You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people
November 22 2026 12.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The left and Jewish people


Page 20 of 22 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Bert the Head Flag Epsom 14 Jun 16 9.36pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

1. Read what was written. I never claimed that Loach, et al, was a Holocaust denier. I said that his argument is a stretch (at best), and the same one used by Holocause deniers.

2. What has Israels killing of Palestinians got to do with whether someone is making anti-Semitic comments. Where have I claimed that Israel hasn't killed Palestinians? That's just you lying to make a point and it's also just a strawman argument, and a sloppy one at that.

3. If you don't agree with what I wrote, counter it with evidence rather than yet another strawman argument.

4. Wrong again. The use of gas was discussed regarding Iraq in the 1920s, as well as in the Russian Civil War, and on the North-West Frontier. The discussion is also mentioned in several biographies of Churchill and histories of the British Empire (which tells me you should actually read the stuff you claim to be citing). Yet there is no evidence that gas was used in Iraq in the 1920s, despite Churchill being in favor, or on the NW Frontier, or by the British in the Russian Civil War.

That being said, so what? What has Churchill's favorable opinion on the utility of poison gas, 100 years ago, got to do with whether someone is being anti-Semitic today? Or is that just another poor attempt at a strawman argument?

Essentially, your, and Nick's, argument boils down to the opinion that Israel is bad, so no comments made by Israel's opponent can be anti-Semitic. That's not just fallacious, that's downright silly. Thus, to paraphrase Wolfgang Pauli seems appropriate: "what you are arguing is so wrong, it's not even wrong."

And, as with Nick Gusset, I will leave this matter there for the same reasons.


Here are some books/articles on the subject of collaboration between Zionists and the Nazi’s:

Hannah Arendt, in her 1960 book “Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report in the Banality of Evil,” writes: “To a Jew this role of the Jewish leaders in the destruction of their own people is undoubtedly the darkest chapter of the whole dark story.”

In “The Transfer Agreement: The Dramatic Story of the Pact between the Third Reich and Jewish Palestine” (containing an afterword by ADL head Abe Foxman), pro-Israel writer Edwin Black reports that in 1933 Zionist leaders concluded a secret pact with the Third Reich that transferred 60,000 Jews and $100,000 to Palestine, Zionists promising in return that they would halt the worldwide boycott “that threatened to topple the Hitler regime in its first year.”

Author-researcher Lenni Brenner wrote of Zionist-Nazi collusion in “Zionism in the Age of Dictators,” of which the London Times stated: “Brenner is able to cite numerous cases where Zionists collaborated with anti-Semitic regimes, including Hitler’s.”

Brenner’s second book on the topic, “51 Documents, Zionist Collaboration with the Nazis,” includes a 1940 letter from underground Zionist terrorist leader Avraham Stern proposing that Jewish militias would fight on Germany’s side in exchange for Nazi help in creating an “historic Jewish state.”

In “What Price Israel,” American Council for Judaism member Alfred Lilienthal describes FDR’s efforts to set up a program to rescue refugees, only to find Zionists sabotaging it. Roosevelt explained: “The Zionist movement knows that Palestine is, and will be for some time, a remittance society. They know that they can raise vast sums for Palestine by saying to donors, ‘There is no other place this poor Jew can go.’”

When New York attorney Morris Ernst joined this refugee effort, he was shocked: “I was thrown out of parlors of friends of mine who very frankly said ‘Morris, this is treason. You are undermining the Zionist movement.’” Ernst wrote that he found a fanatical movement of men “little concerned about human blood if it is not their own.”

In “The Seventh Million: The Israelis and the Holocaust,” Israeli historian Tom Segev quotes Zionist leader and future Israeli Prime Minister David Ben Gurion: “If I knew that it was possible to save all the Jewish children of Germany by transporting them to England, but only half of them by transporting them to Palestine, I would choose the second.”

Segev writes that Ben-Gurion worried that ‘the human conscience’ might cause various countries to open their doors to Jewish refugees from Germany and saw this as a threat, warning: ‘Zionism is in danger.’”

The list is taken from Counterpunch.

