You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The rest of the season
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The rest of the season


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
DenTyler Flag Sidcup 04 Feb 24 2.58pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It seems clear that we need to accept that Eze and Olise will be out and try and use the squad we have available.

Surely, Franca has to start. Perhaps Ayew can play more centrally. We need to use Mateta and Edouard up front together one way or another, but I might go five at the back against the better sides. Johnson back in goal.

We have to grind out points.

I just saw your message on the Roy stay or go thread. Regarding pant wetting.

Could I ask and not looking for a slanging match etc. Exactly how far do you continue to follow under Roy. At what point and how deep in trouble does it need to be before it is no longer pissing our knickers as you put it and you see it as the majority now do?

I genuinely want to know because I would dearly love to be proved wrong and we be safe for another season.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Feb 24 6.40pm

Further to my earlier point about Parish's dilemma in terms of sacking Roy and hiring a replacement ;


[Link]

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Jacey Flag 04 Feb 24 7.10pm

Other of our relegation threatened rivals will be jubilant that we appear to be too weak to sack Hodgson and just relish the prospect of an easy three points when they play us,particularly if we are without our dynamic duo,Olise and Eze!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Feb 24 7.15pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Willo,

I take it that you anticipate yet another abject display and inevitable heavy defeat.

It is more than likely that both Eze and Olise will be missing, accordingly I am expecting yet another abject display and defeat.
A truly awful watch, once again, for long-suffering supporters at Selhurst Park.

Edited by Willo (04 Feb 2024 7.15pm)

 

georgey wood Flag South London and Proud 04 Feb 24 7.29pm

I believe Roy’s time is up and clearly there’s some sort of issue in the boardroom regarding strategy and transfers. However nobody really knows what’s going on there who wants want and who’s paying for what etc. The thing we do know is the summer window was a mess and we’ve signed young players with potential that clearly aren’t fancied by the manager.

For what it’s worth I was fine with Roy staying on another year as I believed (stupidly) he would be backed at least with a right back and a Zaha replacement. Nobody saw the bad luck with injuries but singing a kid from Brazil and an inferior keeper with our entire summer transfer kitty was insanity and that’s on the owners and freedman there is no way Roy wanted them signings.

However now it’s so toxic and the fans aren’t aren’t aligned with the manager and owners it has to be time for a change of manager and set up with the squad we have available. We have to make some changes to that starting team and formation with or without Roy in situ.

This leads me onto my main point ( presuming Eze, Olise and Guehi are out for the next month and big fixtures v Everton, Burnley and Luton) what formation and players would you play? For me Johnstone back in goal a No brainer but looks like something is going on there behind the scenes as Johnstone is so superior in every area especially distribution and coming for or punching crosses.

For me the back 5 hasn’t worked, it may work now with Munoz but I would go for a back 4 of Munoz, Anderson, Richard’s and Mitchell ( he’s only playing as nobody else at the club lol) for me he’s now being targeted by the oppo like Wardy was especially in possession all teams start their press when he gets the ball.

The midfield I can’t work out and for me is our biggest problem since Decoure’s injury: He’s such a big loss to Roy’s system and let’s be honest even Anderson and Guehi were only looking like world beaters as they had him sitting in front that’s so onvios now! We’re not protecting the back four and there’s too big a gap from them to Mateta. Do we trust Wharton to play DM? Could Lerma play DM? For me Hughsey though a decent footballer and probably great 5 aside player hasn’t got the legs to play in there at Prem level. So do you go Schlupp (can’t pass and lost wide) but does have work rate and actually a threat at times driving forward from a central area. Do we try Ahmada or Ozoh in there?

The other option is obviously Franca or Ahmada wide right or Franca maybe Eddie in the 10 role to close gap to Mateta and replace Eze. Eddie can’t play wide left for me as too lazy and especially with a bang average left back behind him. So that leaves Ayew wide left and Mateta up top who has improved over the last few months he is at least holding the ball up better. ( although choosing between him and Eddie is like choosing earache or toothache if I’m honest) one or both need upgrading in the summer.

This is the reality of our situation with Roy or a new manager. Whether you play the youngsters or the senior pro’s. I honestly don’t know what I would do but setting up not to get beat and getting beat heavily can’t continue so the shape, personal or both have to change. Any suggestions welcome! See you all at next Monday and I’ll be behind the team whoever’s in charge or whoever’s playing! COYP

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 04 Feb 24 7.33pm

Originally posted by georgey wood

I believe Roy’s time is up and clearly there’s some sort of issue in the boardroom regarding strategy and transfers. However nobody really knows what’s going on there who wants want and who’s paying for what etc. The thing we do know is the summer window was a mess and we’ve signed young players with potential that clearly aren’t fancied by the manager.

