You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I thought we were not a selling club anymore?
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I thought we were not a selling club anymore?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Jun 24 2.00pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It’s not clubs that want release clauses it’s the players that want them, if the club says no to the players who want them, they will stay then go for free, I thought the whole idea in any business, including football is, buy small, sell big

Indeed, it's so the club can't control them and has to let them go. No club is going to force a release clause on a player but might entice a player to sign by offering one. In that case, the club needs to make it as high as possible - as high as the player will accept and ensures the agent gets a big fee.
Olise clearly insisted on this.

 


Red and Blue Army!

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 28 Jun 24 3.41pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


He is worth more to us on the field than money in the bank.

With a defence of:

Riad - Andersen - Richards

and a supporting cast of Holding, Lerma, Ward, Clyne (I think I've forgotten someone too)

and no suitable cover for either wing back ... not sure. I think many on here would say we could use ~£60m elsewhere in the team.

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Whatever he loses in value this season, would probably be what we would pay to replace him.

That logic only really stands if the club replaces him with a ~£30m signing on a 1 year contract.

Keep Guehi:

2024: £60m value
2025: Sell for £30m, spend £30m

Net Zero

Sell Guehi

2024: Sell £60m, spend £30m = club is up +£30m
2025: Club is £30m up, plus whatever additional value the new signing(s) has acquired.

Selling him now vs next year is a decision worth roughly what we spent on Munoz and Wharton combined. It's not trivial.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Jun 24 3.58pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

That logic only really stands if the club replaces him with a ~£30m signing on a 1 year contract.

Keep Guehi:

2024: £60m value
2025: Sell for £30m, spend £30m

Net Zero

Sell Guehi

2024: Sell £60m, spend £30m = club is up +£30m
2025: Club is £30m up, plus whatever additional value the new signing(s) has acquired.

Selling him now vs next year is a decision worth roughly what we spent on Munoz and Wharton combined. It's not trivial.

So you are yet another modern football fan who seems to care more about bank balances than football.

We have just signed a new centre half so along with Richards, we have 4 quality players along with Clyne and Ward, making 6, to play in a back 3.
We do need cover for Mitchell but that's hardly a reason to sell Guehi.

It amazes me that fans are so happy to see some of the best players we have ever had at the club just walk away with a wish you good luck.

The club will live and die by its performances on the pitch. That is what fans pay to see and that is what keeps us in the top division.
Top players at low prices will not always be available, and our ability to sign quality depends more on the club's ambition than money in the bank.

We are not a top six club.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (28 Jun 2024 3.58pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 28 Jun 24 4.20pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

That logic only really stands if the club replaces him with a ~£30m signing on a 1 year contract.

Keep Guehi:

2024: £60m value
2025: Sell for £30m, spend £30m

Net Zero

Sell Guehi

2024: Sell £60m, spend £30m = club is up +£30m
2025: Club is £30m up, plus whatever additional value the new signing(s) has acquired.

Selling him now vs next year is a decision worth roughly what we spent on Munoz and Wharton combined. It's not trivial.

A good analysis.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 28 Jun 24 4.27pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

If you are a club that inserts release clauses into your players’ contracts you are an actively selling club.
Think of a shop window with a price on a piece of merchandise.
If you want the merchandise ,and can afford it, you go and purchase it.

The argument in favour of the clauses is that the club can protect it’s investment and incentivise the better players to sign up with us through these clauses, with the players knowing we won’t stand in their way.

I can understand this argument to a degree, but for me it’s more like a case of the cart driving the horse.
The players pick and choose their clubs at times that suit them and the clubs that supposedly manage them forego their right to control their resources.
Five year contracts , with release clauses, become largely redundant.

If this seems an exaggeration does anybody seriously believe that Palace want to lose Olise this summer (with perhaps more to follow)?

That's the nature of the relationship between talented players and clubs - the player holds all the leverage in the negotiation... if they don't like what you're offering, they will nearly always have other options, particularly if they're as good as Olise is.

