This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Untrue. He wasn't arrested at all. I refer you to my previous post. Whether arrested or simply removed from the scene for failing to follow requests is beside the point. The guy was trying to provoke reactions which the police cannot permit. It’s their job to ensure peaceful protests remain peaceful.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
Can't see what all the fuss is about? He can do what he wants. If the police advise him and he ignores their advice let the cocky barsteward take the consequences. The "minority groups" seem to hold all the sway in our society nowadays. Somewhat unfortunately perhaps the police cannot allow that although I suspect some of the officers would like to. They are required to ensure the peace is kept and deal with behaviour that might threaten it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t use the BBS. That bit obviously didn't apply to you. Breach of the peace you mean? The point is, takes a deep breath, that a Jewish person should not have to be constrained from going where he pleases in Britain simply because a bunch of Leftist antisemites and Muslims decide they want to demonstrate every single weekend in our national capital. What would happen if he had done the same with a right wing march? What would the police have done? What would you say about it then? The Left is full of hypocrites and the Police are an instrument of political wokery.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
Can't see what all the fuss is about? He can do what he wants. If the police advise him and he ignores their advice let the cocky barsteward take the consequences. The "minority groups" seem to hold all the sway in our society nowadays. Ironic really considering the uk is 80% white.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That bit obviously didn't apply to you. Breach of the peace you mean? The point is, takes a deep breath, that a Jewish person should not have to be constrained from going where he pleases in Britain simply because a bunch of Leftist antisemites and Muslims decide they want to demonstrate every single weekend in our national capital. What would happen if he had done the same with a right wing march? What would the police have done? What would you say about it then? The Left is full of hypocrites and the Police are an instrument of political wokery. The point is that he, or anyone else of whatever religion or group they belong to, are not constrained from going anywhere they please. Just so long as they, and me and you, do so legally. He hasn’t been constrained by his Jewishness but by his actions. It’s completely irrelevant what the other party were protesting about. So long as they do it legally and peacefully then they are exercising their democratic right to express an opinion. If the police decide that someone is trying to disrupt them from exercising that right in a manner by which a breach of the peace might occur then they have no choice other than to act. If a peaceful right wing march took place, with legal banners, no promotion of hate speech or encouragement of violence, then anyone trying to disrupt it would deserve and get the same response from the police. The problem being, of course, that many right wing marches are neither peaceful nor legal.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The point is that he, or anyone else of whatever religion or group they belong to, are not constrained from going anywhere they please. Just so long as they, and me and you, do so legally. He hasn’t been constrained by his Jewishness but by his actions. It’s completely irrelevant what the other party were protesting about. So long as they do it legally and peacefully then they are exercising their democratic right to express an opinion. If the police decide that someone is trying to disrupt them from exercising that right in a manner by which a breach of the peace might occur then they have no choice other than to act. If a peaceful right wing march took place, with legal banners, no promotion of hate speech or encouragement of violence, then anyone trying to disrupt it would deserve and get the same response from the police. The problem being, of course, that many right wing marches are neither peaceful nor legal. What defines right wing. Is it holding the national flag or having a short haircut ? Edited by cryrst (24 Apr 2024 11.43pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The point is , if he was attacked by the pro-Palestinian mob it would have proved the weekly marches are not " peaceful " if you are of a different opinion. It's a peaceful mob only as long as you don't question what they are doing, which makes the Met look biased again. It was not about protecting him it was about protecting the image of the mob Edited by HKOwen (24 Apr 2024 11.32am) Every group will contain a mix of people. Some better at self restraint than others. It’s unreasonable to describe the marchers as a whole as a mob. The police have a duty to intervene whenever they believe a breach of the police is threatened and if someone is deliberately taking actions designed to provoke hot heads they will. Those seeking to divert attention away from the provocation by constant references to a group protesting about a humanitarian crisis and expressing concerns for innocent people caught up in a terrible situation aren’t thinking straight. Whilst anyone expressing any kind of support for a terrorist group like Hamas deserve condemnation those whose concern is entirely for the innocent do not. Those who attempt to provoke trouble are not helping anyone, or their cause.