You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Due to no game on Saturday...
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Due to no game on Saturday...


Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 13 Feb 03 12.56pm

How much time would you give the weapons inspectors?

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 12.59pm

Time enough to actually have a look, I'd have thought. But we've been massing the troops since Resolution 1441 was passed -- seems we WANT it to fail.

The one person in all this who scares me, isn't Saddam and isn't Osama -- it's DUBYA.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 13 Feb 03 1.05pm

To fuel the debate, I passed on NickinOX's comments to an anti-war/anti-US work colleague (I have loads in my office!). So the following answers are not mine!

Quote NickinOX at 13 Feb 2003 11:14am

In response to Bexter, and others elsewhere who seem incapable if rational debate on the issue of Iraq.

Firstly, this idea that we and America sold Saddam all his weapons is crap. If you bothered to look at what kit he has purchased in the past and what he buys now, you would find that it is almost exclusively Russian. With a number of French and German weapons systems thrown in.
So your proposition that it is the US who armed him is laughable.

No one ever said we sold him ALL the weapons but if you remember a small thing called the Scott Report on the Arms to Iraq affair, you will recall
the then Tory govt. was lining its pockets with these sales. Also, perhaps this why we are seeing Russia, France and Germany being a little more
circumspect than we are.


Quote Secondly, even if a previous US government helped keep Saddam in power, and I have no doubt that they did, that surely enhances the moral obligation they have to remove him.

That's like saying, it's my football and I'm going home so you can't play. It's a nonsensical argument and is no excuse for killing thousands of
civilians.

Quote Thirdly, the Allied generals planning an invasion of Japan, which they were certain would be necessary, expected over 1,000,000 Allied casualties. Tojo himself said that 110,000,000 will die if the Allies invade. So what is the moral problem with the use of this weapon in those circumstances, especially when we consider that Japan and Germany were attempting to build atomic weapons of their own and would have certainly used them, without any moral qualms.

1) This is sepculation
2) We were actually "at war" then. This build-up of pressure on Iraq cannot be called a war. Anyone who watched any of the BBC's coverage last night will have seen that Iraq's three pea-shooters held by several blokes standing in a line with their hands over their bo***cks may not exactly be a match for the 43,000 British troops already in the region (not to mention the Yanks).


Quote Fourthly, you mention oil. There is already access to Iraqi oil. France and Russia already have billions of dollars of oil contracts with Iraq. France is Iraq's biggest western trade partner, with several billion dollars worth of trade each year and Russia has oil and trade contracts worth 40-50 billion dollars with Iraq.

Yes, but the US doesn't. BP also plans to get back the oil fields it lost when they were nationalised (only 10% of BP's oil comes from the North Sea - most comes from Russia at the moment). If oil reserves were expressed as a ratio, the US has 10 years left and Iraq has more than 500 years.

Quote Finally, read the Amnesty International (also Human Rights Watch) report on Saddam and his use of the sanctions to starve and control his people by allowing millions to die over the last 12 years. Who has blood on their hands now. The UK and US who have consistently tried to resolve this situation, or countries like Germany, France and Russia who would like the status quo to continue. Russia waging a fine and moral war in Chechnya, near the Caucasus oil pipelines and fields.

A "fine and moral war" in Chechnya backed and fully supported by America, that is - Bush recently added several Chechen groups to his "banned" terrorist organisations giving Russia absolute legitimacy to conquer.
Amnesty has campaigned for many, many years against arms exports and specifically against the export of weapons used for torture (electroshock batons) still available from any good British retailer backed by a convenient export credit agreement from the Department of Trade and Industry to regimes such as Iraq and Saudi Arabia.
Yes, everybody knows Saddam Hussein has used the sanctions (which we imposed remember, not him) to crush his people - as a Sunni Muslim he is actually in a minority in Iraq. His opponents, the Shi'ites, represent a large majority of the ordinary people he controls and aims to crush with our "unwitting" help. Surely, this is an argument to END the sanctions not continue them.
After the 1991 Gulf War, America encouraged the Shi'ites to rise up and overthrow Saddam and at the exact moment when they looked like doing just that...the US troops stood aside and allowed the Iraqi "elite" Republican Guard to quash the rebellion. In whose interests do the US and UK government's operate?...