Re Church and gas - Actually you are probably right that Churchill did not use gas as I had suggested. My point was that you suggested that if a “main-stream academic” doesn’t step forward to defend an argument then it can’t be true. But that depends how you classify a main stream academic. Churchill was in favour of using gas but I agree that is not the same thing.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jun 16 10.05pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head


Here are some books/articles on the subject of collaboration between Zionists and the Nazi’s:

Hannah Arendt, in her 1960 book “Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report in the Banality of Evil,” writes: “To a Jew this role of the Jewish leaders in the destruction of their own people is undoubtedly the darkest chapter of the whole dark story.”

In “The Transfer Agreement: The Dramatic Story of the Pact between the Third Reich and Jewish Palestine” (containing an afterword by ADL head Abe Foxman), pro-Israel writer Edwin Black reports that in 1933 Zionist leaders concluded a secret pact with the Third Reich that transferred 60,000 Jews and 0,000 to Palestine, Zionists promising in return that they would halt the worldwide boycott “that threatened to topple the Hitler regime in its first year.”

Author-researcher Lenni Brenner wrote of Zionist-Nazi collusion in “Zionism in the Age of Dictators,” of which the London Times stated: “Brenner is able to cite numerous cases where Zionists collaborated with anti-Semitic regimes, including Hitler’s.”

Brenner’s second book on the topic, “51 Documents, Zionist Collaboration with the Nazis,” includes a 1940 letter from underground Zionist terrorist leader Avraham Stern proposing that Jewish militias would fight on Germany’s side in exchange for Nazi help in creating an “historic Jewish state.”

In “What Price Israel,” American Council for Judaism member Alfred Lilienthal describes FDR’s efforts to set up a program to rescue refugees, only to find Zionists sabotaging it. Roosevelt explained: “The Zionist movement knows that Palestine is, and will be for some time, a remittance society. They know that they can raise vast sums for Palestine by saying to donors, ‘There is no other place this poor Jew can go.’”

When New York attorney Morris Ernst joined this refugee effort, he was shocked: “I was thrown out of parlors of friends of mine who very frankly said ‘Morris, this is treason. You are undermining the Zionist movement.’” Ernst wrote that he found a fanatical movement of men “little concerned about human blood if it is not their own.”

In “The Seventh Million: The Israelis and the Holocaust,” Israeli historian Tom Segev quotes Zionist leader and future Israeli Prime Minister David Ben Gurion: “If I knew that it was possible to save all the Jewish children of Germany by transporting them to England, but only half of them by transporting them to Palestine, I would choose the second.”

Segev writes that Ben-Gurion worried that ‘the human conscience’ might cause various countries to open their doors to Jewish refugees from Germany and saw this as a threat, warning: ‘Zionism is in danger.’”

The list is taken from Counterpunch.

Re Church and gas - Actually you are probably right that Churchill did not use gas as I had suggested. My point was that you suggested that if a “main-stream academic” doesn’t step forward to defend an argument then it can’t be true. But that depends how you classify a main stream academic. Churchill was in favour of using gas but I agree that is not the same thing.

An interesting read Bert don't expect an analytical response from some members of this site though!

All of this evidence was used by the Labour member in the transcript of his hearing that I posted a lengthy extract of earlier in the thread.


What's galling is that Ken Livingstone was called out for alluding to this when he said there was collusion between elements of Jewish society and Nazi’s. That's not anti semetism. In fact it could be argued that the Jewish colluders were acting in an anti semitic way.

Ken lost his show on LBC yet Katie Hopkins is allowed to continue spouting her bile on the airwaves. I'm not saying Ken is perfect, but but was stitched up in this case.


I'm still waiting to hear from Matt why asking for the full context of a horrible tweet sent by the councillor in the telegraph link he posted is a flimsy argument, especially when he himself (no pun intended) said that context is important!


Edited by nickgusset (14 Jun 2016 10.11pm)

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 15 Jun 16 12.45pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head


Here are some books/articles on the subject of collaboration between Zionists and the Nazi’s:

Hannah Arendt, in her 1960 book “Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report in the Banality of Evil,” writes: “To a Jew this role of the Jewish leaders in the destruction of their own people is undoubtedly the darkest chapter of the whole dark story.”

In “The Transfer Agreement: The Dramatic Story of the Pact between the Third Reich and Jewish Palestine” (containing an afterword by ADL head Abe Foxman), pro-Israel writer Edwin Black reports that in 1933 Zionist leaders concluded a secret pact with the Third Reich that transferred 60,000 Jews and 0,000 to Palestine, Zionists promising in return that they would halt the worldwide boycott “that threatened to topple the Hitler regime in its first year.”

