You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 20 of 187 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 >
Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 12.04pm

Apparently net immigration into this country per year is around about the population of the city of Southampton.

Those who have supported the immigration (EU) policies of the main parties are partly responsible for the genuine suffering undergone by the mainly working class people of this country.

Downgrade in housing chances.
Downgrade in public services provision.
Downgrade in job chances.
For certain jobs, a downgrade in wages.

Large sections of the left and some on the right have their heads stuck in the sand and won't be happy until this small island is shoulder to shoulder.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 May 14 12.16pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 12.04pm

Apparently net immigration into this country per year is around about the population of the city of Southampton.

Those who have supported the immigration (EU) policies of the main parties are partly responsible for the genuine suffering undergone by the mainly working class people of this country.

Downgrade in housing chances.
Downgrade in public services provision.
Downgrade in job chances.
For certain jobs, a downgrade in wages.

Large sections of the left and some on the right have their heads stuck in the sand and won't be happy until this small island is shoulder to shoulder.

As I've said, the issue needs to be discussed Stirling. I just don't think UKIP are the right way to go...

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 12.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.16pm


As I've said, the issue needs to be discussed Stirling. I just don't think UKIP are the right way to go...


Without Ukip representing these concerns the topic would have continued to be dismissed.

Before Ukip all you would hear was the left characterizing these elements as the views of 'bigots'....You'd be called racist and demonised and dismissed. Others would just deny there was even a problem.

No other party tackled this issue.....What right do they now have to pretend to care?

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 May 2014 12.29pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 May 14 12.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 12.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.16pm


As I've said, the issue needs to be discussed Stirling. I just don't think UKIP are the right way to go...


Without Ukip representing these concerns the topic would have continued to be dismissed.

Before Ukip all you would hear was the left characterizing these elements as the views of 'bigots'....You'd be called racist and demonised and dismissed. Others would just deny there was even a problem.

No other party tackled this issue.....What right do they now have to pretend to care?

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 May 2014 12.29pm)

I hear you. But there are other parties that are anti eu. Why are they not getting as much coverage? (That said, Dave Nellist of TUSC was on the Daily Politics the other day , though I haven't had a chance to watch it yet)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 2.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.44pm]

I hear you. But there are other parties that are anti eu. Why are they not getting as much coverage? (That said, Dave Nellist of TUSC was on the Daily Politics the other day , though I haven't had a chance to watch it yet)


I would have liked to have seen that.

I would be happier if these parties remained single issue parties.....They could join together then upon that issue and not get so tied up in other areas.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 2.25pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 12.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.16pm


As I've said, the issue needs to be discussed Stirling. I just don't think UKIP are the right way to go...


Without Ukip representing these concerns the topic would have continued to be dismissed.

Before Ukip all you would hear was the left characterizing these elements as the views of 'bigots'....You'd be called racist and demonised and dismissed. Others would just deny there was even a problem.

No other party tackled this issue.....What right do they now have to pretend to care?

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 May 2014 12.29pm)

I hear you. But there are other parties that are anti eu. Why are they not getting as much coverage? (That said, Dave Nellist of TUSC was on the Daily Politics the other day , though I haven't had a chance to watch it yet)

Because virtually nobody supports them. The TUSC party at a European level is No2EU is it not? They got 1% of the vote last time whereas UKIP got 16.5%. For No2EU to get coverage on the basis of vote share you'd also have to give time to the BNP, the English Democrats, the Christian Party and the Socialist Labour Party.

I simply can't comprehend why parties put up candidates who are pretty much certain to lose their deposit. All that happens is that votes are taken from credible challengers, which often harms the prospect of any change in the elected representatives.

Presumably you still live in Chislehurst? Unless you live in Mottingham & Chislehurst North ward, you're going to be voting locally in an election where it's pretty much certain that a Tory is going to win. By moving your vote from a left wing party who will keep their deposit (Labour/Lib Dems/Greens) to one that won't, you're simply increasing a Tory's majority.

At the risk of a slightly harsh stereotype of your position, isn't your politics pretty well summarised by you being anti-Tory? I know I am. From that perspective (and despite strongly associating myself with the Labour party) I always vote for whoever has the best chance of keeping the Tories out. I'd feel a dick if I voted TUSC in this election and found out that the Tories had won by a small margin.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 2.26pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 2.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.44pm]

I hear you. But there are other parties that are anti eu. Why are they not getting as much coverage? (That said, Dave Nellist of TUSC was on the Daily Politics the other day , though I haven't had a chance to watch it yet)


I would have liked to have seen that.

