You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Olise, guehi,eddy
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Olise, guehi,eddy


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
dg1937 Flag 23 Apr 24 11.55pm

Palace can’t pick who he goes to. Team trigger the release clause, team only have to match it. The two teams then negotiate with him and he opts for the one that offers him the deal he likes best. Why would team (c) come in with a higher bid, they essentially only need to match the release clause to get into a negotiation with him, not with Palace? I accept I could have got this entirely wrong but that’s how it looks to me.

 

dg1937 Flag 23 Apr 24 11.57pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Palace can’t pick who he goes to. Team A trigger the release clause, team B only have to match it. The two teams then negotiate with him and he opts for the one that offers him the deal he likes best. Why would team C come in with a higher bid, they essentially only need to match the release clause to get into a negotiation with him, not with Palace? I accept I could have got this entirely wrong but that’s how it looks to me.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Apr 24 7.22am

Originally posted by dg1937

Palace can’t pick who he goes to. Team trigger the release clause, team only have to match it. The two teams then negotiate with him and he opts for the one that offers him the deal he likes best. Why would team (c) come in with a higher bid, they essentially only need to match the release clause to get into a negotiation with him, not with Palace? I accept I could have got this entirely wrong but that’s how it looks to me.

That's the downside to a release clause. The club is guaranteed a minimum transfer fee but as you said any bidding war will be between the player and the buying clubs, Palace will not be involved.

 


One more point

Teddy Eagle Flag 24 Apr 24 8.08am

Originally posted by Badger11

That's the downside to a release clause. The club is guaranteed a minimum transfer fee but as you said any bidding war will be between the player and the buying clubs, Palace will not be involved.

Release clauses only really affect clubs our size where keen young players probably wouldn't sign without one. Clubs in lower divisions can't insist on them because they need whatever fees they can get while the big boys have crazy sums built in (Ansu Fati has a 1 bn Euro release clause so he's unlikely to stay at Brighton).

 

Glazier#1 Flag 24 Apr 24 9.43am

Originally posted by dg1937

Oh, ok. I didn't realise that.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 24 Apr 24 10.12am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Selling is all well and good - if the replacements are as good or better and cheaper. If not, then it isn't worth it. Which is kind of a circular argument. I expect one or two agents to unsettled at least one of our stars in the summer.
Say Guehi, for example, he's been injured, Richards looks good. However, Guehi has been injured - might not go for what he would have done, and try to think of cheap, good central defenders. There are only a couple that fit the bill - and they'd have to want to come here.
Say Eze, possibly could replace with a couple of players but they're going to be high fees, likely high wages. I immediately think of maybe Gibbs White, maybe Gallagher - any cheaper, any better? Maybe Barkley? Perhaps worth a shout but I'd rather Eze.
I'm not sure you can get another Olise. He needs a very high fee. I guess I'd take young, exciting, quick. Perhaps a couple fit the bill.
Doucoure - probably needs to come back before there will be interest. Don't think you could do any better than Wharton to replace him. We're not buying Lavia.
I think Andersen will perhaps get offers - probably quite high ones. If we can get a young English replacement for the same value then perhaps - but it's a risk.
It's not as easy as it all sounds when you delve into it.
I guess to reverse this: think of who's young and already doing well in a high enough league. Then think if they would suit us - or even consider us (for instance no one from Real or Barcelona are on their way to Selhurst), then consider who we could sell to buy them and how much profit we would make. You can then wonder if it's worth it. For instance, I'd take Branthwaite from Everton but would it be worth selling Guehi or Andersen to buy him? It's not an easy decision. Colwill similar. And any of these could be well overpriced and frankly well overrated.

There are players in the championship that are quality that would be suitable to replace some that might go, imo, the Championship is probably the second most competitive league in Europe, possibly with the Bundesliga, the closest player, to Olise, i have watched who is in our price range is Morgan Whittaker, from Plymouth, but i suspect he would cost 20m+, and Jacob Greaves from Hull for CD replacement, Edouard is coming to his last season on his contract, so we try to sell him, not easy, or keep using him as Mateta back up, and let him leave on a free, imo, Johnstone, Olise and Guehi will all leave in the summer, i hope not.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Apr 24 10.58am

We've supposedly been after Ronnie Edwards for so long a restraining order might be imposed, so possibly he might come in if Guehi goes. Eduoard has failed to live up to expectations so I don't think he'd be hard to replace. It was a miracle we got Olise for what we paid and I can't see that happening again. I guess if he leaves we'll see just how good Dougie and his team are in finding a replacement. You would think they've been planning for it for a while given last summer.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 24 Apr 24 11.08am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

We've supposedly been after Ronnie Edwards for so long a restraining order might be imposed, so possibly he might come in if Guehi goes. Eduoard has failed to live up to expectations so I don't think he'd be hard to replace. It was a miracle we got Olise for what we paid and I can't see that happening again. I guess if he leaves we'll see just how good Dougie and his team are in finding a replacement. You would think they've been planning for it for a while given last summer.