Author-researcher Lenni Brenner wrote of Zionist-Nazi collusion in “Zionism in the Age of Dictators,” of which the London Times stated: “Brenner is able to cite numerous cases where Zionists collaborated with anti-Semitic regimes, including Hitler’s.”

Brenner’s second book on the topic, “51 Documents, Zionist Collaboration with the Nazis,” includes a 1940 letter from underground Zionist terrorist leader Avraham Stern proposing that Jewish militias would fight on Germany’s side in exchange for Nazi help in creating an “historic Jewish state.”

In “What Price Israel,” American Council for Judaism member Alfred Lilienthal describes FDR’s efforts to set up a program to rescue refugees, only to find Zionists sabotaging it. Roosevelt explained: “The Zionist movement knows that Palestine is, and will be for some time, a remittance society. They know that they can raise vast sums for Palestine by saying to donors, ‘There is no other place this poor Jew can go.’”

When New York attorney Morris Ernst joined this refugee effort, he was shocked: “I was thrown out of parlors of friends of mine who very frankly said ‘Morris, this is treason. You are undermining the Zionist movement.’” Ernst wrote that he found a fanatical movement of men “little concerned about human blood if it is not their own.”

In “The Seventh Million: The Israelis and the Holocaust,” Israeli historian Tom Segev quotes Zionist leader and future Israeli Prime Minister David Ben Gurion: “If I knew that it was possible to save all the Jewish children of Germany by transporting them to England, but only half of them by transporting them to Palestine, I would choose the second.”

Segev writes that Ben-Gurion worried that ‘the human conscience’ might cause various countries to open their doors to Jewish refugees from Germany and saw this as a threat, warning: ‘Zionism is in danger.’”

The list is taken from Counterpunch.

Re Church and gas - Actually you are probably right that Churchill did not use gas as I had suggested. My point was that you suggested that if a “main-stream academic” doesn’t step forward to defend an argument then it can’t be true. But that depends how you classify a main stream academic. Churchill was in favour of using gas but I agree that is not the same thing.

So, the best you can do is lift a bunch of selective quotes verbatim from an anti-zionist Trotskyist (Brenner), and from a website that describes itself as left-wing muckraking with a radical attitude.

As I said, main stream academic?

As for the highly selective, and out of context, selected quotes: I dont see where anyone has disputed that some Jews collaborated with the Nazis. Just like some French, and some Russians, and some British, etc., all did. That does not, however, mean all people of a specific nationality or race collaborated. Livingstone is intelligent enough to know how to use his words, and he did not talk about a few Zionists, or a few Jews, individually working with the Nazis: instead his comments were not qualfied. That is where the problem is.

By the way, the full quote from Ben Gurion was: "If I knew that it was possible to save all the children in Germany by transporting them to England, but only half of them by transporting them to Palestine, I would chose the second—because we face not only the reckoning of those children, but the historical reckoning of the Jewish people." Thus, whether you happen to agree with him or not, he saw this as the only way to stop the Jewish race being eraticated over the longer term. Remember, this was a sentiment about 1930s Europe and what was happening to Jews there. That's not quite the same thing as implied in your more selective use, now, is it? By the way, the book that quote was taken from discusses how Jewish people tried to come to terms with what was happening in the 1930s and 1940s and how they tried to rationalize this and make the best of a series of bad options. It is not about them actively aiding the Nazis to further their Zionist agenda, as was the clear implication of Livingstone and others of that ilk.

And that, really, is my final word.

Try reading this (it's the Atlantic):
[Link]

And this from the TLS (written by Toby Lichtig, who often writes for the Guardian):

[Link]

Edited by NickinOX (15 Jun 2016 12.56pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

johnfirewall Flag 15 Jun 16 1.37pm

Is deporting Jews rather than killing them Zionism?

Is them accepting that option collaboration with the Nazis?

We stopped actually debating Labour's anti-Semitism several pages ago, and the left's as a whole even earlier. Please stop using the lack of opposition to a completely different argument in their defence. Yes it's all died down with only the EU referendum for the media to worry about and yes some have been reinstated after investigation in to the ridiculous and offensive things which they said, but the agenda is still there, and whether it's based on anti-Zionism, it still manifests itself in the same way.

