You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Funding Problems . . .
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace Funding Problems . . .


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Mar 24 12.07pm

Originally posted by pssguy

But then teams will know we are desperate to sell to balance the books and offer lower transfer fees

Not for those with release clauses

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 26 Mar 24 12.58pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

. . . or maybe not.

Story is from the 'Mail' so it can't be true, because 'wissie' doesn't trust nor believe them. Anyhoo, the club have taken out a 'significant' loan from an American Investment Co, MGG, taken against future transfer dealings & 'day-to-day' running costs . . . [Link]

Whilst the only source for this story is the Mail it appears authoritative and based on knowledge. Unlike the spin which many Mail stories contain! How big and precisely why isn't said but it does look as though something is cooking behind the scenes and maybe we need short-term bridging finance to get someone in, before we move one, or more, out. Only time will tell, because the club won't.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 26 Mar 24 2.21pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I can see that the £125 million losses over 3 seasons
(£24.2 + £40 + £61.1 = £125.3) includes around £21 million Covid losses over 2 seasons 2019/20 + 20 / 21 -

I think that Covid losses are relevant to the financial accounts but they are not counted against FFP/ Profit & sustainability calculations -

Part of Evertons argument against FFP / Profit & sustainability in the first case revolved around how much they allocated against Covid losses (I forget the numbers but the amount of relief against losses that they claimed was substantially more than other clubs of the same / similar size)

Of course I am not an accountant but thats how it looks to me.

At last, someone is seeing it as it is.

100% this. I have been calling it for a years, the net debt of our club is a worry, especially when the board are not underwriting the losses. Our directors are looking for a return on their investment and with the current losses, something needs to be done.

We are close the the ffp line so will deffo be sales.

THE CLUB IS LOSING APPROXIMATELY 400k A WEEK

But it’s never mentioned, never discussed. It’s just continually swept under tithe carpet.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 26 Mar 24 3.00pm

Almost all football clubs lose money -
for some its more of a vanity project, for Palace at least we are trying to make it become a viable self sustaining business ( as much as is realistic) which is why:
a) We spent so much on the academy to gain class one status - i.e produce a production line of players to support the first team or be sold at a profit -
b) Reduce the %age of player wages against club revenue (I forget the actual numbers but it used to be something like 84% whereas its now 69% (ish)
c) Stay in the PL as it provides considerably higher income than the Championship + Improve position in the league as every place increases income by approximately £2.25 million
d) Upgrade main stand + 8000 seats + matchday revenue.
Obviously there are other initiatives but these are ones that come to mind immediately.
So whilst its not talked about on a daily basis I dont think its ever far from the shareholders thoughts.

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

At last, someone is seeing it as it is.

100% this. I have been calling it for a years, the net debt of our club is a worry, especially when the board are not underwriting the losses. Our directors are looking for a return on their investment and with the current losses, something needs to be done.

We are close the the ffp line so will deffo be sales.

THE CLUB IS LOSING APPROXIMATELY 400k A WEEK

But it’s never mentioned, never discussed. It’s just continually swept under tithe carpet.

 

beak Flag croydon 26 Mar 24 4.41pm

I might be wrong but this looks like a cash flow deal.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Mar 24 4.48pm

Originally posted by beak

I might be wrong but this looks like a cash flow deal.

Which is what I said a page or so back but everyone ignored that as they had conspiracy theories to consider

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 26 Mar 24 5.01pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Which is what I said a page or so back but everyone ignored that as they had conspiracy theories to consider

Like the yanks making sure they get a pay day even if its just the interest on the loans

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Mar 24 5.07pm

Originally posted by beak

I might be wrong but this looks like a cash flow deal.

That was how I read it.

What we need to look for is when we pay the loan off? If it gets rolled over year after year then clearly it is debt.

Hopefully as one poster said it means we can buy targets without the pressure of having to sell first. So we may buy a centre back at the start of the window and hold out selling Guehi until the price is right.

 


One more point

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Mar 24 6.00pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Whilst the only source for this story is the Mail it appears authoritative and based on knowledge. Unlike the spin which many Mail stories contain! How big and precisely why isn't said but it does look as though something is cooking behind the scenes and maybe we need short-term bridging finance to get someone in, before we move one, or more, out. Only time will tell, because the club won't.

We all know you don't like the Mail. So, go back to where you think you are superior & leave us supporters alone.

Off you go, no one's interested on these threads what you think, bye

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 26 Mar 24 6.51pm

eagleman13

We all know you don't like the Mail. So, go back to where you think you are superior & leave us supporters alone.

Off you go, no one's interested on these threads what you think, bye

------------------------------------------------------------------

Please don't speak on my behalf. Who exactly are "us supporters"?

