You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Local Elections/Mayoral election 2024.
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Local Elections/Mayoral election 2024.


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 May 24 3.33pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Absolutely everything - services, bureaucracy, strikes, immigration, communal violence, crime, taxation, NHS, the weather, Palace's form, Wisbech's posts (hard to believe I know.)

Just taking a few of the more serious suggestions;

- Public Services - pretty much across the board public services are performing worse than under the previous Labour government

- NHS - performing far worse now than when the Tories took power, by pretty much every metric going

- Immigration - immigration rates are considerably higher now than when the Tories took power

- Tax - we currently have the highest tax burden since the 2nd world war, and certainly higher than when the Tories took power


There's not really any logic to the suggestion that these things will be worse under a Labour government, given they have all got considerably worse since Labour lost power. If Labour were so bad, we would have seen some sort of improvement over the decade+ that they have not been in power.


I've said many times I won't be voting for Starmer's Labour, but these sort of lazy tropes that somehow it's going to get worse than the worst government I've ever seen, don't really have any grounding in reality.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 03 May 24 3.42pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Just taking a few of the more serious suggestions;

- Public Services - pretty much across the board public services are performing worse than under the previous Labour government

- NHS - performing far worse now than when the Tories took power, by pretty much every metric going

- Immigration - immigration rates are considerably higher now than when the Tories took power

- Tax - we currently have the highest tax burden since the 2nd world war, and certainly higher than when the Tories took power

There's not really any logic to the suggestion that these things will be worse under a Labour government, given they have all got considerably worse since Labour lost power. If Labour were so bad, we would have seen some sort of improvement over the decade+ that they have not been in power.

I've said many times I won't be voting for Starmer's Labour, but these sort of lazy tropes that somehow it's going to get worse than the worst government I've ever seen, don't really have any grounding in reality.

I agree that all these things have been worse under the Tories, my view is that they will get even worse under Labour. This is largely due to the two parties being practically the same on all issues. Governments in general are incompetent, spendthrift, wasteful and inefficient. Labour general do more governing, so will be worse that even the Tories have been, especially as they will move us closer to the EU if not try to rejoin which would be truly disastrous as it would mean even more government.

Edited by georgenorman (03 May 2024 3.46pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 May 24 3.44pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I agree that all these things have been worse under the Tories, my view is that they will get even worse under Labour. This is largely due to the two parties being practically the same on all issues.

Fair enough.

I think some of them will improve narrowly but the bigger picture will remain bleak because, as you say, they are both signing from the same flawed hymn sheet.

A very-slightly shinier version of the same pile of s***.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 03 May 24 4.04pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

What do you foresee getting worst under Labour, given what a roaring success this current Government have been?

What have this government improved since the last Labour government?

I too feel that things will get worse under labour. They will select their targets for higher taxation and it will be those that they consider to be the 'rich' i.e. anyone they consider to be middle class or higher.

I believe that private pensions will be hit. The 25% tax free allowance will go. There may be a higher tax rate for private pension payments.

Income tax, the 40% tax rate will become 45%, the 45% will become 50% and the threshold lowered to 100K. They may even introduce a higher than that tax rate.

There may be a new indirect tax for income not earned under PAYE or self employment.

Car's will be hit with higher road tax for cars considered to be "ungreen" or that cost over a certain amount to buy.

All this whilst the cost of the welfare state will explode.......again.

In terms of what the tories did, that has conveniently been forgotten. Payments to people and businesses during covid. Payments to people and businesses during the energy crisis. Increases in the minimum wage. To name just a few.

But as they does not fit lets pretend it never happened.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 03 May 24 4.05pm

Originally posted by The groover

I too feel that things will get worse under labour. They will select their targets for higher taxation and it will be those that they consider to be the 'rich' i.e. anyone they consider to be middle class or higher.

I believe that private pensions will be hit. The 25% tax free allowance will go. There may be a higher tax rate for private pension payments.

Income tax, the 40% tax rate will become 45%, the 45% will become 50% and the threshold lowered to 100K. They may even introduce a higher than that tax rate.

There may be a new indirect tax for income not earned under PAYE or self employment.

Car's will be hit with higher road tax for cars considered to be "ungreen" or that cost over a certain amount to buy.

All this whilst the cost of the welfare state will explode.......again.

In terms of what the tories did, that has conveniently been forgotten. Payments to people and businesses during covid. Payments to people and businesses during the energy crisis. Increases in the minimum wage. To name just a few.

But as that does not fit lets pretend it never happened.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 May 24 4.15pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

What do you foresee getting worst under Labour, given what a roaring success this current Government have been?

What have this government improved since the last Labour government?

So how has your life changed under the tories ?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 May 24 4.21pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So how has your life changed under the tories ?

Off the top of my head; a complete void of public services despite high tax rates, can't get a doctor's appointment, can't get any medical treatment in any sort of reasonable time, mountains of student loan debt, my mortgage has gone through the roof, can barely afford to have kids due to childcare costs and we have a scandalously high cost of living across the board.

That enough?


 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 May 24 4.25pm

Originally posted by The groover

I too feel that things will get worse under labour. They will select their targets for higher taxation and it will be those that they consider to be the 'rich' i.e. anyone they consider to be middle class or higher.

I believe that private pensions will be hit. The 25% tax free allowance will go. There may be a higher tax rate for private pension payments.

Income tax, the 40% tax rate will become 45%, the 45% will become 50% and the threshold lowered to 100K. They may even introduce a higher than that tax rate.

There may be a new indirect tax for income not earned under PAYE or self employment.

Car's will be hit with higher road tax for cars considered to be "ungreen" or that cost over a certain amount to buy.