I would be happier if these parties remained single issue parties.....They could join together then upon that issue and not get so tied up in other areas.

I'm like a modern day staffie. There's a new contender for most helpful poster award in town.

[Link]

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 2.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 12.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.16pm


As I've said, the issue needs to be discussed Stirling. I just don't think UKIP are the right way to go...


Without Ukip representing these concerns the topic would have continued to be dismissed.

Before Ukip all you would hear was the left characterizing these elements as the views of 'bigots'....You'd be called racist and demonised and dismissed. Others would just deny there was even a problem.

No other party tackled this issue.....What right do they now have to pretend to care?

Housing, public services, jobs and wages have all been part of public discourse between parties and with the public for many years. They've not been discussed within the context of immigration much because generally if you think immigrants contribute more in taxes than they take out, it's very difficult to make the inferences you make.

UKIP aren't just the only party that "isn't afraid to discuss the true impact of immigration", they're also the party that is most wrong. There also isn't a public discourse about whether the MMR jab should be banned. Because those who think it should invariably hold beliefs that are incorrect.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 10 May 14 3.04pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 2.26pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 2.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.44pm]

I hear you. But there are other parties that are anti eu. Why are they not getting as much coverage? (That said, Dave Nellist of TUSC was on the Daily Politics the other day , though I haven't had a chance to watch it yet)


I would have liked to have seen that.

I would be happier if these parties remained single issue parties.....They could join together then upon that issue and not get so tied up in other areas.

I'm like a modern day staffie. There's a new contender for most helpful poster award in town.

[Link]

We're still waiting for a graph on inequality levels in the UK, before your head gets too big.


 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 10 May 14 4.06pm

Just listened to Any Questions on Radio 4. UKIP were criticised for bleating about economic and social problems and then only offering overly simplistic solutions...

...
...

...by the GREENS!!

Hahahahaha

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 4.28pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 2.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 12.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.16pm


As I've said, the issue needs to be discussed Stirling. I just don't think UKIP are the right way to go...


Without Ukip representing these concerns the topic would have continued to be dismissed.

Before Ukip all you would hear was the left characterizing these elements as the views of 'bigots'....You'd be called racist and demonised and dismissed. Others would just deny there was even a problem.

No other party tackled this issue.....What right do they now have to pretend to care?

Housing, public services, jobs and wages have all been part of public discourse between parties and with the public for many years. They've not been discussed within the context of immigration much because generally if you think immigrants contribute more in taxes than they take out, it's very difficult to make the inferences you make.

UKIP aren't just the only party that "isn't afraid to discuss the true impact of immigration", they're also the party that is most wrong. There also isn't a public discourse about whether the MMR jab should be banned. Because those who think it should invariably hold beliefs that are incorrect.


This is a constant line you put out and you always ignore the answers.

Firstly the statistics that you are quoting from to support your implicit 'immigrants make us richer' are debated.

Secondly and more importantly saying that immigrants pay slightly more tax.....And if I remember correctly it is only slightly ....Saying that completely ignores the costs of providing for these people.

If these immigrants were all earning loads of money and paying large tax amounts and feeding their spare cash back into the economy (instead of a lot of them sending it home) then there would be some sense in your answer.

As it is.....Immigrants increase job competition for British workers and lower wages in some sectors.

Housing low paid immigrants takes away possible housing for British residents and the lack of supply increases the rent or price...The fact that the state needs to build many many new houses for our significantly increasing population puts your 'immigrants pay more tax' line into almost comic relief.

The cost of bigger populations emerging too quickly with their required infrastructure far outweighs the debatable extra income you refer to.


Edited by Stirlingsays (10 May 2014 4.31pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 4.52pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2014 3.04pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 2.26pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 2.15pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2014 12.44pm]

I hear you. But there are other parties that are anti eu. Why are they not getting as much coverage? (That said, Dave Nellist of TUSC was on the Daily Politics the other day , though I haven't had a chance to watch it yet)


I would have liked to have seen that.

I would be happier if these parties remained single issue parties.....They could join together then upon that issue and not get so tied up in other areas.

I'm like a modern day staffie. There's a new contender for most helpful poster award in town.

[Link]

We're still waiting for a graph on inequality levels in the UK, before your head gets too big.

Venn diagram is all you're getting. Record levels of inequality and current level of inequality being the two sets:

O

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 6.07pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

This is a constant line you put out and you always ignore the answers.

Firstly the statistics that you are quoting from to support your implicit 'immigrants make us richer' are debated.

They are, but usually the debate ends in "well yes, obviously they're a net contributor given they were educated in another country and may well return there later in life when their care needs are greater".

