Quote legaleagle at 18 Jul 2014 8.31am
Quote dannyh at 18 Jul 2014 7.24am
[
I hope your final para made you feel clever. Then,at least it served a purpose, however minor. Though it did show your propensity to attribute characteristics wantonly to a whole group of people, whether in a profession, or an ethnic/religious group.
It was tongue in cheek hence the smiley
Any chance we can leave the Primary School playground gutter out of it in future?
You stop being condescending to anyone else's opinion bar your own, then we have a deal.
You misunderstood my point re Jews. I was talking about in Israel. Also, while you correct my technical details, you don't deal with the substance of the point I was making in response to your's. But lets move on.
Errrr yes I did answer you. The Israeli Government has infinitely more force at it's disposal than HAMAS, and you implied the military wing of HAMAS ran the country of Palestine, I showed you they don't, or does that not fit your agenda?
In case anyone is interested in seeing that opposition to the Israeli Government's policies is indeed is very much alive in Israel, I will post in a minute an article from the Israel Times. Check out also,as an example,the work of Israel human rights group B'T Salem. Check out the "Peace Now" movement. They are a minority but do show that the alarming tendency in some circles to lump all Jews together in a negative context (in Israel or worldwide) is in fact....b.ll.cks...
No one was lumping all Jews together, I said I see little support not no support, but little support, which you have admitted stating they are in the minority.
And unless I've missed something my point still remains that whilst HAMAS are no Angels, in a tale of the tape their activities for want of a better word, disappear into insignificance when compared to the attacks by Israeli GOVERNMENT troops, while the rest of the world looks on saying and doing nothing.
With NI talks took place between the UK government and the two main para military/political protagonists the IRA/Seinfein and the UVF/UDF and (It would appear) the Rev Ian Paisley. My argument is that the Israeli Government has no interest in giving any ground, and as political power see's HAMAS as having no negotiating power, more over where ever possible they nick more Palestinian territory when it thinks no one is looking.
Basically can you imagine the outcry across the world if, during the troubles in NI, our troops went about blowing the fcuk out of catholic strongholds with tanks air strikes and special forces troops and then ever increasing the boundaries of the UK's influence in Ireland, Fcuk me we are still dealing with the fall out from Bloody Sunday !
Your living in cloud Cuckoo land mate.
Edited by legaleagle (17 Jul 2014 10.05pm)
Edited by legaleagle (17 Jul 2014 10.11pm)
Edited by dannyh (18 Jul 2014 7.25am)
If you go back to my original posting, you will note I said your overall opinion was one a person could perfectly reasonably hold,ie it was fair enough,I might not agree with absolutely all of it, but I wasn't dissing it.
I was simply trying to argue against one small detail,your suggesting that, on one side was "the whole Israeli government" and on the other just HAMAS.I therefore understood you to be saying "HAMAS" was not "the whole government" of Gaza. I was using the word "HAMAS" (as I thought you were)in the sense of the overall Islamic Resistance Movement, incorporating both the political and military wings.
I had also understood you to be suggesting a very small number of Jews/no Jews not being in line with the Israel Government over Gaza. and yes, we Jews (even those who like me are not Zionists) do get jumpy about wholesale lumping together of the Israeli government/Zionists as "the Jews". Forgive me/us. When I say minority,I mean perhaps a quarter-to a third. Your original words were "what the Jews are doing is nothing short of war crimes". For some reason I didn't understand you just to be referring to the Israeli government/those Israeli Jews supporting them.
Edited by legaleagle (18 Jul 2014 8.36am)
Edited by legaleagle (18 Jul 2014 8.37am)
Please educate me then, who is the second biggest political party in Israel and are they totally opposed to the shelling of kids playing on a beach ?
Because if what you say is accurate and a 1/4 to a 1/3 of Jews are repulsed (as they should be) by the goings on in Gaza, and are opposed to such outright murder on a large and indiscriminate scale, then surely such a number would have a leader, and a voice in Israel, to put pressure on the current turbo nutter that’s in power in Israel a the moment.
I do see your point that not all Jewish people are behind the stance taken by the Israeli government on Palestine, but I really don't see, (and that may be through my own ignorance) any significant Jewish (israel or otherwise) opposition to the constant slaughter of Palestinian people, the majority of which are not HAMAS and just want to live in a house that will stand up for more than a month without being, Bombed, bulldozed, or blown to kingdom come by Israeli artillery.
And unless I am very much mistaken, I'm pretty sure the Palestinians where there first. (and Please don't start quoting the times of the great sky fairy, your better than that.)So on that proviso, it’s a bit small man syndrome to have a foreign policy of “if you fcuk us, we will fcuk you 10 times with a ten foot dildo”. It can’t be any surprise for you to read the reaction towards Israel, when all we see is the same consistent scenario played out whereby HAMAS fires a few rockets over the wall and some Israeli is on telly moaning about a splinter, and then they retaliate by flattening a Palestinian settlement with air strikes, artillery and tank fire, killing 50 odd men women and children, your just not going to win world wide support/approval for that are you ?
I think that’s what people object to the most, the constant over the top retaliation. When mainland Britain got bombed in the eighties and ninties by the Provo's we didn't send our Air force over to Dublin and flatten the place. Yes, HAMAS are a pain in the arse and are terrorists, but they are like terrorist lite, or terrorist Zero, and does a few unguided rockets launched in the general direction of Israel warrant shelling and killing children playing on a beach ?
No it does not, and that is my point in a microcosm.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"
|