You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Alexi Navalny -dead.
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexi Navalny -dead.


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 Feb 24 9.48am

Originally posted by eaglesdare

The US government can solve a murder mystery in a Russian prison, but has no answers about a high profile prisoner, in a US Federal prison, committing suicide while in protective custody......

good point well made

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

snytaxx Flag London 17 Feb 24 10.02am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I'll state once again, you present claims made by Ukraine as facts and yet accuse me of 'Russian propaganda'.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

No, you are projecting. To stress once again, no I dont unless they come with actual evidence. In the case of Mr. Lira, everything posted is literally his work or opinion, i'm sorry if you don't like that. I guess never meet your hero's as they say. I do also correctly accuse you of propagating Russian talking points because... you do.

This thread is about Navalny, yet the first thing you mention when commenting on this news is to bring up Mr. Lira despite them being false equivalents. How is this not defending Russia via Whatabout'ism? Furthermore, you then go into detail on other posts on 'how Ukraine is definitely going to lose' and now Julian Assange critiquing the west gets a mention and yet you accuse me of bring up irrelvant information.

Indeed its taken a 'hit job' on your favourite 'journalist' to get you to even talk about the subject matter in question.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Once again here...and as I previously stated, you present reasons why you don't like Lira's personality. I find that irrelevant to what happened to him. He didn't deserve to die.

None of that has any relevance to the fact he died in Ukrainian captivity. You don't address the claims made by himself and his father on the torture and financial extortion while there but instead accept as fact Ukraine's claims....when you have no way of knowing either way.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

I think you are missing the point, so I will simplify it. The claims about mistreatment in the case of Mr. Lira are just that, claims. It's possible the man was personally bumped off by Zelensky, it's also possible that given Coach Red Pill lived in some pretty squalid conditions prior to his arrest and was not in good health that he died of natural causes. We just don't know.

What we do know is Navalny had been targetted for assasination in the past, its possible that he did just keel over and die? Yes, but we actually have some hard evidence of a motive and prior agression other that conjecture and hearsay which befalls the alledged mistreatment of Lira. They are also different in terms of motives, reasons and value in having them both bumped off. That is why they are false equivalents.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I watched some Lira videos before he died. People can do the same if they wish. That will prove the fact that he was an opinion journalist of that war. People can argue about the definition of journalist if they wish but he does fit a definition for me and people can make their own mind up.

People can speculate that doing a hit job on someone like this to justify not liking them and thus presenting the idea that what happened to them was unimportant could be seen as rather tactless.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

Allow me to link a highlight reel.

[Link]

My favourite part is where he tells someone who doesn't agree with him to 'die painfully'. The true art of journalism right there.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Now moving onto Navalny.

I don't regard this man's politics as migrating reasons for not caring that he's died in Russian captivity. I find no reason to believe Russia and all the reasons you give for accepting an innocent demise of Lira falls under the same unknowable category.

As you spent rather a lot of time slagging off Lira because of...in some ways I'd agree...his questionable behaviour I'll do the same for Navalny.

Not for the same purpose that you did....to suggest that someone holding controversial views doesn't matter when captive but for the reason that he also...at one point as a prominent activist...held views quite more controversial than Lira.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

Again, you've missed the point while on damage control with Coach Red Pill's pretty disturbing history. Navalny was put in prison for contempt of court and embezzlement and charged prior to Russian's open invasion of Ukraine. Some of his 'crimes' even took place while he was in a coma after having been poisoned by the Russians back in 2020. I continually question the relevance of bringing up Lira given that as previously stated, they have significantly different histories and motives / benefits for wanted them bumped off. That is why they are false equivalents.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Before 2012 Navalny was a Russian nationalist who regularly attended what you'd regard as extreme marches and it's reported that he wanted to strip Chechens, Dargins, and all other nations in the Caucasus of their Russian citizenship and compared them to cockroaches and flies and he held strong anti Islamic and immigration views. The behaviour of the marches he attended and helped organise is on video....I'll attach a video of this below.


