This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by beak
[Link] Bournemouth spent a net £126 million before the start of the season. The Bournemouth comparison is a good one, especially as they play the same formation as us - 4231, and are doing a lot better. When you look at their team there are only a few i would have in front of what we have at Palace - CF, RB and LW spring to mind. So clearly we have under performed in comparison. In terms of their net spend, this is a little misleading as their 2 big purchases - Adams and Scott were both injured when they signed and haven't had an impact this season. Their success is built on a mobile top 4. Many of their purchases have been in the £10m area, exactly our price range. Aarons is a busy little RB, similar to a younger Clyne. He cost about £7m i think and Sinisterra was bought on loan. Instead we bought an untried teenager from Brazil for an excessive amount and surely even the biggest Roy hater would not say the kid should be starting for us in the Prem.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Last season Mr Hodgson had Zaha,Eze and Olise at his disposal, the football played was quite refreshing and surprised many who viewed the manager tactically as more conservative. This season of course Zaha is in Turkey and Olise and Eze have hardly played together.There has also been the loss of Doucoure. I will accept that only 2 home wins all season and only 1 win in our last 11 games is cause for wailing and lamentation. Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2024 11.33am) Agree, however, the real positive in that period was that Zaha barely featured. He was subbed before HT in the first game v leicester (at 0.0), came back for West Ham and Spurs and then was injured again v Bournemouth just after HT, albeit after a great set up for our first goal. So in those 10 games he essentially played 3 x 90 minutes.
|
|
|
Doucoure is a key loss. Originally posted by Willo
Last season Mr Hodgson had Zaha,Eze and Olise at his disposal, the football played was quite refreshing and surprised many who viewed the manager tactically as more conservative. This season of course Zaha is in Turkey and Olise and Eze have hardly played together.There has also been the loss of Doucoure. I will accept that only 2 home wins all season and only 1 win in our last 11 games is cause for wailing and lamentation. Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2024 11.33am)
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Doucoure is a key loss. good call. 442 would help Schlupp on the left who looks lost but has played on the left in a 442 for may seasons.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Doucoure is a key loss.
Edited by doombear (22 Jan 2024 12.23pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
The OP has entitled the thread "Don't Blame Roy!). Well I do blame him for what is in his area of control, namely, how he coaches the squad and how he sets us up to play. He wonders how we always seem to start slowly (and concede the first goal - as I've said elsewhere, something we did more than any other PL team in 2023). Well if your first aim is always to try and stop the other team from scoring instead of trying to score the first goal yourself, what do you expect will happen? As has been said by many, we are useless in both penalty areas when there are corners. Setting up defensively will (and usually does) result in conceding more corners than under a more progressive system. The game against Arsenal encapsulated this perfectly. Our full backs seem to have little idea what to do with throw-ins other than (usually) give the ball to the opposition. Rarely do we see quick throw-ins from our players or players moving quickly to find space to receive the ball. We have one of the worst shot-to-goal conversion rates in the PL. And what is Hodgson's answer? "Keep working on what we do in practice lads". Sorry, his methods are well past their sell-by date IMHO. Football has moved on and it's time he did - into retirement. Finally, YES, the board has much to answer for but that doesn't let Hodgson off the hook. Agree.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
good call. 442 would help Schlupp on the left who looks lost but has played on the left in a 442 for may seasons. Yes. or 4-3-1-2, 4-4-2, 4-4-1.1 none of these formations have been tried, Andersen playing long diagonal passes up to Mateta, with Edouard and Eze supporting, Ala Wimbledon, a lot more could have been tried, fit the team for the players, not vice versa
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Doucoure is a key loss. Managers have of course their preferred way of playing and the 'Shape' of the team but some adopt a more flexible approach than others. Carlos Corberan deploys a number of systems and one is left guessing as to which formation his team will play at the start.He also changes formations during games as did Mark Warburton.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
The OP has entitled the thread "Don't Blame Roy!). Well I do blame him for what is in his area of control, namely, how he coaches the squad and how he sets us up to play. He wonders how we always seem to start slowly (and concede the first goal - as I've said elsewhere, something we did more than any other PL team in 2023). Well if your first aim is always to try and stop the other team from scoring instead of trying to score the first goal yourself, what do you expect will happen? As has been said by many, we are useless in both penalty areas when there are corners. Setting up defensively will (and usually does) result in conceding more corners than under a more progressive system. The game against Arsenal encapsulated this perfectly. Our full backs seem to have little idea what to do with throw-ins other than (usually) give the ball to the opposition. Rarely do we see quick throw-ins from our players or players moving quickly to find space to receive the ball. We have one of the worst shot-to-goal conversion rates in the PL. And what is Hodgson's answer? "Keep working on what we do in practice lads". Sorry, his methods are well past their sell-by date IMHO. Football has moved on and it's time he did - into retirement. Finally, YES, the board has much to answer for but that doesn't let Hodgson off the hook. Can't disagree with any of that Doombear.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything. |
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
The Bournemouth comparison is a good one, especially as they play the same formation as us - 4231, and are doing a lot better. When you look at their team there are only a few i would have in front of what we have at Palace - CF, RB and LW spring to mind. So clearly we have under performed in comparison. In terms of their net spend, this is a little misleading as their 2 big purchases - Adams and Scott were both injured when they signed and haven't had an impact this season. Their success is built on a mobile top 4. Many of their purchases have been in the £10m area, exactly our price range. Aarons is a busy little RB, similar to a younger Clyne. He cost about £7m i think and Sinisterra was bought on loan. Instead we bought an untried teenager from Brazil for an excessive amount and surely even the biggest Roy hater would not say the kid should be starting for us in the Prem. Two absolute no-brainer signings that we should have been all over. Clubs like Bournemouth really do put us to shame at the moment - in terms of recruitment, managers and generally having a plan/identity, they are streets ahead of us.