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 1.09pm

Excellent post, Penge.

On the point about banned terrorist organisations, I note that Noraid still hasn't been banned -- presumably because the IRA don't target America (not to mention the Oirish vote needing a little massage).

Nice to know they want to look after their allies, innit...

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 13 Feb 03 1.25pm

Well you should wake up and smell the roses Slugs, coz it aint Bush who's gonna anthrax London! When you're laying in a ward full of dying innocent black, white, Asian people, both young and old, your cock has turned black and fallen off and you're coughing up more blood than you ever thought possible, let me know if you still think Bush is the main threat to YOU! YOU LIVE IN LONDON MAN!!! Where dy'a think this attack is gonna happen? Margate? YOU ARE IN REAL DANGER! GET IT INTO YOUR HEAD! And as for your trendy anti-war marches, I'd be a little careful there, Muslim terrorists don't give a flying s*** what you're all waving your little placards for, you're all western infidel pigs to those unthinking machines, perfect target! Now that would be ironic! All those middle-class British people in the same place at the same time, all more than happy to welcome a shifty looking Muslim van driver into their midst, whilst tooting his horn in supposed support while he off-loads his deadly cargo!

So, no war eh, coz war costs lives. Ok we'll leave Saddam alone. How many innocent Iraqis will die at his hands in the next ten years? A million? Two? Ten?

Many Iraqi soldiers will die in the war (their choice), but no more than a few hundred civilians would perish. Now that may be a few hundred too many, but do the maths, it's a damn site less than the multitude that will die without the war!

Your anti-war stance is cowardly and selfish! And stop all the 'Majority' bulls***, I'm sick of hearing it! Has there been a nationwide poll? NO! Has anyone asked me? NO! So where does this phoney statistic come from? It's f***ing bulls***!

PETEALIATOR IS f***ING BACK!!!!!!
If only briefly and on fewer occasions! It is after all, quality over quantity that counts
!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Bexter Flag By the Sea 13 Feb 03 1.30pm

a few hundred civilians! whose nose ain't working??

i live in london, and work here, and get the tube - i don't give in to threats or government propoganda, and i have lived through it before with our friends the ira.

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 2.02pm

Sorry for not writing this myself, but this guy does it for a living...

We're their allies - so why aren't they ours?

Rod Liddle
Wednesday February 12, 2003
Yes, it was in The Guardian

What a divine pleasure it was to hear the Republican senator Pete King eviscerating the hapless French on our radios yesterday morning. It was a perfect way to begin the day: basking in the happiness of not being French, of not being, as Bart Simpson has it, a "cheese-eating surrender monkey".

The French are, according to Pete, an irrelevance - and useless, to boot. "They don't even have a working aircraft carrier," he kept repeating, between diatribes about France's heroic and longstanding commitment to the principle of capitulation. Garlic-swathed beignet-stuffed sexually dysfunctional trash-pop Petainist belching Gauloise-smoking hypocritical papist b****** haw-hee-haw Johnny bloody Halliday up-yours-Delors coward monkeys, the lot of them. From Biarritz to Lille. Via the town of Vichy. And apart from Emmanuelle Béart, of course.

For people like me, who enjoy a bit of spite and vituperation first thing, just to get the juices flowing, it was magnificent stuff. And there - curiously unspoken - in the background was the knowledge that Pete and other similarly enraged US politicians couldn't say the same thing about us, could they? We're right behind them, the Yanks, and this will ensure us a sliver of love from our transatlantic cousins, if only by the process of disassociation. And this matters, being loved by the US.