People who are concerned about immigration often cite "common sense". I'd say there's no more obvious example of common sense than the conclusion that immigrants are statistically likely to pay more in tax than they take out.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Secondly and more importantly saying that immigrants pay slightly more tax.....And if I remember correctly it is only slightly ....Saying that completely ignores the costs of providing for these people.

It doesn't ignore the costs of providing for these people, the costs are part of the calculation. Imagine Manuel comes over here and pays £10,000/year in taxation and only uses £9,000 state-provided services and benefits, for example. He is a net contributor. His £10,000 not only pays for the provision of the services that he uses, it pays for (part of) someone else's services too.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

If these immigrants were all earning loads of money and paying large tax amounts and feeding their spare cash back into the economy (instead of a lot of them sending it home) then there would be some sense in your answer.

They feed a lot of it into the economy, that's unavoidable. They've got to pay for accommodation here and they're not going to pop back to their original country every time they want a bit of grub, or a telly or whatever.

If the "sending money home" examples had a deflationary effect upon the economy you'd have areas rich in immigrants seeing lower economic growth. No evidence of that happening that I've seen/heard about.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

As it is.....Immigrants increase job competition for British workers and lower wages in some sectors.

Perhaps, but I wouldn't say competition in your job is a bad thing and obviously the best way to create jobs is to have people who put money into the economy and who pay more taxes than they take in services. As immigration increases, so does employment. Look at the last 60 years or so in the UK, for example.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Housing low paid immigrants takes away possible housing for British residents and the lack of supply increases the rent or price... The fact that the state needs to build many many new houses for our significantly increasing population puts your 'immigrants pay more tax' line into almost comic relief.

Hopefully you're beginning to see a pattern in my argument at this stage. The immigrants are net contributors to the state, so those who are net beneficiaries by having their housing subsidised are more than funded by other immigrants who are net contributors.

Whether the state needs to build more houses is of course another debate, but it's not really a debate worth having unless you can calculate the costs of building the new housing and the financial surplus to the state that the immigrants generate.

If there are 26 million houses that 4 people on average can stay in, that's capacity for over 100 million people to live. I'd argue if we can house 35 million more people than we have in the country and struggle to even house those we have, that's a wider problem with the way the economy/state is structured, not a problem with the number of people who need to be housed.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

The cost of bigger populations emerging too quickly with their required infrastructure far outweighs the debatable extra income you refer to.

Percentage increase in the population (per decade) over the last century:

1901 38,237,000 385,000 1.01%
1911 42,082,000 195,000 0.46%
1921 44,027,000 201,000 0.46%
1931 46,038,000 213,000 0.46%
1951 50,225,000 258,000 0.51%
1961 52,807,000 312,000 0.59%
1971 55,928,000 42,000 0.08%
1981 56,357,000 108,000 0.19%
1991 57,439,000 161,000 0.28%
2001 59,113,000 167,400 0.28%
2011 63,700,000 458,700 0.72%

The average rate of increase in GDP (the size of the economy itself) over that period was about 1.4%, so since the period between 1900 and 1910, the growth of the economy has been more than twice the rate of the growth of the population for the last century.

Not only this, but government spending as a percentage of GDP has risen from about 15% early in the last century to about 45% today, so government spending has essentially been growing approximately 6 times as fast as population.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

TUX Flag redhill 10 May 14 6.12pm

The cost of bigger populations emerging too quickly with their required infrastructure far outweighs the debatable extra income you refer to.
-----------------------------------------------

And there lies the problem that 'the blinkered' constantly miss. Immigrants do pay more revenue (fact) than they take, fairplay, but at what cost to those already here (including the blinkered) and our infrastructure etc as I've previously posted.
The 'blinkered' are way too busy panicking about a minor party getting some power rather than address the failings of THE MAJOR PARTIES!


Why, because it's easier. Tut tut.



 

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 6.30pm

Quote TUX at 10 May 2014 6.12pm

The cost of bigger populations emerging too quickly with their required infrastructure far outweighs the debatable extra income you refer to.
-----------------------------------------------

And there lies the problem that 'the blinkered' constantly miss. Immigrants do pay more revenue (fact) than they take, fairplay, but at what cost to those already here (including the blinkered) and our infrastructure etc as I've previously posted.
The 'blinkered' are way too busy panicking about a minor party getting some power rather than address the failings of THE MAJOR PARTIES!

Why, because it's easier. Tut tut.

When the UK population was rising by 214,500 a year for half a century between 1911 and 1961, how do you suppose the money was found to fight two world wars and build a national infrastructure that included state run schools and hospitals up and down the country?