They will not lose money on Scott unless he breaks a leg, and will likely make a big profit there in a few years. Senesi is now an Argentian international and they'll profit on him. Zabarnyi is a big prospect. We should be approaching it the same way - we know we are going to have north of £100m incoming over the next 12 months with likely sales of Olise, Guehi and/or Andersen - spend that money now, and ok our net spend might look bad for 12 months, but at least we're not absolutely crippled every time we lose a player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
The OP has entitled the thread "Don't Blame Roy!). Well I do blame him for what is in his area of control, namely, how he coaches the squad and how he sets us up to play. He wonders how we always seem to start slowly (and concede the first goal - as I've said elsewhere, something we did more than any other PL team in 2023). Well if your first aim is always to try and stop the other team from scoring instead of trying to score the first goal yourself, what do you expect will happen? As has been said by many, we are useless in both penalty areas when there are corners. Setting up defensively will (and usually does) result in conceding more corners than under a more progressive system. The game against Arsenal encapsulated this perfectly. Our full backs seem to have little idea what to do with throw-ins other than (usually) give the ball to the opposition. Rarely do we see quick throw-ins from our players or players moving quickly to find space to receive the ball. We have one of the worst shot-to-goal conversion rates in the PL. And what is Hodgson's answer? "Keep working on what we do in practice lads". Sorry, his methods are well past their sell-by date IMHO. Football has moved on and it's time he did - into retirement. Finally, YES, the board has much to answer for but that doesn't let Hodgson off the hook. Spot on. Best post I've read in a long time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by beak
[Link] Bournemouth spent a net £126 million before the start of the season. How on earth can a club the size of Bournemouth with a capacity of 13,000 spend 126million on players, this is ridiculous!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
How on earth can a club the size of Bournemouth with a capacity of 13,000 spend 126million on players, this is ridiculous! Bournemouth have had attendances of just over 11,000 this season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Roy was called back from retirement by Parish because no ambitious manager wants to put his name on the line with the weak squad we have, plus the dysfunctional board all of whom seem to be in disagreement with Parish and want out. This results in no team investment, poor quality or aged players in key position, all of which Roy has made clear on multiple occasions telling Parish et.al what he wants, they seem to ignore him, they cannot walk the talk and whilst he remains in place little will change and Parish will happily go on picking up his pocket money bonus from the club,for as long as can get away with it! Well said and I absolutely agree. Too many Palace supporters are like abused wives who refuse to acknowledge their partner's abuse. As long as she keeps accepting his BS he is enabled to continue doing what he always does: The sad Palace story of the last TEN YEARS.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Two absolute no-brainer signings that we should have been all over. Clubs like Bournemouth really do put us to shame at the moment - in terms of recruitment, managers and generally having a plan/identity, they are streets ahead of us.
They will not lose money on Scott unless he breaks a leg, and will likely make a big profit there in a few years. Senesi is now an Argentian international and they'll profit on him. Zabarnyi is a big prospect. We should be approaching it the same way - we know we are going to have north of £100m incoming over the next 12 months with likely sales of Olise, Guehi and/or Andersen - spend that money now, and ok our net spend might look bad for 12 months, but at least we're not absolutely crippled every time we lose a player. Yep I agree. And as a result, their squad is 100% better than ours. I think the bold bit is key, especially understanding how it fits into the 3 year cycle. Trying get players in early, bed them in and make sure they are ready to cover departures. e.g. Buy Ronnie Edwards now for 10m , loan him back for the rest of the season. Sell Anderson in the summer for 30m. It would also mean we can end our love with extending contracts of 'end of life players'. Luka, Jairo, Tomkins. How much money has been thrown after bad.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.