It's a Palace forum. What's wrong with anyone (particularly a long standing forum member) joining in the chat? If you don't like someones opinions skip them and move on. Maybe "us supporters" don't want you calling people out on our behalf. When on the Palace forum, why not concentrate on what unifies us rather than look for wedges to drive us apart?

Anyway, maybe this new approach by Palace ties in with the appointment of Glasner. I get the impression he is not interested in PL survival every year and wants to move us onwards and upwards. When interviewed, he must have told the board that investment in new players will be needed. Palace may have made certain commitments to him in that respect. This new funding approach might be another signal that we are going to try and move forward from next season.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Mar 24 7.35pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

We all know you don't like the Mail. So, go back to where you think you are superior & leave us supporters alone.

Off you go, no one's interested on these threads what you think, bye

Don't let it bother you mate. They can't kill you and they can't... Well, you know.

 


Red and Blue Army!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 26 Mar 24 8.22pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Don't let it bother you mate. They can't kill you and they can't... Well, you know.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 27 Mar 24 9.02am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Almost all football clubs lose money -
for some its more of a vanity project, for Palace at least we are trying to make it become a viable self sustaining business ( as much as is realistic) which is why:
a) We spent so much on the academy to gain class one status - i.e produce a production line of players to support the first team or be sold at a profit -
b) Reduce the %age of player wages against club revenue (I forget the actual numbers but it used to be something like 84% whereas its now 69% (ish)
c) Stay in the PL as it provides considerably higher income than the Championship + Improve position in the league as every place increases income by approximately £2.25 million
d) Upgrade main stand + 8000 seats + matchday revenue.
Obviously there are other initiatives but these are ones that come to mind immediately.
So whilst its not talked about on a daily basis I dont think its ever far from the shareholders thoughts.

I don’t disagree with the points, however the club has still racked up more losses.

Unlike many other clubs, the losses are underwritten by the owners etc… our owners are loaning us the money and we are paying interest on their loans. They have not been converted into shares like other clubs, they are expecting the money back. Our other board member/ceo takes a salary of around 2m a year. He has taken approximately 16m put the club in his tenure.

The mistake is comparing us to other clubs. We are trying to be more sustainable whilst paying back the debt, whilst building a new stand. Whilst remaining competitive in the league…..all equals more debt and loans.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Mar 24 10.10am

Hi Ali -
Your certainly correct to be concerned, with the amount of money involved who wouldnt be - but I would comment as follows:

Our losses have been reducing year on year which indicates that we have a handle on the situation & its being managed better now than previously (down from £60 Million / £40 Million / £24 Million

Our main Shareholders are a group of 4 as opposed to say Forest where one mans decisions on investment are conclusive & if he choses to write off losses its his decision alone

Borrowing money from the market formalises the transaction & the flow of money is properly documented & recognised as a club transaction rather than one individual putting his hand in his pocket.

When John Textor invested & joined he did so with the purchase of shares & has increased his interest in the club since -

Steve Parish does not take £2 million out of the club every year - this is recorded in the clubs accounts - without checking every years figures I think its about £800,000 per year, on years where he has received more in terms of bonuses its documented that he reinvested (or has indicated that he intends to reinvest) them back into the club.

Football clubs tend to make money when they are successful or when they are sold - I dont think anyone can argue that CPFC isnt worth a whole lot more now than it was in 2010 or when the Americans came on board.

That's as I see things, for sure others will see it differently -

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Almost all football clubs lose money -
for some its more of a vanity project, for Palace at least we are trying to make it become a viable self sustaining business ( as much as is realistic) which is why:
a) We spent so much on the academy to gain class one status - i.e produce a production line of players to support the first team or be sold at a profit -
b) Reduce the %age of player wages against club revenue (I forget the actual numbers but it used to be something like 84% whereas its now 69% (ish)
c) Stay in the PL as it provides considerably higher income than the Championship + Improve position in the league as every place increases income by approximately £2.25 million
d) Upgrade main stand + 8000 seats + matchday revenue.
Obviously there are other initiatives but these are ones that come to mind immediately.
So whilst its not talked about on a daily basis I dont think its ever far from the shareholders thoughts.

I don’t disagree with the points, however the club has still racked up more losses.

Unlike many other clubs, the losses are underwritten by the owners etc… our owners are loaning us the money and we are paying interest on their loans. They have not been converted into shares like other clubs, they are expecting the money back. Our other board member/ceo takes a salary of around 2m a year. He has taken approximately 16m put the club in his tenure.

