You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?
November 16 2026 12.54pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?


Page 20 of 25 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 >
Nevermind Flag 18 Apr 14 12.41pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 7.43pm

Quote The Sash at 17 Apr 2014 3.43pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 1.37pm

Quote Baldfella at 17 Apr 2014 12.37pm

Quote fed up eagle at 17 Apr 2014 12.34pm

Apparently Cardiff are trying to say that the result we got there should not stand due to the supposed leak.
This smacks of desperation on Cardiff's part but I wouldn't put it past the powers that be to screw us over.
This story is on the BBC sport website.

Thoughts?

Not against you personally mate but you're the most recent poster that seems to think the powers that be would want to "screw us over" ! What do you base this on ?

Complete rubbish, Palace make the same contributions towards their partition in the Premier League, they will get same treatment as any other club.

As stated before: SECTION B Rule B15 states: "In all matters and transactions relating to the league each club shall behave towards each other club and the league with the utmost good faith".

SECTION B Rule 17 goes on, "A Club shall not without the Board’s prior written consent either during its membership of the League or at any time after its membership has terminated disclose or divulge either directly or indirectly to any Person whatsoever or otherwise make use of any confidential information as to the business or finances of the League or any other Club or any of their dealings, transactions or affairs or as to any other matters which may come to its knowledge by reason
of its membership save to statutory and regulatory authorities or as may be required by law or to such Officials and Auditors of that Club to whom such disclosure is strictly necessary for the purpose of their duties and then only to the extent so necessary".
That to me is what Cardiff may be using as justification for their complaint, I may be wrong but as I read that as a non Englishman, it could also implicate Cardiff for their failings.

Also there is no mention of this type of issue in APPENDIX 5 & 6 Managers and clubs code of conduct.

So unless the Premier league introduce a new rule, it's a storm in a teacup, as this sort of thing has been going on for years, even when I was playing it was going on, every club tried to get their opponents lineup before they named theirs, and I retired in 1977, it's called trying to outwit your opponent.

Exactly - As I said earlier, there is no actual 'rule' that has been broken, you could argue if we did do this then we went against a very shaky and vague ethical 'guidleine' to which no-one can actually pass a judgement on


It seems as though we are both correct, a lawyer has looked at this for FYP and his spin on this is:
The claims include the suggestion that Palace's sporting director attempted to obtain the team sheet by phoning the Cardiff City performance analyst - who has subsequently been sacked by the club - although he was unsuccessful in his endeavours.

In an even more bizarre twist, Cardiff have claimed that after Moody had discovered the line-up, he mistakenly sent a text message to former Palace boss Dougie Freedman with the information; before Freedman alerted his friend Ole Gunnar Solskjaer about the leak. The BBC explained that the document sent to the Premier League notes that Cardiff midfielder Aron Gunnarsson is named as the source of the leak; something which the player and his agent both have denied.

We asked our resident lawyer, Andy Street to give us his view on the situation, and he believes there is nothing for Palace fans to worry about.

Would appreciate it if you could link to the article rather than copying and pasting it in its entirety.

[Link]

Edited by Nevermind (18 Apr 2014 12.42pm)

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 18 Apr 14 1.04pm

Quote Nevermind at 18 Apr 2014 12.41pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 7.43pm

Quote The Sash at 17 Apr 2014 3.43pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 1.37pm

Quote Baldfella at 17 Apr 2014 12.37pm

Quote fed up eagle at 17 Apr 2014 12.34pm

Apparently Cardiff are trying to say that the result we got there should not stand due to the supposed leak.
This smacks of desperation on Cardiff's part but I wouldn't put it past the powers that be to screw us over.
This story is on the BBC sport website.

Thoughts?

Not against you personally mate but you're the most recent poster that seems to think the powers that be would want to "screw us over" ! What do you base this on ?

Complete rubbish, Palace make the same contributions towards their partition in the Premier League, they will get same treatment as any other club.

As stated before: SECTION B Rule B15 states: "In all matters and transactions relating to the league each club shall behave towards each other club and the league with the utmost good faith".

SECTION B Rule 17 goes on, "A Club shall not without the Board’s prior written consent either during its membership of the League or at any time after its membership has terminated disclose or divulge either directly or indirectly to any Person whatsoever or otherwise make use of any confidential information as to the business or finances of the League or any other Club or any of their dealings, transactions or affairs or as to any other matters which may come to its knowledge by reason
of its membership save to statutory and regulatory authorities or as may be required by law or to such Officials and Auditors of that Club to whom such disclosure is strictly necessary for the purpose of their duties and then only to the extent so necessary".
That to me is what Cardiff may be using as justification for their complaint, I may be wrong but as I read that as a non Englishman, it could also implicate Cardiff for their failings.

Also there is no mention of this type of issue in APPENDIX 5 & 6 Managers and clubs code of conduct.

So unless the Premier league introduce a new rule, it's a storm in a teacup, as this sort of thing has been going on for years, even when I was playing it was going on, every club tried to get their opponents lineup before they named theirs, and I retired in 1977, it's called trying to outwit your opponent.

