This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.13pm
So the slimey bearded tramp has finally made a comment about the mass slaughter of innocent civillians by saying he doesnt agree with a shoot to kill policy on terrorists . Corbyn you are an utter utter spinless wnaker. if I ever meet you in public please dont be offended if I tell you so. You pathetic apologist hangwringing tawtt. I don't generally agree with a shoot to kill policy in any situation either, except where the situation is conflict based. Its never worked in the past, it won't work in the future. You may have to shoot, but the problem of a 'shoot to kill' policy is that 95% of the time you don't actually know with any certainity who is and who is not a terrorist, and even when you do, capture represents a better source of intelligence than death. Certainly in a situation where they're engaged in an operation and lives are actually in danger, or you've established the individual is engaged in terrorist activities beyond reasonable doubt, and capture is not possible. But as an operating procedure, its always backfired and blown up in the face of the state.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Nov 2015 1.02am
Quote -TUX- at 17 Nov 2015 8.55pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Nov 2015 6.37pm
After 7/7 a survey with British Muslims showed that 16 percent though that the 7/7 attacks were wrong but the cause of the bombers was right. 13 percent though the bombers should be considered martyrs. Compare this to the attitudes of other groups in Britain....Sorry it isn't good enough to ignore and cherry coat. It's common knowledge for balanced observers that in many Islamic countries tolerance for other religions or the western mindset is limited (outside of tourist areas). However, it's important to also acknowledge that the people leading the fight against IS on the ground are Muslims. Excepting the Kurds, who are as secular as you get for middle eastern Muslims, these Muslims may not exactly be western minded either.......But there is a big big gap between that and accepting the stone age rule of IS. I feel the real picture about Islamic sentiment isn't the simplistic pictures presented by the pro or the anti groups but somewhere in the middle. There is a problem within Islamic communities in this country and others and those who deny reality only worsen the problem and provide succor and cover. However it's also true that the majority reject anything to do with these animals and this must also be recognised. It isn't a simple picture. Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Nov 2015 7.05pm)
Because otherwise we forget that many Muslims are just getting on with their lives and lump everyone in together. If we interned all Muslims, then that would send a very poor message to Muslims fighting IS. I know we do have a fifth columnist mindset of varying degress amongst a number of Muslims. I'm not sure what can be done about that. Going back to the 13%, that's not actually as bad as it looks. Back in the 70s, 25% of young Germans polled said they would shelter or support members of the Baader-Meinhoff gang. A key point to remember, which you also touch on, is that Daesh are a subsect, of a subsect of a subset of Sunni Islam, who are diametrically opposed to most of the Islamic community outside their own sect, and kill far more Muslims on a daily basis, than they've killed westerners. Since we began bombing IS, we effectively entered into a war with them, and it will be unavoidable that this will result in consequences from our enemy and a fifth column at home (as every war ever has done), and that ultimately some of these individuals will be successful. All we can do is try to locate them, subvert them or eliminate them, ideally before they can cause harm, and in a manner that doesn't generate further 'martyrs'. More importantly, we as a society also need to identify what appeal IS has to young Muslims, and counter that. Internment was a total disaster in Ireland, it effectively alienated Catholic communities, and drove them towards republicanism and ultimately created an environment in which the Provos and Stickies could establish a safe command structure, and recruit people who had been interned without real cause. Like you, I see internment as a bad plan, because you either create a PR disaster like Gitmo bay, that serves to recruit generations of enemies, or provide a safe place where terror suspects can meet and communicate and share information and tactics (the founders of ISIS were largely put togeather in the Iraqi prison systems). Also, in preventing attacks, we need people from the Muslim communities, more than anything else. The Intelligence services need agents, handlers and assets who speak languages, know dialects, can move freely in targeted mosques and community groups etc - and the best approach is to recruit specifically within those communities.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote npn at 18 Nov 2015 9.55am
Quote Kermit8 at 18 Nov 2015 9.47am
Quote cornwalls palace at 18 Nov 2015 9.32am
Quote Hoof Hearted at 17 Nov 2015 3.54pm
Quote elgrande at 17 Nov 2015 3.49pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Nov 2015 1.49pm
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.13pm
So the slimey bearded tramp has finally made a comment about the mass slaughter of innocent civillians by saying he doesnt agree with a shoot to kill policy on terrorists . Corbyn you are an utter utter spinless wnaker. if I ever meet you in public please dont be offended if I tell you so. You pathetic apologist hangwringing tawtt.
I actually think Corbyn has been naive although I understand his sentiment. Acouple of thoughts on that,and I am sure I will infuriate some on here with it.
Tragic case of mistaken identity, but no reason to adopt Corbyn's "let's talk about this" strategy when dealing with armed terrorists prepared to blow themselves up and kill/maim hundreds of innocent people.
A right Royal fvck up, in short. The police's version of events is different, surprisingly. Edited by Kermit8 (18 Nov 2015 9.49am)
Once told that the man was the one they were looking for, and once he was on a train, blowing his brains out was absolutely the right course of action (to prevent imminent further loss of life), but they could/should have taken him out before he got into a confined space (they could perhaps have arrested him then, or worst case taken him out without risk to bystanders should he actually be carrying explosives). Suicide bombers are a different breed - they have no fear of death, and indeed embrace it, so identifying yourself before shooting merely gives them the chance to detonate their devices The shooter holds some responsibility, but not the blame, that entirely lies with the stupidity of the policy adopted by the Police, the communications and tactics and a failure to actually devise a policy and process based on 'real world examples'. The operation was a total f**k up from start to finish, that ultimately cost an innocent man his life in what was a brutal and violent death that ultimately was unavoidable once operation cratos was approved by idiots within the police force. Its notable that the IDF doesn't operate by such a procedure (they're actually quite adept at capturing suicide bombers).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.