The mistake is comparing us to other clubs. We are trying to be more sustainable whilst paying back the debt, whilst building a new stand. Whilst remaining competitive in the league…..all equals more debt and loans.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Mar 24 10.41am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Hi Ali -
Your certainly correct to be concerned, with the amount of money involved who wouldnt be - but I would comment as follows:

Our losses have been reducing year on year which indicates that we have a handle on the situation & its being managed better now than previously (down from £60 Million / £40 Million / £24 Million

Our main Shareholders are a group of 4 as opposed to say Forest where one mans decisions on investment are conclusive & if he choses to write off losses its his decision alone

Borrowing money from the market formalises the transaction & the flow of money is properly documented & recognised as a club transaction rather than one individual putting his hand in his pocket.

When John Textor invested & joined he did so with the purchase of shares & has increased his interest in the club since -

Steve Parish does not take £2 million out of the club every year - this is recorded in the clubs accounts - without checking every years figures I think its about £800,000 per year, on years where he has received more in terms of bonuses its documented that he reinvested (or has indicated that he intends to reinvest) them back into the club.

Football clubs tend to make money when they are successful or when they are sold - I dont think anyone can argue that CPFC isnt worth a whole lot more now than it was in 2010 or when the Americans came on board.

That's as I see things, for sure others will see it differently -

Posters keep mentioning this, not sure why.

Unlike the other investors Parish is the full time manager of the club so whether he gets paid £800,000 or £2m this is his compensation for that role. If he steps back someone else will have to be paid to do it.

If I was an investor I would be happy with Parish's job performance.

 


One more point

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Mar 24 10.58am

For the first few years following 2010 he didnt take a salary at all -

Originally posted by Badger11

Posters keep mentioning this, not sure why.

Unlike the other investors Parish is the full time manager of the club so whether he gets paid £800,000 or £2m this is his compensation for that role. If he steps back someone else will have to be paid to do it.

If I was an investor I would be happy with Parish's job performance.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 27 Mar 24 11.24am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

At last, someone is seeing it as it is.

100% this. I have been calling it for a years, the net debt of our club is a worry, especially when the board are not underwriting the losses. Our directors are looking for a return on their investment and with the current losses, something needs to be done.

We are close the the ffp line so will deffo be sales.

THE CLUB IS LOSING APPROXIMATELY 400k A WEEK

But it’s never mentioned, never discussed. It’s just continually swept under tithe carpet.

Agree, but football is a strange best.

Abramovich bought Chelsea for c £135m and then funded it by £100m for each year he owned it (so £2m loss a week) and when the loss making business was put up for a distressed sale it fetched £2.5bn.
Unbelievable.

I suspect 1 or 2 big player sells would make the accounts look a lot better. However, you make a good point, these losses are unsustainable in the longer term.

Re FFP - covid losses can be taken into account - the issue with Everton is that they made theirs up.
The academy has been a big cost - £30m upfront and £5m a year to run - these can be taken off too.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Mar 24 11.35am

Indeed, Abramovic had to write off a £1.5 billion debt before he could offer Chelsea for sale.

Originally posted by palace99

Agree, but football is a strange best.

Abramovich bought Chelsea for c £135m and then funded it by £100m for each year he owned it (so £2m loss a week) and when the loss making business was put up for a distressed sale it fetched £2.5bn.
Unbelievable.

I suspect 1 or 2 big player sells would make the accounts look a lot better. However, you make a good point, these losses are unsustainable in the longer term.

Re FFP - covid losses can be taken into account - the issue with Everton is that they made theirs up.
The academy has been a big cost - £30m upfront and £5m a year to run - these can be taken off too.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 27 Mar 24 11.50am

Originally posted by Badger11

Posters keep mentioning this, not sure why.

Unlike the other investors Parish is the full time manager of the club so whether he gets paid £800,000 or £2m this is his compensation for that role. If he steps back someone else will have to be paid to do it.

If I was an investor I would be happy with Parish's job performance.

I have no issue with SP getting paid, however, i do think his payments are excessive, and as a part owner (which most CEOs aren't) i think there should be an upper limit.
£500k a year, £10k a week, seems quite reasonable and would be comparable for a (non football) company with c£150m turnover.
He does seem to be quite highly compensated when comparing other Prem clubs.

[Link]

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Mar 24 12.05pm

Originally posted by palace99

I have no issue with SP getting paid, however, i do think his payments are excessive, and as a part owner (which most CEOs aren't) i think there should be an upper limit.
£500k a year, £10k a week, seems quite reasonable and would be comparable for a (non football) company with c£150m turnover.
He does seem to be quite highly compensated when comparing other Prem clubs.

[Link]

Unfortunately can’t open the link

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Funding Problems . . .