You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Lose to S Utd Roy quits / Win Roy stay for season
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Lose to S Utd Roy quits / Win Roy stay for season


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Jan 24 10.16am

Originally posted by EagleAlan78

The reason for the poor form is barely anything to do with the injuries it’s the constant same tactics, squads, and game management of the clown in charge. We made hard work of beating a very very poor injury hit Brentford team. We still have players that are left out after having a good game and players put in the squad that are clearly not good enough. I can guarantee I can tell you every game what tactics and squad Roy is gonna play. He has no plan b or any level of game management. Any division he manages in he will finish more often than not mid table at very best because every decent manager can predict what he is going to do. As for this being the best time for a palace fan. Even Pardew era was a bit better than this. Regarding signings at most I reckon we will get a loan deal and maybe 1 actual signing. What is the point. All Hodgson does is play his underperforming favourite. Can’t stand parish but don’t blame him for not giving him any money to spend as all Hodgson will do is keep them on the bench. The blokes is destroying most of our players and our club as a whole


Edited by EagleAlan78 (23 Jan 2024 2.42am)

You like using the word clown. Having read your recent posts, I can see why.

I'm interested to know which players have had a good game and then been left out.

Players '' put in the squad '' ? What does that even mean ?? Are those the players signed by the club ?

Hodgson is only capable of obtaining mid table finishes ? Err yeah, why do you think he got the job ?

You obviously don't like Hodgson and you can't stand Parish and you want Palace to lose to Sheffield United ! Not your year is it...

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Jan 24 10.50am

Originally posted by EagleAlan78

The reason for the poor form is barely anything to do with the injuries it’s the constant same tactics, squads, and game management of the clown in charge. We made hard work of beating a very very poor injury hit Brentford team. We still have players that are left out after having a good game and players put in the squad that are clearly not good enough. I can guarantee I can tell you every game what tactics and squad Roy is gonna play. He has no plan b or any level of game management. Any division he manages in he will finish more often than not mid table at very best because every decent manager can predict what he is going to do. As for this being the best time for a palace fan. Even Pardew era was a bit better than this. Regarding signings at most I reckon we will get a loan deal and maybe 1 actual signing. What is the point. All Hodgson does is play his underperforming favourite. Can’t stand parish but don’t blame him for not giving him any money to spend as all Hodgson will do is keep them on the bench. The blokes is destroying most of our players and our club as a whole


Edited by EagleAlan78 (23 Jan 2024 2.42am)

That’s just not true is it. There is no doubt that injuries have contributed to our below par performances.
We can debate Roy’s tactics all day, but no manager can win games without game winning players.
I would ask why we spent 25 million on a luxury player who was not ready for the Premier League and did not bolster the squad where it was clearly needed.

Given that, we would still struggle without Doucoure and Olise against top sides.
Beside that, sometimes you can just play teams when they are in a run of form. Luck plays a part.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (23 Jan 2024 10.53am)

 

doi209 Flag Fighting for the weak and innocent... 23 Jan 24 11.01am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

What a load of total cobblers.

We have been without key players for much of the season. All we have to do is finish above three other teams.
If we win tomorrow, we are still on course to do that.
When Olise and Ayew return we will be better.

Don’ t throw your toys out of the pram like an angry baby. Support the team and hope for a couple of deals to boost the squad.

This is the best period we have ever had as Palace fans. Get a grip.


Next week....

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Jan 24 12.23pm

Originally posted by doi209

Next week....

Yes indeed. Next Tuesday.


 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jan 24 12.34pm

I guess I could research it but why bother? I get the feeling Roy is not the resigning type. I have no idea why I think that.

 


Red and Blue Army!

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jan 24 1.18pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I get the feeling Roy is not the resigning type.
.

nor was Pardew. Who played a more exciting football and lost a ton of games.

got a poor result ? blame some of the players. Our midfielders are often invisible. Our 'keeper is not as good as Guaita nor Speroni. Some of our defenders are getting old and slow.

my only criticism of Roy is his reluctance to bring on Subs for the final 20 minutes.

Another criticism of Palace generally was Milivojovic & Benteke......we continue to start players proven to be not good enough. And underperformers have not gone away. Still with us today.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jan 24 1.53pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

nor was Pardew. Who played a more exciting football and lost a ton of games.

got a poor result ? blame some of the players. Our midfielders are often invisible. Our 'keeper is not as good as Guaita nor Speroni. Some of our defenders are getting old and slow.

my only criticism of Roy is his reluctance to bring on Subs for the final 20 minutes.

Another criticism of Palace generally was Milivojovic & Benteke......we continue to start players proven to be not good enough. And underperformers have not gone away. Still with us today.