All this whilst the cost of the welfare state will explode.......again.

In terms of what the tories did, that has conveniently been forgotten. Payments to people and businesses during covid. Payments to people and businesses during the energy crisis. Increases in the minimum wage. To name just a few.

But as they does not fit lets pretend it never happened.

Again, we have a higher tax burden now than we did under the last Labour government.

If the grand sum of 13 year's work is a few handouts during crisis and an inevitable increase to the minimum wage, I'd suggest you are being very generous with your praise.

This is objectively one of the worst governments we've ever had, by just about any measure.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 May 24 4.28pm

Originally posted by cryrst

So how has your life changed under the tories ?

It’s been a hundred times better than it would’ve under a Labour government…as we are soon to find out!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 May 24 4.30pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I agree that all these things have been worse under the Tories, my view is that they will get even worse under Labour. This is largely due to the two parties being practically the same on all issues. Governments in general are incompetent, spendthrift, wasteful and inefficient. Labour general do more governing, so will be worse that even the Tories have been, especially as they will move us closer to the EU if not try to rejoin which would be truly disastrous as it would mean even more government.

Edited by georgenorman (03 May 2024 3.46pm)

Lib Dems maybe, but I would be stunned if any move towards the EU was anything other than wholly trade related. Starmer knows that an EU rejoin is political poison. At present he is just about dragging along a noisy and vociferous loony left in his potential centrist government. However, the left are so rabidly Brexit they make Rees Mogg look like a Europhile. A rejoin would cause internal mayhem.

I hope they move closer to free movement of labour, but you lefty protectionists abhor that.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 May 24 4.31pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

It’s been a hundred times better than it would’ve under a Labour government…as we are soon to find out!

Talk about a triumph of delusion over reality.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 May 24 4.33pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Talk about a triumph of delusion over reality.

The Tories could start executing family members and there's a sizeable percentage of British voters who would turn around and say "but can you imagine it was Labour?"

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 May 24 4.38pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Talk about a triumph of delusion over reality.

I’ve lived through many, many years of both administrations and I know personally which one has been by far the better.

I think you call it experience and certainly not delusion!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 03 May 24 4.38pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

The Tories could start executing family members and there's a sizeable percentage of British voters who would turn around and say "but can you imagine it was Labour?"

There's a reason why there have been very few socialist governments.

When you get a little older, you might get it.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 May 24 4.43pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

There's a reason why there have been very few socialist governments.

When you get a little older, you might get it.

Literally not one person here is talking about a ‘socialist government’.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 May 24 4.59pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Off the top of my head; a complete void of public services despite high tax rates, can't get a doctor's appointment, can't get any medical treatment in any sort of reasonable time, mountains of student loan debt, my mortgage has gone through the roof, can barely afford to have kids due to childcare costs and we have a scandalously high cost of living across the board.

That enough?


Doctors appointments have for years been difficult to get. I would think the fact, and it’s a known fact that new arrivals get preference has an effect.
The mortgage rate was the lowest ever for twelve years until recently. It was just bad luck you joined the market at the wrong time. Your student loan debt doesn’t impact your credit rating and isn’t started to be payed back until you hit 20 ish grand salary and then the payments are quite low. It also dies after 30 years no matter how much you owe. It should also enable you to achieve a higher earning power for life so will or should be beneficial depending what you studied. Tbh you shouldn’t consider kids if you can’t afford them but TIC you never will from my experience . Bite the bullet on that as the emotion will far outweigh the hard times. The cost of living is dropping and yes it is higher than it maybe should but when I was a kid the predictions of how today would be were cataclysmic. Public services are always rubbish for some and great for others. That is a lot to do with local councils and is a bit of a red herring in your list.

So under labour how is the above going to change?
You won’t have your loan wiped out, mortgage rates will no doubt go up sadly for you.
Kids will still be expensive and local councils will still be good for some and bad for others.

I’m trying not to be pedantic but I’ve lived under a labour hmg and it will be worse than now for workers and tax payers. Better for feckless and workshy.
Private companies will become worse due to the tax take for labour to fulfil their utopian socialist society. Don’t wish too hard as you may get what you wish for but freedom to actually choose a hmg is a good thing.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 03 May 24 5.44pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Literally not one person here is talking about a ‘socialist government’.

Would you welcome a socialist government? Which parties do you think would be socialist and what would their key policies be?

 

Matov Flag 03 May 24 6.28pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

The Tories could start executing family members and there's a sizeable percentage of British voters who would turn around and say "but can you imagine it was Labour?"

A valid point. My attitude to this, as in life, is that I much prefer dealing with people who want to spit in my face rather than stab me in the back.

Why I loathe the Conservatives far more than Labour. Labour detest so much of what I value but are at least open about this. That I can cope with.

Where as the Tories masquerade as promoting the kind of values I have yet have over seen entire swathes of that destroyed. The Tories disgust me.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

eaglesdare Flag 03 May 24 6.45pm

The looney leftie woke labour party can't even define what a woman is. That alone tells me all I need to know about how much worse they will be.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 03 May 24 7.57pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Again, we have a higher tax burden now than we did under the last Labour government.

If the grand sum of 13 year's work is a few handouts during crisis and an inevitable increase to the minimum wage, I'd suggest you are being very generous with your praise.

This is objectively one of the worst governments we've ever had, by just about any measure.

The Tories have been a shower but please don't forget that during COVID Labour demanded more money be dished out their COVID response was the same as the Tories only more so. I don't remember Starmer and Co demanding the government spend less.

 


One more point

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Local Elections/Mayoral election 2024.