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The point is that he, or anyone else of whatever religion or group they belong to, are not constrained from going anywhere they please. Just so long as they, and me and you, do so legally. He hasn’t been constrained by his Jewishness but by his actions. It’s completely irrelevant what the other party were protesting about. So long as they do it legally and peacefully then they are exercising their democratic right to express an opinion. If the police decide that someone is trying to disrupt them from exercising that right in a manner by which a breach of the peace might occur then they have no choice other than to act. If a peaceful right wing march took place, with legal banners, no promotion of hate speech or encouragement of violence, then anyone trying to disrupt it would deserve and get the same response from the police. The problem being, of course, that many right wing marches are neither peaceful nor legal. Legally. So which part of wishing to go where you please in London is illegal? Do me a favour Wisbech. The police response to demonstrations is clearly selective. The patriotic White working class are now being treated like the enemy, and being Jewish clearly means that you have to go into hiding at weekends in London. This is the country you want? Heaven help us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
What defines right wing. Is it holding the national flag or having a short haircut ? Edited by cryrst (24 Apr 2024 11.43pm) The national flag has unfortunately been appropriated by some and is being hidden behind to justify xenophobia. So it depends on the circumstances whether it is indicative of a genuine sense of pride in our country or of a problematic attitude. The police will judge solely on behaviour and the law. If any protest/march is peaceful and doesn’t break the law then it will be accommodated. If others try to disrupt it they wil be challenged. Terrorists would be arrested. Antifa, or a legal right wing group, could march so long as they stay onside of the legal lines.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Legally. So which part of wishing to go where you please in London is illegal? Do me a favour Wisbech. The police response to demonstrations is clearly selective. The patriotic White working class are now being treated like the enemy, and being Jewish clearly means that you have to go into hiding at weekends in London. This is the country you want? Heaven help us. Everywhere is legal unless there have been restrictions, usually temporary because of specific events, in place. Restrictions designed to ensure safety for everyone. You cannot go in anyone’s private spaces though and if the police believe it’s necessary to define temporary no go areas so they can handle things safely then they must do so. That applies to everyone, whatever group they think they fit into. Some would describe the “patriotic white working class” in very different terms. No doubt Yaxley-Lennon feels he belongs there which says enough.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The national flag has unfortunately been appropriated by some and is being hidden behind to justify xenophobia. So it depends on the circumstances whether it is indicative of a genuine sense of pride in our country or of a problematic attitude. The police will judge solely on behaviour and the law. If any protest/march is peaceful and doesn’t break the law then it will be accommodated. If others try to disrupt it they wil be challenged. Terrorists would be arrested. Antifa, or a legal right wing group, could march so long as they stay onside of the legal lines. Having a fear of foreigners isn’t actually illegal. Preferring to be around your own isn’t racist. When the pro Hamas protesters block roads and spray buildings with paint. That is illegal. When was the last time the right did that?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That bit obviously didn't apply to you. Breach of the peace you mean? The point is, takes a deep breath, that a Jewish person should not have to be constrained from going where he pleases in Britain simply because a bunch of Leftist antisemites and Muslims decide they want to demonstrate every single weekend in our national capital. What would happen if he had done the same with a right wing march? What would the police have done? What would you say about it then? The Left is full of hypocrites and the Police are an instrument of political wokery. Who would have put these two words together a year ago? Antisemitism has been a trope of the right for longer than I've been around. And who and where are the "left" who are antisemitic? Are all leftists antisemites? What is a leftist? Am I? What's going on?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Who would have put these two words together a year ago? Antisemitism has been a trope of the right for longer than I've been around. And who and where are the "left" who are antisemitic? Are all leftists antisemites? What is a leftist? Am I? What's going on? Whatever it is it's been going on for longer than a year.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Having a fear of foreigners isn’t actually illegal. Preferring to be around your own isn’t racist. When the pro Hamas protesters block roads and spray buildings with paint. That is illegal. When was the last time the right did that? The suffix phobia is fear and loathing/aversion to. No illegality there unless I suppose you are in McMarxist Land
