You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bring back Roy
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bring back Roy


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
PatrickA Flag London 25 May 24 3.43pm

I think if anyone is watching the FA Cup final today it appears that Roy is coaching Manchester United.
Ten behind the ball, packed penalty area defensively and everybody in shape.
Thing is that today it is actually working!

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 25 May 24 4.23pm

Which is why we are still in the Premier thanks to Roy.

Edited by PZ Eagle (25 May 2024 5.19pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 25 May 24 5.08pm

Roy does deserve a proper goodbye.

People have been praising Glasner and so they should but we say if what Roy had he did not do well add in 2 new signings plus players returning from injury we performed.


Lets not forget Pardew & Viera had good spells at first.

Next season and the following will be the real tests.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 May 24 9.42pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

Roy does deserve a proper goodbye.

People have been praising Glasner and so they should but we say if what Roy had he did not do well add in 2 new signings plus players returning from injury we performed.


Lets not forget Pardew & Viera had good spells at first.

Next season and the following will be the real tests.

Let’s ask Mateta if he’d rather have Roy back. If Roy had the first team fit he’d just have ten different players behind the ball.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 May 24 7.21am

Originally posted by grumpymort

Roy does deserve a proper goodbye.

People have been praising Glasner and so they should but we say if what Roy had he did not do well add in 2 new signings plus players returning from injury we performed.


Lets not forget Pardew & Viera had good spells at first.

Next season and the following will be the real tests.

Roy would not have wanted Munoz and I believe (not ITK) that he wanted Kalvin Phillips not Wharton.
Roy does deserve a decent send off but let’s not pretend the team hasn’t improved , in particular in the fitness department and his coaching methods have been left behind.

 

YT Flag Oxford 26 May 24 7.46am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Let’s ask Mateta if he’d rather have Roy back. If Roy had the first team fit he’d just have ten different players behind the ball.

Calm down, dear! Where did grumpymort say Roy should come back? He merely said that the man deserves a proper goodbye. How can any Palace fan find issue with that?

Reading through his fat-fingers typing, he also speculates what OG would have done with the painfully thin, injury-ravaged squad that Roy was trying to manage, which surely is a fair point and we'll never know the answer. Incidentally and with obvious hindsight, RH got us to within 3 points of PL survival.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 26 May 24 8.05am

Originally posted by YT

Calm down, dear! Where did grumpymort say Roy should come back? He merely said that the man deserves a proper goodbye. How can any Palace fan find issue with that?

Reading through his fat-fingers typing, he also speculates what OG would have done with the painfully thin, injury-ravaged squad that Roy was trying to manage, which surely is a fair point and we'll never know the answer. Incidentally and with obvious hindsight, RH got us to within 3 points of PL survival.

Happy to give him a proper goodbye. Then hopefully we can all move on.

 

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 26 May 24 8.32am

Reading player interviews it is clear they are happier now with everything across the board. Also having Glasner gives us a chance to keep our best players.

Roy definitely deserves a good send off, he did a lot for this club over the years. Perhaps next season something can be arranged for one of the games. Glasner seems a very respectful man and spoke well of Roy on occasions, so to have the players, so seems it would suit the whole club. If Roy doesn’t want the attention then it will be great to see him as a special guest in the stands

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 May 24 8.47am

Move to nostalgia please mods, we have bigger fish to fry these days.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 26 May 24 1.44pm

Originally posted by rikz

Testimonial for ward in the summer, with palace playing a palace 11 managed by Roy.

I'd rather watch a Joel Ward Palace team managed by Roy Vs a Steve Coppell invitation team. Sir Steve would (I'm sure) happily share the applause with Roy.

Everyone wins.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 26 May 24 7.35pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Move to nostalgia please mods, we have bigger fish to fry these days.

It’s a fair shout Roy does deserve a send off - not only for what he did for us but in football management generally.

IMO - his last stint just showed how desperately he was out of touch with the modern game and tactics. It was season too far - should have stayed retired after the season before..!!

He’ll always be one of our own - but OG has proved just how much time had caught up with Roy in the end..!!

COYP

 

Jacey Flag 26 May 24 9.41pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

It’s a fair shout Roy does deserve a send off - not only for what he did for us but in football management generally.

IMO - his last stint just showed how desperately he was out of touch with the modern game and tactics. It was season too far - should have stayed retired after the season before..!!

He’ll always be one of our own - but OG has proved just how much time had caught up with Roy in the end..!!

COYP

Spot on!!

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 May 24 5.54am

I am of the opinion that CPFC will do something to thank Roy publicly (IDK anything) but my gut feeling would have been that we didnt do anything end of season because:

a) Maybe feelings were still a bit raw over the way he left

b) Maybe it was considered a time to plant OG front & centre stage given the tremendous end of season run we had, a kind of nod towards looking forward rather than back ?