Yes, indeed, Roy does blame players. But not sure he blames the correct ones. Can he change? Not so sure.

 


Red and Blue Army!

pssguy Flag 23 Jan 24 1.56pm

"Understand that Roy Hodgson is set to remain in charge of Crystal Palace for next week’s game against Sheffield United after holding talks with chairman Steve Parish after Arsenal defeat. That and games against Brighton and Chelsea will be crucial in determining his future

— Ed Aarons (@ed_aarons) January 23, 2024"

So no new manager bedded in and no transfers. Great

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 23 Jan 24 2.46pm

Originally posted by pssguy

"Understand that Roy Hodgson is set to remain in charge of Crystal Palace for next week’s game against Sheffield United after holding talks with chairman Steve Parish after Arsenal defeat. That and games against Brighton and Chelsea will be crucial in determining his future

— Ed Aarons (@ed_aarons) January 23, 2024"

So no new manager bedded in and no transfers. Great

Isn’t it just, so demoralising

Edited by Phil’s Barber (23 Jan 2024 2.47pm)

 

redshift Flag Toronto 23 Jan 24 6.01pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Yes, indeed, Roy does blame players. But not sure he blames the correct ones. Can he change? Not so sure.

I can answer that. He can't. At 76 if he changes at all it's probably due to a medical episode. I'm in the same age cohort and even the idea of changing exhausts me.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 23 Jan 24 6.13pm

So he will remain in charge for next week it seems.
He won’t change. It will be same players in same formation. Sit back from kick off. Play for the draw. They will then score from a corner/ free kick and we will lose.
Head in sand Parrish.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jan 24 7.12pm

Sheffield will be there for the taking. The two games after that....much tougher. And so, of the next possible 9 points...what would be optimistic ?

3+1+1 = 5

very optimistic, i reckon. For Roy or anybody else for that matter.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

stancummins Flag 24 Jan 24 6.21am

Well it looks like he will have his talisman Jordan Ayew back for Tuesday given the Afcom results yesterday. I am sure that Olise will be pushed to be fit as well , and Rak Saki will be in the frame so there should be no excuse on the players availability side

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 24 Jan 24 6.44am

You would anticipate that he would fly back to the UK Thursday, although sometimes players take the opportunity to grab couple extra days to visit extended family whilst they are back in their home region, certainly hope that's not the case this time with
J Ayew.

Originally posted by stancummins

Well it looks like he will have his talisman Jordan Ayew back for Tuesday given the Afcom results yesterday. I am sure that Olise will be pushed to be fit as well , and Rak Saki will be in the frame so there should be no excuse on the players availability side

 

cannongilbert Flag 24 Jan 24 6.48am

I've read a few optimistic approaches here and much as I would like to follow, the facts are indisputable. Although you have some top defenders, the way they(and the rest of the team) react in set pieces is of a much lower level than they really are. Without an addition in the RB position as soon as possible we are in trouble. An for God's sake lets try being a little more attack-minded. Week after week it has been proven that the philosophy of sitting back hoping not to concede a goal is wrong. Also, we must use the best in each position. I don't think its so bad to splash out 10.000.000 for one of the two right backs of whom there have been rumours lately, after the summer recruitments we have made. Of course I am unaware of what might be going on behind the scenes. COYP!

 

Glazier#1 Flag 24 Jan 24 12.28pm

Originally posted by stancummins

Well it looks like he will have his talisman Jordan Ayew back for Tuesday given the Afcom results yesterday. I am sure that Olise will be pushed to be fit as well , and Rak Saki will be in the frame so there should be no excuse on the players availability side

No, no, no.

MO must not be 'pushed' at all. It's vital for him and us that he is brought along carefully to enable;

A full recovery that will mean, when he does start, he's not liable to break down again. Then he'll be able to help us for the remainder of the season. Patience.

To save him from the possibility of causing irreparable damage that could affect his career.

After all, he's a gem that deserves to grace our game(no matter who for) for years to come.

 

The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 24 Jan 24 1.46pm

“Morning Roy, come in sit down, oh you are!”

“You wanted a word Steve?”

“Yes, we’ll, what a mess eh. Things are not looking good n I’m
under pressure from the others to make some big decisions”. I
guess they saw the banners....Oh, thanks, I love a Werther” Mmm,
where was I? Oh yes..."

“Sorry to interrupt Steven, but you don’t want to take any notice
of a few whingers, they’ll get over it when we thump the Blades.
Anyway, they’ve been spoilt up to now”.

“Let’s hope so old friend. You know we go back a long way, well
you do at least. Me on the muddy Whitehorse end n you an
apprentice, but the Yanks are getting twitchy and want some
answers”.