And then, rather disconcertingly, it suddenly occurred to me that this was the same Pete King who has spent the past 15 years similarly eviscerating the British, or the "Bruddush", for "centuries of oppression" inflicted upon the Irish people. Pete could always be relied upon to say a few words in support of Martin Galvin's evil Noraid organisation, or to wade into some delicate and confusing conundrum of Northern Ireland politics with his size 12 cowboy boots, ready to give succour to the IRA for the sake of securing a few more votes from his Irish and faux-Irish constituents. He always did so with a mixture of brio and crass ignorance. It is the same Pete King, isn't it?

Of course it is. And many of you may well agree with him about Northern Ireland. But my point is more straightforward. We should not delude ourselves that we get anything from standing four-square beside George W Bush, or any other American president, for that matter. They think we're an irrelevance too, and useless, and antiquated and decadent. And what's more, no matter how loyal we strive to be, they would not so much as bother to cross the road to piss on us were we suddenly to catch fire. This has been the signal lesson of the past 20 years of international politics.

Beginning, of course, with the Falklands "dispute". As the then defence secretary, John Nott, made clear in his strange autobiography, the Americans were a big problem. At least half of the US administration - a section led by the perfidious Jean Kirkpatrick - was vocally supportive of the Argentinian cause and attempted to thwart our attempts to regain the islands by force. Why? Because siding with us disturbed their various, disgusting, machinations in Latin America (please don't believe the US opposition was motivated by moral disgust at the prospect of bloodshed).

Incidentally, who were our real allies then, according to Nott? The cowardly French, who provided us, sotto voce, with invaluable intelligence on the Super Etendard fighter aircraft.

A year later the US invaded (ineptly, of course) the British sovereign territory of Grenada without so much as a by-your-leave or bud, do you mind if we sort this problem out? On this occasion, according to Denis Healey, what irked our prime minister, Margaret Thatcher, most "was not so much the overthrow of the (Grenadian) dictatorship ... as the fact that he (President Reagan) deliberately and successfully deceived her on his intentions, though he had often told her she was his personal friend and closest ally. Moreover, he did so as part of a conspiracy with certain commonwealth governments in the Caribbean, which also kept Mrs Thatcher in the dark." Plus ça change, huh.

More recently, within weeks of September 11 2001, the US failed, astonishingly, to outlaw Noraid, despite having proscribed and seized the assets of every other terrorist fundraising organisation in the known universe. There is terrorism directed against the US and terrorism directed elsewhere, you see.

And a little later, as Britain incurred a good deal of wrath for sticking its head above the parapet to support, unequivocally, financially and with our own servicemen, America's War Against Terror and immediate adventure in Afghanistan, the US whacked illegal tariffs on our steel exports, desperately injuring a beleaguered British industry.

Of course, the two issues are not remotely related, as US trade representatives, blank-faced and unrepentant, frequently pointed out. And it may well be that the US was "right" in all of the above little contretemps with Britain. But my point is more simple - and I suppose, fairly crass: that in every case where Britain may have expected, or even just desired, a degree of loyalty from our "closest allies", that loyalty has not been remotely forthcoming. It was last forthcoming, in fact, in about 1942.

None of this should deflect Tony Blair from supporting the US in a war against Iraq if he believes it is morally the right course of action and, further, that it is in our best interests. He may well think both of these things. But increasingly the debate is being seen as a question of where we stand; are we part of Europe or do we append our allegiance to the US? And, further, what do we gain as a result?

The French are perpetually accused of pursuing a selfish foreign policy and it is a charge which is hard to deny. But it is rather less selfish and small-minded than that pursued by the US, a country for which the concept "ally" works only, it would appear, in one direction.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Nuno Flag have no idea.... 13 Feb 03 2.04pm

many of us live in London and many of us lived with the fear of an IRA attack. This I believe is worse though. How can people not take these threats seriously astounds me. Lets not forget on SEP 10th 2001 if I had posted a thread saying was it possible to fly 2 passenger jets into the New York Twin towers and then watch the Towers collapse I would have had replies saying I was mad. These people are capable of anything. Personally I will be know where near the centre of London on Saturday.