Exactly - As I said earlier, there is no actual 'rule' that has been broken, you could argue if we did do this then we went against a very shaky and vague ethical 'guidleine' to which no-one can actually pass a judgement on


It seems as though we are both correct, a lawyer has looked at this for FYP and his spin on this is:
The claims include the suggestion that Palace's sporting director attempted to obtain the team sheet by phoning the Cardiff City performance analyst - who has subsequently been sacked by the club - although he was unsuccessful in his endeavours.

In an even more bizarre twist, Cardiff have claimed that after Moody had discovered the line-up, he mistakenly sent a text message to former Palace boss Dougie Freedman with the information; before Freedman alerted his friend Ole Gunnar Solskjaer about the leak. The BBC explained that the document sent to the Premier League notes that Cardiff midfielder Aron Gunnarsson is named as the source of the leak; something which the player and his agent both have denied.

We asked our resident lawyer, Andy Street to give us his view on the situation, and he believes there is nothing for Palace fans to worry about.

Would appreciate it if you could link to the article rather than copying and pasting it in its entirety. http://fiveyearplanfanzine.co.uk/news/4835-crystal-palace-spygate-saga-rumbles-on-a-lawyer-s-view.html

Edited by Nevermind (18 Apr 2014 12.42pm)

I usually do, but because of it's significance and the fact those with some smartphones can't upload such links, I posted it so they had a chance to read it.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 18 Apr 14 1.08pm

Big Tone and his logs of team practice and team picked on Monday is game, set, and match.

Hopefully we bow out now, leave Tan and the BBC journalist in front of the rest of the press and let them either dig themselves deeper or apologise. Either way we move on.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Typical Palace Flag Allington 18 Apr 14 1.19pm

I'm surprised they haven't reported us for being in breach of the trade descriptions act as according to Alan Hansen we were supposed to be crap and heading for relegation.

 


When a train runs out of steam it stops when a man runs out of steam he keeps going......

glazedallover Flag Allier 18 Apr 14 1.54pm

Quote Nevermind at 18 Apr 2014 12.41pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 7.43pm

Quote The Sash at 17 Apr 2014 3.43pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 17 Apr 2014 1.37pm

Quote Baldfella at 17 Apr 2014 12.37pm

Quote fed up eagle at 17 Apr 2014 12.34pm

Apparently Cardiff are trying to say that the result we got there should not stand due to the supposed leak.
This smacks of desperation on Cardiff's part but I wouldn't put it past the powers that be to screw us over.
This story is on the BBC sport website.

Thoughts?

Not against you personally mate but you're the most recent poster that seems to think the powers that be would want to "screw us over" ! What do you base this on ?

Complete rubbish, Palace make the same contributions towards their partition in the Premier League, they will get same treatment as any other club.

As stated before: SECTION B Rule B15 states: "In all matters and transactions relating to the league each club shall behave towards each other club and the league with the utmost good faith".

SECTION B Rule 17 goes on, "A Club shall not without the Board’s prior written consent either during its membership of the League or at any time after its membership has terminated disclose or divulge either directly or indirectly to any Person whatsoever or otherwise make use of any confidential information as to the business or finances of the League or any other Club or any of their dealings, transactions or affairs or as to any other matters which may come to its knowledge by reason
of its membership save to statutory and regulatory authorities or as may be required by law or to such Officials and Auditors of that Club to whom such disclosure is strictly necessary for the purpose of their duties and then only to the extent so necessary".
That to me is what Cardiff may be using as justification for their complaint, I may be wrong but as I read that as a non Englishman, it could also implicate Cardiff for their failings.

Also there is no mention of this type of issue in APPENDIX 5 & 6 Managers and clubs code of conduct.

So unless the Premier league introduce a new rule, it's a storm in a teacup, as this sort of thing has been going on for years, even when I was playing it was going on, every club tried to get their opponents lineup before they named theirs, and I retired in 1977, it's called trying to outwit your opponent.

Exactly - As I said earlier, there is no actual 'rule' that has been broken, you could argue if we did do this then we went against a very shaky and vague ethical 'guidleine' to which no-one can actually pass a judgement on


It seems as though we are both correct, a lawyer has looked at this for FYP and his spin on this is:
The claims include the suggestion that Palace's sporting director attempted to obtain the team sheet by phoning the Cardiff City performance analyst - who has subsequently been sacked by the club - although he was unsuccessful in his endeavours.

In an even more bizarre twist, Cardiff have claimed that after Moody had discovered the line-up, he mistakenly sent a text message to former Palace boss Dougie Freedman with the information; before Freedman alerted his friend Ole Gunnar Solskjaer about the leak. The BBC explained that the document sent to the Premier League notes that Cardiff midfielder Aron Gunnarsson is named as the source of the leak; something which the player and his agent both have denied.

We asked our resident lawyer, Andy Street to give us his view on the situation, and he believes there is nothing for Palace fans to worry about.

Would appreciate it if you could link to the article rather than copying and pasting it in its entirety.

