You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace for England - Match Thread
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace for England - Match Thread


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
dreamwaverider Flag London 07 Jun 24 10.59pm

Originally posted by mileend

Half time analysis

Mainoo too far forward for the Iceland goal to have any chance of helping protect the defence against the counter attack

Southgate will be worried how open we were

Guehi was one of the better performances

Im really not sure Southgate knows what is going on. No system no plan. Just constantly trying out players.
We are so lucky to have got Glasner. He is exceptional especially after Roy.

 

mileend Flag East London 07 Jun 24 11.58pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Im really not sure Southgate knows what is going on. No system no plan. Just constantly trying out players.
We are so lucky to have got Glasner. He is exceptional especially after Roy.

I think his plan is to always have two disciplined central midfielders

But everyone hates that, as it means exciting forwards miss out

So he tried to follow the zeitgeist that as long as everyone is really talented attacking just pick a lot of attacking minded players and it will work out

It could. But it didn't.

Iceland really did us a favour by showing how easy it is to thwart that obvious strategy

Out of 26 players he has only picked one, and that was an out there kind of left field pick, that has a centre midfield discipline to the midfield art of passing, and defending but most critically of positional sense and their role within a team.

Basically he has boxed himself into a corner with his football beliefs and the squad that he has picked that he has only one solution. Which is Adam Wharton.

I fear he will go for Conor Gallagher instead. Who has other admirable qualities. But not ones that will work on this international stage to give any structure to England's play. Or Trent Alexander-Arnold who really has no natural gifts in the centre.

Basically Adam allows everyone else to look really good and do good things.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 08 Jun 24 12.48am

We’ve had a superb squad in recent tournaments that would have won them if Southgate hadn’t been the manager. The same problems have been shown in the last couple of matches where the build up is just too slow and allows the opposition to defend in numbers easily and have the odd breakaway to punish us as happened tonight. Bellingham coming in will help but sadly with Southgate as manager we will screw this competition up as well as with the past winnable ones. Our midfield is just to cautious and our passing not direct enough :-(

 

pssguy Flag 08 Jun 24 1.24am

Originally posted by mileend

I fear he will go for Conor Gallagher instead. Who has other admirable qualities. But not ones that will work on this international stage to give any structure to England's play. Or Trent Alexander-Arnold who really has no natural gifts in the centre.

Basically Adam allows everyone else to look really good and do good things.

We'll see. Southgate brought Alexander-Arnold on as a right back where he played OK, like he did when Wharton replaced him in that position against B & H and where he proved more effective than he had in midfield.
From this game, Mainoo played himself out of a starting role and although Gallagher performed well at the end of the season it was alongside the more defensively-minded Caicedo. Rice also looks to get forward on the ball but with Mainoo ahead of him Iceland (pop 377,689) were looking more likely team to score at the end of the game

Wharton may prove too inexperienced but with a shaky defence, I think the only way England have a hope of winning is if he is a starter

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 08 Jun 24 7.12am

Well that was rubbish but may have done our boys a favour. So many poor performances last night the longer it went on the better Wharton is looking.

Guehi did okay so will start not sure who with as they seem to falling like 9 pins.

Eze was ignored when he came on we kept punting the ball down the right.

Mainoo err no thanks, too negative.

Palmer showed he was lively but several times he hesitated when we needed a first time ball. There is a player there Kane needs to tell him just bloody shoot.

Gordon - Just rubbish.

I expect the team will look a lot different for the first game, it better had anyway.

Edited by Badger11 (08 Jun 2024 7.13am)

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 08 Jun 24 8.56am

We would have won last night if both Wharton and Eze had been on for at least half the game! Or, more truthfully, had a much better chance.

Wharton because he doesn’t always pass sideways but spots the runs that others miss. Eze because his close control and ability to run at defences disorganises them so gaps appear. We would also have lost possession more often as a consequence but that’s not always a bad thing. Forcing the opposition to move upfield can leave gaps behind so when possession is regained with aggressive pressing they can be exploited.

We have seen it ourselves these past months. Are we about to see it again?

