This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by monkey
Yes apart from half a decent season and a goal in the cup final, he was a waste of space……I’m taking it you meant worst Seem to recall a heated debate when he played. He was an enigma. Complete disaster when he played but when he was injured we ALWAYS lost. I opined he operated as a glue that bonded the shape and enabled the others. I know, fetching a bit. There had to be a reason successive coaches always played him when fit.
|
|
|
Oh on topic jedinak and delaney offered best value. The worst value are players who's names I've forgotten and don't want to remember.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Seem to recall a heated debate when he played. He was an enigma. Complete disaster when he played but when he was injured we ALWAYS lost. I opined he operated as a glue that bonded the shape and enabled the others. I know, fetching a bit. There had to be a reason successive coaches always played him when fit. Some formations require a player that can run around aimlessly, pointing at random spots on the pitch. Punch was the best in the business.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Ismael. We paid £2.75m - not a huge sum even then (late-90s), but twice as much as we received when he left 9 months later. I beg to differ. It was a staggeringly high fee at the time. It remained our record fee paid for 14 years.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by palace_in_frogland
Some formations require a player that can run around aimlessly, pointing at random spots on the pitch. Punch was the best in the business. Good value then?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Seem to recall a heated debate when he played. He was an enigma. Complete disaster when he played but when he was injured we ALWAYS lost. I opined he operated as a glue that bonded the shape and enabled the others. I know, fetching a bit. There had to be a reason successive coaches always played him when fit. Sorry there's no way Puncheon can be described as a 'complete disaster when he played'. He was regularly our best player, particularly in the 13/14 and 14/15 seasons. He doesn't quite make a best signings list for me, but he shouldn't be anywhere near a worst either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Seem to recall a heated debate when he played. He was an enigma. Complete disaster when he played but when he was injured we ALWAYS lost. I opined he operated as a glue that bonded the shape and enabled the others. I know, fetching a bit. There had to be a reason successive coaches always played him when fit. I know he was popular with some, I think his important goals especially for Pulis and his cup final goal elevated him to better than what he actually was, but for me he was lazy and went missing in far too many games. But I’ll never forget that cup final goal, for just a few brief minutes,we thought he’d won us the cup
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Punch was a great and cheap (free?) signing who gave us some incredible memories and seemed to also be a fan. To put him among the worst is both absurd and despicable. Definitely one whose goals and contributions positively affected the history of the club. I suspect nobody was more disappointed than him at the form in which his career with us ended. But then again he had a long period under Pardew so that would ruin many a good footballer. I know that is harsh, he did give us some memorable moments I’ll give him that, especially one of the worst penalties I’ve ever seen
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I think Benteke suffered from playing under a succession of defensive managers and living off scraps. He was great under Allardyce. Look at the change in perspectives on Mateta. So much of it due to a shift on team mentality and approach. People hate Benteke. I'm definitely not one of them I think he also suffered from being lazy and wanting the ball on a plate for him all the time. Good strikers who go through a lean spell for whatever reason work hard for the team and try to make something happen, he was visibly lazy and for a big bloke he didn’t exactly attack the ball in the area.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Punch was a great and cheap (free?) signing who gave us some incredible memories and seemed to also be a fan. To put him among the worst is both absurd and despicable. Definitely one whose goals and contributions positively affected the history of the club. I suspect nobody was more disappointed than him at the form in which his career with us ended. But then again he had a long period under Pardew so that would ruin many a good footballer. Which meant this goal celebration was one of the most memorable Palace ever!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I think Benteke suffered from playing under a succession of defensive managers and living off scraps. He was great under Allardyce. Look at the change in perspectives on Mateta. So much of it due to a shift on team mentality and approach. People hate Benteke. I'm definitely not one of them I think it didn't help Benteke, but he was also incredibly wasteful with the chances he did get and had a crap work rate. Mateta, even when he wasn't scoring, was never overly wasteful or lazy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I loved Punchy, he was hit and miss but i will never forget his goal against Norwich, what it meant to him. Apart from that . . .
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Punch was a great and cheap (free?) signing who gave us some incredible memories and seemed to also be a fan. To put him among the worst is both absurd and despicable. Definitely one whose goals and contributions positively affected the history of the club. I suspect nobody was more disappointed than him at the form in which his career with us ended. But then again he had a long period under Pardew so that would ruin many a good footballer. Punch cost about £1m when we made his loan permanent. I see his career in 3 parts. First 2 to 3 years really good, scored some important goals and was a key player. The next couple of years he drifted further back and had less impact on games. Roy saw this and dropped him for Luka quite quickly and suddenly we looked more of a team. Finally the late ACL injury v Man City kept him out for a year and he was never the same player afterwards. So 2 good years, 2 average years and 2 years where he didn't feature. If Ward had stayed on his man (Mata) he may have scored the winner in the cup final for us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Benteke, i hated the ignorant, self important, lazy, talentless, waste of space, arrogant oaf. Pretty much sums him up for me as well, but I’ll add waste of money to your list, we must have paid that charlatan knocking on £36 million in wages in his time with us
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
Pretty much sums him up for me as well, but I’ll add waste of money to your list, we must have paid that charlatan knocking on £36 million in wages in his time with us
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.