Why he changed to the rainbow loving western pipedream?....I don't know, CIA money maybe, that's not important. He didn't deserve to die and Russia were responsible for his safety.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

Why is it when anyone is Eastern Europe changes their opinion to liking basic human rights as often readily available in the west, it always has to be the work of the CIA? Can't the man just have a natural change in heart? You used to be self pescribed 'neo con' once? Was it the FSB who finally 'saved' you? Did they pay you? Or did you come to this conclusion naturally? If you did, why does Navalny not get to make his own mind up independently?

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

To me it makes no difference what their political opinions are. When the mainstream media crafts a message that presents a 'goodies and baddies' choice between regimes I am sufficiently interested to look. Ukraine and Russia can be what they are, however as we are being asked to believe narratives and pay tens of billions to one side and possibly enter a war against Russia I feel more objectivity on claims is a valid pursuit.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)


Couldn't resist a cheeky russian propaganda point there could you? Love it!

Is it not possible that Russia's casus belli for attacking another soveriegn country is just wrong? Thus making it a rare case of wrong vs right? How did the Mainstream Media get involved? Did they make Putin give the order to attack? For all the claims of 'I make my own analysis', you seem to conveniently ignore the direction of travel of both of these countries even prior to 2014 and just accept Putin's narrative as pointed out in other posts.


Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You make great play of saying there is a false equivalence between these men's deaths. I on the other hand see that they were both single men held by regimes punishing them. They are both dead and unlike you I criticise both regimes for this.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)


Apart from you dont, infact you've constantly drawn attention to the narrative of the man who has in the past tried to kill Navalny and likely has finally suceeded. Consistently talked up Russian war progress, talked down / dismissed Ukranian resistance. The closest thing to a criticism of Russia I can find from you can be summed up as "Oh well, Russia eh?". Hardly stinging criticism is it?

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

One man's death was ignored by mainstream western media, despite his captivity and lack of American action (he held an American passport) and his treatment having been raised at the Biden press briefing room by a journalist and his cause being raised by, booted out of the mainstream' journalists like Tucker Carlson....probably the single most popular journalist in the world.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

Yes, because aside from you and the patreon's at Coach Red Pill most people probably saw the guy as totally irrelevant, not a real journalist and alround nasty piece of work and probably didn't think any scoop showing the 'lies of the Zelensky regime' which his follow demanded via faux outrage would actually stand up to scrutiny actual journalism is supposed to entail. Hence why only fellow grifters like Tucker chose to take up his 'injustice'.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I suspect that what happened to both these men was wrong. However, one man's death is ignored by the mainstream and the other man's death is spread far and wide across media outlets across the world.

People can draw their own conclusions.


Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Feb 2024 5.21am)

Yes, I look forward to you challenging the Russian narrative on this in the coming days given your neutral status in all of this.

Have a good weekend.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Feb 24 12.00pm

I considered replying to this guy again but it becomes a pointless passive aggressive, 'yes it is, no it isn't' ego fest that never ends and frankly bores me: It's a merry-go-round.

People can look at the different perspectives and see what they consider the most balanced position.

So if anyone is curious and wants to ask me a question based on any of this I'll reply but other than that I'm good.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 17 Feb 24 1.27pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

The US government can solve a murder mystery in a Russian prison, but has no answers about a high profile prisoner, in a US Federal prison, committing suicide while in protective custody......

and the Brits never identified the bloke who stabbed the Christian Lady at Speaker's Corner.

violence coming from a predictable source. In both the cases of Navalny and the preacher lady.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 17 Feb 24 1.36pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Assange and Alexi Navalny were in prison to try and break them.
Russia decided it couldn't break Navalny,...Assange may come to a similar fate.

maybe. Or maybe it was to make a public example of them. To scare the next generation of trouble-makers.

similar to Leon Trotski in Mexico City. "he got an ice pick, that made his ears burn"

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

snytaxx Flag London 17 Feb 24 2.18pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I considered replying to this guy again but it becomes a pointless passive aggressive, 'yes it is, no it isn't' ego fest that never ends and frankly bores me: It's a merry-go-round.

People can look at the different perspectives and see what they consider the most balanced position.

So if anyone is curious and wants to ask me a question based on any of this I'll reply but other than that I'm good.

