This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 31 Jul 2015 8.46am
Sending in the Army will give more man power to guard against the illegal activety (there's that word again illegal funny how that keeps cropping up) of breaking through fences, breaking into lorrys, and trying to gain illegal entry into the UK. The police dont have the numbers to cope, send the army in to patrol in riot gear no leathal weapons and you gain control of the situation, the simple fact of the matter is, at the moment there is not sufficeint man power to stop people attempting illegal (oh look there it is again) entry into the UK. We can't, its a foreign nation, so we cannot deploy troops in France unless a) France asks us and b) NATO agrees. Deploying the military to police civilians isn't something to be taken lightly either. Rarely ends well and its not like these people are 'that much trouble'. I hate seeing the Army or Military deployed essentially as a means of government actually doing its job properly. Not really sure of how well trained the army are to deal with riots either. What we should actually do is spend revenue on the Border Agency and Immigration service to improve its capacity to protect points of common ingress, scanning equipment such as thermal imaging devices and staff. It could also do with proper funding for services involved in processing applicants. But we also should not be doing the French Governments job for them either. This camp isn't really fit for human habitation either.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote chris123 at 31 Jul 2015 10.43am
Quote Mr Palaceman at 31 Jul 2015 10.23am
Quote Tom-the-eagle at 31 Jul 2015 7.40am
I am writing this having been up since 6 this morning working, I am also writing this having just paid a (what was for me) huge amount for my half yearly tax last night which I (or my family) cannot really afford. On that basis, excuse me if I do not sound too sympathetic towards these economic migrants who would all be entitled to free healthcare, education, benefits and housing, for which I would need to start work even earlier in the morning in order to be able to pay even more tax to make sure all their needs are met when I, a small business owner, an employer, get absolutely sweet FA in help from the government even though I work 7 days a week just to put bread on my kids table. Do people not understand – all these people come at a HUGE cost to us, the taxpayer. I have been watching this debate for a while and I agree with elements of both sides of the arguement but there are some myths that seem to get repeated time and time again and one of them is that everyone who comes here gets everything free. That just isn't true. The truth is that migrants who come here put more in and take less out than the locals. They tend to work rather than claim benefits, so huge cost to the taxpayer I think not. Historically the taxman has made more from immigration than is paid out in benefits for those that come and just claim. Having said that, why should anyone be allowed to claim anything, when they have not paid in or contributed in some way the the betterment of our nation. If that is allowed to happen then those that work hard and contribute just feel the system is unfair and who can argue with that. So there needs to be effective control over who comes here and I believe that is the sovereign right of our country and should not be left for the EU to dictate. Most EU member states would, I believe, have no problem in letting Migrants pass through their country to come here because they don't want them in their countries even more than us. We have, I believe, always been a more tolerant country than say, Spain, Italy, France or Germany. When it comes to helping those from other countries, the British people have always been right up there, in the giving of charity to foreign causes but on a government level, we don't take as many, as Germany for instance, who take 6 times as many and France who take twice as many as us. Another thought is that even if migrants do contribute to the country and it's economy, there are other factors that need to be considered, such as social impact and the fact that large numbers of the population just don't want foreigners here and that view is important because it's just how some people feel and right or wrong, that isn't going to change with what's going on now. Reading through these threads, it seems to me that there are many threads stating the problems without really offering any practical solutions to those perceived problems. They aren't going to stop wanting to come, while their own countries are in turmoil, that's a reality that we have to accept. We are going to have to invest more in the stability of those countries where the migrants come from and I believe that we can do that in a way that benefits our country. If we don't the tide will increase and spending money on fences will not stop them. If I was them, I would want to come here, we are a lot safer and you can make a fair living most of the time. When some of them can't even live, let alone earn, what do they have to lose by coming here? That's what needs to change before people stop wanting to come and it is becoming more apparent that we cannot cope with those migrants who have the determination to come to Europe/Britain for a better life.
Primarily, yes, but its also our problem to an extent if they're breaking out of the camp and trying to get to the UK. We shouldn't just be sending them back to the French camp if we intercept them.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote chris123 at 31 Jul 2015 12.10pm
If they are economic migrants, with no right to stay, they should be sent back to their country of origin. I think the problem is more determining if they are. Its complicated by the fact that most asylum applicants and illegals travel on fake documentation and tracking their country of origin can be very hard if they won't admit it. Even then that country may very well state a different case. Its much harder than people imagine, because genuine asylum seekers rarely travel on legitimate documents.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.