You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton deducted two points
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton deducted two points


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
est1905 Flag 15 Apr 24 5.27pm

Originally posted by ambrose7


Quick reminder that after that run of 14 games, Everton face the only 3 sides Palace have beaten SINCE SEPTEMBER and all at home. After the first game they are 1/1.

It doesn't matter a jot that they have to play Arsenal and Liverpool. They have 2 more golden chances to win that don't include Forest at home where they will also be favourites. Meanwhile, we don't have a single fixture left that we are favourites for. Surely anyone would swap our fixtures for theirs in a heartbeat?

Hows that pessimism going for you today? Found any more stats that point to our inevitable doom?
As mentioned again and again (and not just by me) its the injuries to key players that have made this seasons results (and your stats) so disappointing. Yesterday proved what a level Palace can play at when we have close to a full strength team available. Yes we rode our luck a bit in the second half but our defending was superb. On another day we could have been going in at half time 3 0 up.
As said before I am very confident we will pick up another 4 to 6 points between now and the end of the season. Probably more.
I just wish the doom and gloomers amongst us would just hold their nerve during the rough patches and have some faith

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 15 Apr 24 5.54pm

Originally posted by est1905

Hows that pessimism going for you today? Found any more stats that point to our inevitable doom?
As mentioned again and again (and not just by me) its the injuries to key players that have made this seasons results (and your stats) so disappointing. Yesterday proved what a level Palace can play at when we have close to a full strength team available. Yes we rode our luck a bit in the second half but our defending was superb. On another day we could have been going in at half time 3 0 up.
As said before I am very confident we will pick up another 4 to 6 points between now and the end of the season. Probably more.
I just wish the doom and gloomers amongst us would just hold their nerve during the rough patches and have some faith


I think part of the problem is that too many fans have bought into Hodgson's practice of "bigging-up" the opposition in pre-match press conferences so that even to gain a point from the ensuing game is a minor miracle.

Glasner, refreshingly, always looks at what we can do by playing our game and ensure we make life difficult for the opposition by identifying their weaknesses and using them to our advantage.

Then, of course, the doom mongers always like to play the "Oldham" card.

I think I've been pretty consistent this year in saying we can hit 40 points again, and as I've posted elsewhere, we gained 8 points in the reverse fixtures against the upcoming 6 opponents and I see no reason why we can't at least match that.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 Apr 24 7.43am

i reckon the FA are doing a balance between

a) deducting points and meting out justice

and

b) keeping the relegation fight exciting and interesting.


i reckon they will nail Everton again in May, thus keeping Luton up.

but then again, what would i know ?

Edited by PalazioVecchio (16 Apr 2024 7.48am)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 16 Apr 24 7.57am

Originally posted by doombear


I think I've been pretty consistent this year in saying we can hit 40 points again, .

33 points is probably already enough. The bottom 5 teams are gash.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

NJ CLOCKTOWER Flag Tarragona 16 Apr 24 8.01am

Why is it that Sheffield utd get there points deducted next season?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Apr 24 8.47am

Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER

Why is it that Sheffield utd get there points deducted next season?


I suspect it's because they fell foul of the EFL rules and not the PL ones.

 

mileend Flag East London 16 Apr 24 9.00am

Originally posted by doombear


I suspect it's because they fell foul of the EFL rules and not the PL ones.

correct, it's an EFL penalty

[Link]

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 16 Apr 24 9.00am

Originally posted by est1905

Hows that pessimism going for you today? Found any more stats that point to our inevitable doom?
As mentioned again and again (and not just by me) its the injuries to key players that have made this seasons results (and your stats) so disappointing. Yesterday proved what a level Palace can play at when we have close to a full strength team available. Yes we rode our luck a bit in the second half but our defending was superb. On another day we could have been going in at half time 3 0 up.
As said before I am very confident we will pick up another 4 to 6 points between now and the end of the season. Probably more.
I just wish the doom and gloomers amongst us would just hold their nerve during the rough patches and have some faith

Be pretty dull on here if we all had the same opinion on everything. And it’s amazing how many “told you so” posts appear after these wins. Not so many after the losses and draws.