For what it’s worth I was fine with Roy staying on another year as I believed (stupidly) he would be backed at least with a right back and a Zaha replacement. Nobody saw the bad luck with injuries but singing a kid from Brazil and an inferior keeper with our entire summer transfer kitty was insanity and that’s on the owners and freedman there is no way Roy wanted them signings.

However now it’s so toxic and the fans aren’t aren’t aligned with the manager and owners it has to be time for a change of manager and set up with the squad we have available. We have to make some changes to that starting team and formation with or without Roy in situ.

This leads me onto my main point ( presuming Eze, Olise and Guehi are out for the next month and big fixtures v Everton, Burnley and Luton) what formation and players would you play? For me Johnstone back in goal a No brainer but looks like something is going on there behind the scenes as Johnstone is so superior in every area especially distribution and coming for or punching crosses.

For me the back 5 hasn’t worked, it may work now with Munoz but I would go for a back 4 of Munoz, Anderson, Richard’s and Mitchell ( he’s only playing as nobody else at the club lol) for me he’s now being targeted by the oppo like Wardy was especially in possession all teams start their press when he gets the ball.

The midfield I can’t work out and for me is our biggest problem since Decoure’s injury: He’s such a big loss to Roy’s system and let’s be honest even Anderson and Guehi were only looking like world beaters as they had him sitting in front that’s so onvios now! We’re not protecting the back four and there’s too big a gap from them to Mateta. Do we trust Wharton to play DM? Could Lerma play DM? For me Hughsey though a decent footballer and probably great 5 aside player hasn’t got the legs to play in there at Prem level. So do you go Schlupp (can’t pass and lost wide) but does have work rate and actually a threat at times driving forward from a central area. Do we try Ahmada or Ozoh in there?

The other option is obviously Franca or Ahmada wide right or Franca maybe Eddie in the 10 role to close gap to Mateta and replace Eze. Eddie can’t play wide left for me as too lazy and especially with a bang average left back behind him. So that leaves Ayew wide left and Mateta up top who has improved over the last few months he is at least holding the ball up better. ( although choosing between him and Eddie is like choosing earache or toothache if I’m honest) one or both need upgrading in the summer.

This is the reality of our situation with Roy or a new manager. Whether you play the youngsters or the senior pro’s. I honestly don’t know what I would do but setting up not to get beat and getting beat heavily can’t continue so the shape, personal or both have to change. Any suggestions welcome! See you all at next Monday and I’ll be behind the team whoever’s in charge or whoever’s playing! COYP

Good post! I would add - think Anderson has been poor for a while. He seems to have lost his Mojo - ever since the Newcastle move didn’t materialise .

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Feb 24 7.47pm

Originally posted by georgey wood

I believe Roy’s time is up and clearly there’s some sort of issue in the boardroom regarding strategy and transfers. However nobody really knows what’s going on there who wants want and who’s paying for what etc. The thing we do know is the summer window was a mess and we’ve signed young players with potential that clearly aren’t fancied by the manager.

For what it’s worth I was fine with Roy staying on another year as I believed (stupidly) he would be backed at least with a right back and a Zaha replacement. Nobody saw the bad luck with injuries but singing a kid from Brazil and an inferior keeper with our entire summer transfer kitty was insanity and that’s on the owners and freedman there is no way Roy wanted them signings.

However now it’s so toxic and the fans aren’t aren’t aligned with the manager and owners it has to be time for a change of manager and set up with the squad we have available. We have to make some changes to that starting team and formation with or without Roy in situ.

This leads me onto my main point ( presuming Eze, Olise and Guehi are out for the next month and big fixtures v Everton, Burnley and Luton) what formation and players would you play? For me Johnstone back in goal a No brainer but looks like something is going on there behind the scenes as Johnstone is so superior in every area especially distribution and coming for or punching crosses.

For me the back 5 hasn’t worked, it may work now with Munoz but I would go for a back 4 of Munoz, Anderson, Richard’s and Mitchell ( he’s only playing as nobody else at the club lol) for me he’s now being targeted by the oppo like Wardy was especially in possession all teams start their press when he gets the ball.

The midfield I can’t work out and for me is our biggest problem since Decoure’s injury: He’s such a big loss to Roy’s system and let’s be honest even Anderson and Guehi were only looking like world beaters as they had him sitting in front that’s so onvios now! We’re not protecting the back four and there’s too big a gap from them to Mateta. Do we trust Wharton to play DM? Could Lerma play DM? For me Hughsey though a decent footballer and probably great 5 aside player hasn’t got the legs to play in there at Prem level. So do you go Schlupp (can’t pass and lost wide) but does have work rate and actually a threat at times driving forward from a central area. Do we try Ahmada or Ozoh in there?