Edited by johnfirewall (15 Jun 2016 1.41pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 09 Jul 16 2.09pm

National paper prints bulls*** shocker.


[Link]

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Jul 16 4.32pm

Chakrabarti's conclusions,in essence, were:

"...This Inquiry was triggered by a series of unhappy incidents which did no credit to the Labour Party.

...The Labour Party is not overrun by antisemitism, Islamophobia or other forms of racism. ... However, as with wider society,
there is too much clear evidence (going back some years) of minority hateful or ignorant attitudes and
behaviours festering within a sometimes bitter incivility of discourse. This has no place in a modern
democratic socialist party that puts equality, inclusion and human rights at its heart."


Sounds about right and hopefully people in the party will now be a bit more aware of the issue and those who simply reject it as a "right wing media plot" will be more open in future to the reality...

Corbyn,for example,is not an anti-semite in my view.But, it is worrying that he saw no problem in describing as "friends" an organisation whose
Charter blames Jews per se for the French Revolution,and both world wars (Hamas), ..its unimaginable he would have done the same with an organisation that had expressed similar views about say Asian or African people....

Edited by legaleagle (10 Jul 2016 9.32am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Jul 16 9.00pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

Chakrabarti's conclusions,in essence, were:

"...This Inquiry was triggered by a series of unhappy incidents which did no credit to the Labour Party.

...The Labour Party is not overrun by antisemitism, Islamophobia or other forms of racism. ... However, as with wider society,
there is too much clear evidence (going back some years) of minority hateful or ignorant attitudes and
behaviours festering within a sometimes bitter incivility of discourse. This has no place in a modern
democratic socialist party that puts equality, inclusion and human rights at its heart."


Sounds about right and hopefully people in the party will now be a bit more aware of the issue and those who simply reject it as a "right wing media plot" will be more open in future to the reality...

Corbyn,for example,is not an anti-semite in my view.But, it is worrying that he saw no problem in describing an organisation whose
Charter blames Jews per se for the French Revolution,and both world wars
(Hamas), ..its unimaginable her would have done the same with an organisation that had expressed similar views about say Asian or African people....

Teah, let's blame the Germans for everything. They don't have anyone expressing outrage on their behalf.

 

johnfirewall Flag 16 Sep 16 12.38pm

An MP refuses to speak alongside John McDonnell as a result of his appearance with the woman who blamed slavery on Jews and is subsequently branded 'right-wing' by an activist that has previously heckled her.

[Link]

Funny how certain allegiances can make you 'right-wing' while others are perfectly acceptable.

 

banbandanas Flag Birmingham 17 Sep 16 10.11am

One thing I admire about Jews is that the wearing of a skullcap precludes the wearing of a bandana. Or does it? I suppose they could wear the cap under a bandana, or over it. Or am I being paranoid. Does anyone know the real truth about this?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 25 Sep 16 6.22pm

[Link]

Letter to Chuka Umunna from some Jewish people. Stop weaponising anti semetism.

Edited by nickgusset (25 Sep 2016 6.24pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Sep 16 7.09pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

[Link]

Letter to Chuka Umunna from some Jewish people. Stop weaponising anti semetism.

Edited by nickgusset (25 Sep 2016 6.24pm)

According to the Chair of Jewish Labour Movement only 8% of British Jews now support Labour.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 28 Sep 16 8.38am

[Link]

Max looks like George Daws

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

banbandanas Flag Birmingham 28 Sep 16 9.15am

Can we expect a fulsome tribute to Shimon Peres from Corbyn?

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 28 Sep 16 8.59pm

Why doesn't she just shut up?

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 28 Sep 16 9.52pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Why doesn't she just shut up?

[Link]

Socialism at its finest. Everyone is equal, unless your wealthy, Jewish, "middle class" etc

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Sep 16 7.49am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

According to the Chair of Jewish Labour Movement only 8% of British Jews now support Labour.

Yep and the modern Labour party must share in the responsibility of creating an environment towards Jews that has seen them leave this country in large numbers.

Antisemitism has mainly come from their party. They support minorities who themselves contain large percentages of antisemitic people.

Great swapping of people that.