“Answers, I’ll give ’em Answers. What do the ‘septics’ know
about’ football, or rather soccer anyway”.

"You have a point there Mr H , but I’ve got to be frank with you,
there’s no money for transfers right now, and with relegation
staring us in the face and an old buffer in charge, who’d want
to come here anyway?. We might get the odd loan if Dougie gets
his digit out of his rear end, but as it stands, the best peas,
Kalvin Phillips that is, seem to have gone to Farrows, err, I
mean Hammers. Hah, did you get that Roy?"

“Yes, very amusing Steve but it’s not a problem, I think we have
a decent enough squad to survive”.

"Oh, and another thing, Brighty ask me to ask you why you insist
on sticking with the old tossers and don’t give the youngsters a
run out?”

“Huh, I wondered when he’d put his tuppence in. Tell him to mind
his own business, I’m in charge, and anyway, Ray n Mac makes
those decisions, I’d certainly give the kids a few minutes”. Was
there anything else Stevie boy only I need to get over to the
training ground to work on set pieces?

“Well I was wondering what you are up to next season…, no reason,
just asking”.

“You’d have to ask Mrs H that one, she makes my decisions, but
she won’t want me hanging around like a bad smell, so who knows.
Talking of smells, was that you?.. Another Werther?”

“Cheers, I’ll take one for later. Let’s catch up again next
Wednesday then”.

"I'll put it in my diary Steven. nice to chat

Edited by The Yorkshire Eagle (24 Jan 2024 1.51pm)

Edited by The Yorkshire Eagle (24 Jan 2024 4.23pm)

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 24 Jan 24 3.12pm

Roy has on previous occasions upped sticks and walked before being sacked. ‘By mutual agreement’ is the term used. There is the possibility that, following a win against Sheffield, Roy will leave, going out on a high to cement his legacy.

However, given he appears to have no other interests outside football, I suspect he will soldier on regardless.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 24 Jan 24 3.50pm

Originally posted by The Yorkshire Eagle

“Morning Roy, come in sit down, oh you are!”

“You wanted a word Steve?”

“Yes, we’ll, what a mess eh. Things are not looking good n I’m
under pressure from the others to make some big decisions”. I
guess they saw the banners....Oh, thanks, I love a Werther” Mmm,
where was I? Oh yes..."

“Sorry to interrupt Steven, but you don’t want to take any notice
of a few whingers, they’ll get over it when we thump the Blades.
Anyway, they’ve been spoilt up to now”.

“Let’s hope so old friend. You know we go back a long way, well
you do at least. Me on the muddy Whitehorse end n you an
apprentice, but the Yanks are getting twitchy and want some
answers”.

“Answers, I’ll give ’em Answers. What do the ‘septics’ know
about’ football, or rather soccer anyway”.

"You have a point there Mr H , but I’ve got to be frank with you,
there’s no money for transfers right now, and with relegation
staring us in the face and an old buffer in charge, who’d want
to come here anyway?. We might get the odd loan if Dougie gets
his digit out of his rear end, but as it stands, the best peas,
Jack Harrison, that is, seem to have gone to Farrows, err, I
mean Hammers. Hah, did you get that Roy?"

“Yes, very amusing Steve but it’s not a problem, I think we have
a decent enough squad to survive”.

"Oh, and another thing, Brighty ask me to ask you why you insist
on sticking with the old tossers and don’t give the youngsters a
run out?”

“Huh, I wondered when he’d put his tuppence in. Tell him to mind
his own business, I’m in charge, and anyway, Ray n Mac makes
those decisions, I’d certainly give the kids a few minutes”. Was
there anything else Stevie boy only I need to get over to the
training ground to work on set pieces?

“Well I was wondering what you are up to next season…, no reason,
just asking”.

“You’d have to ask Mrs H that one, she makes my decisions, but
she won’t want me hanging around like a bad smell, so who knows.
Talking of smells, was that you?.. Another Werther?”

“Cheers, I’ll take one for later. Let’s catch up again next
Wednesday then”.

"I'll put it in my diary Steven. nice to chat

Edited by The Yorkshire Eagle (24 Jan 2024 1.51pm)

Very good , well done

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 24 Jan 24 3.50pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git


However, given he appears to have no other interests outside football, I suspect he will soldier on regardless.

well at 76, would you expect him to be DJ'ing Drill Rap at a mixing desk with the Thornton Heath Massive ?

can i request any Eagle with a talent for photoshop , please create that image for all of us.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (24 Jan 2024 3.54pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Lose to S Utd Roy quits / Win Roy stay for season