Sorry Stirling, looks like I've violated your safe space. Still plenty of good news from the front regarding avdiivka. Something to push out those awkward questions on Navalny away from the headlines.

 

eaglesdare Flag 17 Feb 24 2.51pm

I am pretty sure Putin would have loved to make a martyr of the guy by killing him.................

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Feb 24 3.27pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

I am pretty sure Putin would have loved to make a martyr of the guy by killing him.................

There's video of him the day before talking to lawyers, looked fine.

I exclude nothing, however Occam's razor is usually correct. His safety was the responsibility of Russia.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 17 Feb 24 5.16pm

Originally posted by beak

[Link] The West must respond by doubling Ukranian aid and allowing the Ukraine to attack military targets in Russia.

If you're that passionate about taking the Russians on I can drive you to Uzhhorod.

Good luck fella

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Matov Flag 17 Feb 24 5.37pm

Originally posted by snytaxx

Still plenty of good news from the front regarding avdiivka. Something to push out those awkward questions on Navalny away from the headlines.

LOL. Its weird. There Russia is, about to achieve a victory, and they decide to kill this man so that nobody would read about it.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 17 Feb 24 5.47pm

Genuinely surprised people are shocked they're offing political prisoners when Russia has no problems at all killing enemies of the state abroad.

Russia does what it wants.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

snytaxx Flag London 17 Feb 24 9.48pm

Originally posted by Matov

LOL. Its weird. There Russia is, about to achieve a victory, and they decide to kill this man so that nobody would read about it.

To be honest I don't think the timing matters as much to Putin. Navalny dying is an own goal internationally but at this point Russia has bungled it's invasion so badly that it's not really going to matter in the grand scheme of things in terms of optics.

Russian TV will simply ignore, spin and downplay the story while saying how victory in Adviivka means it's only a matter of time.

If you (plural) are intentionally or unintentionally doing Russia's bidding by propagating russian talking points and pushing against support to Ukraine before Navalny died, it's likely you (again plural) will still keep doing it. I.e. everyone seems to have already picked a side internationally.

It's also possible the guy genuinely did just die, even if that is unlikely. In which case the whole question of timing is irrelevant.

 

Matov Flag 18 Feb 24 8.09am

Originally posted by snytaxx


It's also possible the guy genuinely did just die, even if that is unlikely. In which case the whole question of timing is irrelevant.

Rule 1 of this Geo-politics malarkey. There are no coincidences. Somebody decided this guy's time was up. Question is was it Moscow or somewhere much further West.

I see zero upside for this to be Putin. But as a way of diverting attention from what seems to be a developing negative situation for Ukraine on the battlefield, then job done.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Feb 24 8.22am

Originally posted by Ouzo Dan

Genuinely surprised people are shocked they're offing political prisoners when Russia has no problems at all killing enemies of the state abroad.

Russia does what it wants.

Exactly, when Putin murdered Alexander Litvinenko the FSB could have used any number of untraceable poisons or simply staged an accident. Instead they used radioactive Polonium which was easily traceable back to the BA flight from Moscow.

Putin was sending a message to his enemies I can kill you anywhere anytime and I don't give a damn if people know this.

 


One more point

snytaxx Flag London 18 Feb 24 9.05am

Originally posted by Matov

Rule 1 of this Geo-politics malarkey. There are no coincidences. Somebody decided this guy's time was up. Question is was it Moscow or somewhere much further West.

I see zero upside for this to be Putin. But as a way of diverting attention from what seems to be a developing negative situation for Ukraine on the battlefield, then job done.

The case for it (assuming it was foul play) being 'the west' makes zero sense for the following reasons.

1. Why risk Navalny, you could pick another russian dissident like Kasparov who'd be easier to dispatch?
2. The supposed reward (headlines in the west) aren't going to increase support for Ukraine, as mentioned it's likely most people have already chosen their side.
3. If the west really wanted to help Ukraine in a more tangible way they'd pull their finger out and actually commit more ammo and equipment rather than the trickle which Ukraine has been recieving. Before anyone comes back about the supposed 'billions sent to Ukraine'. We've provided less than 5% of our defence budget each year and most of this in previously purchased assets. It's a trickle. Putin doesn't care what the headlines or the optics look like in the UK.

