This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Rak-Sakyi Loan
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Goalpost1 Worcester Park 23 Jul 24 11.33am |
|
|
I think a £12m deal plus a percentage sell on and it'd be good business for where he is currently. True he could have a brilliant season at Saints but equally he might not, especially when you consider they are likely to be amongst the relegation candidates.
|
MFW94 Sutton 23 Jul 24 12.43pm |
|
|
the biggest thing I always noticed was Olise and Jes are the same age and were miles apart in quality.
10+ mill for someone whose only ever really played at League One level .
Shame for Jes, injuries last season did no favours.
Of course if goes to Southampton and scores double figures and is a superstar, we should exercise a buy back clause.
Personally would rather him go on loan for a season in the championship and potentially drive up his value or come back a better player (philogene at Villa is a prime example of this they got him back)
|
Putitout Oxford 23 Jul 24 2.06pm |
|
Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE
Sky reporting he wants to leave, the saints are willing to increase offer as he is keen to play under Martin?
Edited by DANGERCLOSE (23 Jul 2024 11.12am)
It would be no surprise if he wanted to leave. He should want to play at a good level.As things stand his opportunities are still limited at Palace. The same thing applied to O’Brian,. If Southampton, offer more game time than he is getting ,maybe more money, why would he not be up for it? A loan would suit Palace, but if that’s enough for the player, could be the biggest question here.
|
est1905 23 Jul 24 4.43pm |
|
|
I think he only wants to leave because Southampton are offering a season in the Premier League whereas Glasner has probably already told him the most he can currently hope for at Palace is a place on the bench. Southampton are said to either want to buy him or a season long loan with an option to buy (fee agreed now) For me thats just stupid business. We could agree to £10m and then he tears it up this season and we end up losing him for a lot less than we could get. I think we have nothing to lose by letting him go on a season long loan and even give Southampton an option to buy at the end BUT we decide how much we want for him at the end of the season based on his performances for them on loan. They'll try and argue its their coaches who have improved him. Palace will argue back we dont really care. He's our player we'll charge what we want.
|
viveasheagle perth 28 Jul 24 2.09am |
|
|
He has started pre-season on fire. I think the gap between him and Olise is now a lot closer. I think he is staking a proper claim for a starting role.
|
radicalsteve ottawa 28 Jul 24 8.43pm |
|
|
He missed a whole season of experience because of Roy/injury. In pre-season he looks to have the potential to be the real deal, great individual goal yesterday and he tracks back. When Olise first started playing for us he was quite raw at times and poor in tracking back, notwithstanding it was clear he had stuff in his locker that others only dream about. This is an interesting situation for Olie assuming we sign Saar. I would put him above Ayew, Edouard and Schlupp as it stands, so why would we sell him?
|
taylors lovechild 29 Jul 24 9.18am |
|
|
I don't think JRS is in the same bracket as Olise. I would love to see him push on and make it for us, but my gut feeling is he'll end up being a solid Championship-level winger, or possibly a squad player for a bottom-half PL team. If we do sign Sarr then I'd take the £12 million Southampton are rumoured to have offered with a sell-on clause in case he does make it to a higher level. Hopefully he proves me wrong though and becomes a star for us.
|
Badger11 Beckenham 31 Jul 24 10.47am |
|
|
Terrible click bait reporting.
[Link]
They don't mention he was out injured for a large part of the season.
It looks like he does want to leave which is a pity but these days players all have the power.
One more point
|
eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 31 Jul 24 11.26am |
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Terrible click bait reporting.
[Link]
They don't mention he was out injured for a large part of the season.
It looks like he does want to leave which is a pity but these days players all have the power.
Not surprised with that Widnes based website, awful. He's not gone with the squad to the States, agree with you, looks like he's off, pity.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
|
Palace in the Blood 31 Jul 24 11.31am |
|
|
I think people misunderstood my original post and I agree with a lot people are saying. He is not ready for EPL with us so it is in everybody's interest that he leaves on loan to see how he does. The question is where championship or Southampton? Secondly how do we protect our asset and get best return. In my view this may be to Southampton as they will play in EPL. This gives us best indication if he will make it however it may be a step too far too quickly. Let him make decision its his career. If he goes to championship there is likely to be no option to buy. Southampton seem to want an option to buy. My logic is Southampton are likely to be relegation contenders. So my original post suggested an obligation to buy at a high figure if they were not. Even if they survive this season they may still be relegation contenders for a couple of seasons so it makes sense to me to have a return route if we want if this were to happen. This protects both us and player. Southampton meanwhile will have to think seriously about the potential cost - purchase then subsequent relegation. This may dampen their interest but will avoid unsettling him further
Edited by Palace in the Blood (31 Jul 2024 11.33am)
|
eaglesdare 31 Jul 24 11.34am |
|
|
Maybe we will learn from the Jake obrien saga. Loan or have a buy back clause.
|
eritheagle Erith 31 Jul 24 11.41am |
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Maybe we will learn from the Jake obrien saga. Loan or have a buy back clause.
I think maybe Textor had a hand in the deal for him to go Everton.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 31 Jul 24 11.50am |
|
|
This should be the first time a club refers one of its own transfers to the Premier League for investigation. Dodgy doesn't cover this.
Red and Blue Army!
|
eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 31 Jul 24 12.14pm |
|
|
Well, he would do, he is the owner of Lyon.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
|
PatrickA London 31 Jul 24 12.17pm |
|
|
From JRS's perspective we have brought in potentailly 2 players in Kamada and probably Sarr who are more likely to occupy Olise's old position. Why stay to be third choice? Reading between the lines Palace want to loan him to a Championship club, whereas JRS sees an immediate route to Premier League football with Southampton. It will be interesting to see how it plays out, in particular with JRS not going on the tour.
|
Stirlingsays 31 Jul 24 12.21pm |
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I don't think JRS is in the same bracket as Olise. I would love to see him push on and make it for us, but my gut feeling is he'll end up being a solid Championship-level winger, or possibly a squad player for a bottom-half PL team. If we do sign Sarr then I'd take the £12 million Southampton are rumoured to have offered with a sell-on clause in case he does make it to a higher level. Hopefully he proves me wrong though and becomes a star for us.
I know what you mean but I think he's better than the Championship and does make it.
I think the only doubts about him are physical and that's solvable via aging and the gym. My prediction is that this guy will be a regular Premiership player, it's just which club it's with.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 31 Jul 24 12.43pm |
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I know what you mean but I think he's better than the Championship and does make it.
I think the only doubts about him are physical and that's solvable via aging and the gym. My prediction is that this guy will be a regular Premiership player, it's just which club it's with.
I tend to agree. I know plenty of others do too. Obviously Southampton too - and, let's face it, they've been far, far better than us with young talent. Southampton sniffing around should really give us quite a big clue.
Red and Blue Army!
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jul 24 1.56pm |
|
|
I believe JRS has 3 years left on his contract. He seems to want PL football now but has either been told or believes he's down the pecking order at Palace.
The fact that he hasn't travelled to the States could mean he's going to be sold but equally it could simply mean that he has been earmarked for a loan out and it's therefore pointless including him in further friendlies.
I suspect (just my opinion) that he wants out permanently to Southampton where he may have been told he'll be a regular starter.
If he does want out, then as long as the fee is at least the £12m touted on the click bait sites and there's a decent sell-on clause then goodbye and we move on.
|
taylors lovechild 31 Jul 24 3.05pm |
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I know what you mean but I think he's better than the Championship and does make it.
I think the only doubts about him are physical and that's solvable via aging and the gym. My prediction is that this guy will be a regular Premiership player, it's just which club it's with.
If he stays then I hope you're right. My issue is partly his physicality, but he also seems to be on the periphery a lot of the time. He is a very composed finisher, which is a big positive and he looked great in League One at times. It is always so hard to see which way it will go with wingers as so many show promise and then flop. My view is probably unfair as with us it's largely based on friendlies and a handful of cameos.
|
Stirlingsays 31 Jul 24 3.12pm |
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
If he stays then I hope you're right. My issue is partly his physicality, but he also seems to be on the periphery a lot of the time. He is a very composed finisher, which is a big positive and he looked great in League One at times. It is always so hard to see which way it will go with wingers as so many show promise and then flop. My view is probably unfair as with us it's largely based on friendlies and a handful of cameos.
Attacking wingers need teams that have the ball enough to utilize their threat.
In defensive teams they can be lost to the game and be ineffective. In other teams they are gold dust.
From what I've seen of the guy it's clear he has attacking ability and will only get better. How much better is the million dollar question...That comes down to how good an eye and knowledge your decision makers have on what is required......it's a far better problem to have than not.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|