do and if we sell Olise and or Guehi where are the replacements coming from to not only perform to a PL standard but kick on. Again no recruitment plan!

 


Bring back Brolin

beak Flag croydon 21 Jan 24 11.30am

Originally posted by Willo

With respect Evan Ferguson was signed from Bohemians.

In terms of Brighton, when one considers their current squad, the only players who have progressed from the academy are Jack Hinshelwood and Lewis Dunk.

Brighton have signed a number of players from abroad for insignificant sums in PL terms :

Mitoma £2.5 Mill, Buonanotte £10 Mill, Adingra £8 Mill, Enciso £11.5 Mill, Moder £6 Mill, Dahoud Free, Mac Allister £7 Mill, Caicedo £4.5 Mill, Bissouma £15 Mill, Cucurella £15 Mill etc etc.

Edited by Willo (21 Jan 2024 11.17am)

Wow! Straight from Willopeadia!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 21 Jan 24 11.32am

Originally posted by beak

Wow! Straight from Willopeadia!

S'ok, he's missed one, Valentin Barco from Boca Jnr 19yo winger.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 24 11.48am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think our present problems are a result of a series of bad decisions made last summer.

* the assumption that Zaha was going to stay . My suggestion of giving him a deadline to make up his mind was not met with widespread enthusiasm on here, but he left at the eleventh hour and the club failed to replace him. It was also known at that time that Olise had an injury likely to keep him out for some time
* the assumption that the squad had sufficient depth of quality. Far from having Top Ten potential, the more pertinent question would be to gauge if it was enough to even achieve our usual mid table spot. Factor in a couple of inevitable injuries….
* the signings of Henderson and Franca. Henderson still makes little sense to me. Could we not have identified a decent back up for Johnstone without eating so much into our limited transfer budget ? Franca looks like one for the future, but not for the now. Forget the hefty transfer fee, if he had come through the Academy would you not be thinking, has potential but raw and not ready yet ?
It all feeds into a lack of coherent and structured approach to player recruitment and fee developing strategy.
* re-appointing Roy. To me that was a Red Flag as to the extent of this seasons ambition. I think this is one of those “ weak decisions “ referred to yesterday at the Emirates. As Roy said, ultimately it’s the manager that carry’s the can for poor results and while I don’t hold him solely responsible for our predicament, he’s appearing increasingly like somebody that wants his future decided for him. Which leaves Parish in a position that I’m sure he didn’t want to be in, trying to find a new manager in mid season.

The club feels like a ship without a captain at the moment. A real lack of inspirational leadership on and off the field.

I think the problems start at the top, at Board level. So the what next should start there too, but more likely it won’t. It’s more likely to be a new manager. But I suspect that once again we will be appointing someone that was not first choice but who is available.

I entirely agree with what you say. I’m surprised, but I do!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Jan 24 11.48am

Originally posted by eagleman13

S'ok, he's missed one, Valentin Barco from Boca Jnr 19yo winger.

Signed a few days ago for a sum close to £8 Mill.
I am told he is versatile, able to play in a few positions.

I am also told that Brighton have an impressive Psychology and Well-Being setup designed to help players released by the academy, to settle-in the young players signed from abroad and to provide other support on an on-going basis.I believe this is just part of the role.

Edited by Willo (21 Jan 2024 11.59am)

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 24 11.49am

I was talking to a Liverpool supporter over the Christmas break who was telling me that the waiting list for season tickets at Anfield is estimated to be 100 years, because families that have season tickets just renew them under the family name & pass them down through the generations.

I have no idea what our season ticket waiting list looks like, I added a mate to the list at the start of the season &havent heard anything since, maybe I will over the summer, especially if things go south.

Originally posted by doombear


People love a good soap opera!

Also, there is a waiting list for STs but I've no idea how long it is. In any event, Hodgson WON'T be here next season whichever league we are in.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Jan 24 11.56am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I entirely agree with what you say. I’m surprised, but I do!