Anyway if you think coach loads of people gathering in the London are going to stop the war and that Tony Blair is going change his policies on war just because people are spending a day clogging up London then you are mad...

 


AKA Bacon

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 2.10pm

Quote Bacon at 13 Feb 2003 2:04pm

Anyway if you think coach loads of people gathering in the London are going to stop the war and that Tony Blair is going change his policies on war just because people are spending a day clogging up London then you are mad...

Very true -- why should the Government listen to the people after all? It's not as if we're in a democracy, is it...

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Bexter Flag By the Sea 13 Feb 03 2.11pm

i think it is mad to sit back and do nothing when you feel so strongly about something myself. and irresponsible. and lazy. different opinons i guess - not as if the anti vietnam demos did do any good eh?!

 

Nuno Flag have no idea.... 13 Feb 03 2.14pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 13 Feb 2003 2:10pm

Quote Bacon at 13 Feb 2003 2:04pm

Anyway if you think coach loads of people gathering in the London are going to stop the war and that Tony Blair is going change his policies on war just because people are spending a day clogging up London then you are mad...

Very true -- why should the Government listen to the people after all? It's not as if we're in a democracy, is it...


Doug it took me f***ing ages to write that post
I tend to steer clear of these important issues

But seriously mate, IMHO we are democracy as far as choosing our government is concerned. The rest of it is there choice, they will only listen if there is a substantial risk of losing power.. POLL TAX

Edited by Bacon (13 Feb 2003 2:15pm)

 


AKA Bacon

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 2.23pm

Quote Bexter at 13 Feb 2003 2:11pm

i think it is mad to sit back and do nothing when you feel so strongly about something myself. and irresponsible. and lazy. different opinons i guess - not as if the anti vietnam demos did do any good eh?!

Totally agree. If we decide that debate and demos are pointless, what do we have left? Violence?

People can slate the marchers all they like because they disagree with their aims, but just wait until another issue rears its head (farmers shooting kids in the back, for example?) and watch them all leap to their feet and demand something be done.

Sorry folks, but it works both ways.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Old Chap Flag Orpington 13 Feb 03 2.25pm

Just remember you have the right to march in protest. If you lived in Iraq & tried an anti-government rally you'd be shot or "disappear".

In Germany anyone who didn't fit the states view of a "proper citizen" was gassed, likewise if you were the wrong religion.

Japan considered everyone except them as "non-people", hence the atrocities. Europeans & Americans were only useful as slave labour. Disabled were shot or beheaded. Even now they don't accept they did anything wrong.

Be thankful we live in a tolerant society where you CAN express your opinion

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 2.30pm

I am very thankful, although it seems our tolerance is disappearing fast...

This argument -- that we are free to march but Iraqis aren't -- is specious. Saddam is NOT trying to stop us marching, he is not trying to invade us, he is not doing ANYTHING to us. We are in no danger of losing these rights, at least not at the hands of Saddam anyway.

Can anyone prove otherwise?

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Bexter Flag By the Sea 13 Feb 03 2.30pm

i AM thankful which is why i'm not sqaundering this chance to march. i do feel for all those places where you can't - there are so many.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 13 Feb 03 2.44pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 13 Feb 2003 2:30pm

I am very thankful, although it seems our tolerance is disappearing fast...

This argument -- that we are free to march but Iraqis aren't -- is specious. Saddam is NOT trying to stop us marching, he is not trying to invade us, he is not doing ANYTHING to us. We are in no danger of losing these rights, at least not at the hands of Saddam anyway.

Can anyone prove otherwise?

Hitler wasn't doing anything to us in 1939 yet Britain, declared war on Germany because it was perceived (quite rightly) that his ambitions would not be limited to Poland. By the same token, Saddam is pursuing an agenda which, at the very least, is aimed at attacking Israel (as evidenced by his continuing concealment of various sites from UN weapons inspectors) which, in turn de-stabilises the whole region and, by extension, the world beyond. To say that Saddam poses no threat to the Middle East is naive in the extreme and to wait until he actually does something where indications of his intentions are obvious is not only folly but actually irresponsible.