There are more clubs willing to pay Olise lots of money than there are 'signable' players as good as Olise, and so he holds the cards.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 28 Jun 24 4.28pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

So you are yet another modern football fan who seems to care more about bank balances than football.

We have just signed a new centre half so along with Richards, we have 4 quality players along with Clyne and Ward, making 6, to play in a back 3.
We do need cover for Mitchell but that's hardly a reason to sell Guehi.

It amazes me that fans are so happy to see some of the best players we have ever had at the club just walk away with a wish you good luck.

The club will live and die by its performances on the pitch. That is what fans pay to see and that is what keeps us in the top division.
Top players at low prices will not always be available, and our ability to sign quality depends more on the club's ambition than money in the bank.

We are not a top six club.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (28 Jun 2024 3.58pm)

The two are strongly correlated.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (28 Jun 2024 4.28pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 28 Jun 24 4.49pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

So you are yet another modern football fan who seems to care more about bank balances than football.

We have just signed a new centre half so along with Richards, we have 4 quality players along with Clyne and Ward, making 6, to play in a back 3.
We do need cover for Mitchell but that's hardly a reason to sell Guehi.

It amazes me that fans are so happy to see some of the best players we have ever had at the club just walk away with a wish you good luck.

The club will live and die by its performances on the pitch. That is what fans pay to see and that is what keeps us in the top division.
Top players at low prices will not always be available, and our ability to sign quality depends more on the club's ambition than money in the bank.

We are not a top six club.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (28 Jun 2024 3.58pm)

Yup, go with this. Seems certain posters on here have conveniently forgotten the 'elephant' in the room . . . The Agent.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

HeathMan Flag Purley 28 Jun 24 6.49pm

Lower level clubs, in my opinion, tend to be classified as "feeder" or "selling" clubs. Happy that we are the latter. Imagine a feeder link to Manchester City - Join Palace and if you are good enough you will end up in Manchester. Wilf did not enjoy his time at Man U, and AWB - who came through at the same time as Alexander-Arnold seems to have stagnated, whereas Michael Olise has demonstrated that he is good enough to join Harry Kane in Munich. I doubt if there are any better incentives (apart from playing with two Columbian Internationals) for joining Palace. Looking forward to many treasures joining the Palace Academy.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Jun 24 7.11pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

The two are strongly correlated.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (28 Jun 2024 4.28pm)

I never saw a bank statement score a hat trick.

It wouldn't matter if we had the spending freedom of a top four club. Unless we qualify for the Champions League or win something, no top players will come to Palace. We have previously got our talent from lower leagues but have recently become more attractive through 10 years in the Premier League.

If we continue to sell our best players, all the money in the world will not prevent us from remaining in mediocrity.

 

YT Flag Oxford 28 Jun 24 7.29pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

If we had wanted to keep Olise, I'm sure a big pay rise would have done it. The trouble is that if you have one player on £200k and the others on far less, there is an obvious issue with players wanting pay rises, not to mention the immediate impact on the wages budget.

In this case, the release clause was the problem. It was low because of Olise's rapid rise in profile. Had he been so sought after last season, I'm sure the clause would have been far higher.

Any other players under contract without release clauses cannot leave unless we allow them to. Having lost a star player, I'm sure the board would not sanction another sale unless the money offered was off the scale.

I hope Eze has no desire to leave or has some silly release clause, because the fans of this club deserve better.

They have endured enough mediocrity.

It always makes me laugh when this opinion gets recycled. Why do the fans of this club or of any other club for that matter deserve anything at all and why? Taking HOL as an example, hardly any of us actually pays any money to be fans. Suffering a string of poor performances on illegal streams entitles you to nothing whatsoever.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 28 Jun 24 7.33pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

So you are yet another modern football fan who seems to care more about bank balances than football.

We have just signed a new centre half so along with Richards, we have 4 quality players along with Clyne and Ward, making 6, to play in a back 3.
We do need cover for Mitchell but that's hardly a reason to sell Guehi.