[Link]

Edited by Nevermind (18 Apr 2014 12.42pm)

never mind

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 18 Apr 14 2.12pm

Cardiff are dropping the accusations according to welsh news.

 

Part Time James Flag 18 Apr 14 2.18pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 18 Apr 2014 2.12pm

Cardiff are dropping the accusations according to welsh news.

TV news or any online sources yet?

 




EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 18 Apr 14 2.27pm

Quote Part Time James at 18 Apr 2014 2.18pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 18 Apr 2014 2.12pm

Cardiff are dropping the accusations according to welsh news.

TV news or any online sources yet?


Radio apparently.

 

Palaceacademical Flag Croydon 18 Apr 14 2.28pm

The Premier League regulation L.21. below implies that there is a latest time that the team sheets must be made available not an earliest time before a match. The original FA rule regarding the availability of team sheets was probably to ensure that at least 7 players in each team would play and that a match could legitimately begin. If Tan seriously thinks that keeping his team sheet confidential until the last minute before a game is the secret to success in the Premier league he is deluded.

L.21. At least one hour before the time fixed for the kick-off of a League Match, a senior member of the coaching staff and the first team captain of each participating Club shall attend a briefing with the referee and hand to him and their opponents and, subject to Rule K.80, make available to the media a team sheet

 

billtheglazier Flag twickenham 18 Apr 14 3.04pm

Vincent Tan does behave like a narcissist who finds it hard to accept he is ever wrong or makes a bad judgement.(sacking Malky Mackay for example)..Palace left him with a limp p**** and seeing 'Red' !! ..the realisation that he has made a bad investment and his investment will be relegated, has left him clutching at straws believing that his money will always be the winner..Sadly wrong methinks..and will probably go the same way that Blackburn and their chicken farmers took them..
[Link]

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

slubglurge Flag welling 18 Apr 14 3.26pm

Starry starry night.
But I could have told you, Vincent.
This league was never meant for one.
As ludicrous as you.
Starry starry night.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 18 Apr 14 3.31pm

Quote slubglurge at 18 Apr 2014 3.26pm

Starry starry night.
Change the strip to red from blue
But I could have told you, Vincent.
This league was never meant for one.
As ludicrous as you.
Starry starry night.


Pretty good but I think you have a line missing if I may make so bold

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

palace1234 Flag Space 18 Apr 14 4.02pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 18 Apr 2014 2.12pm

Cardiff are dropping the accusations according to welsh news.


Maybe they have realised what they are doing and how much of an embarrassment they are making of themselves, pretty much the whole football community think they are a joke now ! This goes on everywhere as previous managers, players and journalist have already said, I wonder if they really have dropped these silly accusations !

 

becky Flag over the moon 18 Apr 14 4.09pm

More like Tan couldn't find out who to drop the brown envelope to at the PL and FA to ensure a successful outcome to his complaint - it's the Malay way of doing things.....

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Apr 14 4.21pm

Not sure it would make any difference now. The PL can't just ignore what was said

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Kingvagabond Flag London 18 Apr 14 5.14pm

I think that the second they officially drop the accusations then the league should grow enough bollocks to immediately deduct cardiff ten points for lyign and deliberately dragging the good name of a rival club through the mire.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

kirstonian Flag New Malden 18 Apr 14 5.19pm


lol

cpal.jpg Attachment: cpal.jpg (44.04Kb)

 


"Life should NOT be a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving safely in an attractive and well preserved body, but rather to skid in sideways, chocolate in one hand, Jack Daniels in the other, body thoroughly used up, totally worn out and screaming "WOO HOO what a ride!"


adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 18 Apr 14 5.54pm


I do think there are rules concerning contact between clubs and the employees of clubs prior to a match between these clubs. I stand to be corrected. If I am correct then I suspect if there are proven communications, the league are entitled to know the contents. The league may be seeking evidence pointing to attempts to affect the result of the match. If Tan keeps on about it, he may be insinuating this very point, seeing how badly his team played in the match. Then, if a judgement is made by the league that clears Palace, be sure Tan may take it further, ie through the courts.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 18 Apr 14 6.05pm

The sooner this joke of a man gets out of our football nation, the better - he is ruining it - maybe he has a case, but surely the EPL won't let him win.

At worst, a fine for breaching certain rules - but any expert in the game can see we were just a better team on the day - the same line up as previous games - if we fielded a different line up, formation, then that would set alarm bells.

 


This was once a quality forum....

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 18 Apr 14 6.07pm

Quote adrian b at 18 Apr 2014 5.54pm


I do think there are rules concerning contact between clubs and the employees of clubs prior to a match between these clubs. I stand to be corrected. If I am correct then I suspect if there are proven communications, the league are entitled to know the contents. The league may be seeking evidence pointing to attempts to affect the result of the match. If Tan keeps on about it, he may be insinuating this very point, seeing how badly his team played in the match. Then, if a judgement is made by the league that clears Palace, be sure Tan may take it further, ie through the courts.


I'm really scared Personally I thought he took it up the @rse

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Page 20 of 25 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cardiff complaint - Could we face problems if true?