Maybe I've worn you down !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Swindy Flag Bromley 21 Jan 24 12.04pm

Mr Parish is another in a long line of owners who missleads the fans, stays quiet when the going gets tough, sending out positive and inaccurate messages when it's not.
His main aim is for the club to stay solvent regardless and until the boardroom split is solved or anyone else comes in with the money or ambition, we are stuck with this situation.
Keeping Roy in charge for the foreseeable will hamper efforts in the window I fear, as who is going to come and want to be part of Royball ??

 

palacebob Flag melton mowbray 21 Jan 24 12.08pm

Some points are well made on here and generally seems the reason for lack of investment in the team. Is that there is no desire to invest.
Is it realistic to expect investment from the money people that have minimum input.
Not surprised they are looking elsewhere
Are academie players not just for selling on for pure profit to accommodate ffp
Is Roy not in position because of the cost of replacing him.
All managers players and owners are part time participants in any club and often stay longer than they should it is the same in all businesses.
Maybe fans need to be allocated a position on every board to represent the people that will be there when the others are gone.
Deans agent should be approached for advice how he sold him to freeman as a priority is bloody amazing.

 

beak Flag croydon 21 Jan 24 12.50pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Trigger will be pulled. It always is.

We will just call him Dave.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Jan 24 1.36pm

For me the lack of investment chat is a bit lazy.

There has been some investment, just more often than not poor. We managed the Johnstone situation badly, so had to act and spend on Hendo.

The thing I cannot get my head round is the lack of Wilf replacement. Its hard to put into words how good and how important he's been for us. If It was me in DF's position I may have:

Spent all of my budget on as close to a like for like replacement (and assumed that Ayew could fill in when needed)
or
Brought in a senior loan (Harrison) or free (Andros) AND taken a risk on a youngster e.g. Gnoto

Instead we spent half of our budget on a kid who is so raw, it's going to take him a few seasons to bed in (if at all). And spent WAY over market value.

For me its close to gross incompetence

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 21 Jan 24 2.24pm

Our fundamental issues are a low turnover and a tendency towards short-termism, which limits our opportunities for growth.

The chronic fear of relegation that pervades the club, even after 11 years, means that we have shirked difficult decisions which could have pushed us in either direction and are reliant on crutches.

Zaha was one and we seemingly turned down offers for him, feeling that his worth as a player was greater than what we were offered to sell him.

I'm not saying that we should have taken the £40m Arsenal bid but I feel like we priced him too high to ward off any interest. If we'd been more receptive to offers, perhaps we could have got £60m which would have given us funds to reinvest. However, we were too terrified of life without him to consider it.

Roy is another crutch. I felt a palpable sense of relief when he left the first time and knew when he returned that it would never just be for those few months. Despite our current form being as bad as Vieira's when he was sacked, you still sense the board are afraid to get rid.

When we have invested in players in recent years, generally it's gone well. We signed Franca (£15m), Henderson (£15-20m), Holding (£1m), Lerma, (Free), Doucoure (£20m), Richards (£10m), Ahamada (£10m), Johnstone (Free), Guehi (£20m), Anderson (£15m), Edoaurd (£14m), Mateta (£8m), Olise (£7m), Eze (£15m).

Overall this is outstanding business. Of course some of them have done better than others but that's a combined outlay of around £150-160m and how much are they collectively worth now? Eze, Olise and Doucoure alone are probably worth more than that between them.

What we need to do now is be brave and trust ourselves to progress despite making changes.

Roy has to go, that's clear. We need someone younger, more progressive and who is good at working with young players. Potter would be my choice but I think Cooper would be good as well.

We need to invest more in the squad which means selling. Olise will go and it's out of our hands. I think we should consider selling Guehi too, as he has a high market value, we have cover at CB and I actually think that Anderson is more important to how we play.

Any money raised HAS to be invested in the squad. The strategy of signing good young players from the Championship has done so well for us, we'd be made not to carry it on. We have to get out of this scenario where if one or two players get injured our entire season falls apart.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What has happened/is going to happen?