It amazes me that fans are so happy to see some of the best players we have ever had at the club just walk away with a wish you good luck.

The club will live and die by its performances on the pitch. That is what fans pay to see and that is what keeps us in the top division.
Top players at low prices will not always be available, and our ability to sign quality depends more on the club's ambition than money in the bank.

We are not a top six club.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (28 Jun 2024 3.58pm)

They are just being realistic about how football works.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 28 Jun 24 8.32pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I never saw a bank statement score a hat trick.

It wouldn't matter if we had the spending freedom of a top four club. Unless we qualify for the Champions League or win something, no top players will come to Palace. We have previously got our talent from lower leagues but have recently become more attractive through 10 years in the Premier League.

If we continue to sell our best players, all the money in the world will not prevent us from remaining in mediocrity.

I’ve never seen a manager score one either, but I’m sure we would all agree they’re quite important.

Top players already come to Palace and other non champions league clubs.

There are many examples of ‘all the money in the world’ getting clubs out of mediocrity.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 29 Jun 24 12.11am

We are not a selling club.... but this stadium won't be put up for free..

 


This was once a quality forum....

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 29 Jun 24 7.58am

Every club is a selling club, it’s all about timing and how you manage a player to get the best potential from them in the limited time of their careers. We happen to be in a purple patch at the moment with the quality of player we have.

The last thing we need is to sell too many players in one go which we have been guilty of before and it cost us our top flight status. I’m sure this won’t happen in this instance, but it is annoying that a player can be contacted under contract, get their heads turned then all the shenanigans over what they want to pay for the player.

Will be glad when this transfer window closes, it’s the uncertainty with what team we will have come the 17th August….

Edited by Gary St.Andrews (29 Jun 2024 7.59am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 29 Jun 24 8.01am

Should have another player on the payroll on Monday. Japanese fellah.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Jun 24 8.14am

Originally posted by YT

It always makes me laugh when this opinion gets recycled. Why do the fans of this club or of any other club for that matter deserve anything at all and why? Taking HOL as an example, hardly any of us actually pays any money to be fans. Suffering a string of poor performances on illegal streams entitles you to nothing whatsoever.

Very clever, but short sighted.

I bought a football shirt for my grandson last week, like I do every season.
Perhaps I should encourage him to support a club with more ambition?

Those that pay for season tickets certainly deserve better, and the club also needs to attract fans for the future.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Jun 24 8.17am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I’ve never seen a manager score one either, but I’m sure we would all agree they’re quite important.

Top players already come to Palace and other non champions league clubs.

There are many examples of ‘all the money in the world’ getting clubs out of mediocrity.

If you are happy to see some of the best players we have ever had walk out the door than I wish you all the luck.

 

highbury eagle Flag Islington 29 Jun 24 8.07pm

If we were to increase the season ticket price by 400% we would be able to generate additional funds equivalent to the sale of Olise. I'm sure everyone would be willing to make the sacrifice.

Edited by highbury eagle (29 Jun 2024 8.07pm)

 


Life is the same as it always will be,
Easy as picking foxes from a tree.
M Bolan

rikz Flag Croydon 29 Jun 24 8.35pm

We get 25k in a terrible stadium, we've never won a major honour and have never played in Europe. What would make anyone think we're not a selling club.

 

Aray Flag South London 30 Jun 24 2.34pm

Pay attention at the back. Of course we're a selling club. This is a good thing. The explicit strategy is to buy younger players that have resell value. Not being a selling club, as we were, is financially crippling. Yes its heartbreaking to see an Olise leave but would you prefer to buy a 31-year old looking for his final big payday and who limps out at the end of his contract?

If the money goes towards the new stand - great! If it goes entirely back to strengthen
the squad - great! I don't think Parish is Noades - we'll be replacing any departures. I think we already have with Olise.

Future's bright under Glasner. Cant wait for the season to start.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I thought we were not a selling club anymore?