 

beak Flag croydon 18 Feb 24 10.09am

Originally posted by Ouzo Dan

If you're that passionate about taking the Russians on I can drive you to Uzhhorod.

Good luck fella

I typed AID which obviously doesn't include Western /NATO troops,in fact we are forbidden from entering the war.The thought of Putin winning means he will go further ultimately Calais.

 

snytaxx Flag London 18 Feb 24 10.42am

Originally posted by beak
The thought of Putin winning means he will go further ultimately Calais.

For the record I am generally very sympathetic to the Ukrainians on this subject given it is a rare case of mostly right vs mostly wrong.

I would however urge caution on making statements such as this though as although the sentiment is correct, it vastly exhagerates Putin's aims and abilities and will only ever be seized upon by those who drank the Kremlin kool aid as 'alarmist' and 'scaremongering'.

The key thing to focus on when it comes to opposing Putin's land grab in ukraine is highlighting that by supporting him, not only this unbelievably short sighted and lazy, it's more that is fundementally detremental to our country and actually takes us further away from the nostalgic 'common sense politics' many of us here likely crave.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 18 Feb 24 11.05am

Originally posted by beak

I typed AID which obviously doesn't include Western /NATO troops,in fact we are forbidden from entering the war.The thought of Putin winning means he will go further ultimately Calais.

well, considering how awful the EU has been toward its own people, do not be surprised if the people of France/Ireland/Greece will greet Putin as a liberator. A conquering hero.

Fixing the borders against Africa, cancelling the debt that has destroyed Greece & Ireland. Putting Antifa (and all their corporate collaborators) in their place. Putting the Nuclear Family back to the centre of society. Protecting the youth from sexual predators. Punishing narco-terrorists properly.

Raising the fertility of working-people and lowering that of the longterm unemployed.

Cos the EU is discredited and is already a dying animal.

The West is like Downtown Philadelphia or Malmo Sweden......decadent, broke, dirty, on drugs, crime infested and already ruined.

Rome
Byzantium
hitler
napoleon
the Soviet Union in 1989

all the great European empires fall. 'The West & EU' will be falling fairly soon. And it already started with Brexit, then the War in Ukraine.....next ? i reckon the Financial Markets will finish it off. You bankrupt the EU and you win. Paper money, FIAT money is only worth the paper it is printed on.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (18 Feb 2024 11.41am)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Feb 24 12.12pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

well, considering how awful the EU has been toward its own people, do not be surprised if the people of France/Ireland/Greece will greet Putin as a liberator. A conquering hero.

Fixing the borders against Africa, cancelling the debt that has destroyed Greece & Ireland. Putting Antifa (and all their corporate collaborators) in their place. Putting the Nuclear Family back to the centre of society. Protecting the youth from sexual predators. Punishing narco-terrorists properly.

Raising the fertility of working-people and lowering that of the longterm unemployed.

Cos the EU is discredited and is already a dying animal.

The West is like Downtown Philadelphia or Malmo Sweden......decadent, broke, dirty, on drugs, crime infested and already ruined.

Rome
Byzantium
hitler
napoleon
the Soviet Union in 1989

all the great European empires fall. 'The West & EU' will be falling fairly soon. And it already started with Brexit, then the War in Ukraine.....next ? i reckon the Financial Markets will finish it off. You bankrupt the EU and you win. Paper money, FIAT money is only worth the paper it is printed on.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (18 Feb 2024 11.41am)

It won't be Putin's military that sees the eventual collapse of US and Europe into competing fiefdoms...that will be other factors. We are in decline because of multiple factors not least the fact that our ruling classes, financial system and sociopolitical ideologies aren't fit for purpose.

In the coming years you will notice increasing authoritarianism as society becomes increasingly polarised....essentially the meme about the US being a few years ahead of us is usually accurate.

The next economic collapse will be spicy and will bring more changes than people realise....what those are will be up for grabs.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Feb 2024 1.59pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Alexi Navalny -dead.