Were we telling our citizens to stop shagging for the sake of the infrastructure, or did we just accept that the more workers we had, the more we produced and sold around the world, the more taxes we would generate and the more infrastructure we could build?

National infrastructure didn't just appear at the birth of the United Kingdom, it was built up by generations of citizens who realised that if they put more in than they took out, we'd end up with some sort of support structures if and when we were old, ill or poor.

We can only make investments in our infrastructure if we are in surplus after the states costs are taken from its income, so it's pretty dubious to say we will protect national infrastructure by turning people away who are net contributors to the nation's coffers.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

TUX Flag redhill 10 May 14 7.15pm

We can only make investments in our infrastructure if we are in surplus after the states costs are taken from its income, so it's pretty dubious to say we will protect national infrastructure by turning people away who are net contributors to the nation's coffers.
----------------------------------

Build it and they will come.

Another who has complete disregard for those already here but thinks 'importing more people' is the answer despite the plight of those already here? You couldn't make it up.

What next, I guess you approve of the minimum wage that is then topped up by the Govt (your taxes) ie big business gets state handouts and cheap labour to earn their billions? The Housing Benefit that is again topped up by the Govt (your taxes) even though the majority of households claiming this benefit are in full time work?
What point are you trying to prove bud?
I'd stop now if I were you tbh.

 

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 7.28pm

Presume I've always quoted this to Johnny Eagles earlier in the thread, but with a picture of Stewart Lee's face, you've got the option of knocking one out as you read it Johnny.

StewartLee.jpg Attachment: StewartLee.jpg (86.74Kb)

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

The White Horse Flag 10 May 14 7.41pm

Quote TUX at 10 May 2014 7.15pm

Build it and they will come.

Another who has complete disregard for those already here but thinks 'importing more people' is the answer despite the plight of those already here? You couldn't make it up.

I'm not suggesting we "import more people", I'm just saying don't turn people away who choose to come here and grow the UK economy and public finances.

Quote TUX at 10 May 2014 7.15pm

What next, I guess you approve of the minimum wage that is then topped up by the Govt (your taxes) ie big business gets state handouts and cheap labour to earn their billions?

I think the minimum wage should be higher so that the subsidy is reduced if not entirely obsolete. I think businesses should pay their staff enough to live on if they're working full time.


Quote TUX at 10 May 2014 7.15pm

The Housing Benefit that is again topped up by the Govt (your taxes) even though the majority of households claiming this benefit are in full time work?

Again, I'd rather we built housing owned by the state to rent to people who can't afford market rents, rather than subsidising landlords enormously.


Quote TUX at 10 May 2014 7.15pm

What point are you trying to prove bud?
I'd stop now if I were you tbh.

That "slow immigration, the infrastructure can't cope with population increases" is an argument that would have been wrong whether it was made in 1921, 1961, 2001 or today. Our country has a very good record of expanding infrastructure as population grows.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 7.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

This is a constant line you put out and you always ignore the answers.

Firstly the statistics that you are quoting from to support your implicit 'immigrants make us richer' are debated.

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.07pm

They are, but usually the debate ends in "well yes, obviously they're a net contributor given they were educated in another country and may well return there later in life when their care needs are greater".

People who are concerned about immigration often cite "common sense". I'd say there's no more obvious example of common sense than the conclusion that immigrants are statistically likely to pay more in tax than they take out.

Well, I don't say they are obviously a net contributor like you do. There are studies different from the one you consistently choose to cite as if it's unquestionable truth.


Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Secondly and more importantly saying that immigrants pay slightly more tax.....And if I remember correctly it is only slightly ....Saying that completely ignores the costs of providing for these people.

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.07pm

It doesn't ignore the costs of providing for these people, the costs are part of the calculation. Imagine Manuel comes over here and pays £10,000/year in taxation and only uses £9,000 state-provided services and benefits, for example. He is a net contributor. His £10,000 not only pays for the provision of the services that he uses, it pays for (part of) someone else's services too.

I don't believe the proper costs are apart of the calculation.

As for your example I don't know how many immigrants you know who are approximately on thirty plus grand but I'd wager it's a small minority.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

If these immigrants were all earning loads of money and paying large tax amounts and feeding their spare cash back into the economy (instead of a lot of them sending it home) then there would be some sense in your answer.

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.07pm

They feed a lot of it into the economy, that's unavoidable. They've got to pay for accommodation here and they're not going to pop back to their original country every time they want a bit of grub, or a telly or whatever.

If the "sending money home" examples had a deflationary effect upon the economy you'd have areas rich in immigrants seeing lower economic growth. No evidence of that happening that I've seen/heard about.