If it was me I would see if there is any mileage in bringing Roy / Ray in for the next end of season award ceremony to present him / them with some form of gratitude / lifetime award thingy -

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 27 May 24 12.31pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I am of the opinion that CPFC will do something to thank Roy publicly (IDK anything) but my gut feeling would have been that we didnt do anything end of season because:

a) Maybe feelings were still a bit raw over the way he left

b) Maybe it was considered a time to plant OG front & centre stage given the tremendous end of season run we had, a kind of nod towards looking forward rather than back ?

If it was me I would see if there is any mileage in bringing Roy / Ray in for the next end of season award ceremony to present him / them with some form of gratitude / lifetime award thingy -

I agree there.

Alongside Jacey, I think Plaistow Eagle's post was 'spot on' too.

It feels as though Glasner may as well have arrived in a spaceship to take over from Roy, such is the distance between the approaches.

That said, keeping a club like ours in the top flight is no easy task. Roy achieved that for us and if we are/are ever going on to bigger and better things, he would have to be identified as delivering the platform on which that success was built.

He should be remembered and always welcomed back fondly. No, I do not desire his return in any management capacity but with Roy as a fan and servant of the club, that door should always be open and the invite extended to him.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 May 24 12.51pm

I have seen nothing official on this so it is just guess.

I still thjink OG was approached in the summer, Roy and Ray agreed to stand for just one last season. OG could then relax, assemble his coaching team, agree a deal at leisure while enjoying some critical down time before he dives straight back into the volcano... and then Roy's health took a tumble.

If true, Roy did not leave under a cloud. He left 4 months earlier than planned due to circumstances outside anyone's expectations or control.

As such, some sort of testimonial for them would be nice and appropriate if Roy and Ray are agreed to it.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 27 May 24 1.45pm

Roy and Ray do indeed fully deserve a 'proper Palace send off'
This is not to say that the board weren't heading rapidly towards a 'management situation' that would have required resolving one way or another.
However as Roy's illness seemed to logically solve that problem and pave the way for Oliver Glasner.
I hope when Joel Ward finishes playing at Palace he will be awarded a testimonial match and maybe Roy & Ray will be invited back to manage one of the teams ( Ray in shorts of course!), Maybe Sir Steve the other!
That I think would be a very fitting occasion to give them a 'job' as well as a 'Palace send off'

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 27 May 24 3.55pm

The Club gave Roy a send off after the match against Arsenal in 2021. I suspect even he would be embarrassed by a further send off given the success by Glasner in the team’s performance and the goal scoring feats of Mateta and Sorloth, both of whom he did his best to get rid of during his tenure.

For my part I am no fan of Roy ever since the way he refused to resign after the Iceland humiliation of our national team. He blamed the players then and has continued since with our first team, young players, referees and even us, the fans. Roy has presided over the worst home defeat and lowest number of goals in a season in our entire league history. Roy has not been a failure but I would describe his tenure as mediocre. With only 34 points required from 34 games to keep us out of relegation in his first season and 7 points out of 10 games after Vieira, I do not agree with the opinion that he ‘saved’ us. He rarely visited Selhurst after he left Croydon aged 18 and has been a welcome visitor at Craven Cottage (what an apt name) on a regular basis. He is Richmond Roy now.

I and many others have moved on and wish to expunge the memory of the turgid football we paid to watch.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 27 May 24 5.09pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

The Club gave Roy a send off after the match against Arsenal in 2021. I suspect even he would be embarrassed by a further send off given the success by Glasner in the team’s performance and the goal scoring feats of Mateta and Sorloth, both of whom he did his best to get rid of during his tenure.

For my part I am no fan of Roy ever since the way he refused to resign after the Iceland humiliation of our national team. He blamed the players then and has continued since with our first team, young players, referees and even us, the fans. Roy has presided over the worst home defeat and lowest number of goals in a season in our entire league history. Roy has not been a failure but I would describe his tenure as mediocre. With only 34 points required from 34 games to keep us out of relegation in his first season and 7 points out of 10 games after Vieira, I do not agree with the opinion that he ‘saved’ us. He rarely visited Selhurst after he left Croydon aged 18 and has been a welcome visitor at Craven Cottage (what an apt name) on a regular basis. He is Richmond Roy now.

I and many others have moved on and wish to expunge the memory of the turgid football we paid to watch.

i hate to admit you are right. But you are probably right.

Roy seemed to have little confidence in our players. And it engendered a panic 'park the bus' mentality. Turgid football. And almost zero attempts to take the game by the scruff of the neck.

We seemed to spend 95 minutes scared sh1.tless of the opposition, no matter how rubbish the opposition was.

I had always defended Roy on HOL, but am pleased to have been proven wrong. Our players are mustard.....Glasner is a top manager. Roy became a Dinosaur.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bring back Roy