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

palace chick Flag South Croydon 08 Jun 24 9.35am

I also thought it strange choosing Ramsdale who hasn’t played much over Henderson last night ? We should have 3 keepers that have played regularly lately in the squad. Henderson would have saved that shot last night and we would be moaning about a 0:0 rather than a defeat against poor opposition. We might even have won it rather than having to get back into it the match against a team that just had 11 behind the ball?

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 08 Jun 24 9.53am

Glorified training session really, no one wanted to put a foot in and get injured at this stage, even Southgate said that.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 08 Jun 24 9.57am

Originally posted by Badger11

Well that was rubbish but may have done our boys a favour. So many poor performances last night the longer it went on the better Wharton is looking.

Guehi did okay so will start not sure who with as they seem to falling like 9 pins.

Eze was ignored when he came on we kept punting the ball down the right.

Mainoo err no thanks, too negative.

Palmer showed he was lively but several times he hesitated when we needed a first time ball. There is a player there Kane needs to tell him just bloody shoot.

Gordon - Just rubbish.

I expect the team will look a lot different for the first game, it better had anyway.

Edited by Badger11 (08 Jun 2024 7.13am)

Not a massive difference, it’s only really Pickford and Bellingham to come in from that starting line up last night

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 08 Jun 24 4.44pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Well that was rubbish but may have done our boys a favour. So many poor performances last night the longer it went on the better Wharton is looking.

Guehi did okay so will start not sure who with as they seem to falling like 9 pins.

Eze was ignored when he came on we kept punting the ball down the right.

Mainoo err no thanks, too negative.

Palmer showed he was lively but several times he hesitated when we needed a first time ball. There is a player there Kane needs to tell him just bloody shoot.

Gordon - Just rubbish.

expect the team will look a lot different for the first game, it better had anyway.


Felt sorry for Eze. In both games he ran into space on the left and turned looking for the pass only to see it punted out to the right. Southall ahold do all possible to get Olise to play for England.

Eze, Olise and Wharton playing together would pull the strings !

Edited by Badger11 (08 Jun 2024 7.13am)

Edited by rob1969 (08 Jun 2024 4.45pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Jun 24 5.22pm

Originally posted by palace chick

We’ve had a superb squad in recent tournaments that would have won them if Southgate hadn’t been the manager. The same problems have been shown in the last couple of matches where the build up is just too slow and allows the opposition to defend in numbers easily and have the odd breakaway to punish us as happened tonight. Bellingham coming in will help but sadly with Southgate as manager we will screw this competition up as well as with the past winnable ones. Our midfield is just to cautious and our passing not direct enough :-(


It wasn't cautious enough last night either for the Iceland goal or several other chances they created. Last night saw 11 England players who didn't seem to have played together before.

 

mileend Flag East London 20 Jun 24 11.06pm

OK, it is getting weird now

But I humbly suggest that the only person in English football to fix the shambolic England football team's structure is Adam Wharton. Who was playing in the championship in January.

I didn't really too pay much attention to Mainoo, because he plays for the Man Utd and I don't bother to know anything about them, but apparently he's very good. Now my understanding from the Euro coverage is that he used to be a striker, loved futsal, and dropped back to midfield to get more of the ball. So, given a decent goal return, it's safe to say he is a very attacking midfielder. That is why he likes playing with Declan Rice, because as he says he can go forward and leave Declan to cover behind.

Totally wrong.

We need Rice going forward like he does for Arsenal.

Conor Gallagher - no big explanation. As Palace fans we know he likes to get forward, press and grab a goal or too. He does not have any midfield discipline or short, direct, simple and FAST passing we need in midfield to give the structure and give the super stars up fron the ball quickly in good positions before they are marked.

TAA - that fantasy is now surely a totally busted flush. A dream that didn't happen. Not a central midfielder. Not ever.

No Jordan Henderson, thank god, no Phillips, promising for a while ,but, thank god.

There is only one choice. Adam Wharton. Is it a risk, given his inexperience? Yes, but the other option is a 100% certainly of going out in the last 16 against Germany or last 8 against someone else by keeping it as it is.

Ok, I accept there is another choice. Play Bellingham instead of TAA in central midfield and Foden as No. 10. That is what will probably happen and Gordon on the left.

 

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 20 Jun 24 11.30pm

Eze didn’t do himself any favours for last 15 mins. He looks lost and half asleep. I appreciate he didn’t get many passes or chances but you look at him and he seems blaaaaaah. Gordon will now get the nod.