 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 2.48pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 13 Feb 2003 2:44pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 13 Feb 2003 2:30pm

I am very thankful, although it seems our tolerance is disappearing fast...

This argument -- that we are free to march but Iraqis aren't -- is specious. Saddam is NOT trying to stop us marching, he is not trying to invade us, he is not doing ANYTHING to us. We are in no danger of losing these rights, at least not at the hands of Saddam anyway.

Can anyone prove otherwise?

Hitler wasn't doing anything to us in 1939 yet Britain, declared war on Germany because it was perceived (quite rightly) that his ambitions would not be limited to Poland. By the same token, Saddam is pursuing an agenda which, at the very least, is aimed at attacking Israel (as evidenced by his continuing concealment of various sites from UN weapons inspectors) which, in turn de-stabilises the whole region and, by extension, the world beyond. To say that Saddam poses no threat to the Middle East is naive in the extreme and to wait until he actually does something where indications of his intentions are obvious is not only folly but actually irresponsible.

Hang on a second...

1. We declared war on Hitler due to a treaty with Poland, not due to any perceived danger to the UK. In fact, Hitler didn't want to invade us, but rather to make peace and concentrate on Russia.

2. Where did I say Saddam poses no threat to the Middle East? Before you call me naive, and worse, please read my posts properly mate.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 13 Feb 03 3.04pm

Maybe you should read my posts, too. Mate. I didn't actually accuse you of being naive: I suggested that people who hold such views are.

Secondly, the treaty with Poland was not drawn up specifically to protect that country. It was to be seen as a line drawn in the sand beyond which Hitler should not go if he wanted to avoid war. Hitler didn't want to go to war with us for the simple reason that he didn't want to fight on two fronts where his primary ambition was to annexe the Soviet Union. Make no mistake, though, that his ambition was ultimately to bring the whole of Europe (and beyond) under the swastika. PLEASE don't tell me that Hitler had no issue with Great Britain. It's all in Mein Kampf.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 3.08pm

Well, this is all getting very friendly. Again.

I give up.

I say we kick them out of Britain, string them up, and bomb the b*st*rds back to the Stone Age.

That'll teach 'em.

I can't believe I wasted the last 34 years thinking that peace, harmony and mutual understanding was the best way forward for the human race. I should have known, given the overwhelming evidence, that it is war, hostility and greed that have made us the healthy happy successful species we so clearly are.

F*ck it, I'm off to sell Sarin to the Turkish family up the road.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 13 Feb 03 3.16pm

Now that I have seen the light, and am (perhaps) fit to rejoin the conscious part of the human race that KNOWS violence is the only way, I've drawn up a little hit-list for when we've done with Iraq. (After all, we're not going to want to hang around fixing the damage we've done, that's not sexy enough and doesn't involve any clever missile technology.)

ISRAEL

Obvious really. Has broken more UN sanctions than Saddam, murdered more of its own people than Saddam, has a secret nuclear programme that (unlike Saddam's) actually exists, and is currently in illegal occupation of a neighbouring country. And it's leader is called Sharon, for f*ck's sake.

GERMANY

They did some naughty things around the time my Dad was born.

CHILE

They kicked out the dictator we installed and went back to democracy. Cheeky b*st*rds won't do that again.

INDONESIA

More Muslims than anywhere else on earth, and we know they're all evil, right kids?

KAZAKHSTAN

Because it'll be fun seeing Dubya trying to find it on the map.

BELGIUM

Great beer, excellent chocolate, beautiful country, and Stef. All good points you might think, but surely too good to be true. Must have a secret Anthrax programme in the suburbs of Brussels, I'm sure of it.

WALES

Because I feel like it, and some Welsh bloke p*ssed me off yesterday.


That should keep the military-industrial complex, and the warmongers amongst us, happy for a month or so.

BOMB THEM ALL!!

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Due to no game on Saturday...