The other option is obviously Franca or Ahmada wide right or Franca maybe Eddie in the 10 role to close gap to Mateta and replace Eze. Eddie can’t play wide left for me as too lazy and especially with a bang average left back behind him. So that leaves Ayew wide left and Mateta up top who has improved over the last few months he is at least holding the ball up better. ( although choosing between him and Eddie is like choosing earache or toothache if I’m honest) one or both need upgrading in the summer.

This is the reality of our situation with Roy or a n ew manager. Whether you play the youngsters or the senior pro’s. I honestly don’t know what I would do but setting up not to get beat and getting beat heavily can’t continue so the shape, personal or both have to change. Any suggestions welcome! See you all at next Monday and I’ll be behind the team whoever’s in charge or whoever’s playing! COYP

I've thought this for a long time. We needed two new full backs in the summer not just the one.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 04 Feb 24 7.58pm

Originally posted by georgey wood

I believe Roy’s time is up and clearly there’s some sort of issue in the boardroom regarding strategy and transfers. However nobody really knows what’s going on there who wants want and who’s paying for what etc. The thing we do know is the summer window was a mess and we’ve signed young players with potential that clearly aren’t fancied by the manager.

For what it’s worth I was fine with Roy staying on another year as I believed (stupidly) he would be backed at least with a right back and a Zaha replacement. Nobody saw the bad luck with injuries but singing a kid from Brazil and an inferior keeper with our entire summer transfer kitty was insanity and that’s on the owners and freedman there is no way Roy wanted them signings.

However now it’s so toxic and the fans aren’t aren’t aligned with the manager and owners it has to be time for a change of manager and set up with the squad we have available. We have to make some changes to that starting team and formation with or without Roy in situ.

This leads me onto my main point ( presuming Eze, Olise and Guehi are out for the next month and big fixtures v Everton, Burnley and Luton) what formation and players would you play? For me Johnstone back in goal a No brainer but looks like something is going on there behind the scenes as Johnstone is so superior in every area especially distribution and coming for or punching crosses.

For me the back 5 hasn’t worked, it may work now with Munoz but I would go for a back 4 of Munoz, Anderson, Richard’s and Mitchell ( he’s only playing as nobody else at the club lol) for me he’s now being targeted by the oppo like Wardy was especially in possession all teams start their press when he gets the ball.

The midfield I can’t work out and for me is our biggest problem since Decoure’s injury: He’s such a big loss to Roy’s system and let’s be honest even Anderson and Guehi were only looking like world beaters as they had him sitting in front that’s so onvios now! We’re not protecting the back four and there’s too big a gap from them to Mateta. Do we trust Wharton to play DM? Could Lerma play DM? For me Hughsey though a decent footballer and probably great 5 aside player hasn’t got the legs to play in there at Prem level. So do you go Schlupp (can’t pass and lost wide) but does have work rate and actually a threat at times driving forward from a central area. Do we try Ahmada or Ozoh in there?

The other option is obviously Franca or Ahmada wide right or Franca maybe Eddie in the 10 role to close gap to Mateta and replace Eze. Eddie can’t play wide left for me as too lazy and especially with a bang average left back behind him. So that leaves Ayew wide left and Mateta up top who has improved over the last few months he is at least holding the ball up better. ( although choosing between him and Eddie is like choosing earache or toothache if I’m honest) one or both need upgrading in the summer.

This is the reality of our situation with Roy or a new manager. Whether you play the youngsters or the senior pro’s. I honestly don’t know what I would do but setting up not to get beat and getting beat heavily can’t continue so the shape, personal or both have to change. Any suggestions welcome! See you all at next Monday and I’ll be behind the team whoever’s in charge or whoever’s playing! COYP

Totally agree with you about the midfield. We now have a 19 year old to get the midfield working again. That is a huge weight for him to carry. Personally I don’t think we have a team good enough to keep us up without Olise, Eze, Dacoure and now Geuhi :-(

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Feb 24 8.10pm

The Rest of the Season...

...is looking bleak.

 

GlazierJohn Flag Carshalton 04 Feb 24 9.24pm

We will never know how good the young players in the squad are unless we play them. Playing the same tired journeymen week in week out regardless of position offers no threat. Be more positive and results will improve. There is ability in the squad, just give the youngsters a chance.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The rest of the season