The left do so much for us.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 29 Sep 16 8.27am

"Antisemitism exists and must be exposed and fought against in the same way as other forms of racism by all who are concerned with combating racism and fascism.

Antisemitism and anti-Zionism are not the same. Zionism is a political ideology which has always been contested within Jewish life since it emerged in 1897, and it is entirely legitimate for non-Jews as well as Jews to express opinions about it, whether positive or negative. Not all Jews are Zionists. Not all Zionists are Jews.

Criticism of Israeli government policy and Israeli state actions against the Palestinians is not antisemitism. Those who conflate criticism of Israeli policy with antisemitism, whether they are supporters or opponents of Israeli policy, are actually helping the antisemites. We reject any attempt, from whichever quarter, to place legitimate criticism of Israeli policy out of bounds.

Accusations of antisemitism are currently being weaponised to attack the Jeremy Corbyn-led Labour party with claims that Labour has a “problem” of antisemitism. This is despite Corbyn’s longstanding record of actively opposing fascism and all forms of racism, and being a firm a supporter of the rights of refugees and of human rights globally."

Jewish Socialist Group

[Link]

Interestingly, Israel originally was founded as a socialist state as well as Jewish.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


legaleagle Flag 29 Sep 16 9.14am

Can't disagree with that.

Looks like they are ideological successors of the Bund which was the main Jewish political grouping other than the zionists in pre-war c and E Europe.

But would be nice and reassuring to hear JS actually come out in terms and say:

1.He abhors the nonsense spouted in some margins of the party about Jews being the prime movers behind the slave trade

2.That he abhors Hamas for having a charter that blames Jews per se for,amongst other things,the French revolution and both world wars.And as such,regrets having shared a platform with such people.

Surely not to much to ask of a person with a "longstanding record of actively opposing fascism and all forms of racism..." ?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Sep 2016 9.15am)

 

banbandanas Flag Birmingham 29 Sep 16 9.28am

Originally posted by legaleagle

Can't disagree with that.

Looks like they are ideological successors of the Bund which was the main Jewish political grouping other than the zionists in pre-war c and E Europe.

But would be nice and reassuring to hear JS actually come out in terms and say:

1.He abhors the nonsense spouted in some margins of the party about Jews being the prime movers behind the slave trade

2.That he abhors Hamas for having a charter that blames Jews per se for,amongst other things,the French revolution and both world wars.And as such,regrets having shared a platform with such people.

Surely not to much to ask of a person with a "longstanding record of actively opposing fascism and all forms of racism..." ?

Edited by legaleagle (29 Sep 2016 9.15am)

Not much chance of that, as yesterday he said he was right to apologise on behalf of the party for being involved in the overthrow of a fascist dictator.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 29 Sep 16 9.40am

Originally posted by Kermit8

"Antisemitism exists and must be exposed and fought against in the same way as other forms of racism by all who are concerned with combating racism and fascism.

Antisemitism and anti-Zionism are not the same. Zionism is a political ideology which has always been contested within Jewish life since it emerged in 1897, and it is entirely legitimate for non-Jews as well as Jews to express opinions about it, whether positive or negative. Not all Jews are Zionists. Not all Zionists are Jews.

Criticism of Israeli government policy and Israeli state actions against the Palestinians is not antisemitism. Those who conflate criticism of Israeli policy with antisemitism, whether they are supporters or opponents of Israeli policy, are actually helping the antisemites. We reject any attempt, from whichever quarter, to place legitimate criticism of Israeli policy out of bounds.

Accusations of antisemitism are currently being weaponised to attack the Jeremy Corbyn-led Labour party with claims that Labour has a “problem” of antisemitism. This is despite Corbyn’s longstanding record of actively opposing fascism and all forms of racism, and being a firm a supporter of the rights of refugees and of human rights globally."

Jewish Socialist Group

[Link]

Interestingly, Israel originally was founded as a socialist state as well as Jewish.

Bertie, more smokescreen.

We know the difference between anti semitism and criticising the Israeli government.

However there is a problem with the left with Jewish people. It's almost an obsession.

If this had been self recognised and dealt with, hammering down people equating the 'slave trade with Jewish bankers' for example, would have killed the issue. But as we know Bertie, the left ain't gonna do that.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Page 20 of 22 < 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people