Just based on securing Olise amongst a fair few others, tells me that Dougie and his team are hugely talented in that department. Add in Glasner and his German contacts and who knows what they will pull out the bag next.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Apr 24 11.40am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

There are players in the championship that are quality that would be suitable to replace some that might go, imo, the Championship is probably the second most competitive league in Europe, possibly with the Bundesliga, the closest player, to Olise, i have watched who is in our price range is Morgan Whittaker, from Plymouth, but i suspect he would cost 20m+, and Jacob Greaves from Hull for CD replacement, Edouard is coming to his last season on his contract, so we try to sell him, not easy, or keep using him as Mateta back up, and let him leave on a free, imo, Johnstone, Olise and Guehi will all leave in the summer, i hope not.

A couple of good shouts there. Whittaker and Greaves look good and would likely be lesser fees than who we sell. If we sell. Although, as stated, not entirely sure Olise is replaceable but maybe someone could do a good job without being world class.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rabbit-Tooth Flag London 24 Apr 24 11.46am

Jadon Philogene, Hull.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Apr 24 12.10pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Just based on securing Olise amongst a fair few others, tells me that Dougie and his team are hugely talented in that department. Add in Glasner and his German contacts and who knows what they will pull out the bag next.

The only caveat I would put on that is that Olise, Guehi, Eze and Wharton were already getting rave reviews. Can we keep getting readymade stars for such good fees? Possibly. Munoz is a sign that they can also cast their net into lesser known waters with success.

 

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 24 Apr 24 1.34pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The only caveat I would put on that is that Olise, Guehi, Eze and Wharton were already getting rave reviews. Can we keep getting readymade stars for such good fees? Possibly. Munoz is a sign that they can also cast their net into lesser known waters with success.

That's completely negating Dougies ability to persuade them to come to Palace. It's almost guaranteed we are not the only club in for these players.


I always find it odd how Dougies ability to acquire decent players at a good price, always comes with some stipulation that it's a piece of piss to do because they're "ready made" for the premier league when the reality is that no player who hasn't played in the premier league previously, will be a sure thing of being successful. Wharton even states how much of a step up the premier league is.


I think he's done a great job, on a budget and within the boundaries Palace are faced with.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 24 Apr 24 1.55pm

Originally posted by monkey

Johnstone

Munoz
Andersen
Guehi
Lerma
Mitchell

Doucoure
Wharton

Olise
Mateta
Eze

If we can keep hold of them and if they all stay fit we’ve got a really good side now, that’s without accounting for any new signings, but as we all know ‘if’ is the magic word

And that’s the problem - they won’t all be fit all the time and some will leave. Do you spend a £60m sale fee on an equivalentish replacement at £60m, knowing you’ll maintain the best-case standard, or do you spend on two players at £30m knowing you won’t be quite as good but you’ll limit the downside risk if one is injured.

 

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 24 Apr 24 2.01pm

I think Guehi would be the most sensible to sell if we have to. Brilliant player but we have others that can also do a good job. I'd love to have 1 full season with: Olise, Wharton, Eze, Mateta and Doucoure fit. That'd be incredible. Here's to hoping.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 24 Apr 24 2.12pm

Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1

That's completely negating Dougies ability to persuade them to come to Palace. It's almost guaranteed we are not the only club in for these players.


I always find it odd how Dougies ability to acquire decent players at a good price, always comes with some stipulation that it's a piece of piss to do because they're "ready made" for the premier league when the reality is that no player who hasn't played in the premier league previously, will be a sure thing of being successful. Wharton even states how much of a step up the premier league is.


I think he's done a great job, on a budget and within the boundaries Palace are faced with.