Rather obviously they feed less into the economy than workers who don't send money out of the country.

It is just ridiculous for you to even suggest that this unknowable calculation could be ascertained with the economy. Like much in economics it actually comes down to how you interpret.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

As it is.....Immigrants increase job competition for British workers and lower wages in some sectors.

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.07pm

Perhaps, but I wouldn't say competition in your job is a bad thing and obviously the best way to create jobs is to have people who put money into the economy and who pay more taxes than they take in services. As immigration increases, so does employment. Look at the last 60 years or so in the UK, for example.

Really....You don't mind competition for your job?....What a callous thing to say. We have tons of people looking for jobs.....Large competition for low skilled or semi skilled.....Forced upon zero hour contracts because of no choice and Horsey here thinks it's a good thing. Some Labour man you are......I hope you have lots of competition for your next job mate, I'm sure you'll welcome it.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

Housing low paid immigrants takes away possible housing for British residents and the lack of supply increases the rent or price... The fact that the state needs to build many many new houses for our significantly increasing population puts your 'immigrants pay more tax' line into almost comic relief.

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.07pm

Hopefully you're beginning to see a pattern in my argument at this stage. The immigrants are net contributors to the state, so those who are net beneficiaries by having their housing subsidised are more than funded by other immigrants who are net contributors.

Whether the state needs to build more houses is of course another debate, but it's not really a debate worth having unless you can calculate the costs of building the new housing and the financial surplus to the state that the immigrants generate.

If there are 26 million houses that 4 people on average can stay in, that's capacity for over 100 million people to live. I'd argue if we can house 35 million more people than we have in the country and struggle to even house those we have, that's a wider problem with the way the economy/state is structured, not a problem with the number of people who need to be housed.

Yeah, I'm most definitely noticing a pattern.....Your head stuck firmly in the sand.

The figures you quote are theoretical and no doubt include private property that the state has absolutely no power to affect....The cost to the state to house today is significant...Head in the clouds stuff.

You waffling on about how the state could be structured rather than how it is and will continue to be structured and hence affect the most vulnerable is typical.

Quote Stirlingsays at 10 May 2014 4.28pm

The cost of bigger populations emerging too quickly with their required infrastructure far outweighs the debatable extra income you refer to.


Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.07pm

Percentage increase in the population (per decade) over the last century:

1901 38,237,000 385,000 1.01%
1911 42,082,000 195,000 0.46%
1921 44,027,000 201,000 0.46%
1931 46,038,000 213,000 0.46%
1951 50,225,000 258,000 0.51%
1961 52,807,000 312,000 0.59%
1971 55,928,000 42,000 0.08%
1981 56,357,000 108,000 0.19%
1991 57,439,000 161,000 0.28%
2001 59,113,000 167,400 0.28%
2011 63,700,000 458,700 0.72%

The average rate of increase in GDP (the size of the economy itself) over that period was about 1.4%, so since the period between 1900 and 1910, the growth of the economy has been more than twice the rate of the growth of the population for the last century.

Not only this, but government spending as a percentage of GDP has risen from about 15% early in the last century to about 45% today, so government spending has essentially been growing approximately 6 times as fast as population.

Personally I don't see how those statistics support your side of the argument.

Increased public spending has many fathers......But population growth at least can't lie.

Before Labour open the borders immigration was a minor topic in this country......Statistics and well as common sense informs that it is far more significant now.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 10 May 14 7.49pm

Quote The White Horse at 10 May 2014 6.30pm

Quote TUX at 10 May 2014 6.12pm

The cost of bigger populations emerging too quickly with their required infrastructure far outweighs the debatable extra income you refer to.
-----------------------------------------------

And there lies the problem that 'the blinkered' constantly miss. Immigrants do pay more revenue (fact) than they take, fairplay, but at what cost to those already here (including the blinkered) and our infrastructure etc as I've previously posted.
The 'blinkered' are way too busy panicking about a minor party getting some power rather than address the failings of THE MAJOR PARTIES!

Why, because it's easier. Tut tut.

When the UK population was rising by 214,500 a year for half a century between 1911 and 1961, how do you suppose the money was found to fight two world wars and build a national infrastructure that included state run schools and hospitals up and down the country?

We were in relative terms a wealthy nation a hundred years ago due to trade, exploitation and the advance of capitalism.

The massive costs of war were based upon loans.....The recovery from the second world war was based upon austerity and massive grants from America (Marshall Plan) ....It enabled a large rebuilding plan and hence helped the post war population boom.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 20 of 187 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic