You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton points deduction reduced to 6 points
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton points deduction reduced to 6 points


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Feb 24 3.48pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Not how it works. As with all adjudication, the original decision stands unless overturned on appeal.

As for Forest/Everton#2, the decisions should be based on the merits. These may demonstrate e.g. a far more flagrant breach justifying a harsher sentence; or otherwise. No idea.

Thus, 6 points should not be the default sentence. And as for the time taken, I do agree, but these are new rules and procedures. They are still finding their way through it.

But perhaps how it should work in future.

Other clubs need to know where they stand long before the crucial games at the end of the season.

 

stancummins Flag 26 Feb 24 3.58pm

I believe now the appeal decision has been made and Everton seemingly accepting it , the precedent has been set for the 6 point deduction for the first offence so the second charge for Everton and Forest one you would expect 6 points again . Rumours on Social media are that they will be handed out end of March , given that the appeal process has been used for this first charge i reckon that wont be used again

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 26 Feb 24 4.09pm

Presumably each individual case has its own degree(s) of severity & mitigating factors, so whilst the 6 point deduction may indeed be utilised as a yardstick to gauge future cases I struggle to see it becoming a one size fits all / 1st offence cast in stone type punishment.

I could of course be wrong, after all I don't know anymore than the next guy.

Originally posted by stancummins

I believe now the appeal decision has been made and Everton seemingly accepting it , the precedent has been set for the 6 point deduction for the first offence so the second charge for Everton and Forest one you would expect 6 points again . Rumours on Social media are that they will be handed out end of March , given that the appeal process has been used for this first charge i reckon that wont be used again

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Feb 24 4.10pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Not how it works. As with all adjudication, the original decision stands unless overturned on appeal.

As for Forest/Everton#2, the decisions should be based on the merits. These may demonstrate e.g. a far more flagrant breach justifying a harsher sentence; or otherwise. No idea.

Thus, 6 points should not be the default sentence. And as for the time taken, I do agree, but these are new rules and procedures. They are still finding their way through it.


Do you or did you work in the legal profession silver top?
You sound defensive towards it albeit in football which seems to make its own laws up until someone like Man City and now Everton come at them with their big gun KCs.
I am finding the Premier League handling of all this very messy.
They must have realised that like all rules, they are going to be broken. So they should have had a far slicker faster system in place considering the time frames of the game and the need to work within those.
By the time the Everton and Forest latest 'crimes' are punished and then appealed, considered and decided upon, we will be near or past the end of the season which will make a farce of the whole thing. As for Man City, well if that isn't driven by Middle Eastern investment considerations then I dont know what is.
The more these bodies tamper with the game, the worse it all seems to get.
They must find a way to short circuit this whole sorry matter so that it is simplified and if the rules are broken a straightforward mathematical fine / points deduction.
They really are making a mountain out of what should be a small hill and not giving it enough urgent attention.
If they continue to allow the legal profession to control it, then it will not improve from its current mess.

 

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 26 Feb 24 4.21pm

I think 10 points should have stood. But as usual the FA or whoever makes these decisions and bottled it due to public pressure. The whole point is that it's meant to be a deterrent. 6 points is only 2 wins. 10 was harsh for a reason.

You can also bet that if it happened to us, nobody would be talking about it, nor would we get any points back.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Feb 24 4.24pm

And they've awarded the four points difference to Man City for falsely accusing them.

 


Red and Blue Army!

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Feb 24 4.27pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

And they've awarded the four points difference to Man City for falsely accusing them.



They might as well have done. They give them enough breaks right the way through the season.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Feb 24 4.39pm

Originally posted by indianapalace85

I think 10 points should have stood. But as usual the FA or whoever makes these decisions and bottled it due to public pressure. The whole point is that it's meant to be a deterrent. 6 points is only 2 wins. 10 was harsh for a reason.

You can also bet that if it happened to us, nobody would be talking about it, nor would we get any points back.


The independent appeals panel decided that the original panel had been incorrect on two of the nine charges and therefore, decided that the punishment should be reduced. Whether they bottled it like Chelsea did yesterday is possible but I suspect that, due to the legal implicatiosn, they were careful in their making their decision.

 

stancummins Flag 26 Feb 24 4.52pm

I think as well that with the accounts over a three year rolling period Everton will be hard pressed to argue the the second charge that is thrown at them so that is why at least 6 points will be deducted as they knew these regulations at the start of the period. Forest again knew the rules but tried to bend them by not selling Johnson 6 months earlier so they could maximise his transfer fee, so any argument they have will be very weak

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Feb 24 4.54pm

At least some sort of president has now been set although of course not every case will necessarily be the same.

But it's tempting to think that if Everton get found guilty of a second breach then 6 points will be the minimum they get docked and Forest should expect similar.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

The Dolphin Flag 26 Feb 24 4.56pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

“ shouldn’t be punished for lying” why the hell not? Flagrant disregard for the rules, the game and other clubs. Victims my arse

This!!
There has to be a punishment.
They were £20m over in one year alone - that is 20% of the total allowed for the three year period!
Should be 1 point for every £2m over which is doubled it you try to hide it.

Edited by The Dolphin (26 Feb 2024 4.57pm)

 

RubinsCube Flag Wimbledon 26 Feb 24 4.59pm

Seems to me there are so many aspects of this which lack transparency and consistency. Here are just some of them:

1. No transparency re when points should be deducted relative to the timing of the transgressions in FFP/FSR. Should it be the same season, or the following season, or every (current?) season the transgressions occur? For context, Everton transgressed in windows affecting last season. They would have been relegated last year with even a 3 point penalty. Last year Man City won the title by 5 points: a 6 point deduction as given to Everton today would have resulted in ramifications at the top of the table as well.

2. No transparency on what transgressions (or volume of transgressions) should result in 'x' amount of points deducted. Assuming all infractions committed by Man City/Everton/Forest are fungible (a good accountancy exams word there), how can the 115 supposed infractions by Citeh potentially lead to the same deduction as the 9 infractions or so by Everton, assuming these numbers are accurate (again there is no transparency over precisely how many infractions there have been in each case).

3. No transparency over how similar, or dissimilar, the transgressions by each club are. How can points deductions therefore be consistent club to club and season to season?

4. No transparency or reason why Everton have somehow been penalized, had their appeal heard, and been awarded back points, whilst Forest and City (and maybe others?) are still at first base.

5. No consistency between approaches at Premier League level and lower levels. For context, Luton got hammered for 30 points in 2014. 10 of these deducted points were for player transfer anomalies. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9309_Luton_Town_F.C._season). There was no right of appeal for the transfer related 10 point penalty. The full -30 point penalty kicked in at the start of the season.

Where is the process? Where is the consistency?

I'd be livid if I were a Leicester/Arsenal/Luton fan. I'd also be angry as an Everton fan looking at how Man City/Forest seem to be able to filibuster.

Edited by RubinsCube (26 Feb 2024 5.08pm)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 26 Feb 24 5.25pm

Originally posted by stancummins

I believe now the appeal decision has been made and Everton seemingly accepting it , the precedent has been set for the 6 point deduction for the first offence so the second charge for Everton and Forest one you would expect 6 points again . Rumours on Social media are that they will be handed out end of March , given that the appeal process has been used for this first charge i reckon that wont be used again

To be handed out they would need to have been heard. Have they?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 26 Feb 24 5.29pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

At least some sort of president has now been set although of course not every case will necessarily be the same.

But it's tempting to think that if Everton get found guilty of a second breach then 6 points will be the minimum they get docked and Forest should expect similar.

Thank you, my favourite typo of the week.

All hail the Chief!

Meanwhile, for natural justice to be seen to be done, 6 points should be more of a bench mark for that particular factual matrix than a hard and fast precedent for any offence.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Feb 24 5.36pm

Originally posted by silvertop

To be handed out they would need to have been heard. Have they?


According to the Beeb the cases have to have been heard by 8th April

[Link]

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 26 Feb 24 5.38pm

After Luton's disgraceful 30 point deduction the 10 that Everton got didn't seem excessive to me so I think they have done well getting it cut by 4 points.

The people that really suffer are the fans not the management.

It's a terrible indictment that Man City who appear to most people to be major offenders that they are able to hire the best lawyers to constantly delay their hearing. I think it is possible they will eventually get hammered so hard that demotion to League Two is a possibility, as Rangers suffered a few years back, followed closely by Chelsea.

If the rules are there what excuse is there to be lenient with offenders?

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 Feb 24 5.39pm

I have no idea how you bring transparency to the process. These conversations get very complicated when you hear the grounds on which clubs appeal. I do feel sorry for Everton fans. It's a tedious way to support your football team, waiting on the whims of some bureaucrats in London.

It's a rotten business that is for sure

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

silvertop Flag Portishead 26 Feb 24 5.40pm

Originally posted by RubinsCube

Seems to me there are so many aspects of this which lack transparency and consistency. Here are just some of them:

1. No transparency re when points should be deducted relative to the timing of the transgressions in FFP/FSR. Should it be the same season, or the following season, or every (current?) season the transgressions occur? For context, Everton transgressed in windows affecting last season. They would have been relegated last year with even a 3 point penalty. Last year Man City won the title by 5 points: a 6 point deduction as given to Everton today would have resulted in ramifications at the top of the table as well.

2. No transparency on what transgressions (or volume of transgressions) should result in 'x' amount of points deducted. Assuming all infractions committed by Man City/Everton/Forest are fungible (a good accountancy exams word there), how can the 115 supposed infractions by Citeh potentially lead to the same deduction as the 9 infractions or so by Everton, assuming these numbers are accurate (again there is no transparency over precisely how many infractions there have been in each case).

3. No transparency over how similar, or dissimilar, the transgressions by each club are. How can points deductions therefore be consistent club to club and season to season?

4. No transparency or reason why Everton have somehow been penalized, had their appeal heard, and been awarded back points, whilst Forest and City (and maybe others?) are still at first base.

5. No consistency between approaches at Premier League level and lower levels. For context, Luton got hammered for 30 points in 2014. 10 of these deducted points were for player transfer anomalies. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9309_Luton_Town_F.C._season). There was no right of appeal for the transfer related 10 point penalty. The full -30 point penalty kicked in at the start of the season.

Where is the process? Where is the consistency?

I'd be livid if I were a Leicester/Arsenal/Luton fan. I'd also be angry as an Everton fan looking at how Man City/Forest seem to be able to filibuster.

Edited by RubinsCube (26 Feb 2024 5.08pm)

You are not wrong in what the FA need to achieve, but a few points.

Luton, Man City and Everton/Forest are/were charged under 3 separate sets of regulations with their own discrete rules so it is hardly surprising there is no consistency between their respective treatments. You are not comparing apples.

Why Man City and Chelsea have not had their FFP issue determined by now is vexing and does not credit the FA.

However, on Everton and Forest, which relates to accounting breaches rather than transfer irregularities, these are new rules where the FA is still finding its way. It needs to build up a set of precedents and fine tune its procedure so the clubs fully understand what they can and can't do, how to avoid it, and what the likely penalty and process will be if they flout the rules. This requires time and plenty of clubs trying to bend the rules.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 26 Feb 24 5.42pm

Originally posted by Uphill

After Luton's disgraceful 30 point deduction the 10 that Everton got didn't seem excessive to me so I think they have done well getting it cut by 4 points.

The people that really suffer are the fans not the management.

It's a terrible indictment that Man City who appear to most people to be major offenders that they are able to hire the best lawyers to constantly delay their hearing. I think it is possible they will eventually get hammered so hard that demotion to League Two is a possibility, as Rangers suffered a few years back, followed closely by Chelsea.

If the rules are there what excuse is there to be lenient with offenders?

Everton did not hold back on who they instructed. Top KC like Man City.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Feb 24 5.47pm

Originally posted by RubinsCube

Seems to me there are so many aspects of this which lack transparency and consistency. Here are just some of them:

1. No transparency re when points should be deducted relative to the timing of the transgressions in FFP/FSR. Should it be the same season, or the following season, or every (current?) season the transgressions occur? For context, Everton transgressed in windows affecting last season. They would have been relegated last year with even a 3 point penalty. Last year Man City won the title by 5 points: a 6 point deduction as given to Everton today would have resulted in ramifications at the top of the table as well.

2. No transparency on what transgressions (or volume of transgressions) should result in 'x' amount of points deducted. Assuming all infractions committed by Man City/Everton/Forest are fungible (a good accountancy exams word there), how can the 115 supposed infractions by Citeh potentially lead to the same deduction as the 9 infractions or so by Everton, assuming these numbers are accurate (again there is no transparency over precisely how many infractions there have been in each case).

3. No transparency over how similar, or dissimilar, the transgressions by each club are. How can points deductions therefore be consistent club to club and season to season?

4. No transparency or reason why Everton have somehow been penalized, had their appeal heard, and been awarded back points, whilst Forest and City (and maybe others?) are still at first base.

5. No consistency between approaches at Premier League level and lower levels. For context, Luton got hammered for 30 points in 2014. 10 of these deducted points were for player transfer anomalies. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008%E2%80%9309_Luton_Town_F.C._season). There was no right of appeal for the transfer related 10 point penalty. The full -30 point penalty kicked in at the start of the season.

Where is the process? Where is the consistency?

I'd be livid if I were a Leicester/Arsenal/Luton fan. I'd also be angry as an Everton fan looking at how Man City/Forest seem to be able to filibuster.

Edited by RubinsCube (26 Feb 2024 5.08pm)

Excellent post.

I think fans would be a lot happier if they understood how penalties are calculated and when they apply. I am not even certain that if found guilty Everton and Forest's punishment will apply this season?

As for Man City, will they take away trophies?

Edited by Badger11 (26 Feb 2024 5.47pm)

 


One more point

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton points deduction reduced to 6 points