Absolutely spot on

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Pierre Flag Purley 24 Apr 24 3.33pm

Originally posted by monkey

Johnstone

Munoz
Andersen
Guehi
Lerma
Mitchell

Doucoure
Wharton

Olise
Mateta
Eze

If we can keep hold of them and if they all stay fit we’ve got a really good side now, that’s without accounting for any new signings, but as we all know ‘if’ is the magic word

I agree with most of this and maybe another season of Eze, Olise & Wharton at the club would be fantastic.
But also Richards needs to be retained as he is showing such good defensive qualities at the moment which is why I wouldn't be too bothered if Guehi was sold to release transfer funds and Edouard went as well as we need to bring in another good striker as well to share the load with Mateta and another defensive wing back as competition for Mitchell.
Also if Eze manages to squeeze back into Southgate's euro squad by the end of this season that would be a fantastic achievement and a great advert for playing at Palace as opposed to being lost in a squad somewhere at a top 6 club!

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 24 Apr 24 3.40pm

We are certainly going to sell at least 1 player and release some of those out of contract as we need to reduce wage bill and raise some capital for purchases.

Keeper can we afford both Henderson and Johnstone? If we get an offer we can't turn down I think 1 will go

Central Defender current First choice 3 Andersen, Guehi and Richards with a variety of backups none of whom have let us down. I think Tomkins will be released plus one or both of Clyne or Ward. I think if we get an offer for Holding he will go plus one of 3 current first choices if we get a very good offer. Geuhi seems obvious one but due to his current injury will anyone bid enough to tempt us and will Chelsea match it.

Wing Backs we need cover on right for Munoz and Replacement or backup on left for Mitchell. I also think Mitchell is a possible Sale

Central Midfield we have probably our strongest group Decoure has been injured and we missed him until Wharton arrived. We also have some good youth players in this area so could we sell one?
Will anyone bid on Decoure after injury ? Will we move Lerma or keep Riederweld for CD cover. Hughes contract is up but could he be kept as squad player allowing a youngster to get championship Loan?

Attacking midfield Olise is obvious mover but with his recent injuries will a Champions League club take risk? Man U or chelsea would but if rumours about release clause are true they can't meet it. I have a feeling he will stay another season to prove his fitness and get move he wants. Eze we will have to get astronomical offer to consider and I think he is happy so he won't push Backups Ayew and Ahamda.

Striker has Mateta improved enough to be number 1, Will anyone try to buy him ? Edouard has been a dissapointment so will we sell to release his wages ? I think Mateta will stay as as Number 1 or backup with us looking at other targets including those out of contract elsewhere

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Apr 24 3.44pm

Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1

That's completely negating Dougies ability to persuade them to come to Palace. It's almost guaranteed we are not the only club in for these players.


I always find it odd how Dougies ability to acquire decent players at a good price, always comes with some stipulation that it's a piece of piss to do because they're "ready made" for the premier league when the reality is that no player who hasn't played in the premier league previously, will be a sure thing of being successful. Wharton even states how much of a step up the premier league is.


I think he's done a great job, on a budget and within the boundaries Palace are faced with.

You've put words into my mouth; I think you'll find I've always talked up Dougie's dealings, much more so than most. My point was that there is not a constant production line of players like Olise and Eze in the Championship. Anyway, this is just pointless speculation to kill time between games and to take my mind off the real world!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 08 May 24 9.25am

Clickbait are saying that Chelsea would be prepared to give us Raheem Sterling as part of a deal to sign Olise.

Gee thanks Chelsea are there any crap players you want to offload on us? How about Bobby Tambling, oh yeah you did that one already.

And you can keep Broja his star is on the decline as he can't even break into the Fulham side.

In other news TFL are asking people to avoid congestion around Stamford Bridge where are large number of taxi drivers who are Chelsea fans have unexpectedly turned up. The club as denied this has anything to do with Raheem Sterling's proposed move to Crystal Palace.

 


One more point

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 08 May 24 9.28am

Originally posted by Badger11

Clickbait are saying that Chelsea would be prepared to give us Raheem Sterling as part of a deal to sign Olise.

Gee thanks Chelsea are there any crap players you want to offload on us? How about Bobby Tambling, oh yeah you did that one already.

And you can keep Broja his star is on the decline as he can't even break into the Fulham side.

In other news TFL are asking people to avoid congestion around Stamford Bridge where are large number of taxi drivers who are Chelsea fans have unexpectedly turned up. The club as denied this has anything to do with Raheem Sterling's proposed move to Crystal Palace.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Olise, guehi,eddy