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Who would have put these two words together a year ago? Antisemitism has been a trope of the right for longer than I've been around. And who and where are the "left" who are antisemitic? Are all leftists antisemites? What is a leftist? Am I? What's going on? Leftist anti semites aka Jew haters were those who supported Corbyn. Starmer at least had the cajones to take on board the damning report and weed out some of the worst.There are still plenty in the SCG like led by Burgon. There are some on here who would still reject the revised definition of anti semitism adopted by Labour after the report. Edited by HKOwen (25 Apr 2024 10.19am)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Who would have put these two words together a year ago? Antisemitism has been a trope of the right for longer than I've been around. And who and where are the "left" who are antisemitic? Are all leftists antisemites? What is a leftist? Am I? What's going on? I was fully prepared to believe that claims of antisemitism in the Labour Party were politically motivated. However, the evidence based on recent events suggests that there is a trend of those clearly on the left of politics to be pro Muslim and anti Israel. In the current climate, I'd imagine that the patriotic right would be buddying up to the Jews of Britain whom I would guess would be seen as aligned to Western, and more importantly, British ideals.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Everywhere is legal unless there have been restrictions, usually temporary because of specific events, in place. Restrictions designed to ensure safety for everyone. You cannot go in anyone’s private spaces though and if the police believe it’s necessary to define temporary no go areas so they can handle things safely then they must do so. That applies to everyone, whatever group they think they fit into. Some would describe the “patriotic white working class” in very different terms. No doubt Yaxley-Lennon feels he belongs there which says enough. So you are saying that Jews can't go to London at the weekend because of 'restrictions'. Thank you Heir Wisbech. You spend your days in an imaginary struggle with right wing evil and yet you are happy to see the movements of Jews restricted so that Muslims can dominate our capital. You need to retire your wooden stake and crucifix and take up fishing. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (25 Apr 2024 10.55am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don’t use the BBS. A Jewish person can walk as freely as the next person. What no one can do is behave in a manner which the police believe could result in a breech of the peace. From House of Commons debate: Since 7 October, Auschwitz-Birkenau has been called an “embarrassment to humanity”. “Heil Hitler” has been shouted at Jewish students in the UK. Protests have included shouts to “burn the Jews” on the streets of London. The hats of Jewish men have been thrown off them in our capital, and menorahs have been attacked. We have seen threats from a professor to blow up the Jewish Labour Movement conference. University societies have championed “the resistance”, glorified Palestinian “martyrs” and denied the murder and rape of Israelis at Nova music festival. Synagogues have been targeted and threatened, Jewish schools have been attacked, and Jewish businesses have been vandalised. In Bristol, “Free Palestine” was shouted at visibly Jewish men walking to a Sabbath lunch. In Leeds, a Jewish university footballer was called a “big nose Jew” by a member of the opposing team. In Manchester, a Jewish school was sent a letter saying “warning your school is being targeted, No one is safe, no one should support killers, Palestine forever”. In London, the Wiener Holocaust Library, a great organisation named after Lord Finkelstein’s grandfather, who escaped the Nazis, had “Gaza” spray-painted on its sign. In my area of the west midlands, a swastika was painted on a bridge, and a curry house announced its full support of Hamas. I thank West Midlands police for its support over the last few days in dealing with localised incidents incredibly fast. That is by no means an exhaustive list; rather it is just a small insight to the Jewish experience in Britain over the last few months. Dr Dave Rich of the Community Security Trust describes antisemitism as a Across the UK, in the days following Hamas’s barbaric massacre on 7 October to 13 December, the Community Security Trust recorded 2,098 antisemitic incidents. That figure is expected to rise and 2023 is expected to be the year in which the highest ever number of antisemitic incidents was recorded in the UK. The figure of 2,098 dwarfed the 800 or so incidents recorded up until 7 October and was the highest ever number reported to the CST across any similar period, even during other conflicts in the middle east. To clarify, that is 2,098 incidents of antisemitism as a result of a massacre of innocent Jewish men, women and children in Israel. The impact of this is massive and should not be underestimated. [Nichola Richards MP, Hanzard 9 Jan 2024] Edited by georgenorman (25 Apr 2024 11.16am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.