 

mileend Flag East London 20 Jun 24 11.43pm

Originally posted by XKudu

Eze didn’t do himself any favours for last 15 mins. He looks lost and half asleep. I appreciate he didn’t get many passes or chances but you look at him and he seems blaaaaaah. Gordon will now get the nod.

Agreed. He was caught on the ball several times and seemed totally at a loss about his position or the pace of the game (at least Denmark's pace - perhaps he was trying to fit in with England's pedestrian tortoise pace). He won't be first choice after that. If Southgate wants to freshen it up then Wharton and Gordon are yet to be tainted by the dismal performances we have seen.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 20 Jun 24 11.44pm

Originally posted by XKudu

Eze didn’t do himself any favours for last 15 mins. He looks lost and half asleep. I appreciate he didn’t get many passes or chances but you look at him and he seems blaaaaaah. Gordon will now get the nod.

Agreed

 

mileend Flag East London 20 Jun 24 11.54pm

here is the guardian piece about the midfield

[Link]

it's like everyone knows the answer but is too embarrassed to say 'he must pick Wharton'

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 21 Jun 24 6.42am

Originally posted by mileend

Agreed. He was caught on the ball several times and seemed totally at a loss about his position or the pace of the game (at least Denmark's pace - perhaps he was trying to fit in with England's pedestrian tortoise pace). He won't be first choice after that. If Southgate wants to freshen it up then Wharton and Gordon are yet to be tainted by the dismal performances we have seen.

I have said before that Eze is great with Olise. I am more convinced than ever that if he leaves then the Eze we saw last night for England will be what people see. He seems to have found a place at palace and for his sake I would stay. He flourished under Roy and again under OG but was not great under PV.

As for England… I was screaming for Wharton. But possibly under Roy Southgate it could ruin him. But as it’s our country… stick him in and watch the team suddenly find rhythm and class.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Jun 24 7.39am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I have said before that Eze is great with Olise. I am more convinced than ever that if he leaves then the Eze we saw last night for England will be what people see. He seems to have found a place at palace and for his sake I would stay. He flourished under Roy and again under OG but was not great under PV.

As for England… I was screaming for Wharton. But possibly under Roy Southgate it could ruin him. But as it’s our country… stick him in and watch the team suddenly find rhythm and class.

Wharton got 10 minutes in one of our pre tournament friendlies. He was superb. 100% pass accuracy. Really noticed by everyone.
What does Southgate do? Nothing. We haven't even heard about him again.
Managers moods in interviews always seems to translate into team performance.
Look at Glasner, Guardiola, Klopp and then Roy and Southgate. Chalk and cheese.
Southgate has become a nervous wreck. In interview, he has developed a forehead twitch. He is nervous, unsure and muddled. He talks as though he is trying to convince the world he knows what he is doing. Hasn't got a clue. Never has had.
He has got a great bunch of players who he simply cannot mould because he doesn't know how to.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 21 Jun 24 8.03am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Wharton got 10 minutes in one of our pre tournament friendlies. He was superb. 100% pass accuracy. Really noticed by everyone.
What does Southgate do? Nothing. We haven't even heard about him again.
Managers moods in interviews always seems to translate into team performance.
Look at Glasner, Guardiola, Klopp and then Roy and Southgate. Chalk and cheese.
Southgate has become a nervous wreck. In interview, he has developed a forehead twitch. He is nervous, unsure and muddled. He talks as though he is trying to convince the world he knows what he is doing. Hasn't got a clue. Never has had.
He has got a great bunch of players who he simply cannot mould because he doesn't know how to.

Too true. Thank god we didn’t get him as our manager

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 21 Jun 24 8.14am

Originally posted by XKudu

Eze didn’t do himself any favours for last 15 mins. He looks lost and half asleep. I appreciate he didn’t get many passes or chances but you look at him and he seems blaaaaaah. Gordon will now get the nod.


Yes, Eze looked like little boy lost but then he's not a wide player. He performs best as a no 10 and England have enough of those. Southgate has to play Gordon out wide - the only natural left winger (to use that increasingly old-fashioned term) in the squad.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace for England - Match Thread