 

NJ CLOCKTOWER Flag Tarragona 16 Apr 24 3.31pm

Originally posted by doombear


I suspect it's because they fell foul of the EFL rules and not the PL ones.


Quotes thanks! that makes sense.I forget they are both two different entities...

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 16 Apr 24 4.22pm

Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER


Quotes thanks! that makes sense.I forget they are both two different entities...

Indeed and why Leicester faces a point deduction in the PL next season if they get promoted . Not sure how many years they can bank that penalty though Leicester are not subject to fast tracking the case as they were not a PL club when that vote took place .
They will argue they were not a PL club when the accounts were due an offence that is seen as greater than N Forests who got 4 points

LOL its a right mess , the FA should be running all football in England .

 

est1905 Flag 16 Apr 24 5.21pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Be pretty dull on here if we all had the same opinion on everything. And it’s amazing how many “told you so” posts appear after these wins. Not so many after the losses and draws.

...but we're not allowed to call out the WRONG 'told you so's' when we actually do play well and do win? You know, the pessimists that kept banging on and on about how doomed we are. How we're supposedly not going to win another game this season?
So those 'told you so's' are above criticism even when they are so painfully wrong then.

Got it.

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 Apr 24 6.26pm

Our form has been terrible this season and there's no hiding from that.
We've had to rely on Burnley and Sheffield United for more than a third of our points.
One great win against Liverpool can't mask that.
Hyperbolic reaction to one win seems a tad over the top.
Similarly Mitchell had his best game of the season and has an assist from Sunday.
This alone does not necessarily make him the answer to our left wing back position in Glasner's system.
Hopefully he will be, but it would seem prudent to observe more games before reaching such conclusion.
There, I've said it and managed not to insult any fellow fans.

Originally posted by est1905

...but we're not allowed to call out the WRONG 'told you so's' when we actually do play well and do win? You know, the pessimists that kept banging on and on about how doomed we are. How we're supposedly not going to win another game this season?
So those 'told you so's' are above criticism even when they are so painfully wrong then.

Got it.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Apr 24 11.07pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Our form has been terrible this season and there's no hiding from that.
We've had to rely on Burnley and Sheffield United for more than a third of our points.
One great win against Liverpool can't mask that.
Hyperbolic reaction to one win seems a tad over the top.
Similarly Mitchell had his best game of the season and has an assist from Sunday.
This alone does not necessarily make him the answer to our left wing back position in Glasner's system.
Hopefully he will be, but it would seem prudent to observe more games before reaching such conclusion.
There, I've said it and managed not to insult any fellow fans.


Absolutely. However, as I've watched developments under Glasner, I see an improvement in the quality of our football and note that several players seem to be playing at a better level than was the case previously.

I shall be interested in seeing how the rest of the season unfolds.

Edited by doombear (16 Apr 2024 11.12pm)

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 17 Apr 24 8.10am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Our form has been terrible this season and there's no hiding from that.
We've had to rely on Burnley and Sheffield United for more than a third of our points.
One great win against Liverpool can't mask that.
Hyperbolic reaction to one win seems a tad over the top.
Similarly Mitchell had his best game of the season and has an assist from Sunday.
This alone does not necessarily make him the answer to our left wing back position in Glasner's system.
Hopefully he will be, but it would seem prudent to observe more games before reaching such conclusion.
There, I've said it and managed not to insult any fellow fans.

One correspondent has already that Mitchell was restricted by Hodgeson’s tactics so may not appear to be a wing back. However, he has always been able to put in a good cross, is having his best year for assists and is the top English tackler in the EPL and fourth overall (Premier League Player Stats). To me he always seems worried about getting caught out going too far forward but Glasner is working on that. He kept Salah quiet for the second successive match and was congratulated by him at the end. I think he deserves more respect, after all he is ‘one of our own’.

 

est1905 Flag 17 Apr 24 3.28pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Our form has been terrible this season and there's no hiding from that.
We've had to rely on Burnley and Sheffield United for more than a third of our points.
One great win against Liverpool can't mask that.
Hyperbolic reaction to one win seems a tad over the top.
Similarly Mitchell had his best game of the season and has an assist from Sunday.
This alone does not necessarily make him the answer to our left wing back position in Glasner's system.
Hopefully he will be, but it would seem prudent to observe more games before reaching such conclusion.
There, I've said it and managed not to insult any fellow fans.

What is over the top? What is (your pompous word) Hyperbolic about it?
Countless people on here were embarrassingly negative. For weeks. Despite obvious improvement under Glasner. I (as well as others) pointed out out form has little to do with stats and mostly to do with horrendous injuries to key players from the very first game (Doucoure) to now. Once we get our best players back I, in fact not only me but a few others felt the results will come but we all got written off as over optimistic and a load of stats thrown out about our recent form and (because of this) its apparently impossible to see where our next win is coming from.
Beating Liverpool was simply proof that stats mean nothing. They were only based upon a team that had half its first choice players out anyway.
We have issues to be addressed with the team of course we do. Thats Glasner's job to sort out as I am sure he will. But I personally dont see the need for all the doom and gloom and have every right to say so.
You claim you've sdaid your piece without offending anyone, dropping a big hint that you think I have. Please point out to me how I haver possibly offended anyone with anything I've said. In the grown up world we're still allowed to say what we think.....just

 

PatrickA Flag London 17 Apr 24 5.40pm


I think this response proves my point in a variety of ways and will leave it at that.


Originally posted by est1905

What is over the top? What is (your pompous word) Hyperbolic about it?
Countless people on here were embarrassingly negative. For weeks. Despite obvious improvement under Glasner. I (as well as others) pointed out out form has little to do with stats and mostly to do with horrendous injuries to key players from the very first game (Doucoure) to now. Once we get our best players back I, in fact not only me but a few others felt the results will come but we all got written off as over optimistic and a load of stats thrown out about our recent form and (because of this) its apparently impossible to see where our next win is coming from.
Beating Liverpool was simply proof that stats mean nothing. They were only based upon a team that had half its first choice players out anyway.
We have issues to be addressed with the team of course we do. Thats Glasner's job to sort out as I am sure he will. But I personally dont see the need for all the doom and gloom and have every right to say so.
You claim you've sdaid your piece without offending anyone, dropping a big hint that you think I have. Please point out to me how I haver possibly offended anyone with anything I've said. In the grown up world we're still allowed to say what we think.....just

 

peterg Flag Anerley 17 Apr 24 7.09pm

We were unlucky in three important matches

1 Bournemouth - goal ruled out for marginal offside in build-up.
2 Luton - last-second equaliser after we had numerous near-misses
3 Nottm For - hit post on 88mins with score at 1-1.

One of the players said Palace had not been getting the breaks. We got them big-time v Liverpool, and I feel they were well-deserved and overdue.

 


The right place at the right time

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 17 Apr 24 7.58pm

I'm not sure we've been unlucky.

But we have certainly deserved more points than we've got.

For me its a case of not being clinical. We could have put all those games to bed in the first halves

 

NJ CLOCKTOWER Flag Tarragona 20 Apr 24 5.37am

Originally posted by mileend

correct, it's an EFL penalty

[Link]

Does that mean that, if they did not get relegated they would not lose the two points until they did?

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Apr 24 6.49am

I think the punishment has been awarded on the basis of probability that Sheff Utd will go down either this season or next & the punishment will kick in at the start of their next season in the Championship.

Originally posted by NJ CLOCKTOWER

Does that mean that, if they did not get relegated they would not lose the two points until they did?

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton deducted two points